Deepfake pornography, or simply fake pornography, is a type of synthetic pornography that is created via altering already-existing photographs or video by applying deepfake technology to the images of the participants. The use of deepfake pornography has sparked controversy because it involves the making and sharing of realistic videos featuring non-consenting individuals, typically female celebrities, and is sometimes used for revenge porn. Efforts are being made to combat these ethical concerns through legislation and technology-based solutions.
History
The term "deepfake" was coined in 2017 on a Reddit forum where users shared altered pornographic videos created using machine learning algorithms. It is a combination of the word "deep learning", which refers to the program used to create the videos, and "fake" meaning the videos are not real.[1]
Deepfake pornography was originally created on a small individual scale using a combination of machine learning algorithms, computer vision techniques, and AI software. The process began by gathering a large amount of source material (including both images and videos) of a person's face, and then using a deep learning model to train a Generative Adversarial Network to create a fake video that convincingly swaps the face of the source material onto the body of a pornographic performer. However, the production process has significantly evolved since 2018, with the advent of several public apps that have largely automated the process.[2]
Deepfake pornography is sometimes confused with fake nude photography, but the two are mostly different. Fake nude photography typically uses non-sexual images and merely makes it appear that the people in them are nude.
Notable cases
Deepfake technology has been used to create non-consensual and pornographic images and videos of famous women. One of the earliest examples occurred in 2017 when a deepfake pornographic video of Gal Gadot was created by a Reddit user and quickly spread online. Since then, there have been numerous instances of similar deepfake content targeting other female celebrities, such as Emma Watson, Natalie Portman, and Scarlett Johansson.[3] Johansson spoke publicly on the issue in December 2018, condemning the practice but also refusing legal action because she views the harassment as inevitable.[4]
Rana Ayyub
In 2018, Rana Ayyub, an Indian investigative journalist, was the target of an online hate campaign stemming from her condemnation of the Indian government, specifically her speaking out against the rape of an eight-year-old Kashmiri girl. Ayyub was bombarded with rape and death threats, and had doctored pornographic video of her circulated online.[5] In a Huffington Post article, Ayyub discussed the long-lasting psychological and social effects this experience has had on her. She explained that she continued to struggle with her mental health and how the images and videos continued to resurface whenever she took a high-profile case.[6]
Atrioc controversy
In 2023, Twitch streamer Atrioc stirred controversy when he accidentally revealed deepfake pornographic material featuring female Twitch streamers while on live. The influencer has since admitted to paying for AI generated porn, and apologized to the women and his fans.[7][8]
In January 2024, AI-generated sexually explicit images of American singer Taylor Swift were posted on X (formerly Twitter), and spread to other platforms such as Facebook, Reddit and Instagram.[9][10][11] One tweet with the images was viewed over 45 million times before being removed.[12][10] A report from 404 Media found that the images appeared to have originated from a Telegram group, whose members used tools such as Microsoft Designer to generate the images, using misspellings and keyword hacks to work around Designer's content filters.[13][14] After the material was posted, Swift's fans posted concert footage and images to bury the deepfake images, and reported the accounts posting the deepfakes.[15] Searches for Swift's name were temporarily disabled on X, returning an error message instead.[16]Graphika, a disinformation research firm, traced the creation of the images back to a 4chan community.[17][18]
A source close to Swift told the Daily Mail that she would be considering legal action, saying, "Whether or not legal action will be taken is being decided, but there is one thing that is clear: These fake AI-generated images are abusive, offensive, exploitative, and done without Taylor's consent and/or knowledge."[15][19]
It emerged in South Korea in August 2024 that many teachers and female students were victims of deepfake images created by users who utilized AI technology. Journalist Ko Narin of The Hankyoreh uncovered the deepfake images through Telegram chats.[26][27][28] On Telegram, group chats were created specifically for image-based sexual abuse of women, including middle and high school students, teachers, and even family members. Women with photos on social media platforms like KakaoTalk, Instagram, and Facebook are often targeted as well. Perpetrators use AI bots to generate fake images, which are then sold or widely shared, along with the victims’ social media accounts, phone numbers, and KakaoTalk usernames. One Telegram group reportedly drew around 220,000 members, according to a Guardian report.
