There may have been a concert garden on the site as early as the 1880s, but there was a theatre there by 1904.[2] During the heyday of Yiddish theatre in the Yiddish Theater District in Manhattan, the venue was the Player's Theatre, and was part of the "Jewish Rialto" along Second Avenue.[3] By the 1920s, the theatre was exhibiting films, but was converted back to dramatic use in 1958,[2] with the first production, Little Mary Sunshine, opening in November 1959.[4]