Allegations of unlawful campaigning in the 2016 EU referendum
Several allegations of unlawful campaigning in the 2016 EU referendum have been made. Some allegations were dismissed by the investigating bodies, but in other cases wrongdoing was established, leading to the imposition of penalties. Sanctions have included the levying of the maximum fine possible on Facebook for breaches of data privacy.
On 4 March 2017, the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) reported that it was 'conducting a wide assessment of the data-protection risks arising from the use of data analytics, including for political purposes' in relation to the Brexit campaign.[1][2] In May 2017, the ICO also launched an investigation into the use of data analytics for political purposes, making reference to both the EU referendum and the 2015 general election.[3][4][5] In March 2018 The Economist had still opined that breaches of electoral law were unlikely to have had a substantive effect on the outcome of the EU Referendum: "Does any of this matter beyond Westminster? If Vote Leave is found to have breached the rules, that will support the notion that Leavers played fast and loose in 2016. Yet Remainers spent a lot more, and benefited from a government leaflet costing £9m that openly backed their cause. On the evidence so far, it is hard to conclude that the 52:48 result was changed by digital marketing, however cleverly done."[6]
In July 2018, the Information Commissioner's Office main report was published and showed it was investigating a number of bodies for unlawful use of data during the EU Referendum—particularly the unlawful passing of data from one organisation to another.[7] The investigation was at that point ongoing due to an appeal by UKIP, which was rejected in February 2019.[8][9] In April 2019, the investigation was in this respect ongoing.[5] In November 2019 it was reported that the ICO would next report is spring 2020 or later.[10]
The sections below report penalties and enforcement notices that have been issued.
Vote Leave
On 19 March 2019, Vote Leave was fined £40,000 for sending 196,154 unsolicited electronic messages to people who had not given consent for their contact details to be used for these purposes.[11][12]
On 24 October 2018, the Information Commissioner's Office served a legal notice requiring AggregateIQ Data Services Ltd to 'erase any personal data of individuals in the UK'.[19]
Facebook
On 24 October 2018, the Office found that between 2007 and 2014, Facebook had broken the UK data law then in force, the Data Protection Act 1998, and applied £500,000, the highest penalty allowed under that Act, noting that under more recent legislation, the General Data Protection Regulation the fine would have been much higher. Facebook allowed application developers to access people's data "without sufficiently clear and informed consent" and failed to keep their personal information secure, which allowed Aleksandr Kogan and his company Global Science Research to harvest the data of as many as 87 million people worldwide (including at least one million in the UK) to share a subset of this data further, including with SCL Group, the parent company of Cambridge Analytica. Facebook also did not act firmly enough to ensure that, once known, these data breaches were remedied.[20][21] In July 2019, it was reported that Facebook would be fined around $5bn by the US Federal Trade Commission in relation to the same and related issues.[22]
Electoral Commission (2017-2018)
Spending returns
In February 2017, the Electoral Commission announced that it was investigating the spending of Britain Stronger in Europe and Vote Leave, and smaller organisations, as they had not submitted all the necessary invoices, receipts, or details to back up their accounts.[23]
In the ensuing months, it levied a number of fines on political parties and other campaign entities for breaching campaign finance rules during the referendum campaign, with £20,000 as the maximum possible fine under the law .[24] Fines of £1000 or more were:
The Electoral Commission fined the Constitutional Research Council for not declaring its donation of £435,000 to the DUP, though the Electoral Commission found that the DUP had not itself broken electoral law.[31] Press speculation continued, both on the question of the ultimate source(s) of the Constitutional Research Council's donation, and the legitimacy of its use, which included £282,000 for pro-Brexit advertising in the Metro newspaper, which does not circulate in Northern Ireland.[26][32] In December 2018, the Good Law Project initiated judicial proceedings over the commission's decision not to investigate further.[33] In August 2018 the Electoral Commission noted that 'The Commission continues to be prohibited by legislation from disclosing any information concerning donations to Northern Ireland recipients made prior to 1 July 2017 (section 71 of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000). We continue to urge the UK Government to bring forward legislation that will enable us to publish information on donations from January 2014.'[34]
