circumstances; use them with caution, generally. Shortcut WP:VALNETWP:VALNET Valnet-owned properties have repeatedly been discussed and found to be of questionable...

Guide to deletion (glossary) Help, my article got nominated for deletion! Valnet Inc. (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs |...

games/Sources/Archive 10#Polygon In May 2025, Vox Media sold Polygon to Valnet and promptly laid off most Polygon staff; as of May 2025, this event's long-term...

summarizes it here for convenience. In May 2025, Vox Media sold Polygon to Valnet and promptly laid off most Polygon staff; as of May 2025, this event's long-term...

WP:RSP/BLURAYWP:RSP/BLURAY WP:RS/CBMWP:RS/CBM WP:RS/IMDBWP:RS/IMDB WP:RS/VALNETWP:RS/VALNET Blu-ray.com should not be used for its home video release information as...

also: WP:VALNET Screen Rant is an entertainment website that offers news in the fields of television, films, and comic books. It is owned by Valnet, parent...

FENS · JSTOR · TWL) The current sources are either not reliable or are WP:VALNET owned, meaning they can't be used to establish notability. One of the sources...

lot, but there really isn't much on him. Google News hits turn up only Valnet and unreliable sources, Scholar yields no hits except for one book source...

MovieWeb is additionally owned by Valnet, but I am admittedly unsure if it is also a content farm to the same degree Valnet usually is with sources like Game...

and buzz around her. However, lifting the hood shows that it was mostly Valnet, and a lot of the articles cited barely make a comment about her herself...

20 June 2024 (UTC) Per Wikipedia:VALNET, which is also cited at Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources, Valnet sources do not contribute to notability...

with others being either, primary, unreliable, trivial/directories or Valnet. Final Weapon isn't likely a reliable website. ᴢxᴄᴠʙɴᴍ (ᴛ) 08:36, 25 November...

more suitable for a fan wiki—and the sourcing is fairly weak, largely Valnet and other unreliable sources (Looper, SVG) that describe the agency rather...

coverage tend to be by Screen Rant, which do not count in this regard per WP:VALNET. In addition, information unrelated to the character's development and reception...

09:39, 4 March 2026 (UTC) @Sparks19923 Valnet sources cannot be used to show notability per Wikipedia:VALNET. Just because a character appeared in a...

Comic Book Resources and ScreenRant are Valnet-owned and can't used to demonstrate notability per WP:VALNET. The collector's guide is not "independent...

(nevermind the usual Valnet complaints).--Kung Fu Man (talk) 05:32, 7 February 2025 (UTC) Comment What's frustrating about the Valnet situation is that their...

primarily unreliable, or fall back on ValNet with little substance (please note while I'm not *against* ValNet sources, the lists being the backbone of...

are not Valnet outlets, just to be clear on those two. Unless the point of the statement was more that their output has become more like Valnet since their...

TheGamer is a Valnet source, but it's post-August 2020 and the author seems legit, so I'd consider that to be one of those exceptions to the Valnet rule and...

haven't found those sources. There's Screenrant articles: [1], [2] but Valnet sites aren't considered reliable sources. Mika1h (talk) 14:21, 29 January...

sources used in the article are not only from unreliable sources like WP:VALNET sites, but the actual coverage of the character in them is trivial, with...

Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Video_games/Sources#Valnet_and_the_"notability"_issue shows that your advocacy in favour of Valnet has mostly been rejected. Lewis (baseball)...

sometimes GA/FL) quality source, why is it's inclusion justified here? Removed Valnet content. The only one I thought might be valuable to include would be the...

n-spacers-guild-navigators-spice), all sources I found were low-quality Valnet sources. Industrial Insect (talk) 14:22, 15 April 2025 (UTC) Note: This...

image's caption. Some editors expressed concern over the site's connection to Valnet, which runs several content farms. Digital Trends is a Portland, Oregon-based...

unilaterally added by an editor who may or may not have a bias against Valnet properties (justified or otherwise), and no one has done their due diligence...

FlipandFlopped ㋡ 00:32, 10 October 2025 (UTC) @Flipandflopped See Wikipedia:VALNET. Valnet sources do not contribute to notability. Magneton Considerer: Pokelego999...

TWL) A character from DC Comics. A search yields largely plot summary or VALNET sources. I did find one solid Comicbook.com hit [1] but beyond that it's...

it's enough. CBR is also Valnet which is unreliable. PARAKANYAA (talk) 18:39, 16 November 2024 (UTC) Yeah, listicle + Valnet is not a great combo. Only...

also tends to have a similar, if stricter view on Valnet. Also, not sure what you mean by WP:VALNET not mentioning this when it outright states: "In general...

Financial Post, with listings on 1 other websites and a primary references to Valnet and the website itself (with passing mention to be found in searches). Sadly...

source, and nearly every other source used for WP:SIGCOV purposes is WP:VALNET or plucking WP:ROUTINE coverage from sources. This article is also a huge...

reliable sources. Every single source used in the article at present is a WP:VALNET source, which cannot be used to establish notability in most cases. And...

and fantasy. ᴢxᴄᴠʙɴᴍ (ᴛ) 17:41, 14 May 2026 (UTC) Comment - I added the Valnet sources in an attempt to add more references to the article, as it has had...

controversy about Valnet, can you try your best to replace or simply remove all of them? There is a strong consensus now at WP:VG (Wikipedia:VALNET) and recently...

content farm Valnet site listicle links such as CBR or TheGamer, etc. My point from the previous nom still stands besides the addition of Valnet sites. ᴢxᴄᴠʙɴᴍ...

prior to being purchased by Valnet, due to concerns over undue weight and content farming. (Screen Rant was purchased by Valnet in 2015, according to our...

most prominent source is on Ryan George YouTube videos. Related to the Valnet merges/additions, I suggest redirected to the section there. IgelRM (talk)...

Are they connected to Valnet? I don't think so. Another article is mentioned by another user above. Also unconnected to Valnet. Feel free to add other...

(talk) 19:53, 21 September 2024 (UTC) Comment Valnet sources do not contribute to notability per Wikipedia:VALNET. Has one ever considered Magneton? Pokelego999...

notability unfortunately. Refs 1 and 4 are WP:PRIMARY. Refs 9 and 18-20 are WP:VALNET. Refs 2, 5, 7, and 9 don't mention Parasect or only give a name drop. Refs...

but I wouldn't use it for featured content due to some quality concerns) Valnet news sites: ScreenRant, GameRant and TheGamer sources should be replaced...

listed at WP:VALNET as a "situational source" The Explorer (ref 4), a student newspaper Game Rant (refs 12 and 14), another WP:VALNET source, explicitly...

Gommeh (talk 🎮 sign) 17:31, 22 July 2026 (UTC) CBR is situational post-2016 as per WP:VALNET, hence the need to evaluate it in more detail. From my point of view, the...

Reception isn't doing much better either. 26 and 27 are both Wikipedia:VALNET sources, which do not contribute to notability, and the Polygon source doesn't...

problem with Valnet for sourcing, but these are just not cutting the mustard.--Kung Fu Man (talk) 21:46, 29 November 2023 (UTC) The point of Valnet's sites are...

mentions of the character (The bulk of which were unreliable or belonged to WP:VALNET). Some reviews for his titular episodes were included, but do not include...

non-high-quality sources from the article (e.g., WP:VALNET, but there are also many more besides Valnet sources) The article should not rely on primary sources...

trends or laying out our own opinions". ^a In May 2025, Polygon was sold to Valnet, resulting in the layoff of most staff including Hall. ^b In September 2024...

over the WP:N bar. Hobit (talk) 14:44, 19 July 2024 (UTC) Per Wikipedia:VALNET Screen Rant does not contribute to the notability of a subject. Is there...

