It was started in the basement of the Holy Cross Polish National Church on St. Mark's. Ann Magnuson, who managed the club and hosted events, described it as home to:
"...pointy-toed hipsters, girls in rockabilly petticoats, spandex pants, and thrift-store stiletto heels... suburban refugees who had run away from home to find a new family ... who liked the things we liked — Devo, Duchamp, and William S. Burroughs — and (more important) hated the things we hated — disco, Diane von Fürstenberg, and The Waltons."[2]
Magnuson describes a "Punk Do-It-Yourself aesthetic" which inspired events such as:
A theatrical remake of "The Bad Seed" by Andy Rees
Erotic Day-Glo art shows
Theme parties (or "enviroteques")
Putt-Putt Reggae Night (miniature golf played on a course made of refrigerator boxes designed to resemble a Jamaican shantytown)
Model World of Glue Night (New York's hippest built airplane and monster models, burned them, and sniffed the epoxy)[2]
Tom Scully and Susan Hannaford ran a Monster Movie club on Tuesday nights. Drew Staub remembers that at 9:00 pm on Tuesdays, “They’d show the really worst monster movie that they could find. And everybody would scream and drink and carry on. I was the house critic of the movie.... I was known for that, and it used to gain me free admission.”[3] (Hannaford relocated to Berlin and opened the Berlin Tea Room in August 2006.)[citation needed]
Keith Haring used to perform from inside a fake television set, and read his "neo-dada poems"[4] at the Club 57 Wednesday night poetry readings,[5] and later put on evenings and exhibitions there. He curated the "Black Light Show" there, an early show of his own works (1981), and an exhibition of Kenny Scharf's hand-customized appliances.
Artist Scott Covert cofounded Playhouse 57 with Andy Rees at Club 57.[6]
Besides Magnuson's input, the main contribution to the Club 57 style was from School of Visual Arts undergraduate students (including Haring, Holliday, Scharf, and Sex), who used it as a playground. “At Club 57 there were drugs and promiscuity — it was one big orgy family. Sometimes I’d look around and say, 'Oh, my God! I’ve had sex with everybody in this room!'[7] It was just the spirit of the times — and it was before AIDS," remembers Scharf. "Everybody there was either living together or sleeping together." Drew Staub agreed.[3] Scharf recalls that "Ann Magnuson may have been twenty-four, but she was like our mom."[3] Jean-Michel Basquiat fell out with Kenny Scharf, in part over Club 57: "esthetically I really hated Club 57. I thought it was silly. All this old and bad shit. I’d rather see something old and good.”[8]
Other contributors included Shawn McQuate the Great aka AMMO, dancer, performance-artist and designer. Stacey Elkin and Shawn were known as the fashion designers of the club, and made costumes for many of the Club 57 performers, like Magnuson, Scharf, and model and artist Kitty Brophy. McQuate the Great/Shawn AMMO was John Sex's boyfriend for two years during the early club days. McQuate did several happenings, including having 50 performance artists performing at the same time, in Universal Interaction 1981. Also, Ande Whyland, Robert Carrithers, Minn Thometz-Sanchez and so many others played a vital role in the club's aesthetic.[citation needed]
In 1981 Steve Mass of the Mudd Club began showing up at Club 57, and began hiring members of the Club 57 crowd to help acquire part of that scene. Haring was later hired to curate shows at the Mudd Club.[8]
Club 57 closed in the early 1980s – "around 1983", according to Magnuson[2] – after the community of artists moved on to larger and more expensive venues, and many concurrently began to suffer from AIDS.[9]
Since Club 57’s closure, the building that once housed has become a voluntary not-for-profit behavioral health and primary care clinic.[10]
The club was the subject of Club 57: Film, Performance, and Art in the East Village, 1978–1983, an exhibition held at the Museum of Modern Art in 2017.[9]
Reynolds, Simon (February 2006). Rip It Up and Start Again: Postpunk 1978-1984. Penguin Books. pp. 264–266, 278–279.
Van Pee, Yasmine (2004). Boredom is always counterrevolutionary : art in downtown New York nightclubs, 1978-1985 (MA thesis). Center for Curatorial Studies at Bard College.