Investigations revealed numerous chat groups on Telegram where users, mainly teenagers, create and share explicit deepfake images of classmates and teachers. The issue came in the wake of a troubling history of digital sex crimes, notably the notorious Nth Room case in 2019. The Korean Teachers Union estimated that more than 200 schools had been affected by these incidents. Activists called for a "national emergency" declaration to address the problem.[29] South Korean police reported over 800 deepfake sex crime cases by the end of September 2024, a stark rise from just 156 cases in 2021, with most victims and offenders being teenagers.[30]
On September 21, 6,000 people gathered at Marronnier Park in northeastern Seoul to demand stronger legal action against deepfake crimes targeting women.[31] On September 26, following widespread outrage over the Telegram scandal, South Korean lawmakers passed a bill criminalizing the possession or viewing of sexually explicit deepfake images and videos, imposing penalties that include prison terms and fines. Under the new law, those caught buying, saving, or watching such material could face up to three years in prison or fines up to 30 million won ($22,600). At the time the bill was proposed, creating sexually explicit deepfakes for distribution carried a maximum penalty of five years, but the new legislation would increase this to seven years, regardless of intent.[30]
By October 2024 it was estimated that "nudify" deep fake bots on Telegram were up to four million monthly users.[32][33]
Ethical considerations
Deepfake CSAM
Deepfake technology has made the creation of child sexual abuse material (CSAM), also known as child pornography, faster and easier than it has ever been. Deepfakes can be used to produce new CSAM from already existing material or creating CSAM from children who have not been subjected to sexual abuse. Deepfake CSAM can, however, have real and direct implications on children including defamation, grooming, extortion, and bullying.[34]
While both deepfake pornography and generative AI pornography utilize synthetic media, they differ in approach and ethical implications.[35] Generative AI pornography is created entirely through algorithms, producing hyper-realistic content unlinked to real individuals.[36][37] In contrast, Deepfake pornography alters existing footage of real individuals, often without consent, by superimposing faces or modifying scenes.[38][39]Hany Farid, a digital image analysis expert, has emphasized these distinctions.[40]
Consent
Most deepfake pornography is made using the faces of people who did not consent to their image being used in such a sexual way. In 2023, Sensity, an identify verification company, has found that "96% of deepfakes are sexually explicit and feature women who didn’t consent to the creation of the content."[41]
Combatting deepfake pornography
Technical approach
Deepfake detection has become an increasingly important area of research in recent years as the spread of fake videos and images has become more prevalent. One promising approach to detecting deepfakes is through the use of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs), which have shown high accuracy in distinguishing between real and fake images. One CNN-based algorithm that has been developed specifically for deepfake detection is DeepRhythm, which has demonstrated an impressive accuracy score of 0.98 (i.e. successful at detecting deepfake images 98% of the time). This algorithm utilizes a pre-trained CNN to extract features from facial regions of interest and then applies a novel attention mechanism to identify discrepancies between the original and manipulated images. While the development of more sophisticated deepfake technology presents ongoing challenges to detection efforts, the high accuracy of algorithms like DeepRhythm offers a promising tool for identifying and mitigating the spread of harmful deepfakes.[1]
Aside from detection models, there are also video authenticating tools available to the public. In 2019, Deepware launched the first publicly available detection tool which allowed users to easily scan and detect deepfake videos. Similarly, in 2020 Microsoft released a free and user-friendly video authenticator. Users upload a suspected video or input a link, and receive a confidence score to assess the level of manipulation in a deepfake.
Legal approach
As of 2023, there is a lack of legislation that specifically addresses deepfake pornography. Instead, the harm caused by its creation and distribution is being addressed by the courts through existing criminal and civil laws.[42]
Victims of deepfake pornography often have claims for revenge porn, tort claims, and harassment.[43] The legal consequences for revenge porn vary from state to state and country to country.[43][44] For instance, in Canada, the penalty for publishing non-consensual intimate images is up to 5 years in prison,[45] whereas in Malta it is a fine of up to €5,000.[46]
The "Deepfake Accountability Act" was introduced to the United States Congress in 2019 but died in 2020.[47] It aimed to make the production and distribution of digitally altered visual media that was not disclosed to be such, a criminal offense. The title specifies that making any sexual, non-consensual altered media with the intent of humiliating or otherwise harming the participants, may be fined, imprisoned for up to 5 years or both.[44] A newer version of bill was introduced in 2021 which would have required any "advanced technological false personation records" to contain a watermark and an audiovisual disclosure to identify and explain any altered audio and visual elements. The bill also includes that failure to disclose this information with intent to harass or humiliate a person with an "advanced technological false personation record" containing sexual content "shall be fined under this title, imprisoned for not more than 5 years, or both." However this bill has since died in 2023.[48]
In the United Kingdom, the Law Commission for England and Wales recommended reform to criminalise sharing of deepfake pornography in 2022.[49] In 2023, the government announced amendments to the Online Safety Bill to that end. The Online Safety Act 2023 amends the Sexual Offences Act 2003 to criminalise sharing intimate images that shows or "appears to show" another (thus including deepfake images) without consent.[50] In 2024, the Government announced that an offence criminalising the production of deepfake pornographic images would be included in the Criminal Justice Bill of 2024.[51][52] The Bill did not pass before Parliament was dissolved before the general election.