TWL) There are no sources with WP:SIGCOV, with the exception of one WP:VALNET source (ScreenRant). Mikeycdiamond (talk) 18:09, 19 September 2025 (UTC)...

unreliable in a way that other Valnet sources are not? I believe that general consensus is that being owned by Valnet is not disqualifying, and the article...

(UTC) I didn't know about VG/S, thank you for mentioning it. I see now that Valnet is listed as questionable reliability and that invalidates the sources I...

fails WP:USERG. Source 11, wow, this far before Valnet appears? Source 12, Complex, which is as bad as Valnet, and doesn't really say anything. Source 13...

since 2023 having been declared unreliable. The rest of the sources are WP:VALNET sources, which cannot be used to establish notability. Google News searches...

reliability (e.g. games.gg), sources that can't establish notability (e.g. Valnet sources), and unreliable user-generated sites (e.g. Modrinth and the Create...

unreliable at WP:VG/S and CBR is considered situational, and both are from Valnet, which can't be used to demonstrate notability. Also, that isn't the complete...

these comics. I did search to find a bit of reception, but I can only find Valnet sources, which are not reliable, and even those are limited. Di (they-them)...

Lawgivers 2 on Pocket Gamer [1] and some listicles about Lawgivers 2 on Valnet style sites like TheGamer and GameRant: [2][3][4]. Nothing wrong with listicles...

Fails GNG; and a WP:BEFORE search turned up pretty much nothing except for Valnet sources which do not contribute to notability anyways. Merge as ATD per...

primary sources, with the exception of an article that was published by a Valnet-owned publisher. Furthermore, it might not be a valid search term, as a...

computer hacker character in film, while the other two ([5], [6]) are WP:VALNET sources which do not show much in the way of notability. Although these...

of them were either plot summaries, trivial mentions, or low quality WP:VALNET sources. Searches still yield absolutely nothing in the way of WP:SIGCOV...

20 October 2024 (UTC) Redirect/Merge - The added sources are all either Valnet sites or trivial mentions. Not enough to really pass the WP:GNG, but its...

🌽33 20:07, 30 June 2026 (UTC) Well a major problem here is the use of Valnet, or really the fact that it's 3 whole articles for that, and they're lists...

Collider's credibility, as it is a Valnet property, and such websites are known to be content farms/mills. Speaking of Valnet, there's a handful of Comic Book...

on sites like TheGamer, which does not contribute to notability per WP:VALNET. I also checked Japanese sources, and there appears to only be routine coverage...

summary hit from Nerdist but every other hit has been trivial mentions or Valnet. There's a perfectly valid section to contain this info, as even with Nerdist...

replaced with more reputable sources where appropriate. See WP:RS/VALNET and WP:VALNET for more. Shortcuts WP:MCUBUDGETSWP:MCUBUDGETS WP:JEFFSNEIDERWP:JEFFSNEIDER...

TheGamer (IIRC Valnet sources are considered marginally reliable by en VG/RS..? 2) There are few more like this from GameRant (another Valnet source); I am...

search only turned up this source from Comic Book Resources, which is a WP:VALNET source and cannot be used to establish notability. This could probably remain...

amount of discussion, albeit it can be hard to see the trees amongst the Valnet forest.--Kung Fu Man (talk) 09:07, 24 November 2023 (UTC)Merge A closer...

of SIGCOV or significant discussion, even in content farm sources like Valnet. Would support a redirect to Companion (Doctor Who) or List of Doctor Who...

reliability. A WP:BEFORE search only yielded a Game Rant article, which is a Valnet content farm with also questionable reliability. There are no critic reviews...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) No sources with SIGCOV besides two IMDB and WP:VALNET articles. Mikeycdiamond (talk) 14:00, 20 September 2025 (UTC) Note: This...

dates should probably be moved. It isn't an issue at GAN, but sources from Valnet, Inc. (TheGamer, Game Rant, etc.) won't pass high-scrutiny source reviews...

sources of low quality (like Newsrama), dead sources like ref 12, too many Valnet sources like Comicbook.com, plenty of blogs, and plenty of unreliable sources...

WP:CBR and ScreenRant is not a source to determine reliability per WP:VALNET. Warm Regards, Miminity (Talk?) (me contribs) 10:02, 3 January 2025 (UTC)...

I think a bit problem is so much of it relies on questionable refs and Valnet, and some of the former are interwoven into the article, concerns I brought...

discussions. Spiderone(Talk to Spider) 19:48, 3 July 2026 (UTC) Comment one VALNET source counts for one RS, there are a bunch of potential RS on Google Scholar...

(talk) 12:12, 8 December 2025 (UTC) Delete Sources are either WP:ROUTINE, WP:VALNET, or don't have WP:SIGCOV. Mikeycdiamond (talk) 13:19, 8 December 2025 (UTC)...

them provide significant coverage regarding "BIG SHOT" itself, or are WP:VALNET sources - which cannot be used to establish notability. Some of the sources...

this source as a WP:VALNET post-Mid 2023? The other VALNET's should be fine since they were published prior to that I don't think VALNET is all that justified...

a scholarly book, all but two of the potential sources were operated by Valnet. With regards to the article's current sources, all of them were published...

time to find sigcov on a quick google search. Article mostly relies on Valnet sources at reception, thus failing WP:GNG. SyFy Wire is the only valuable...

Are currently WP:VALNET sources, but should be okay for use here considering they were all published before being acquired by Valnet Ref 55: Actually...

section to Conception section as a subsection. Replace or remove Valnet sources per WP:VALNET. Add OCLC numbers. Translate titles that are not in English into...

masthead[3] We also have a review in by Sam Stone in CBR [4]. CBR is owned by Valnet, so marginal reliability overall, but Sam Stone is also published in PopVerse...

Sheeva was added to MK11 as DLC, and she got barely anything outside the Valnet sites. Sindel and Nightwolf has gotten much more in comparison. As for the...

sources are either plot summary or hail from trivial mentions or Wikipedia:VALNET. There's little in the way of SIGCOV or an actual indication of the importance...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) I disagree with the AfC acceptance. Ignoring Valnet content farm, non-independent sources, and simple database entries, there...

from ScreenRant, which even if one were to discount the concerns at WP:VALNET of using the site as the sole means of establishing notability, would not...

possible paid news. ZDNet - Single paragraph of prose Makeuseof - Part of the Valnet content farm, unusable for anything else than the most basic of facts. Livemint...

comic book character who has literally no SIGCOV, only being referenced in Valnet sources. There is no possible notability I can find for this character,...

reliable or prior to being purchased by Valnet, due to concerns over undue weight and content farming. Valnet is really just the worst kind of content...

thing I found was an entry in a ScreenRant list: [1], ScreenRant is a WP:VALNET site. Suggesting a merge to Land of Oz#Gillikin Country. See also previous...

summary briefly mentioning him, an officially published guidebook, or a WP:VALNET site. The content here could be potentially merged to List of DC Comics...

WP:FIXTHEPROBLEM. Sparks19923 (talk) 09:39, 4 March 2026 (UTC) @Sparks19923 CBR is a Valnet source, which does not contribute notability, and is additionally considered...

2020, meaning it provides as much notability to the subject as an average Valnet source. Beyond that, Game Rant briefly discussed it, but it also does not...

and starting over. It only cites one source (which is an unreliable WP:VALNET source) and it seems to indiscriminately list characters with no semblance...

already in the article do not count towards SIGCOV due to being owned by WP:VALNET. I think this should probably be redirected to List of Star Wars planets...

two sentences) plot summary, all from Comic Book Resources. Even if WP:VALNET was not an issue with those sources, they would still not actually qualify...

worth merging (the only secondary source being used for "Reception" is a Valnet site "Top Ten" style list) but the history will be there if anyone wants...

qualifier that content published by Valnet on any of these sites are notable, and in fact, the text states that Valnet-published material is allowed, but...

of the content. In other words, view it as you would IMDb. MovieWeb is Valnet. Much of their stuff is considered to be questionable as they tend to rely...

