Based on articles that appeared in Reader's Digest magazine,[1] the episodes were true stories that were varied in their themes, plots, and content. Themes included crime, heroism, mystery, romance, and human interest.
Erskine gained the rights to make the series after he went through every issue the magazine had published since 1928 to ensure that the TV series would reflect the magazine "as faithfully as possible".[36]
The show replaced Soldier Parade.[33] It was broadcast on Mondays from 8 to 8:30 p.m. Eastern time.[3]
Critical response
A review of the premiere episode in the trade publication Variety said that Erskine "appears to have successfully translated that human interest element that's made the Reader's Digest a literary phenom into television terms."[34] It commended Gruber's writing and Beaudine's directing and described the cast as "excellent".[34]
J. P. Shanley, writing in The New York Times, found the December 5, 1955, episode ("The Sad Death of a Hero", about the 1925 Scopes trial) to be "an uninspired presentation."[37] Shanley wrote, "Douglass Dumbrille was effective as the uncompromising Fundamentalist Bryan."[37] Carl Benton Reid "had some impressive moments" as Darrow, the review said.[37] The main negative factor was introduction of "a side issue" about a journalist covering the trial and a teacher who influenced her.[37]
^ abcdMcNeil, Alex (1996). Total Television: the Comprehensive Guide to Programming from 1948 to the Present (4th ed.). New York, New York: Penguin Books USA, Inc. p. 812. ISBN0-14-02-4916-8.
^"The Show-Makers". Motion Picture Daily. January 16, 1956. p. 12. Retrieved November 9, 2024.
^ abBrooks, Tim; Marsh, Earle (1999). The Complete Directory to Prime Time Network and Cable TV Shows 1946-Present (7th ed.). New York: The Ballentine Publishing Group. p. 998. ISBN0-345-42923-0.
^ abcd"Go Fight City Hall Stars Raymond". The Sacramento Bee. June 16, 1956. p. F-30. Retrieved July 28, 2025. "Gene Raymond, host of the TV Reader's Digest series, [...] will portray Albert Whitman, a taxpayer in a New York suburb who is aroused to action against the politicians who control the municipal government. [...] Jean Byron will play Whitman's wife, Claire. Their children, Kitty and Ted, will be portrayed by Joan Young and Chet Marshall."
^ ab"TV Fill-In". The Washington Daily News. February 27, 1956. p. 37. Retrieved July 28, 2025.' "TV Reader's Digest: Marguerite Chapman stars as a private eye in 'The Case of the Uncertain Hand.'"
^ ab"TV Tips: Young Love Dominates Schedule". Oregon Journal. May 7, 1956. p. 19. Retrieved July 28, 2025. "TV Reader's Digest version, 'The Old, Old Story," stars Rosemary De Camp in a drama of a pair of teenagers determined to marry despite, parental opposition."
^ ab"RADIO AND TV HIGHLIGHTS FOR TONIGHT". Santa Barbara News-Press. February 13, 1956. p. A-6. Retrieved July 28, 2025.' "TV Reader's Digest presents "Texas in New York." starring Marilyn Erskine (7)."
^"Television Programs". Hollywood Citizen-News. January 24, 1955. p. 18. Retrieved July 24, 2025. "In 'Trouble on the Double,' KABC (7) at 8, Walter Elwood (Peter Graves) follows telephone instructions in delivering the fourth child of his wife, Elsie (Nancy Gates). [...] TV Reader's, Digest."
^"Television Programs". Hollywood Citizen-News. January 31, 1955. p. 18. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "Martha Scott will be seen as Mrs. Robert Louis Stevenson, Douglas Montgomery as her husband in "The Most Unforgettable Character,' KABC (7) at 8. [...] TV Reader's Digest."
^"TV Gossip". The News of Cumberland County. February 5, 1955. p. 5. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "Monday, Channel 6, at 8 O'clock, TV Reader's Digest, 'How Chance Made Lincoln President'; drama of five fateful events starring Richard Gaines, Vivi Janiss; Hugh Reilly hosts series based on articles that have appeared in Reader's Digest."
^"Today's Television Highlights". Newsday (Suffolk Edition). February 14, 1955. p. 5. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "Drama. 8:00 (7) Reader's Digest: 'I'd Pick More Daisies,' Richard Denning, Jeanne Cagney."
