Sophistical Refutations

Part of a series on
Rhetoric
History
Concepts
Genres
Criticism
Rhetoricians
Works
Subfields
Related

Sophistical Refutations (Greek: Σοφιστικοὶ Ἔλεγχοι, romanized: Sophistikoi Elenchoi; Latin: De Sophisticis Elenchis) is a text in Aristotle's Organon in which he identified thirteen fallacies.[note 1] According to Aristotle, this is the first work to treat the subject of deductive reasoning in ancient Greece (Soph. Ref., 34, 183b34 ff.).

Overview

On Sophistical Refutations[1][2] consists of 34 chapters. The book naturally falls in two parts: chapters concerned with tactics for the Questioner (3–8 and 12–15) and chapters concerned with tactics for the Answerer (16–32). Besides, there is an introduction (1–2), an interlude (9–11), and a conclusion (33–34).[3]

Fallacies identified

The fallacies Aristotle identifies in Chapter 4 (formal fallacies) and 5 (informal fallacies) of this book are the following:

Fallacies in the language or formal fallacies (in dictionem):
  1. Equivocation
  2. Amphiboly
  3. Composition
  4. Division
  5. Accent
  6. Figure of speech or form of expression
Fallacies not in the language or informal fallacies (extra dictionem):

Footnotes

  1. ^ Sometimes listed as twelve.

References

  1. ^ Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. "On Sophistical Refutations". Retrieved 2020-12-19.
  2. ^ Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). "Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>". Retrieved 2020-12-19.
  3. ^ Krabbe, E.C.W. "Aristotle's On Sophistical Refutations. Topoi 31, 243–248 (2012)". doi:10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0. S2CID 170350834. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)

Further reading

  • Gysembergh, Victor (2023). Forgotten Ancient Commentaries on Aristotle's Sphistical Refutations: Fragments of Aspasios, Herminos, Alexander, Syrianos and Philoponos. Boston: De Gruyter. ISBN 9783111332666.

Read other articles:

User talk:Mike Christie

If I leave a message on your talk page, I'll keep your talk page on my watchlist until you reply (for a few days, at least), so you can reply here or on your talk page as you prefer. If you use a {{talkback}} template here, please sign it so the archive bot will archive it. For other discussions, there's no need to ping me if I've edited the page or section you have posted to; I'll be watching those pages for a week or so. Loch Muick Archives 1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · 6 · 7 · 8 · 9�...

Campeonato Asiático de Atletismo de 2019 - Salto com vara feminino

Campeonato AsiáticoAtletismo 2019 Provas de pista 100 m masc fem 200 m masc fem 400 m masc fem 800 m masc fem 1500 m masc fem 5000 m masc fem 10000 m masc fem 100 m com barreiras fem 110 m com barreiras masc 400 m com barreiras masc fem 3000 mcom obstáculos masc fem Revezamento 4×100 m masc fem Revezamento 4×400 m masc fem mis Provas de campo Salto em distância masc fem Salto triplo masc fem Salto em altura masc fem Salto com vara masc fem Arremesso de peso masc fem Lançamento d...

The Sea Wolf (film 1920)

The Sea WolfPoster filmSutradara George Melford ProduserDitulis olehWill M. Ritchey (skenario)BerdasarkanThe Sea Wolfoleh Jack LondonPemeranNoah Beery, Sr.SinematograferPaul P. PerryDistributorParamount Pictures / ArtcraftTanggal rilis 16 Mei 1920 (1920-05-16) Durasi70 menitNegara Amerika Serikat BahasaFilm bisu dengan antar judul Inggris The Sea Wolf adalah sebuah film drama Amerika Serikat tahun 1920 yang hilang[1] yang berdasarkan pada novel tahun 1904 karya Jack London, disut...

Felix Chung

Dalam artikel ini, nama keluarganya adalah Chung. Sesuai dengan kebiasaan Hong Kong, nama gaya Barat-nya adalah Felix Chung dan nama gaya Tionghoa-nya adalah Chung Kwok-pan. Felix Chung pada 2020 Felix Chung Hanzi tradisional: 鍾國斌 Alih aksara Yue (Kantonis) - Romanisasi Yale: Jūng Gwok bān - Jyutping: Zung1 Gwok3 ban1 Felix Chung Kwok-pan (Hanzi: 鍾國斌, lahir 4 November 1963) adalah anggota Dewan Legislatif Hong Kong saat ini mewakili Partai Liberal. Ia juga menjadi pemimpin P...