Campaign spending
Arron Banks, Better for the Country, and Leave.EU
Leave.EU ran a separate campaign to the official pro-Brexit group Vote Leave.[2][35] In May 2018, the Electoral Commission gave Leave.EU the maximum available fine of £20,000 for unlawfully overspending. Leave.EU failed to include in its referendum spending return spending of £77,380 in fees paid to the company "Better for the Country Limited" as its campaign organiser. Leave.EU also paid for services from the US campaign strategy firm Goddard Gunster which were not reported in its spending return.[28]
The Commission concluded that the overspend exceeded the statutory spending limit by over 10% – and that 'the actual figure was in fact greater'.[36] The Electoral Commission's director of political finance and regulation and legal counsel said that the "level of fine we have imposed has been constrained by the cap on the commission's fines".[36][37] In May 2018, Leave.EU's co-founder Arron Banks stated that he rejected the outcome of the investigation and would be challenging it in court.[38]
Vote Leave and BeLeave
In March 2017, the Electoral Commission cleared Vote Leave of breaking spending limits, but in October 2017 it re-opened the investigation due to new evidence.[39] In July 2018, it found Vote Leave to have broken electoral law, spending over its limit.[40] Not declaring £675,000 incurred under a common plan with Darren Grimes´ Brexit campaign BeLeave, Vote Leave unlawfully overspent its £7m limit by £449,079. The Electoral Commission referred the matter to the police.[39]
Date
Organisation
Cause
Penalty
Sources
17 July 2018
Vote Leave
Breaching statutory spending limit (responsible person: David Alan Halsall).
In September 2018, the High Court of Justice found that Vote Leave had received incorrect advice from the UK Electoral Commission, but confirmed that the overspending had been illegal. Vote Leave said they would not have overspent without the inaccurate advice and declared that they would appeal against their fine.[43][44] In March 2019 Vote Leave announced that they would not make an appeal.[45]
Vote Leave attempted to prosecute the Electoral Commission for publishing its July 2018 report 'Report of an investigation in respect of: Vote Leave Limited, Mr Darren Grimes, BeLeave, Veterans for Britain', alleging that it had caused 'reputational damage', but their request for judicial review was rejected in January 2019, since the Electoral Commission's publication had been lawful.[46]
Metropolitan Police and Crown Prosecution Service (2018-present)
Having established that the Vote Leave and BeLeave campaigns had broken electoral law in July 2018, the Electoral Commission passed files to the Metropolitan Police Service for criminal investigation on the 19th of that month.[39][47]
As the police investigation proceeded, high-profile political interventions took place. On 16 October 2018, a cross-party group of 77 MPs, including members of all the large parties, wrote to the Metropolitan Police and National Crime Agency to express concern that criminal investigations had perhaps stalled, and were told that investigations were ongoing.[48][49]
In June 2019, Ben Bradshaw (Labour MP), Caroline Lucas (Green MP), Tom Brake (Liberal Democrat MP), Jenny Jones (Green lord) and Fiona Mactaggart (former Labour MP) applied for judicial review of the Metropolitan Police, arguing that criminal investigations had been unjustifiably delayed. The Metropolitan Police reported again that investigation was ongoing.[50] In October 2019, the Metropolitan Police passed a file on their investigation to the Crown Prosecution Service for 'early investigative advice'.[47][51]
Venice Commission (since 2019)
On 19 June 2019, a cross-party group of 38 of the 73 UK Members of the European Parliament wrote to the Venice Commission, a body of the Council of Europe charged with assisting Council members regarding constitutional law, to request an investigation into "the breach of spending rules and data-protection laws" and "the exclusion of non-UK EU citizens residing in the UK from the franchise".[52]
In July 2018, the House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee released an interim report on Disinformation and ‘fake news’, stating that the largest donor in the Brexit campaign, Arron Banks, had "failed to satisfy" the Committee that his donations came from UK sources, and may have been financed by the Russian government.[54] In February 2019, the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport select committee's 18-month investigation into disinformation and fake news published its final report,[55] calling for an inquiry to establish, in relation to the referendum, “what actually happened with regard to foreign influence, disinformation, funding, voter manipulation, and the sharing of data, so that appropriate changes to the law can be made and lessons can be learnt for future elections and referenda”.[56]