(which ultimately proved to be untrue) from unreliable sources like WP:VALNET sites, or simple plot recaps where the crown appears to fill out a "list...

through, and I didn't see any citation mismatches. Valnet Per WP:VALNET, sources published by Valnet should be met with heightened scrutiny, although they...

yields quite literally nothing bar trivial mentions in announcements and VALNET listicles, and the current article cites no sources whatsoever. Clearly...

13 January 2024 (UTC) Merge per Zx, somewhat. I'll add I'm not against Valnet lists being used, but if they're discussing the work and not just reiterating...

ミラP@Miraclepine 01:55, 24 June 2025 (UTC) The sources in the linked FGO AFD are WP:VALNET sources, so I don't think this is any kind of precedent. I have not looked...

(talk) 19:32, 2 February 2024 (UTC) @User:Skynxnex I'm down with using Valnet editorials when they say something useful, but those three are either just...

above also isn't convincing me, given it's mainly reviews and valnet. And normally I like Valnet but you need some meat to go with it.--Kung Fu Man (talk)...

coverage there. Jclemens (talk) 00:37, 19 April 2024 (UTC) According to WP:VALNET: "In general, these sites should not be used to demonstrate notability outside...

Trying to dig deeper shows not much unfortunately other than a lot of Valnet. I could see individual articles perhaps (especially Astolfo), but the list...

while attributed to reliable sources (minus some references to Gameranx, a Valnet source, and esports.gg which is dubious), is just basic observations that...

Guardian. The other sources are kind of meh. ScreenRant and MovieWeb are both Valnet. ScreenRant is considered to be situationally usable but I'm not certain...

my! (Mushy Yank) 16:29, 5 October 2024 (UTC) Lets take a look: CBR: WP:VALNET WBUR: Local NPR affiliate, pretty plot based but does have some COV. if...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) All I could find for this character were Valnet sources or posts from the official Marvel site. The character appears to...

TheGamer, which is another source that can't demonstrate notability per WP:VALNET. There is no actual material or sourcing present in this article that leads...

topic meets WP:N. A large number of the sources are from a content farm Valnet Inc. and the remainder appear to be WP:GAMECRUFT. I think this topic should...

best horror games, etc.)) Do NOT use Codes articles or How To articles. Valnet sources do NOT count to significant coverage. Beebom is kinda... im not...

up WP:ROUTINE coverage of the role's various changes in the comics, WP:VALNET sources that don't contribute to notability, or summary style articles that...

uses primary sources, and there's a heavy reliance on Comicbook.com and Valnet properties (CBR, Screenrant, Gamerant), churnalism sites that hold a "situational...

Whoa, I'm late to the party but WP:VALNET is the findings of WikiProject Video Games. At WP:RSPLIST, the only Valnet source listed is Screen Rant, which...

WP:GNG. Did some BEFORE but did not see anything at Google news at all. Valnet sources doesn't contribute to notability. 🍕BP!🍕 (🔔) 12:09, 16 November...

the idea on building a list up on primarily valnet lists Piotrus...and I'm usually in favor of using Valnet as a source.--Kung Fu Man (talk) 03:42, 13...

(talk) 14:59, 15 December 2024 (UTC) This source falls under Wikipedia:VALNET and is not helpful in demonstrating notability Magneton Considerer: Pokelego999...

What discussion I managed to find with a WP:BEFORE was either a lot of Valnet, material discussing already introduced characters from games such as FGO...

article discussing the factions [1], and there's [2] and [3] if you like Valnet, but there's less out there than I would have guessed. The thing stopping...

characters. This character is simply not standalone notable and largely uses Valnet sites for its reception. ᴢxᴄᴠʙɴᴍ (ᴛ) 22:40, 25 March 2024 (UTC) Redirect/merge...

2025 (UTC) There's an article by Screenrant: [2], which according to WP:VALNET shouldn't be used to establish notability. There's also this book that talks...

the scenes history of the character. A brief BEFORE yields nothing but Valnet articles (Which do not contribute to notability), unreliable sources, or...

unchallenged at best (discussion 1, discussion 2), despite being owned by Valnet, which has reputably prioritized quantity and sensationalism over quality...

Asap is like if you can find a reliable source to replace because it is Valnet. Article without author doesn't mean it cannot be used, so it should be...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Fails WP:GNG, sources provided include two valnet sources (not great for notability), an io9 listicle (okay ish), and meaww...

Gommeh (talk! sign!) 13:51, 26 June 2026 (UTC) TheGamer is a Valnet source, and WP:VALNET says that this is a situationally reliable source. I would try...

computer hacker character in film, while the other two ([5], [6]) are WP:VALNET sources which do not show much in the way of notability. Although these...

Valum only a part of it, while CBR has no bearing on notability per WP:VALNET. The development is entirely about the script, with the Polygon source and...

reliable sources (Metacritic link) and all sourcing in the article is WP:VALNET sourcing or sites similar to it which cannot establish notability. I ran...

computer hacker character in film, while the other two ([5], [6]) are WP:VALNET sources which do not show much in the way of notability. Although these...

discussing Valnet. Hemiauchenia (talk) 20:51, 31 May 2025 (UTC) Delete for now but without prejudice against recreation as further discussions about Valnet are...

fact weakly pass GNG, and that's when you ignore the dozens of mentions in Valnet sites like CBR and GameRant. I do think the sourcing is relatively weak...

is almost entirely WP:ROUTINE announcements regarding the character, WP:VALNET sources, which do not provide notability, or brief listicle rankings without...

completely different article that does not mention Price at all. 27 is Valnet, not usable in notability discussions. 28 just says "Captain Price, the...

computer hacker character in film, while the other two ([5], [6]) are WP:VALNET sources which do not show much in the way of notability. Although these...

press releases are considered primary sources. GameRant article is by WP:VALNET so it shouldn't be used for notability but it's also fairly standard coverage...

consensus (Dexerto, Sportskeeda, Odyssey per USERGEN). GameRant is a WP:VALNET site and can't be used as evidence for SIGCOV. The others are simply coverage...

at WP:VG/RS. MoonJet (talk) 05:48, 10 April 2023 (UTC) Pretty much any Valnet Inc. hosted site falls under this category, yet they're among the few sites...

I am not currently convinced by questionable/situational sources (e.g.: valnet) and I see a lot of these characters are already covered in more standard...

Wikipedia:WikiProject Video games/Sources, the Game Rant article is a listicle at a WP:VALNET site, and the The Record is a literal one-sentence mention (in passing)...

three sources, two of which are unreliable and the third of which is WP:VALNET. No sources have been demonstrated showcasing why this version meets notability...

BrigadierG (talk) 12:42, 28 March 2024 (UTC) SVG is unreliable, while Valnet sources like GameRant doesn't help WP:GNG, see WP:VG/RS. Possibly in all...

attributed more to the game than the guy itself. While I'm not opposed to using Valnet for notability, those are just too weak to do the job.--Kung Fu Man (talk)...

The most prevalent source in the article, Comic Book Resources and other Valnet sites, are not reliable sources. --Mika1h (talk) 16:29, 26 October 2023...

Bill Burr Will Write & Star in Directorial Debut Old Dads". Screen Rant. Valnet. Retrieved April 5, 2022. Seabaugh, Julie (July 3, 2014). "L.A.'s New Wave...

is more along the lines of writers who are hired by sites such as IGN or Valnet. That's preferable. 11WB 💬 12:49, 6 August 2026 (UTC) @11WB SFE is (currently)...

computer hacker character in film, while the other two ([8], [9]) are WP:VALNET sources which do not show much in the way of notability. Although these...

requirements. Siliconera is the only source [1] providing WP:SIGCOV? While the Valnet sources do not contribute to notability, and the Chinese sources appear...

