In early 1780 he joined the newly recommissioned HMS Sandwich, flagship of Rodney, sailing for the Leeward Islands Station.[2][7] On 17 April Carnegie was present during the Battle of Martinique where the twenty ships of the line of Rodney fought the twenty-three ships of the line of the Comte de Guichen.[2][8] While the battle itself was inconclusive, Sandwich fought alone against de Guichen's flagship Couronne and two of her consorts for an hour and a half, taking a great amount of damage.[9] For his service during the battle Carnegie was promoted to commander by Rodney, although his rank was only confirmed on 10 September.[2] In January 1781 Carnegie assumed as his first command the fire shipHMS Blast.[2] In early 1782 he transferred commands to the 20-gun HMS Saint Eustatius which had been taken at the capture of Sint Eustatius, at which Carnegie was present.[Note 2][2][10][11]
Post-Captain
On 7 April 1782 Carnegie was promoted to post captain and given command of the frigate HMS Enterprise which had newly arrived on station in the Leeward Islands from England.[2][12][1] On 4 October Enterprise captured the American 22-gun privateerMohawk off Cape Ann, which was taken into service as HMS Mohawk.[12] At the end of the American Revolutionary War in 1783, Carnegie sailed Enterprise to England where he paid her off in May 1784.[2][12] With the Royal Navy at peace, Carnegie was left unemployed. His elder brother David died in 1788 leaving him his father's heir and holding the courtesy title of Lord Rosehill.[2] In 1790 he briefly took command of the frigate HMS Heroine during the Spanish Armament, relinquishing command when that threat diminished.[6] On 22 January 1792 Carnegie's father died, leaving him to inherit as Earl of Northesk.[2]
Carnegie continued his stint of brief frigate commands into 1793, taking command of HMS Beaulieu in January and sailing her to the Leeward Islands before returning to England later in the year in HMS Andromeda escorting a convoy.[2][13][14][1] His next true command was of the brand new 64-gun third rate HMS Monmouth from September 1796, with Charles Bullen as his first lieutenant.[2][15][16] Carnegie and Monmouth were assigned to the North Sea Fleet of Admiral Adam Duncan the same year.[2][17] On 12 May 1797 many ships of the fleet including Monmouth were at the Nore when the Nore Mutiny began. Carnegie was confined to his cabin by his mutinous crew, until 6 June when he was brought before the committee of delegates that the mutineers had set up on Sandwich.[2][17] Carnegie was selected by the committee to carry their terms to the king because of his reputation as a friend to seamen.[2] While refusing to guarantee any success, Carnegie agreed to convey the terms and left the Nore for London.[17] He took the mutineers' terms to the Admiralty from where the First Lord of the AdmiraltyLord Spencer took him to the king. The demands were rejected, and a different officer returned to the mutineers with the reply.[2]
Soon after the mutiny ended Carnegie resigned his command of Monmouth and thus missed the Battle of Camperdown. He stayed unemployed for four years.[2] In October 1800 he was given command of the 98-gun second-rateHMS Prince in the Channel Fleet.[18] He commanded Prince until she was paid off at the start of the Peace of Amiens in April 1802.[18][2] The Peace expired in May 1803 and Carnegie was given the 100-gun first-rateHMS Britannia in June to again serve in the Channel Fleet of Admiral William Cornwallis at the blockade of Brest.[19] Towards the end of the year Britannia was stationed near the Isle of Wight to protect against possible invasion from France.[20]
Admiral
Carnegie was promoted to rear-admiral on 23 April 1804 as a rear-admiral of the white, keeping Britannia as his flagship and taking Charles Bullen as his flag captain.[21][19] He stayed on the Brest blockade until detached with Vice-Admiral Robert Calder and twenty ships of the line to reinforce the fleet of Vice-Admiral Cuthbert Collingwood at Cádiz in August 1805, where the combined fleet of Admiral Pierre-Charles Villeneuve was sheltering.[21][22] By October Carnegie was third in command of the Mediterranean Fleet commanded by Vice-Admiral Lord Nelson off Cádiz.[2] The combined fleet sailed on 18 October and the British fleet came up with them on 21 October to fight what would become the Battle of Trafalgar.[23] Nelson looked to pierce the combined fleet with two columns and for this purpose Britannia was in the windward column led by Nelson in HMS Victory.[2]
Britannia was a slow ship that did not sail well, and so Nelson ordered Carnegie to 'assume a station as most convenient' during the attack, allowing him the best chance to reach the battle on time.[24] Later he was ordered to break through the enemy line behind their fourteenth ship, making Britannia the fourth ship of the windward column to join the action.[25] Upon breaking the enemy line Britannia came up with and dismasted a French 80-gun ship, and then engaged three of the enemy ships attempting to attack Victory.[26]Britannia fought throughout the battle and received fifty-two casualties, of which ten were killed.[2][19] After the battle was won the British began to secure their prizes, but a large storm meant that many of the newly captured ships had to be abandoned; Carnegie ignored Collingwood's orders to leave the prisoners of war on board the ship nearest to him, Intrépide, and had Britannia's boats rescue them all before scuttling the prize.[27][2]
Carnegie served as the governor of the British Linen Company from 1800 to his death in 1831. The company held an important history in the economic development of Scotland, as it stimulated industrial investment in the production of linen and spinning factories across the rural Highlands and the East Coast. By the nineteenth century, the company had undergone a full transformation from a manufacturing company into a bank.[31]
Carnegie died on 28 May 1831 in Albemarle Street, London after a short illness, and was buried alongside Nelson and Collingwood in the crypt at St Paul's Cathedral, where his tomb and memorial slab can still be seen.[2][33]
Family
He married Mary Ricketts, only daughter of William Henry Ricketts and niece of Admiral of the Fleet Lord St Vincent, on 9 December 1788 in Paris. They had nine children:[34][30]
Burke, John (1846) A Genealogical and Heraldic Dictionary of the Peerage and Baronetage of the British Empire. London: Henry Colburn.
Fraser, William (1867). History of the Carnegies, Earls of Southesk, and of their Kindred. Vol. II. Edinburgh: Private.
Lee, Christopher (2005). Nelson and Napoleon. London: Headline Book Publishing. ISBN0-7553-1041-1.
Malcolm, Charles A (1950) The History of the British Linen Bank. Edinburgh: T & A Constable Ltd.
Marshall, John (1823) Royal Naval Biography: or, Memoirs of the Services of all the Flag-Officers, Superannuated Rear-Admirals, Retired-Captains, Post-Captains, and Commanders Volume 1 - Part 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN978-0-511-77733-2
Winfield, Rif (2007). British Warships in the Age of Sail 1714–1792: Design, Construction, Careers and Fates. London: Pen & Sword. ISBN978-1-84415-700-6.
Winfield, Rif (2008). British Warships in the Age of Sail 1793–1817: Design, Construction, Careers and Fates. London: Seaforth. ISBN978-1-86176-246-7.
Further reading
White, Colin and the 1805 Club (2005) The Trafalgar Captains. London: Chatham Publishing. ISBN1-86176-247-X