European Parliament (2016–2019)
In 2016–18, the European Parliament found that the Alliance for Direct Democracy in Europe (ADDE), a group of European political parties led by the UK Independence Party (UKIP), had misspent over €500,000 of EU funding. Some of this was on UKIP's 2015 UK election campaign and opinion polling during the 2016 Brexit referendum campaign. The Parliament required the repayment of the funds and denied the organisations some other funding.[57][58]
In 2019, the European Court of Justice overturned the European Parliament's decision to ask the ADDE to repay money and to deny them further grant money, stating that the parliament had not been impartial when making its decision.[59] "The court also rejected the parliament's claim that ... ADDE had broken EU spending rules by spending public funds on an opinion poll before the 2016 Brexit referendum."[59]
Other allegations
National Crime Agency and Metropolitan Police
In November 2017, the Electoral Commission said that it was investigating allegations relating to the funding sources of funding of pro-Brexit organisations, specifically that Arron Banks, an insurance businessman and the largest single financial supporter of the Brexit campaign, violated campaign spending laws.[60] From 1 November 2017 to 1 November 2018, the Electoral Commission investigated the source of £8m paid to the closely associated organisations Leave.EU and Better for the Country Ltd., a company of which Banks was a director and majority shareholder.[61][62] The company donated £2.4 million to groups supporting British withdrawal from the EU.[60] The investigation began after the Commission found "initial grounds to suspect breaches of electoral law".[63] The Commission specifically sought to determine "whether or not Mr Banks was the true source of loans reported by a referendum campaigner in his name" and "whether or not Better for the Country Limited was the true source of donations made to referendum campaigners in its name, or if it was acting as an agent".[60][64]
The Commission found reasonable grounds for suspecting that 'various criminal offences may have been committed'.[62] Different aspects of the case were referred to the National Crime Agency and Metropolitan Police for criminal investigation. On 13 September 2019, the Metropolitan Police concluded that while "it is clear that whilst some technical breaches of electoral law were committed by Leave.EU in respect of the spending return submitted for their campaign, there is insufficient evidence to justify any further criminal investigation",[65][66] and on 24 September 2019, the National Crime Agency said it had found no evidence of criminality in respect of the issues raised by the Electoral Commission and that no further action would be taken.[67]
Private prosecutions
In R (Wilson) v Prime Minister, the claimants argued that illegality through Russian interference, criminal overspending by Vote Leave and criminal investigation into the largest donor, Arron Banks, before and during the referendum undermined the integrity of the result, and rendered the decision to leave void. The case was not upheld.
In Ball v Johnson, Marcus J. Ball brought a crowdfunded case against the MP and Vote Leave chairman Boris Johnson, alleging misconduct in public office on the grounds that he knowingly lied when claiming that the UK sent £350m to the EU each week and that this could instead be spent on the National Health Service.[68] An initial court decision that Johnson was to be tried was overturned on 7 June 2019.[68][69]
^House of Commons Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, 'Disinformation and ‘fake news’: Final Report', Eighth Report of Session 2017–19 [HC 1791] (House of Commons, 18 February 2019).
House of Commons Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, 'Disinformation and ‘fake news’: Final Report', Eighth Report of Session 2017–19 [HC 1791] (House of Commons, 18 February 2019).
The front page of the Shamrock published on October 3, 1874. Irish weekly literary paper The ShamrockCategoriesIrish literature, culture, poetry, GaelicFrequencyWeeklyFounded1866First issue6 October 1866Final issue10 August 1912CountryIrelandBased inDublinLanguageEnglish The Shamrock was an Irish literary newspaper published in Dublin from 1866 to 1912.[1][2][3] It was a nationalist weekly publication printed and circulated every Saturday. Noteworthy illustrators, writ...
DNA reverse transcribed from RNA CDNA redirects here. For other uses, see CDNA (disambiguation). For the general property of complementarity in molecular biology, see Complementarity (molecular biology). For complementation tests used in genetics research, see Complementation (genetics). This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Compleme...