Conyo14 (talk) 03:12, 20 April 2024 (UTC) It is situational as a source, but Valnet sources does not help notability according to WP:VG/RS. 🥒Greenish Pickle...

Khoury and Timothy Callahan. In April 2016, Comic Book Resources was sold to Valnet Inc., a company known for its acquisition and ownership of media properties...

it provides confirmation of the parallel to Green Lantern Corps by a non-Valnet source. And a really weird fact, Guardians of the Galaxy is listed as "Highest...

is more along the lines of writers who are hired by sites such as IGN or Valnet. That's preferable. 11WB 💬 12:49, 6 August 2026 (UTC) @11WB SFE is (currently)...

is more along the lines of writers who are hired by sites such as IGN or Valnet. That's preferable. 11WB 💬 12:49, 6 August 2026 (UTC) @11WB SFE is (currently)...

article's sources are either brief TRIVIALMENTIONS or are sourced from Valnet sources. The reception leans quite a bit on a TechRaptor source, which per...

unwarranted. Pokelego999 (talk) 22:08, 4 September 2023 (UTC) Movieweb, Valnet and Dreadcentral sources doesn't contribute WP:GNG. Metro and Bvtack are...

(2015) p.84-86, and this article in CBR (which is considered reliable pre Valnet purchase, and the site was relaunched in August 2016 - the article is from...

(it's three total sentences of a brief overview) and, even if it were, WP:VALNET sources cannot demonstrate notability; Law.com is about a lawsuit involving...

character" nonsense that lacks any SIGCOV) and weaker hits from things like WP:VALNET listicles. There's nothing in any of the coverage I could see, nor this...

majority of these sources are unreliable (fansites like Tohokingdom or WP:VALNET sites like GameRant), literal pieces of fiction (various comic books), or...

of what is available. - Cukie Gherkin (talk) 21:02, 23 March 2024 (UTC) Valnet, but [10] [11] both discuss the character in the film to a significant extent...

the info it's verifying yet Ref 30: I'm generally opposed to seeing WP:VALNET sources in GAs/FAs, especially after the 2023 layoffs. I've also found a...

the not-outright-unreliable or user-generated sources here are from WP:VALNET, and most of the rest are just from Anime News Network. The current state...

background of Valnet operators Stephane Manos and Ouissam Youssef" Unfortunately, I fail to see the logic/reasoning in how the background of Valnet affects...

but the page itself appears to have not been archived. He also has some Valnet sources covering him, but it appears that they are not longer accepted for...

publication" on VGRS TheGamer is noted as a "situational source" on VGRS (see: WP:VALNET) Cracked.com is noted as "generally unreliable" on RS/PS Medium is a self-published...

Literature. Mika1h (talk) 17:50, 13 April 2025 (UTC) Comment I'm seeing VALNET stuff like this listicle, so they clearly exist and are discussed, but it's...

shallow in coverage. For example, most of the reception is either cited to WP:VALNET sources (which cannot establish notability) (e.g. GameRant, Collider), or...

WP:LOCALCON existing for WP:VALNET sources at the WP:A&M project. If such a local consensus does exist, it would mean that the current Valnet sources in the article...

article from Screen Rant (not a source we should be using here, see WP:RSP/VALNET), this article from The Daily Telegraph about the show Disenchantment that...

here either, especially going through google news and excluding the usual valnet: there's no discussion or analysis. Scholar also had nothing. Trying a web...

April 2026 (UTC) Plenty. VFX Voice, The Digital Fix, CBR (I'm aware it's a Valnet source), Looper, ONE Esports. I think GNG is more than passed with this...

is more along the lines of writers who are hired by sites such as IGN or Valnet. That's preferable. 11WB 💬 12:49, 6 August 2026 (UTC) @11WB SFE is (currently)...

(talk) 07:31, 3 May 2024 (UTC) That web aticle doenst count for very much. Valnet sources are not great for showing notability. Questions? four Olifanofmrtennant...

Beyond that, though, is very little. There's some trivia articles from Valnet, which generally don't count for notability, but that's about it, and none...

an agreeable compromise for Valnet. I can speak for myself here, but I feel that other VG editors will agree, the Valnet topic is tiresome. Some of you...

appear to be reliable. Prose OK, most of my concerns have been adressed (Valnet sources are still in the article, though). I will take at the prose next...

reliability of subsequent articles. We learned the hard way with Red Ventures and Valnet. And many other factors play a role. SVG-image-maker (talk) 01:08, 14 July...

@Rublamb I wouldn't consider the Game Rant source SIGCOV per Wikipedia:VALNET, but I do have to admit the other sources scrape together just enough for...

rest of the sources aren't much better, since we have several sources from Valnet-owned publications that can't be used to contribute towards notability....

image's caption. Some editors expressed concern over the site's connection to Valnet, which runs several content farms. 1   The Diplomat WP:THEDIPLOMAT 📌 1...

appropriately placed. -- Tavix (talk) 18:28, 27 June 2026 (UTC) FextraLife → Valnet  (talk · links · history · stats)     [ Closure: keep/retarget/delete ] ...

two sources. PCGamer is reliable, so that's good. But Gamerant, part of Valnet's suite, is considered unsuitable for WP:N questions. So this entire list...

are a few sources out there indicating notability, however they are WP:VALNET sources, so I'm not very confident that this would be accepted and moved...

not very helpful for notability due to content farm reasons per Wikipedia:VALNET. For a subject like this, I'd expect at least a few strong citations that...

as this from Comic Book Resources. CBR is considered unreliable per WP:VALNET and this RS/N discussion, however the depth is what I would consider to...

would not be considered significant coverage in regards to notability. Valnet owns a number of gaming oriented websites including Comic Book Resources...

and GameRant. Problem is, two of the sources fall under purview of WP:VALNET, and an additional NME source I've discovered doesn't qualify as WP:SIGCOV...

WP:ROUTINE coverage on gameplay changes when new games come out, as well as WP:VALNET articles that do not provide notability per WP:VG/RS. A search through Books...

historically reliable, but unreliable following a June 2025 acquisition by WP:VALNET per a December 2025 RSN discussion. Militaryland [1,691], no consensus in...

MOS:CONFORMTITLE. I am not sure Screen Rant would be a great source for a FAC per WP:VALNET (and while the link is about video game sources, I do think that it is applicable...

not those sources"? BoomboxTestarossa (talk) 19:52, 22 August 2023 (UTC) Valnet sources are widely known as content farms, it's telling that the main source...

of the arguments for deletion are really only vetted against the use of Valnet sources and either ignore or completely omit any mention of the other reliable...

22 October 2025 (UTC) Trust in ScreenRant, however, is variable per WP:VALNET. --Slgrandson (How's my egg-throwing coleslaw?) 00:43, 23 October 2025 (UTC)...

instance it's published on The Sportster which is redlisted at WP:RS/PS#Valnet and specifically listed as unreliable at WP:PW/RS. The PWI interview is...

WP:VALNET (see below) confused with a diff source, yeah, it's probably unreliable, removed I'm not thrilled with the citing of various WP:VALNET sources...

Hydrangeans (she/her | talk | edits) 04:35, 28 March 2024 (UTC) I believe Valnet sources like CBR doesn't contribute to GNG after checking WP:RSP. But, I...

main page. -Mushy Yank. 00:39, 28 March 2025 (UTC) All of these bar the Valnet source (Which doesn't contribute to notability) are all either just character...