Tropospheric scatter

Method of communicating with microwave radio signals over considerable distances A tropospheric scatter system can bridge large distances while a microwave relay system (below) requires multiple relay stations due to its line of sight limitation. Boswell Bay, Alaska White Alice Site, Tropospheric scatter antenna and feeder. Pacific Scatter System Tropospheric scatter, also known as troposcatter, is a method of communicating with microwave radio signals over considerable distances – often up...

1910 Mexican general election

1910 Mexican general election ← 1904 June 26 and July 10, 1910 1911 → Presidential election   Nominee Porfirio Díaz Francisco I. Madero Party National Re-election Party National Anti-Re-election Party Popular vote 18,625 196 Percentage 98.93% 1.04% President before election Porfirio Díaz Elected President Porfirio Díaz Politics of Mexico Federal government Constitution of Mexico(history) Human rights LGBT rights Law Abortion Labor Nationality Capital punishm...

Johannes Ericson (1850–1894)

Johannes Ericson Född11 april 1850[1]Landa församling[1], SverigeDöd21 september 1894[1] (44 år)Chicago[1], USAMedborgare iSverigeSysselsättningPolitiker[1][2], lantbrukare[1]BefattningAndrakammarledamot (1888–1890)[1][2]Politiskt partiNya lantmannapartiet[1]Redigera Wikidata Johannes Ericson i riksdagen kallad Ericsson i Borekulla, född 11 april 1850 i Landa socken, Hallands län, död 21 september 1894 i Chicago, hemmansägare och riksdagsman. Ericson var ägare till ...

Теплоізоляційні матеріали

Теплоїзоляція будинку з використанням матів кам'яної вати (базальтової вати) Спінені теплоізолятори, що застосовуються при ізолюванні труб Теплоізоляці́йні матеріа́ли — матеріали, що відрізняються невеликою теплопровідністю. Використовуються для теплової ізоляці...

Delhi-class destroyer

Indian class of warships INS Delhi underway Class overview NameDelhi class BuildersMazagon Dock Limited Operators Indian Navy Preceded byRajput class Succeeded byKolkata class Built1987–2001 In commission1997–present Planned3 Completed3 Active3 General characteristics TypeGuided-missile destroyer Displacement6,200 tonnes (full)[1] Length163 m (535 ft) [1] Beam17 m (56 ft)[1] Draught6.5 m (21 ft)[1] Propulsion 2 × Zor...

Bone Ace

Bone AceA licking game for moneyThe Bone AceOriginEnglandAlternative namesBone-Ace, Bon AceTypeFishing gamePlayers7 or 8Cards52DeckEnglish pattern, French-suited Bone-Ace or Bon Ace is an historical English gambling game using playing cards for seven or eight players that appears related to Thirty-One. History Bone-Ace is recorded as early as 1611 in John Florio's The World of Wordes,[1] but its rules first appear in 1674 in Cotton's The Compleat Gamester where he describes it as triv...

Scapegoat Hill

Human settlement in EnglandScapegoat HillView of the villageScapegoat HillLocation within West YorkshirePopulation1,246 OS grid referenceSE0884016430Metropolitan boroughKirkleesMetropolitan countyWest YorkshireRegionYorkshire and the HumberCountryEnglandSovereign stateUnited KingdomPost townHUDDERSFIELDPostcode districtHD7Dialling code01484PoliceWest YorkshireFireWest YorkshireAmbulanceYorkshire UK ParliamentColne Valley List of places UK England Y...

Deklarasi Pillnitz

Pertemuan di Puri Pillnitz pada tahun 1791. Lukisan minyak oleh J. H. Schmidt, 1791. Deklarasi Pillnitz merupakan sebuah pernyataan yang dikeluarkan pada tanggal 27 Agustus 1791 di Istana Pillnitz, Sachsen antara kaisar Leopold II dan raja Friedrich Wilhelm II dari Prusia. Negosiasi ini membahas pertanyaan Polandia[1] (lihat Pemisahan Polandia) dan pertempuran antara Kekaisaran Romawi Suci dan Kesultanan Utsmaniyah. Setelah Louis XVI gagal melarikan diri dan ditangkap di Varennes, Kai...