Pengepungan StrasbourgBagian dari Perang Prancis-PrusiaReruntuhan kota setelah pengepunganTanggal14 Agustus – 28 September 1870(1 bulan dan 2 minggu)LokasiStrasbourg, FranceHasil Kemenangan jermanPihak terlibat Kekaisaran Jerman Prusia Baden Württemberg French Empire French RepublicTokoh dan pemimpin August von Werder Jean-Jacques Uhrich Pasukan Korps Pengepungan Benteng StrasbourgKekuatan 40.000 pria366 senjata dan mortir 23.000 pria1.277 artileriKorb...
العلاقات السودانية الكرواتية السودان كرواتيا السودان كرواتيا تعديل مصدري - تعديل العلاقات السودانية الكرواتية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين السودان وكرواتيا.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه ال...
Voce principale: Associazione Calcio Reggiana 1919. AC Reggiana 1919Stagione 2012-2013Sport calcio Squadra Reggiana Allenatore Lamberto Zauli[1], poi Luigi Apolloni[2], poi Lamberto Zauli Presidente Alessandro Barilli Lega Pro Prima Divisione15º nel girone A (salva dopo aver vinto i play-out) Coppa ItaliaPrimo turno Coppa Italia Lega ProSecondo turno Maggiori presenzeCampionato: Iraci (30)Totale: Iraci (31) Miglior marcatoreCampionato: P. Rossi (6)Totale: P. Rossi (7) S...
Riccardo Sebellin Riccardo Sebellin (Vicenza, 15 settembre 1847 – Vicenza, 4 settembre 1925) è stato un imprenditore, politico e dirigente sportivo italiano, noto per essere stato l'ottavo presidente del Vicenza Calcio dal 1920 al 1925. Indice 1 Biografia 2 Note 3 Bibliografia 4 Voci correlate 5 Collegamenti esterni Biografia Appartenente a una ricca famiglia imprenditoriale, i cui avi si erano trasferiti a Rossano già all'inizio del XVIII secolo,[1] Riccardo Sebellin fu sindaco d...
Paul Gottlieb Nipkow (1884 circa) Paul Julius Gottlieb Nipkow (Lauenburg in Pomerania, 22 agosto 1860 – Berlino, 24 agosto 1940) è stato un inventore tedesco. Indice 1 Inizi 2 Il disco di Nipkow 3 Primi sistemi televisivi 4 Trasmettitore Paul Nipkow 5 Note 6 Altri progetti 7 Collegamenti esterni Inizi Mentre era a scuola a Neustadt, Nipkow fece degli esperimenti nella telefonia e nella trasmissione di immagini in movimento. Dopo il diploma, si trasferì a Berlino per studiare scienze. Egli...
Genus of flowering plants in the spurge family Euphorbiaceae Not to be confused with Euphoria. For the family commonly called euphorbias and spurge family, see Euphorbiaceae. Euphorbia Euphorbia serrata Scientific classification Kingdom: Plantae Clade: Tracheophytes Clade: Angiosperms Clade: Eudicots Clade: Rosids Order: Malpighiales Family: Euphorbiaceae Subfamily: Euphorbioideae Tribe: Euphorbieae Subtribe: EuphorbiinaeGriseb. Genus: EuphorbiaL. Type species Euphorbia antiquorumL. Subgenera...
Process of copying a segment of DNA into RNA This article is about transcription in biology. For other uses, see Transcription. Part of a series onGenetics Key components Chromosome DNA RNA Genome Heredity Nucleotide Mutation Genetic variation Allele Amino acid Outline Index History and topics Introduction History Evolution (molecular) Population genetics Mendelian inheritance Quantitative genetics Molecular genetics Research Geneticist DNA sequencing Genetic engineering Genomics ( template) ...