Stony Brook Press, a student-ran newspaper, reliable? Not a big fan of VALNET sources, but Collider is more reliable than most so should be fine. Rolling...

Pokelego999 (talk) 21:12, 27 July 2024 (UTC) The VALNET articles are the first several references; the non-VALNET ones are like the entire right-handed column...

Game Rant list (that CAN be used to expand the article, that's what WP:VALNET clearly states). Among missing titles in the list is Doctor Whore (https://www...

receotion were mostly filled with listicle-type articles. Unfortunately, valnet source like this [1] doesn't help its notability, an IGN source, which seemed...

for eligibility (No editorial oversight). Anything that's been owned by Valnet long-term is, by default, highly suspect, and GameRant's situation is similar...

to Valnet. It references: A different company (Interhub) A founder (Keezer) who is not part of Valnet’s leadership Allegations from before Valnet was...

From my WP:BEFORE search, the only sources covering this as a group are WP:VALNET sources, which do not confer notability per our guidelines. Most hits for...

tracks [were] added in later updates"? Game Rant and Screen Rant, being Valnet sources, have consistently been ruled by the gavel of Wikipedia FA reviewers...

perspective on the character. One citation just says that he's powerful; one is a Valnet listicle that doesn't provide sigcov; and the other two are lists, one which...

this Sigma) to use because it's not really commentary and closer to a bad Valnet article? Not to mention [22] which is also...really not saying anything...

Learned Their Site Had Been Sold To Valnet (Bleeding Cool, 2016) This post reprints the letter to employees, quotes the Valnet CEO, and a press release. I excluded...

with Valnet I'm hesitant to consider anything from them to meet the high quality bar. Hog Farm Talk 20:05, 13 May 2026 (UTC) I removed both Valnet refs:...

the sources I've provided are affiliated with Marvel; IGN, Collider and Valnet-owned properties like Screenrant and CBR certainly aren't primary sources...

What makes Programming Insider a reliable source? I usually gripe with WP:VALNET sources, are there any better sources that could cover the Collider references...

sources per WP:VG/S, Game Rant is situational but probably okay here per WP:VALNET, Kotaku is probably fine here per Masem, I'm guessing Romonitor Stats hasn't...

citations. Some sources may not have the reliability expected of FAs - e.g., Valnet, which owns Collider, is described as mass quantity over quality to churn...

of Sylveon and how it should have been a support in Unite. TheGamer is Valnet-owned but the author of this article, Cian Maher, has written for IGN, Polygon...

has been owned and operated by online publisher Valnet Inc in Montreal, Canada since July 2020. Valnet (a subsidiary of the Valsef) investment group) oversees...

found one from Christian Today and Game Rant (before being purchased by Valnet, no less). I think there's more than enough here, especially when you consider...

well known character doesn't mean the character is automatically notable. Valnet sources lile ScreenRant doesn't help its notability. GreenishPickle! (🔔)...

425 405 Psychology Today Psychology Today (189 in 160) 189 160 1.181 406 Valnet HardCore Gamers (13 in 11) Hardcore Gamer (163 in 149) Hardcore Gamer (magazine)...

2000's. The Gamer is a long standing news website that, while owned by Valnet, has been recognized by the Video Game project as viable for verification...

Computist Mag 2 1, 2 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) Hardcore Gamer ? Valnet Pub 163 149 1.094 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) Hardcore Gamer (magazine)...

re-draftified over and over. The article heavily leans on primary sourcing and Valnet listicles. -- ferret (talk) 18:25, 20 April 2023 (UTC) Yes, the idea that...

notability per Wikipedia:VALNET. Magneton Considerer: Pokelego999 (Talk) (Contribs) 16:42, 6 November 2025 (UTC) WP:VALNET says that "in general". In...

Type2 Citations Articles ⁠Citations/article⁠ Search 501 Hardcore Gamer ? Valnet Pub 163 149 1.094 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) 501 Track & Field News...

Financial Post, with listings on 1 other websites and a primary references to Valnet and the website itself (with passing mention to be found in searches). Sadly...

the original on 2019-05-27. Retrieved 2019-05-27. The Gamer is owned by Valnet, a publisher that also owns Screen Rant and Comic Book Resources, among...

— ShelfSkewed (newly tagged – originally created 14 years ago) Valnet (edit talk links history) — BD2412 (previously a draft – moved out 1 month...

(talk) 04:06, 29 November 2024 (UTC) Keep GNG is met, and even without the VALNET sources, which are just fine in this case. This is a particularly inconsiderate...

Rant and CBR, but seeing as how they've been quite divisive here owing to Valnet, I'd understand omitting them for proving notability (besides perhaps CBR)...

Bill Burr Will Write & Star in Directorial Debut Old Dads". Screen Rant. Valnet. Retrieved April 5, 2022. Seabaugh, Julie (July 3, 2014). "L.A.'s New Wave...

uses primary sources, and there's a heavy reliance on Comicbook.com and Valnet properties (CBR, Screenrant, Gamerant), churnalism sites that hold a "situational...

but the page itself appears to have not been archived. He also has some Valnet sources covering him, but it appears that they are not longer accepted for...

the mochii (talk) 21:00, 16 July 2023 (UTC) Sadly, that site was sold to Valnet in 2016 so reliability is iffy: discussion about CBR from a year ago, and...

the sources I've provided are affiliated with Marvel; IGN, Collider and Valnet-owned properties like Screenrant and CBR certainly aren't primary sources...

primarily unreliable, or fall back on ValNet with little substance (please note while I'm not *against* ValNet sources, the lists being the backbone of...

Sheeva was added to MK11 as DLC, and she got barely anything outside the Valnet sites. Sindel and Nightwolf has gotten much more in comparison. As for the...

This is just a suggestion, but I would avoid heavy use of Decider and Valnet sources such as Screen Rant. They are considered marginally reliable for...

"Soundtrack of Crazy Bus" article, I'm not even seeing coverage for that in non-Valnet sites. Just random notoriety and popularity. Which doesn't equal notability...

to cover the parent company of the publication, i.e. Valnet, Inc. It is, however, listed at Valnet. — Godsy (TALKCONT) 10:56, 8 July 2024 (UTC) Delete...

Brandon (October 16, 2025) and 208 have an error. Ref 147 (Collider) is a Valnet source so I'd suggest finding a replacement. Vacant0 (talk • contribs) 14:38...

2016, when its founder sold it to Valnet, and it shifted into clickbait/churnalism. So anything before the Valnet acquisition is perfectly reliable,...

date range. Further checks: WP:VALNET: @BP! makes a good point below. Valnet sources are generally of low quality. All Valnet sources, with the exception...

believe the sources are also of high quality, though I'd draw attention to Valnet sources. While I agree that they offer minimal value for the sake of notability...

Forever Magazine ? — ? 1 1 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) MakeUseOf ? Valnet Pub 1 1 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) Makhz ? — ? 1 1 1.000 Wikipedia...

Rant — Source associated with Valnet, a dubious publishing company. See WikiProject Video games' assessment of Valnet and this discussion. Cartoon Brew...

for you: Ref 1: isn't asking for a paid subscription from me? Ref 7: a WP:VALNET source, is there anything better available? Cut Ref 10: VIDEO --> Video...

20 June 2024 (UTC) Per Wikipedia:VALNET, which is also cited at Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources, Valnet sources do not contribute to notability...

churnalism. --Ronz (talk) 17:00, 21 May 2019 (UTC) This is a property of Valnet Inc. It shouldn't be used for BLP or notability at all, and highly questionable...

reliable, while Screen Rant is reliable for pop culture purpose and as a valnet source, it shouldn't be used a lot; that's why I used only once (BTW, GameRant...

have a write up on the questionable reliability of Valnet: WP:VALNET. It seems they consider all Valnet publications except for Hardcore Gamer to be either...

sources have some issue or another. The first two sources are Game Rant, a WP:VALNET source and Event Hubs, an unreliable source. The next two sources are a...

reliable in 2015, at the time of this games release, as it wasn't purchased by Valnet yet. Even now, per this discsusion, there is no current consensus or noticeable...

bolstered by additional sources from The Gamer but I didn't want to work more valnet into this. While I'll admit this article is weaker, I feel the assertions...