Bloco do China

Bloco do China Fundação 25 de agosto de 1971 (52 anos) Cores Vermelho e branco[1] Símbolo Chinês[1] Bairro Parque Centenário Presidente Maria da Paz Jesus do Nascimento[1] O Bloco do China é um bloco de enredo da cidade de Duque de Caxias, no estado do Rio de Janeiro.[2] O bloco tem sua sede administrativa, quadra de ensaios, barracão e ateliê na rua Francisca Tomé, no bairro Centenário. No auge de sua fama, o bloco ensaiava na quadra do Colégio Estadual Senhor do Bonfim, ...

Ken Hamlin

American football player (born 1981) For the baseball player, see Ken Hamlin (baseball). American football player Ken HamlinHamlin during his tenure with the Cowboys.No. 26, 35Position:SafetyPersonal informationBorn: (1981-01-20) January 20, 1981 (age 42)Memphis, Tennessee, U.S.Height:6 ft 2 in (1.88 m)Weight:208 lb (94 kg)Career informationHigh school:Frayser (TN)College:ArkansasNFL Draft:2003 / Round: 2 / Pick: 42Career history Seattle Seaha...

El Avispón Verde (película)

The Green Hornet Título El Avispón VerdeFicha técnicaDirección Michel GondryProducción Neal H. MoritzDiseño de producción Owen PatersonGuion Seth RogenEvan GoldbergBasada en El Avispón Verde de George W. Trendle y Fran StrikerMúsica James Newton HowardFotografía John SchwartzmanMontaje Michael TronickVestuario Kym BarrettProtagonistas Seth RogenJay ChouCameron DiazChristoph Waltz Ver todos los créditos (IMDb)Datos y cifrasPaís  Estados UnidosAño 2011Estreno 14 de enero de 20...

Mark Teahen

American-Canadian baseball player Baseball player Mark TeahenTeahen with the Toronto Blue JaysThird baseman / Right fielderBorn: (1981-09-06) September 6, 1981 (age 42)Redlands, California, U.S.Batted: LeftThrew: RightMLB debutApril 4, 2005, for the Kansas City RoyalsLast MLB appearanceSeptember 28, 2011, for the Toronto Blue JaysMLB statisticsBatting average.264Home runs67Runs batted in332 Teams Kansas City Royals (2005–2009) Chicago White Sox (2010–201...

2 Tawarikh 2

2 Tawarikh 2Kitab Tawarikh (Kitab 1 & 2 Tawarikh) lengkap pada Kodeks Leningrad, dibuat tahun 1008.KitabKitab 2 TawarikhKategoriKetuvimBagian Alkitab KristenPerjanjian LamaUrutan dalamKitab Kristen14← pasal 1 pasal 3 → 2 Tawarikh 2 (atau II Tawarikh 2, disingkat 2Taw 2) adalah bagian dari Kitab 2 Tawarikh dalam Alkitab Ibrani dan Perjanjian Lama di Alkitab Kristen. Dalam Alkitab Ibrani termasuk dalam bagian Ketuvim (כְּתוּבִים, tulisan).[1][2] Teks Na...

Soyuz 7K-OK

Soyuz 7K-OKWahana Soyuz 7K-OK(A) dengan unit docking aktifProdusenKorolevNegara asal Uni SovietOperatorProgram luar angkasa Uni SovietAplikasimembawa tiga kosmonot ke orbit dan kembali SpesifikasiRegimeOrbit bumi rendah ProduksiStatusTidak beroperasiSelesai dibuat16Diluncurkan16Peluncuran pertamaKosmos 133, 1966Peluncuran terkiniSoyuz 9, 1970 Wahana antariksa terkaitPendahuluSoyuz-A (konsep)PenerusSoyuz 7K-OKS Soyuz 7K-T (suksesor) Soyuz 7K-OK merupakan wahana Soyuz generasi pertama yang...

New South Wales C30T class locomotive

New South Wales C30T class3001 at the NSW Rail Museum, ThirlmereType and originPower typeSteamBuilderBeyer, Peacock & CompanyEveleigh Railway WorkshopsBuild date1903 – 1917RebuilderClyde Engineering (10)Eveleigh Railway Workshops (67)Rebuild date1928 – 1933Number rebuilt77SpecificationsConfiguration:​ • Whyte4-6-0 • UIC2'ChGauge1,435 mm (4 ft 8+1⁄2 in) standard gaugeDriver dia.4 ft 7 in (1,397 mm)Adhesive weight8...