Species of songbird Yellow-throated bulbul Conservation status Vulnerable (IUCN 3.1)[1] Scientific classification Domain: Eukaryota Kingdom: Animalia Phylum: Chordata Class: Aves Order: Passeriformes Infraorder: Passerides Family: Pycnonotidae Genus: Pycnonotus Species: P. xantholaemus Binomial name Pycnonotus xantholaemus(Jerdon, 1845) Synonyms Brachypus xantholaemus[2][3] Ixos xantholaemus The yellow-throated bulbul (Pycnonotus xantholaemus) is a species o...
American architect (1837–1915) George B. Post6th President of the American Institute of ArchitectsIn office1896–1898Preceded byDaniel H. BurnhamSucceeded byHenry Van Brunt Personal detailsBorn(1837-12-15)December 15, 1837Manhattan, New YorkDiedNovember 28, 1913(1913-11-28) (aged 75)Bernardsville, New JerseySpouse Alice Matilda Stone (after 1863)Children5Alma materNew York UniversitySignature George Browne Post (December 15, 1837 –...
Municipality and town in Antioquia Department, ColombiaSan Juan de UrabáMunicipality and town FlagSealLocation of the municipality and town of San Juan de Urabá in the Antioquia Department of ColombiaSan Juan de UrabáLocation in ColombiaCoordinates: 8°46′0″N 76°32′0″W / 8.76667°N 76.53333°W / 8.76667; -76.53333Country ColombiaDepartment Antioquia DepartmentSubregionUrabáPopulation (Census 2018[1]) • Total19,992Time zoneUTC-...
British television panel show Have I Got News for YouAlso known as HIGNFY Have I Got a Little Bit More News for You Have I Got a Bit More News for You Have I Got Old News for You Have I Got a Bit More Old News for You GenreComedy panel gamePolitical satireCreated by Jimmy Mulville Presented by Angus Deayton (1990–2002) Guest presenters (2002–present) Starring Ian Hislop Paul Merton (except for series 11) Guest panelists (series 11 only) Country of originUnited KingdomOriginal languageEngl...
Berikut adalah daftar marga angota suku kapas-kapasan atau Malvaceae (s.l., arti luas). Marga dikelompokkan berdasarkan anaksuku masing-masing. Bombacoideae Dalam klasifikasi yang lebih awal anaksuku ini dianggap sebagai suku (famili) Bombacaceae. Ciri-ciri dasar. Terna atau pohon/perdu; daun berseling, biasanya berbentuk tangan, berlekuk, dengan stipula kecil. Bunga hermafrodit, aktinomorf; kelopak lima helai, bergabung di pangkal, sering kali disertai dengan epicalyx; mahkota lima helai, te...
Study of classical optics using Fourier transforms Fourier optics is the study of classical optics using Fourier transforms (FTs), in which the waveform being considered is regarded as made up of a combination, or superposition, of plane waves. It has some parallels to the Huygens–Fresnel principle, in which the wavefront is regarded as being made up of a combination of spherical wavefronts (also called phasefronts) whose sum is the wavefront being studied. A key difference is that Fourier ...
This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources. Find sources: IBM RFID Information Center – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (March 2021) (Learn how and when to remove this message) The IBM RFID Information Center (RFIDIC) software solution is based on EPCglobal's Electronic Product Code Information Services (EPCIS) standard specification. RFID Information...
Sum of inverse squares of natural numbers Part of a series of articles on themathematical constant π 3.1415926535897932384626433... Uses Area of a circle Circumference Use in other formulae Properties Irrationality Transcendence Value Less than 22/7 Approximations Madhava's correction term Memorization People Archimedes Liu Hui Zu Chongzhi Aryabhata Madhava Jamshīd al-Kāshī Ludolph van Ceulen François Viète Seki Takakazu Takebe Kenko William Jones John Machin William Shanks Srinivasa Ra...
Pasunda BubatDate1357LocationBubat square, Trowulan, Majapahit, JavaResult Majapahit victoryTerritorialchanges Sunda kingdom annexed by the Kingdom of Majapahit as per some sources while it maintain its autonomy as per others.Belligerents Majapahit Empire Sunda KingdomCommanders and leaders Gajah Mada Maharaja Lingga Buana †Strength Large number of Majapahit troops stationed in Majapahit capital, exact number unknown The Sundanese royal family, the state officials, servants, guards...