^"Television Programs". Hollywood Citizen-News. February 28, 1955. p. 20. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "In 'A Matter of Life or Death,' KABC (7) at 8, a surgeon saves the life of his enemy's grandson. Bobby Driscoll is Dr. Radford Sawyer when young, Minor Watson, when he is an adult. Jimmy Ogg plays Vernon Kimble, the boy, Erville Alderson, Kimble, the grandfather."
^"Television Programs". Hollywood Citizen-News. March 7, 1955. p. 20. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "Blackbeard? the Pirate meets his end in the play at 8 on KABC (7). Before doing so, he (Jeff Morrow) orders Mary Oakland (Randy Farr) and John Gibbs (Keith Hitchcock) held as hostages. [...] TV Reader's Digest. (7)"
^"Television and Radio: Television Program Notes". New York Herald Tribune. March 28, 1955. p. 30. ProQuest1336813356. Digest: 'The Manufactured Clue,' murder mystery of crime detection in a New Jersey seaside town. Chuck Connors, Paul Stewart and Douglas Spencer (7), 8.
^"TELEVISION HIGHLIGHTS FOR MONDAY". The Baltimore Sun. April 4, 1955. p. 24. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "'Incident on the China Coast,' is the title of a drama about how eight of eighteen persons aboard a big airliner survive a brutal and unexplained attack. Stars Bob Bray and Ann Doran. 8 P.M."
^Marill, Alvin (2008). Sports on Television. Westport, CT: Praeger. p. 16. ISBN978-0-313-35105-1. "Marvin starred in the baseball-oriented drama, 'How Charlie Faust Won a Pennant for the Giants.' Faust was the real-life pre-World War I pitcher for the New York Giants under John McGraw (played by Alan Reed)."
^"TELEVISION HIGHLIGHTS FOR MONDAY". The Hollywood Citizen-News. May 2, 1955. p. 23. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "'Honeymoon in Mexico,' KABC (7) at 8, is the true story of a young Texan and his Boston who adopted 10 Mexican youngsters. Richard Long and Merry Anders are John and Peggy Wilhelm."
^ ab"TELEVISION HIGHLIGHTS FOR MONDAY". The Paterson News. May 2, 1955. p. 23. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "8:00 (7) Television Reader's Digest: 'Million Dollar Story,' with Bill Bouchey, James Bell, Julie Bishop, others."
^"Television Programs". Detroit Free Press. May 23, 1955. p. 41. Retrieved July 31, 2025. TV READER'S DIGEST -Man takes boatload of women around Cape Horn from New York to Seattle in days of pioneers in 'Around the Horn to Matrimony,' staring Robert Hutton, Donna Martel."
^"Television Programs". Hollywood Citizen-News. May 30, 1955. p. 8. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "The efforts of Victor Martin (Gene Barry) to work for better government are thwarted, KABC (7) at 8, in 'The Anatomy of Graft.' Portraying his wife, Jean, is Jaclynne Greene; her father, Emerson Treacy."
^"Radio and Television Programs: Television". The Hammond Times. June 13, 1955. p. 8. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "(7)-TV's Reader's Digest. Mr. Pak Takes Over,' Phillip Ahn, Ken Tobey."
^"Matador". Pasadena Independent. June 20, 1955. p. 21. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "Jack Kelly in the role of Sidney Franklin, bullfighter from Brooklyn, in the 'TV Reader's Digest' drama, 'My First Bullfight,' on KABC-TV tonight at 8."
^"TV Programs for Monday". Detroit Free Press. p. 19. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "7 P.M. 7-TV READER'S DIGEST: 'Six Hours of Surgery,' drama personal problems of five people involved in delicate heart operation on boy, 16. Walter Kingsford, Jerry Paris, Damian 0'Flynn, Jean Byron star."
^Retrieved July 31, 2025. "7:00-TV READER'S DIGEST--Tonight's melodrama, 'The Baron and His Uranium Killing,' stars Marcel Dalio and Steven Geray in a rollicking spy adventure."
^"Radio and TV Highlights for Tonight". Santa Barbara News-Press. October 24, 1955. p. 6. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "TV Reader's Digest presents "Old Master Detective," starring William Talman, Walter Kingsford and Jesse White (7)."
^"8:00 P.M. Tonight! 'Old Master Detective' on TV READER'S DIGEST". New York Daily News. p. 56. Retrieved July 31, 2025. "Was it a priceless masterpiece ... or a worthless fraud? A question is asked about a painting ... and a strange kind of detective sets out to find the $300,000 answer!"