WP:GNG? How do such interviews with that winner count for GNG? Also, per WP:VALNET, Collider has some churnalism, but its reliability is "situational" so far...

Topside ? 3 1, 2, 3 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) TopSpeed ? Valnet Pub 1 1 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) Toque et Verre ? — ? 1 1...

Computist Mag 2 1, 2 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) Hardcore Gamer ? Valnet Pub 13 13 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) Hardcore Gaming 101 Presents:...

Stony Brook Press, a student-ran newspaper, reliable? Not a big fan of VALNET sources, but Collider is more reliable than most so should be fine. Rolling...

Network and The Playlist? I would also advise removing Screen Rant, since WP:VALNET sources are considered low quality for usage in FAC. ScreenRant removed...

(talk) 21:34, 30 June 2022 (UTC) Android Police. Valnet Inc. rang a bell. Previous comments on Valnet et all at RSN have not been favorable.[59][60][61]...

do not see any particular issues with references and their reliability. Valnet sources are used, though TheGamer is now considered reliable. I only used...

was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – Screen Rant proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 31 Oct 2024 – 2023 in downloadable songs...

a big part of the reception section. While I understand the disdain for Valnet, most of that does not apply amongst editors towards editorial pieces, let...

Are currently WP:VALNET sources, but should be okay for use here considering they were all published before being acquired by Valnet Ref 55: Actually...

unchallenged at best (discussion 1, discussion 2), despite being owned by Valnet, which has reputably prioritized quantity and sensationalism over quality...

BroadwayWorld online Wisdom Digital Media G·N·A·B·S·RS·RSN·Talk·LS Collider online Valnet, Inc. G·N·A·B·S·RS·RSN·Talk·LS The Daily Dot online Independent G·N·A·B·S·RS·RSN·Talk·LS...

citations rather than The Guardian. I've added the publisher for TheGamer, Valnet, to the corresponding citation. I've found citations to support the bosses...

{{Better source needed}} next to them. However, I can't find any good non-Valnet sources that can be used to cite the game's plot. Gommeh (talk! sign!) 14:53...

prior to being purchased by Valnet, due to concerns over undue weight and content farming. (Screen Rant was purchased by Valnet in 2015, according to our...

MovieWeb is additionally owned by Valnet, but I am admittedly unsure if it is also a content farm to the same degree Valnet usually is with sources like Game...

major personnel changes happened until July 2025, i.e. a bit after the Valnet acquisition, but I'm fine with this RFC date being June as I think the number...

the original on 2019-05-27. Retrieved 2019-05-27. The Gamer is owned by Valnet, a publisher that also owns Screen Rant and Comic Book Resources, among...

considered questionable sources in the past, with TheGamer being until the Valnet umbrella which are generally seen as not suitable for BLP claims (Screen...

BLP—the former is only marked a marginally reliable on RSP and it's owned by Valnet, a company with concerns about content farming and churnalism. That being...

Expanding on Greenish Pickle's comment, while I don't hold a negative view on Valnet sources the ones used are not really saying anything, and the others added...

2025 (UTC) Valnet sources do not count towards notability? I have never heard this Yoblyblob (Talk) :) 16:56, 25 November 2025 (UTC) WP:VALNET, it is a...

also tends to have a similar, if stricter view on Valnet. Also, not sure what you mean by WP:VALNET not mentioning this when it outright states: "In general...

it and other sites owned by it and ValNet. The conclusion of the discussion led to the creation of WP:RSP/VALNET suggesting we limit the content used...

Donevf Screen Rant isn't considered a reliable source, given that it's Valnet. The Screen Rant writer is Alex Welch who has fairly extensive credits outside...

FlipandFlopped ㋡ 00:32, 10 October 2025 (UTC) @Flipandflopped See Wikipedia:VALNET. Valnet sources do not contribute to notability. Magneton Considerer: Pokelego999...

Low 407 ASOS plc 6,396 213 Start Low 408 Miniclip 6,393 213 Start Mid 409 Valnet 6,391 213 C Low 410 PoliticsPA 6,374 212 Start Low 411 Captive portal 6...

prior to being purchased by Valnet, due to concerns over undue weight and content farming. (Screen Rant was purchased by Valnet in 2015, according to our...

WordsmithTalk to me 05:06, 31 December 2024 (UTC) Movie Trivia Schmoedown → Valnet#Collider  (talk · links · history · stats)     [ Closure: keep/retarget/delete ] ...

There were even recent discussions debating whether TheGamer and its sister ValNet websites are now generally unreliable. The Night Watch (talk) 16:24, 4 October...

collaboration with Valnet. Brachy08 (Talk) 10:22, 12 September 2023 (UTC) Thank you for your feedback. Question though. Why would collaboration with Valnet make their...

Squad Variants Escala i corda Frontó International game Llargues Raspall ValNet List of Catalan plants by scientific name List of endemic plants in Minorca...

09:39, 4 March 2026 (UTC) @Sparks19923 Valnet sources cannot be used to show notability per Wikipedia:VALNET. Just because a character appeared in a...

reliable or prior to being purchased by Valnet, due to concerns over undue weight and content farming. Valnet is really just the worst kind of content...

proposed for splitting by Irecorsan was closed; discussion 09 Nov 2019 – ValNet PRODed by Ravenswing was deproded by VF9 on 15 Nov 2019 09 Feb 2020 – Judaeo-Catalan...

unilaterally added by an editor who may or may not have a bias against Valnet properties (justified or otherwise), and no one has done their due diligence...

-full-blown-video-games/ Dualshockers is a Valnet-owned property, and is listed as unreliable at WP:VALNET. ~ Henry Stickmin has its own section in the...

-full-blown-video-games/ Dualshockers is a Valnet-owned property, and is listed as unreliable at WP:VALNET. ~ Henry Stickmin has its own section in the...

🌽33 20:07, 30 June 2026 (UTC) Well a major problem here is the use of Valnet, or really the fact that it's 3 whole articles for that, and they're lists...

Whoa, I'm late to the party but WP:VALNET is the findings of WikiProject Video Games. At WP:RSPLIST, the only Valnet source listed is Screen Rant, which...

Best Hazbin Hotel Characters" Secondary Questionable: Valnet property. See Wikipedia:VG/S#Valnet No, passing mention, listicle "10 Best Characters From...

thing if the author had worked elsewhere, but she appears to only work on Valnet-affiliated websites. Done, I’m fine removing it as I do agree the site’s...

Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Video_games/Sources#Valnet_and_the_"notability"_issue shows that your advocacy in favour of Valnet has mostly been rejected. Lewis (baseball)...

time period, but it's in my opinion used way too much as a lower-quality Valnet source. I have not done a ref spot-check yet to evaluate for source-integrity...

Pokelego999 was closed as delete by Liz on 26 Jul 2023; discussion 06 Jul 2023 – Valnet Inc. AfDed by Alexandermcnabb was closed as delete by Spartaz on 29 Jul...

Best Hazbin Hotel Characters" Secondary Questionable: Valnet property. See Wikipedia:VG/S#Valnet No, passing mention, listicle "10 Best Characters From...

are not Valnet outlets, just to be clear on those two. Unless the point of the statement was more that their output has become more like Valnet since their...

