Early Start Denver Model
The Early Start Denver Model (ESDM) is a subtype of applied behavior analysis (ABA) marketed as a therapy for autistic toddlers and preschoolers. It was developed by American psychologists Sally J. Rogers and Geraldine Dawson. DevelopmentAmerican psychologists Sally J. Rogers and Geraldine Dawson began developing the Early Start Denver Model during the 1980s.[1] While working at the University of Colorado, Rogers practiced what was then called the "play school model" of intervention, applying it to preschoolers during their regular play activities.[2] The model was based on Piaget's theory of cognitive development[2] and came to be described by Rogers and Dawson as the Denver Model.[3] In 2010, the two researchers published Early Start Denver Model for Young Children with Autism: Promoting Language, Learning, and Engagement,[4] in which the ESDM is manualized and described in detail. It is generally intended for children between 12 and 48 months of age[5] and is a form of ABA, influencing and being influenced by mainstream ABA practices.[2][6] DescriptionThe ESDM is aimed at using "joint activity routines" that explore the child's natural interests to explore their learning potential, shaping everyday activities between the child and their caregivers to maximize their development potential according to the child's assessment.[6] Rogers and Dawson describe the core features of the ESDM as:[4]
AssessmentThe intervention begins with measuring the child's skill levels in language, social skills, imitation, cognition, play, and motor and self-help skills. The assessment serves as a baseline for future reassessments, which are rerun every 12 weeks,[7] and a model of it is presented in Rogers and Dawson's 2010 book,[1] being called the ESDM Curriculum Checklist.[8] Intervention planResults from the first assessment are used to draw an intervention plan, which describes the activities to be performed with the child by the parents and therapists. An interdisciplinary team oversees the progress and readjusts the plan with every new 12-week assessment.[4] The parents are also trained (or "coached") and play a role in the program, taking on some of the activities in the child's intervention plan or, in some cases, conducting it all together.[9] Among the domains focused on by the intervention plan are of particular importance: imitation, nonverbal communication (including joint attention), verbal communication, social development (including emotion sharing), and play.[4] EfficacySeveral studies have been published in an effort to assess its efficacy in mitigating developmental delays in autistic children. Research of this kind is inherently complex, since it involves comparing groups receiving different types of treatment and it is ethically questionable to set aside a control group that would receive no treatment; therefore it is challenging to perform the objective measurement of treatment effects.[1] Rogers and Dawson have conducted different trials of their methods. They co-authored (with six others) a randomized controlled trial study in 2012 that found that younger subject ages and longer hours of weekly intervention correlated with generally improved efficacy.[10] They followed up with a study published in 2015 where they tried to gauge the method's long-term efficacy by examining children at 6 years of age, 2 years after the ESDM had ended. By comparing one group that had received traditional methods of treatment with another group receiving the ESDM treatment starting at between 18 and 30 months of age, they found no significant differences between the groups in core autism symptoms immediately after treatment ended (at 4 years of age); the ESDM group did show, however, significant improvements in core autism symptoms after 2 years, implying that the benefits of the treatment at a younger age affect traits that only become noticeable in later stages of development. This was the first study that analyzed the efficacy of ESDM treatment starting at an age younger than 30 months.[11] Meta-analyses and systematic reviews have shown that the ESDM is promising.[12] A meta-analysis of 12 individual studies with a total of 640 children published in 2020 concluded that, compared to control groups receiving traditional forms of treatment, children receiving the ESDM showed significant improvements in cognition and language abilities (G-test numbers of 0.412 and 0.408, respectively); the paper was co-authored by Rogers.[13] A separate meta-analysis using 11 studies described as high-quality randomized controlled trials analyzed results in four major domains related to autism (autism symptoms, language, cognition, and social communication). The study found that children receiving the ESDM showed significant improvements in the cognition (g = 0.28), autism symptoms (g = 0.27), and language (g = 0.29) domains.[14] A 2017 study co-authored by Rogers examined the cost-effectiveness of applying the ESDM at an early age rather than using the traditional methods of treatment at later stages. The study indicated that the average increased cost of treatment at younger ages was significantly smaller than the total savings in treatments at older ages, with children needing fewer sessions of ABA/EIBI, occupational, physical and speech therapy services.[15] Usage in countriesThe diagnosis of autism has undergone significant changes in recent decades, which means the forms of treatment have also changed.[16] Therefore, countries have incorporated treatment options in heterogeneous ways, meaning that the Denver Model has been adopted with different intensities throughout the world. The list below presents a brief description of how each country's healthcare system (public or private) deal with this form of treatment: AustraliaThe National Disability Insurance Scheme of the Australian government recognizes the ESDM as a form of "naturalistic developmental behavioural intervention" with enough scientific evidence to support it,[17] and will cover the costs of treatment and parent-training sessions if the child is eligible for this type of treatment.[18] BrazilThe Agência Nacional de Saúde Suplementar (ANS), Brazil's regulating body for private healthcare plan providers, recognizes different forms of autism within the scope of pervasive developmental disorders. It lists ESDM as one of the forms of treatment that should be taken into consideration by healthcare providers for developmentally disabled children. Since July 1, 2022, healthcare providers are obligated to provide the form of treatment prescribed by the child's doctor, and this includes the ESDM.[19] FranceSince 2012, the Haute Autorité de Santé of France recognizes ESDM's efficacy and recommends that public healthcare institutions consider it as one of their options when treating autistic children.[20] United StatesAll 50 states have legislation requiring the coverage of autism treatments by private health insurance companies.[21][better source needed] The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention classifies the ESDM as an autism treatment.[22] References
|