Twente

Twente (Olandes: Twente [ˈtʋɛntə] ( pakinggan), Tweants dialect: Tweante) ay isang rehiyon sa silangang Netherlands. Sinasaklaw nito ang pinaka-urbanisado at pinakasilangang bahagi ng lalawigan ng Overijssel. Ang Twente ay malamang na ipinangalan sa Tuihanti o Tvihanti,[1] isang tribong Aleman na nanirahan sa lugar at binanggit ng Romanong mananalaysay na si Tacitus. Ang mga hangganan ng rehiyon ay tinukoy ng rehiyon ng Overijssel ng Salland sa hilagang-kanluran at kanluran (...

26th Reconnaissance Squadron
Alicia, Isabela
Pelegrina galathea
Stratford (Connecticut)
Eclipse lunar de octubre de 2023
Nail Railowitsch Jakupow
Takasaki, Gunma
Parque nacional Świętokrzyski
إلوبيات الشكل
Regras de Baldwin
Shimon Shkop
Хосе Мануель Родрігес Дельгадо
Vieilles Charrues Festival
ماري جيلمور
Messe-Prater (U-Bahn Wina)
日本の外国人
Liste der Autobahnen im Vereinigten Königreich
Nick Marck
Jembatan ANZAC
Dago, Coblong, Bandung
Difusor
ديفيد أندرسون (سياسي كندي)
Kualuh Selatan, Labuhanbatu Utara
Фатіх (мечеть, Стамбул)
Mapane
Norris Bradbury
التعرض للغبار أثناء العمل
East Rounton
セルゲイ・ブリン
The Filipino Channel
Namibia at the 2008 Summer Olympics
Snake Bite Love
Kolsås station
Xylem
Horror fiction
Jurassic Park III
Pomorian Old-Orthodox Church
VH1 (Danish TV channel)
Mary Percy Jackson
Ku70
Wang Zhaojun
مورغان روبرتسون
Receiver operating characteristic
Armageddon, Mon Amour
1937 in Turkey
Disney Fantasy Online
Hope and Glory (film)
Cython
Mercury Seven
Billy Burns (rugby union)
Good Bad Boys
Liste des meilleurs marqueurs en NBA en playoffs
Reflections of China
Cagar Alam Põhja-Kõrvemaa
Harold S. Sawyer
Another Git Together
WULF
1938 Pittsburgh Panthers football team
Кириленко Іван Павлович
С (значення)
Samudra Pasifik
Rune Husk
Charles Bennett (actor)
Settle Down (The 1975 song)
Trevor Releford
The Discoverers (film)
Portmanteau (luggage)
Dan Schwartz
List of DuckTales characters
Rodolfo Falcón (nuotatore 2001)
Équipe d'Angleterre de football au Championnat d'Europe 2000
Magnus Harmonica Corporation
Hem, Netherlands
カルロ・カッラ
Irving Pichel
Azli Yusof
American Train Dispatchers Association
Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova
Clannad (video game)
Kabupaten Boven Digoel
Stadion im. Zbigniewa Podleckiego w Gdańsku
West Michigan's Longest Yard Sale
List of least concern invertebrates
قائمة أفلام المحقق كونان
Greg Boyd (theologian)
List of airports in Romania
/profilpelajar.com/index.php/article/Galaxy rotation curve
Keep the Faith
First Nations nutrition experiments
Nyanyingwe
Marilyn Monroe
Blue Angels
1956 Preakness Stakes
Ted Levine
Bill Haslam
Francis Davis
Talk:Blood and Plum Blossoms
Non-cognitivism
St John the Divine, Horninglow
Acetaldehyde
Taba Baru, Taba Penanjung, Bengkulu Tengah
Muhamad Kasim
Dicyanoacetylene
Talk:Heterosexuality/Archive 1
1708
Succursale de la Banque de Commerce de Gand à Termonde
John Stallworthy
The Beyond (song)
里尔佛兰德站
Chūō, Tokyo
Queens Theatre, Glasgow
46th parallel north
Kiranmoy Nanda
Ulick de Burgh, 1st Marquess of Clanricarde
Saphenista burrens
Crescent Mountain (bukid sa Kanada)
Daftar Duta Besar Indonesia untuk Filipina
