Cash Box said that it has a "pounding rhythm and a vocal performance that scours the emotions," calling the single an "exciting drive side."[3]Billboard called it a "pulsating rocker" and a "blockbuster."[4] Wonder biographer Steve Lodder described the song as being "based around blues changes" but said that it "lacks an 'earworm' hook of a melodic line."[1]
"You Met Your Match" was one of the first songs to use a clavinet in a popular music recording.[5][1]