The first station at the site opened in 1852 on Langley Road as a part of the Charles River Railroad.[2] The Boston and Albany Railroad commissioned a building which design was started by H. H. Richardson in 1886, the year of his death, and which design was finished by Richardson’s successor firm of Shepley, Rutan, and Coolidge. The new station, built by the Norcross Brothers firm of Worcester, opened in 1891.[3] The station was heavily modified in 1905–07 when the line was lowered below grade to eliminate street crossings.[3] The Highland branch was closed in 1958 and quickly converted for streetcar use; streetcar service began in July 1959.
The station building was rented out as commercial space; by 1962, it housed a clothing store.[4] The station building was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1976 as part of the Newton Railroad Stations Historic District. At that time, it housed a sales training agency.[5][6] It was used as travel industry training school beginning around 1977 and a coffee shop beginning around 1988.[7][8][9][10] A Coffee Connection store replaced that coffee shop in the early 1990s.[11][12] It became a Starbucks store in 1994, when the chain bought out Coffee Connection, and closed in 2008.[13][14] A restaurant was open in the building from 2010 to 2022.[15][16][17]
In the early 2000s, the MBTA modified key surface stops with raised platforms for accessibility as part of the Light Rail Accessibility Program. The renovation of Newton Centre was completed around 2002.[18][19] Around 2006, the MBTA added a wooden mini-high platform on the inbound side, allowing level boarding on older Type 7 LRVs. These platforms were installed at eight Green Line stations in 2006–07 as part of the settlement of Joanne Daniels-Finegold, et al. v. MBTA.[20][21] In October 2012, the MBTA changed the station name from Newton Center to Newton Centre to match the village name.[22][23]
^"Subway Service". Ridership and Service Statistics. Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority. October 2003. p. 2.19 – via Internet Archive.
^"Executive Summary"(PDF). Program of Mass Transportation. Boston Regional Metropolitan Planning Organization. January 2004. p. 2-9. Archived from the original(PDF) on February 20, 2012.
^"Settlement Agreement"(PDF). Joanne Daniels-Finegold et al. v. MBTA. April 10, 2006. pp. 10–11.