Bearcat was closed as delete by Liz on 28 Jul 2023; discussion 06 Jul 2023 – Valnet Inc. AfDed by Alexandermcnabb was closed as delete by Spartaz on 29 Jul...

Solaire the knight (talk) 20:54, 9 June 2025 (UTC) The site is run by Valnet so WP:VALNET might be of some use, which says it's reliability is situational...

over the WP:N bar. Hobit (talk) 14:44, 19 July 2024 (UTC) Per Wikipedia:VALNET Screen Rant does not contribute to the notability of a subject. Is there...

@Emperor Valnet's been routinely depreciated, with discussions on WP:VG/S highlighting the why. Additionally there's also the issue that if only Valnet's reporting...

unreliable in a way that other Valnet sources are not? I believe that general consensus is that being owned by Valnet is not disqualifying, and the article...

Kitasan Black: [[Tōkyō Yūshun|'''Tōkyō Yūshun''']] Kitboga (streamer): [[Valnet|Valnet]] Kitchee SC: [[-|-]], [[-|-]], [[-|-]] Kitos War: [[Consul suffectus|''consul...

a book or scholarly source just for that because it feels like thegamer/valnet sources will be recommended to be removed at FAC. Many thanks for the help...

was closed as delete by RL0919 on 27 Jul 2023; discussion 06 Jul 2023 – Valnet Inc. AfDed by Alexandermcnabb was closed as delete by Spartaz on 29 Jul...

Sdkb was closed as delete by Liz on 28 Jul 2023; discussion 06 Jul 2023 – Valnet Inc. AfDed by Alexandermcnabb was closed as delete by Spartaz on 29 Jul...

April 2026 (UTC) Plenty. VFX Voice, The Digital Fix, CBR (I'm aware it's a Valnet source), Looper, ONE Esports. I think GNG is more than passed with this...

is more along the lines of writers who are hired by sites such as IGN or Valnet. That's preferable. 11WB 💬 12:49, 6 August 2026 (UTC) @11WB SFE is (currently)...

lifehacker ~ [1] not about company, short entry in list ✘ No android police valnet valnet not about company, short entry in list ✘ No mashable ~ not about company...

n-spacers-guild-navigators-spice), all sources I found were low-quality Valnet sources. Industrial Insect (talk) 14:22, 15 April 2025 (UTC) Note: This...

Theta Chi News ? — ? 1 1 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) TheThings ? Valnet Pub 2 1, 2 1.000 Wikipedia (J·M·T) Google (J·M·T) Thethings.com ? — ? 3...

Saccharinesilk (talk) 17:41, 22 November 2024 (UTC) This is one of the few Valnet-owned sites that haven't been assessed yet, so I figured I'd bring it up...

instance it's published on The Sportster which is redlisted at WP:RS/PS#Valnet and specifically listed as unreliable at WP:PW/RS. The PWI interview is...

15 January 2025 (UTC) Chris Woodrich Fair enough. I was hesitating this Valnet source before, but I guess a single usage of hisdsource oesn't really harm...

(website) proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – MovieWeb proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion...

(website) proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – MovieWeb proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion...

(website) proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – MovieWeb proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion...

Red Devil (comics) - (3702) - merge - closed 05:23, 30 July 2023 (UTC) Valnet Inc. - (35497) - delete - closed 14:52, 29 July 2023 (UTC) Muriel Frost...

coverage tend to be by Screen Rant, which do not count in this regard per WP:VALNET. In addition, information unrelated to the character's development and reception...

Are they connected to Valnet? I don't think so. Another article is mentioned by another user above. Also unconnected to Valnet. Feel free to add other...

w/|archive-date=November 16, 2025 |access-date=March 4, 2026 |website=[[Valnet|TheGamer]]}}</ref>↵<ref name="ComicB">{{Cite web|last= Adkins|first= Hannah|date=August...

(nevermind the usual Valnet complaints).--Kung Fu Man (talk) 05:32, 7 February 2025 (UTC) Comment What's frustrating about the Valnet situation is that their...

much. Additionally, one of the sources you cite here is CBR, which per WP:VALNET, bears no weight on notability in discussions such as these. The Kotaku...

listed at WP:VALNET as a "situational source" The Explorer (ref 4), a student newspaper Game Rant (refs 12 and 14), another WP:VALNET source, explicitly...

is this ScreenRant article [15]. I am very aware of the... issues with Valnet sources and I've seen much pushback on this source specifically. Do you...

WP:RSP entry notes that the reliability and quality is uncertain after the Valnet purchase. I don't treat this to mean "still high-quality until otherwise...

Not a great source, but nonetheless better than a reddit post, and WP:VALNET sources are usually good enough when it comes to fictional minutiae. I would...

SearXNG. XDA - a site ran by Valnet. It may be reliable, but according to Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Perennial_sources, Valnet runs several content farms...

problem with Valnet for sourcing, but these are just not cutting the mustard.--Kung Fu Man (talk) 21:46, 29 November 2023 (UTC) The point of Valnet's sites are...

sources used in the article are not only from unreliable sources like WP:VALNET sites, but the actual coverage of the character in them is trivial, with...

I am not currently convinced by questionable/situational sources (e.g.: valnet) and I see a lot of these characters are already covered in more standard...

content farm Valnet site listicle links such as CBR or TheGamer, etc. My point from the previous nom still stands besides the addition of Valnet sites. ᴢxᴄᴠʙɴᴍ...

reliability (e.g. games.gg), sources that can't establish notability (e.g. Valnet sources), and unreliable user-generated sites (e.g. Modrinth and the Create...

notability unfortunately. Refs 1 and 4 are WP:PRIMARY. Refs 9 and 18-20 are WP:VALNET. Refs 2, 5, 7, and 9 don't mention Parasect or only give a name drop. Refs...

and the publication is reliable, as it was published years before the VALNET acquisition. AfterEllen was an influential website for lesbian issues. See...

but I'm skeptical about putting it in because of WP:VALNET. I've put it in for now and if needed, can take it out later. It doesn't...

seeing as its content mainly consists of how-to guides and listicles. As a Valnet-owned property, MakeUseOf's fact-checking policy is heavily similar to those...

original content after August 2020 are considered generally reliable." – WP:VALNET Brief trivial mention ✘ No Gary A. Swaby (2015-10-25). "Fleeing the Complex:...

reporter minor award again ✘ No eonline minor award again ✘ No GameRant valnet property + pseudonymous author = no accountability ✘ No Bachelor thesis...

ミラP@Miraclepine 01:55, 24 June 2025 (UTC) The sources in the linked FGO AFD are WP:VALNET sources, so I don't think this is any kind of precedent. I have not looked...

qualifier that content published by Valnet on any of these sites are notable, and in fact, the text states that Valnet-published material is allowed, but...

I avoid using that site, particularly for anything published after the Valnet acquisition. Anyway, please let me know if there are ways to have this information...

Family For Season 48". TheThings. Retrieved January 28, 2026. Owned by Valnet (WP:VALNET). Its reliability was questioned / contested (2024, 2025) ? Unknown...

in 2022 and updated in 2024. I've also found retrospective takes from Valnet's Screen Rant and Game Rant, though I can see that both publications fall...

(UTC) It's owned by Valnet, which has seen some previous discussion here, and is also listed by WikiProject Video games (WP:VALNET). I would agree it is...

Business Hall of Fame - (4522) - delete - closed 23:13, 30 July 2023 (UTC) Valnet Inc. - (35497) - delete - closed 14:52, 29 July 2023 (UTC) Outline (note-taking...

replacing Adobe Illustrator with this service". XDA. Retrieved 2025-09-26. Valnet now Also, the list format, while having many merits, really obscures the...