William King (poet)
غزوة مروان بن محمد لجورجيا
Bartholomew Gosnold
Talk:Rheumatoid arthritis/Archive 4
La Palma, San Salvador
Tamale International Airport
Rhetoric (Aristotle)
Hugo Butler
Sisili River
Desa Jetis (administrativ by i Indonesien, Jawa Tengah, lat -7,52, long 111,11)
ホップ
NHL Winter Classic 2019
Efim Zelmanov
Talk:Friends of Science
Konsonan letup-balik langit-langit belakang nirsuara
Gabriella Kain
Talk:2nd Infantry Brigade (United Kingdom)
Sweden at the 1956 Summer Olympics
Абдулкаримовский сельсовет (Баймакский район)
Howard County, Texas
Historia del Real Club Deportivo de La Coruña (1906-1941)
Suphala
Provinces of Turkey
The Cosmic Man
Pal Mickey
老巡査
Ron Atkinson
Tatsuya Shirai
Harshen Kuturmi
Talk:DMOZ
Predefinição:Cristianismo
Talk:Dexmethylphenidate
Keilan Robinson
Tom Moore (American football coach, born 1945)
Snakes & Arrows
Erich Offierowski
Fletcher Hanks
Sankt Pölten
1995 Australian Drivers' Championship
2004 Holiday Bowl
Talk:List of mathematics scholarship competitions
Criminal Minds (sezona 4)
Sverrir Gudnason
Rabid Death's Curse
Orient Bay (luuk sa Kayutaan Briton sa Kalawrang Indiyanhon)
Grupo Panzer Guderian
Norton Air Force Base
Washington Terrace, Utah
Hylastes porculus
Kepulauan Bird (Queensland)
Bradley Locko
دينار تنظيم الدولة الإسلامية (داعش)
Ralph James
Fairy Queen
Commissioner (film)
2022 National Premier Soccer League season
2023-as UCI Women's World Tour
Vietteacris subfusca
User talk:Wikipedia Notice
Fokker K.I
Jan Klerk se Loop
Shingū-Chūō Station
Guillem Caçador (bisbe de Barcelona)
El Único, Soteapan
United States Nordic Combined Championships 2009
Delta Velidy
Clothing in ancient Greece
Talk:Germantown High School (Tennessee)
Mudigandi Eru
Talk:Kamal Sagar
Remosa kontorhina
Kathy Stobart
Ca' Rando, Pesaro e Urbino
El Ojital (lungsod sa Mehiko, Estado de Puebla)
KSRY
Dolores Costello
Prepops simplex
Laguna Pabellón (lanaw sa Argentina)
Ed Lauter
Vrangdalsliane
Émile Gagnan
DNA Warrior
Ralphs Island
Talk:List of curling clubs in Poland
Virginia Slims of California 1985
Colonia la Esperanza (lungsod sa Mehiko, Estado de Guanajuato)
Earl Averill
Jana Hunter / Devendra Banhart
美術公園
An Ioruais
Baseball Victoria
蜡
Odin Bailey
Begonia kachak
Heinrich Meibom
Volvo Ocean Race
Bursard
Ruta 413 (Costa Rica)
Burgonya bulamacı
Babka (suba sa Rusya, Perm Krai)
Nisreen Elsaim
De Witt Township (Iowa)
Kōh-e Sangī (bukid sa Nasod nga Afghano, Wilāyat-e Ghōr)
Macrothele palpator
Latina kruco
Graywood
Baroque napolitain
Niebla procera
Super Handball League
Lucas Demare
Initiative populaire « pour l'introduction de la semaine de 44 heures »
Hope (Derbyshire)
Talk:De Havilland Canada DHC-4 Caribou
User talk:99.243.193.64
IBM System/4 Pi
Yhdysvaltain avoin tennisturnaus 2012
Heeled bullet
Liechtenstein–United Kingdom relations
2016 Jordanian general election
Ugo Ihemelu
Tanjung Batuampas
Bajeng, Gowa
Headless Cross (album)
Nacer Bouhanni
Långholmen (pulo sa Finland, Uusimaa, Porvoo)
Sankt Oswald bei Plankenwarth
Magnezit
المشارع (السياني)
Talk:Nasiru Mohammed
Talk:Undistinguished micronations
Auplopus ater
Antonio Cortesi