Built as a billiard parlor, the theatre was first named San Francisco Minstrels Music Hall in 1875, where it presented minstrel shows.[2] After this, it was renamed several times, including Hermann's Gaiety Theatre, Jack's Theatre, Theatre Comique and Jonah Theatre.[3] In 1902, the Shuberts leased it and renamed it the Princess Theatre.[2]
The building was demolished and made into retail shops in 1907.[2][3]