Controlling the distribution
While the legal landscape remains undeveloped, victims of deepfake pornography have several tools available to contain and remove content, including securing removal through a court order, intellectual property tools like the DMCA takedown, reporting for terms and conditions violations of the hosting platform, and removal by reporting the content to search engines.[53]
Several major online platforms have taken steps to ban deepfake pornography. As of 2018, gfycat, reddit, Twitter, Discord, and Pornhub have all prohibited the uploading and sharing of deepfake pornographic content on their platforms.[54][55] In September of that same year, Google also added "involuntary synthetic pornographic imagery" to its ban list, allowing individuals to request the removal of such content from search results.[56]
^Kirchengast, T (2020). "Deepfakes and image manipulation: criminalisation and control". Information & Communications Technology Law. 29 (3): 308–323. doi:10.1080/13600834.2020.1794615. S2CID221058610.
Don Goodman Informasi pribadiTanggal lahir 9 Mei 1966 (umur 57)Tempat lahir InggrisPosisi bermain PenyerangKarier senior*Tahun Tim Tampil (Gol)1998 Sanfrecce Hiroshima * Penampilan dan gol di klub senior hanya dihitung dari liga domestik Don Goodman (lahir 9 Mei 1966) adalah pemain sepak bola asal Inggris. Karier Don Goodman pernah bermain untuk Sanfrecce Hiroshima. Pranala luar (Jepang) Profil dan statistik di situs web resmi J. League Data Site Artikel bertopik pemain sepak bola Inggr...
Beautiful TargetLagu oleh B1A4dari album It B1A4Dirilis16 September 2011 (2011-09-16)(lihat riwayat perilisan)FormatUnduhan digitalDirekam2011GenreK-pop, dance-popDurasi3:18LabelWM Entertainment Beautiful Target adalah lagu yang dirilis oleh boy band Korea Selatan B1A4. Lagu ini merupakan singel utama dari album mini kedua dari grup ini yaitu It B1A4, dirilis pada tanggal 16 September 2011.[1] The song was re-recorded in Japanese and used as the group's debut single in Japan, rel...
Faras HamdanLahir1910Tempat lahirBaqa al-Gharbiyye, Kekaisaran UtsmaniyahMeninggal dunia29 November 1966Knesset2, 3Faksi yang diwakili di Knesset1951–1959Pertanian dan Pembangunan Faras Hamdan (Arab: فارس حمدانcode: ar is deprecated ; Ibrani: פארס חמדאןcode: he is deprecated , kelahiran 1910, wafat 29 November 1966) adalah seorang politikus Arab Israel. Ia menjabat sebagai anggota Knesset untuk partai Pertanian dan Pembangunan antara 1951 dan 1959. Pranala luar Media terka...
George Kirke SpoorSpoor pada 1919Lahir(1871-12-18)18 Desember 1871Highland Park, IllinoisMeninggal24 November 1953(1953-11-24) (umur 81)[1]Chicago, IllinoisSuami/istriAda May Thompson (1877–1951)AnakGertrude Keith Spoor (1893–1975)Orang tuaMarvin Spoor (1839–1927) Catherine Stressinger (1853–1947) George Kirke Spoor (18 Desember 1871 – 24 November 1953) adalah seorang pionir film awal. Bersama dengan Gilbert M. Broncho Billy Anderson, ia mendirikan Essana...
Il negazionismo dell'Olocausto è una corrente di pensiero antistorica e antiscientifica[1] il cui principale assunto è la negazione della veridicità dell'Olocausto,[2] ossia del genocidio di ebrei, di Slavi, di prigionieri politici, di prigionieri di guerra sovietici, di Sinti, di portatori di handicap fisici e mentali, di omosessuali e di altre minoranze da parte della Germania nazista. Questa teorizzazione, attraverso l'uso spregiudicato e ideologizzato di uno scetticismo...
World War II Victory Medal World War II Victory Medal Dianugerahkan oleh Department of the ArmyDepartment of the Navy Jenis Medal Persyaratan penerima served in the armed forces between the following dates: antara 7 Desember 1941 dan 31 Desember 1946, untuk jasa militer apapun. Status Dipensiunkan Statistik Anugerah pertama 7 Desember 1941 Anugerah terakhir 31 Desember 1946 Tingkatan Lebih tinggi European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign Medal Lebih rendah Army of Occupation Medal o...
