Simon Reynolds from Melody Maker complimented the production as "amazing, an irresistibly compulsive phuture-phunk mélange of slick soul melody turbo-boosted with hip hop beats."[2] Pan-European magazine Music & Media described it as a "poignant swingbeat tune".[3] Andy Beevers from Music Week rated it four out of five and named it Pick of the Week in the category of Dance, writing, "This excellent single from the teenage female trio, Sisters With Voices, has been the most in-demand US import for the past couple of weeks. Its not hard to see why with its combination of tight soul harmonies and supremely funky mixes from Teddy Riley and Allen Gordon." He concluded that it "should go a long way towards establishing them as a tougher alternative to En Vogue."[4]
Track listings
UK CD single
"I'm So into You" (Allstar's Drop Check Dance Mix)
"I'm So into You" (Allstar's 12" Drop Mix)
"I'm So into You" (Teddy's Extended Mix)
"I'm So into You" (Allstar's Drop Radio Mix)
"I'm So into You" (Teddy's Radio Mix)
US CD maxi single
"I'm So into You" (Teddy's Radio Mix) – 4:35
"I'm So into You" (Teddy's Radio Mix With Rap) – 4:16
"I'm So into You" (Allstar's Drop Radio Mix) – 4:47
"I'm So into You" (Allstar's 12" Drop Mix For Radio) – 5:15
"I'm So into You" (Allstar's Drop Check Dance Mix) – 5:51
"I'm So into You" (Teddy's Extended Mix With Rap) – 5:05
"I'm So into You" (Teddy's Instrumental Bonus) – 5:33
"I'm So into You" (Radio Remix With Rap) – 4:12
US cassette single
A1: "I'm So into You" (Original Radio Version/Video Version) – 4:07
A2: "I'm So into You" (12" Funky Club Mix) – 6:21
B1: "I'm So into You2 (The Funkstrumental Vocal Dub Mix) – 6:10