Vulture.com listed "Keep What You Have Built Up Here" as number 87 of the 100 greatest emo songs.[2]Spin ranked the album number 13 out of the 30 best emo revival albums, writing that the album had "garnered a mythical cult status" after its release.[3]
Track listing
"How to Make Love Stay" – 4:24
"Keep What You Have Built Up Here" – 5:09
"What Safe Means" – 4:01
"It Happened Because You Left" – 8:09
"Rally the Troops! Poke Holes In Their Defenses! Line Our Coffers with Their Coffins!" – 4:23
"It's a Plague, and You're Invited" – 4:11
"Everything Is Connected and Everything Matters (A Temporary Solution to a Permanent Problem)" – 4:01
"The Next Step to Regaining Control" – 6:08
"With Your Greatest Fears Realized, You Will Not Be Comforted" – 3:07
"I Am a Snail, and You Are a Pace I Cannot Match" – 5:14
"An Idea Is a Greater Monument Than a Cathedral" – 6:52