Stasiun Lamongan B07A20 Tampak dalam Stasiun Lamongan pada tahun 2022Lokasi Jalan Panglima Sudirman 27/Raya Gresik-BabatSidokumpul, Lamongan, Lamongan, Jawa Timur 62212IndonesiaKoordinat7°6′56″S 112°25′4″E / 7.11556°S 112.41778°E / -7.11556; 112.41778Koordinat: 7°6′56″S 112°25′4″E / 7.11556°S 112.41778°E / -7.11556; 112.41778Ketinggian+2 mOperator Kereta Api IndonesiaDaerah Operasi VIII Surabaya KAI Commuter Letakkm 188+5...
For other people with this last name, see Hageman (surname). Richard HagemanHageman in 1965Background informationBirth nameRichard HagemanBorn(1881-07-09)July 9, 1881Leeuwarden, Friesland, NetherlandsDiedMarch 6, 1966(1966-03-06) (aged 84)Beverly Hills, California, United StatesGenres20th-century classical music Film scoresOccupation(s)Composer, Songwriter, Conductor, PianistInstrument(s)PianoYears active1899–1954Musical artist Richard Hageman (9 July 1881 – 6 March 1966) was a Dutch...
Peta menunjukkan lokasi Enrique Villanueva Enrique Villanueva adalah munisipalitas yang terletak di provinsi Siquijor, Filipina. Pada tahun 2010, munisipalitas ini memiliki populasi sebesar 6.004 jiwa dan 1.371 rumah tangga. Pembagian wilayah Secara administratif Enrique Villanueva terbagi menjadi 14 barangay, yaitu: Balolong Bino-ongan Bitaug Bolot Camogao Cangmangki Libo Lomangcapan Lotloton Manan-ao Olave Parian Poblacion Tulapos Pranala luar Philippine Standard Geographic Code Diarsipkan ...
German curler Janet StrayerCurler ♀Curling career Member Association GermanyWorld Championshipappearances1 (1993) Medal record Curling World Championships 1993 Geneva German Women's Championship[1] 1993 Janet Strayer is a former German curler.[2] She is a 1993 World women's silver medallist. Teams Season Skip Third Second Lead Alternate Events 1992–93 Janet Strayer Josefine Einsle Petra Tschetsch-Hiltensberger Karin Fischer Elisabeth Ländle GWCC 1993 WCC 199...
Football clubFC GarejiFounded1960; 64 years ago (1960)GroundCentral stadium, SagarejoCapacity2,000ChairmanLazare DatunashviliCoachNestor MumladzeLeagueErovnuli Liga 220232nd in Liga 2 Home colours Away colours FC Gareji (Georgian: საფეხბურთო კლუბი გარეჯი) is a Georgian Association football club from Sagarejo, which currently takes part in Erovnuli Liga 2, the second tier of the national football league. The team has recently made hea...
1958 film by Gene Kelly This article is about the 1958 film. For other uses, see Tunnel of love. The Tunnel of loveTitle card from the trailerDirected byGene KellyScreenplay byJoseph FieldsBased onThe Tunnel of Love1954 novelby Peter De VriesProduced byJoseph Fields Martin MelcherStarringDoris Day Richard Widmark Gig Young Gia Scala Elisabeth Fraser Elizabeth WilsonCinematographyRobert J. BronnerEdited byJohn McSweeneyDistributed byMetro-Goldwyn-MayerRelease date November 21, 1958...
American author and politician (1903–1987) For the Broadway and movie actress, see Claire Luce. Clare Boothe LuceUnited States Ambassador to Italy In officeMay 4, 1953 – December 27, 1956PresidentDwight D. EisenhowerPreceded byEllsworth BunkerSucceeded byJames David ZellerbachMember of the U.S. House of Representativesfrom Connecticut's 4th districtIn officeJanuary 3, 1943 – January 3, 1947Preceded byLe Roy D. DownsSucceeded byJohn Lodge Personal detailsBor...
Lake in the state of Michigan, United States Budd LakeLooking south from Wilson State ParkBudd LakeShow map of MichiganBudd LakeShow map of the United StatesLocationClare County, MichiganCoordinates44°01′22″N 84°47′48″W / 44.02278°N 84.79667°W / 44.02278; -84.79667TypeLakeBasin countriesUnited StatesMax. length1.4 mi (2,300 m)Max. width0.25 mi (400 m)Surface area175 acres (0.7 km2)Max. depth35 ft (11 m)Surface elevat...
Ada usul agar Edward Howard Amstrong digabungkan ke artikel ini. (Diskusikan) Edwin H. ArmstrongDeveloped and advanced the utility of FM technology.Lahir(1890-12-18)18 Desember 1890New York, NYMeninggal31 Januari 1954(1954-01-31) (umur 63)Manhattan, New YorkPendidikanColumbia UniversityPekerjaanelectrical engineer and inventorDikenal atasinventor of FM radioSuami/istriMarion Edwin Howard Armstrong (18 Desember 1890 – 31 Januari 1954)[1] Kepintaran dan keuletannya ...