(UTC) Naked Capitalism - (13387) - keep - closed 03:17, 1 August 2023 (UTC) Valnet Inc. - (35497) - delete - closed 14:52, 29 July 2023 (UTC) University of...

Brendan Guraliuk - (5918) - redirect - closed 16:36, 31 July 2023 (UTC) Valnet Inc. - (35497) - delete - closed 14:52, 29 July 2023 (UTC) James Lafazanos...

is an extremely low quality source that outputs a lot of churnalism (WP:VALNET) and consensus has been that it does not contribute to notability. This...

is an extremely low quality source that outputs a lot of churnalism (WP:VALNET) and consensus has been that it does not contribute to notability. This...

possible paid news. ZDNet - Single paragraph of prose Makeuseof - Part of the Valnet content farm, unusable for anything else than the most basic of facts. Livemint...

replacing Adobe Illustrator with this service". XDA. Retrieved 2025-09-26. Valnet now Also, the list format, while having many merits, really obscures the...

Comic Book Resources and ScreenRant are Valnet-owned and can't used to demonstrate notability per WP:VALNET. The collector's guide is not "independent...

lifehacker ~ [35] not about company, short entry in list ✘ No android police valnet valnet not about company, short entry in list ✘ No mashable ~ not about company...

TheGamer is a Valnet source, but it's post-August 2020 and the author seems legit, so I'd consider that to be one of those exceptions to the Valnet rule and...

How-To Geek (pre-July 2023) 0.98 site:howtogeek.com before:2023-07-01 N WP:VALNET Tech In Asia (pre-Jan. 2024) unrated site:techinasia.com before:2024-01-01...

above also isn't convincing me, given it's mainly reviews and valnet. And normally I like Valnet but you need some meat to go with it.--Kung Fu Man (talk)...

com/wayward-realms-elder-scrolls-fantasy-rpg-stealth-snuff-flame-good-why/ GameRant is a Valnet property Mostly about Wayward Realms ✘ No https://dgoodall.substack...

Cardone Made His $600 Million Fortune". TheRichest. Retrieved 2023-12-04. ~ Valnet property ~ Maybe Cardone, Grant (2022-03-29). "GCTV". GCTV. Retrieved 2023-12-04...

reporter minor award again ✘ No eonline minor award again ✘ No GameRant valnet property + pseudonymous author = no accountability ✘ No Bachelor thesis...

com/wayward-realms-elder-scrolls-fantasy-rpg-stealth-snuff-flame-good-why/ GameRant is a Valnet property Mostly about Wayward Realms ✘ No https://dgoodall.substack...

delete. Rusalkii (talk) 22:23, 29 January 2026 (UTC) Jeremy Jahns (critic) → Valnet#Collider  (talk · links · history · stats)     [ Closure: keep/retarget/delete ] ...

of them were either plot summaries, trivial mentions, or low quality WP:VALNET sources. Searches still yield absolutely nothing in the way of WP:SIGCOV...

(talk) 04:06, 29 November 2024 (UTC) Keep GNG is met, and even without the VALNET sources, which are just fine in this case. This is a particularly inconsiderate...

this source as a WP:VALNET post-Mid 2023? The other VALNET's should be fine since they were published prior to that I don't think VALNET is all that justified...

13 January 2024 (UTC) Merge per Zx, somewhat. I'll add I'm not against Valnet lists being used, but if they're discussing the work and not just reiterating...

MikeM2011 was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – MovieWeb proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 12 May 2024 – List of Girl Meets World...

WP:VALNET (see below) confused with a diff source, yeah, it's probably unreliable, removed I'm not thrilled with the citing of various WP:VALNET sources...

is not a high-quality source (and possibly not even reliable, see WP:RS/VALNET) and as such should not be used for WP:Featured articles (WP:FACR 1c). thank...

WP:VALNET for how the video game world is generally going to see using Game Rant as a source. Sergecross73 msg me 18:09, 2 June 2025 (UTC) WP:VALNET states...

TheGamer (IIRC Valnet sources are considered marginally reliable by en VG/RS..? 2) There are few more like this from GameRant (another Valnet source); I am...

masthead[37] We also have a review in by Sam Stone in CBR [38]. CBR is owned by Valnet, so marginal reliability overall, but Sam Stone is also published in PopVerse...

VTK VTech Laser 200 Vacuum-tube computer The Vagenda Amin Vahdat Valkey Valnet Valve Index Van Eck phreaking Vanguard (microkernel) Vanilla Forums Vanish...

topic meets WP:N. A large number of the sources are from a content farm Valnet Inc. and the remainder appear to be WP:GAMECRUFT. I think this topic should...

of the content. In other words, view it as you would IMDb. MovieWeb is Valnet. Much of their stuff is considered to be questionable as they tend to rely...

listed on WP:VG/S as reliable prior to 2016 when it was purchased by Valnet (see WP:VALNET). That appears to be a similar sentiment to the discussion of the...

present) WP:POLYGON 📌 A B 2025 In May 2025, Vox Media sold Polygon to Valnet and promptly laid off most Polygon staff; as of May 2025, this event's long-term...

Kailash29792 was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – MovieWeb proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 17 May 2024 – Musique(s) électronique(s)...

source, and nearly every other source used for WP:SIGCOV purposes is WP:VALNET or plucking WP:ROUTINE coverage from sources. This article is also a huge...

looking up film topics fills half of the first page of Google with iffy Valnet sources, I generalize that World of Reel tends to show up on page 2 or 3...

unreliable at WP:VG/S and CBR is considered situational, and both are from Valnet, which can't be used to demonstrate notability. Also, that isn't the complete...

Patterson (talk) 11:45, 14 June 2025 (UTC) Similar to how WP:VALNET states that Valnet sources should not be used to establish notability, I do not think...

(UTC) I didn't know about VG/S, thank you for mentioning it. I see now that Valnet is listed as questionable reliability and that invalidates the sources I...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) I disagree with the AfC acceptance. Ignoring Valnet content farm, non-independent sources, and simple database entries, there...

mentions of the character (The bulk of which were unreliable or belonged to WP:VALNET). Some reviews for his titular episodes were included, but do not include...

of all Valnet sites and is therefore not sufficient on its own to effectively support the claim under WP:BLP. This explicit "Don't use Valnet sites" caveat...

notability, The Things is owned by Valnet, which also owns Screen Rant, a "marginally reliable" source (WP:RSP#Screen Rant). Valnet is criticized as a "clickbait/churnalism"...

citations rather than The Guardian. I've added the publisher for TheGamer, Valnet, to the corresponding citation. I've found citations to support the bosses...

most prominent source is on Ryan George YouTube videos. Related to the Valnet merges/additions, I suggest redirected to the section there. IgelRM (talk)...

Gommeh (talk 🎮 sign) 17:31, 22 July 2026 (UTC) CBR is situational post-2016 as per WP:VALNET, hence the need to evaluate it in more detail. From my point of view, the...

through, and I didn't see any citation mismatches. Valnet Per WP:VALNET, sources published by Valnet should be met with heightened scrutiny, although they...

sources of low quality (like Newsrama), dead sources like ref 12, too many Valnet sources like Comicbook.com, plenty of blogs, and plenty of unreliable sources...

fails WP:USERG. Source 11, wow, this far before Valnet appears? Source 12, Complex, which is as bad as Valnet, and doesn't really say anything. Source 13...

2025 (UTC) There's an article by Screenrant: [2], which according to WP:VALNET shouldn't be used to establish notability. There's also this book that talks...

as this from Comic Book Resources. CBR is considered unreliable per WP:VALNET and this RS/N discussion, however the depth is what I would consider to...

not very helpful for notability due to content farm reasons per Wikipedia:VALNET. For a subject like this, I'd expect at least a few strong citations that...

blog at the same time but also not, and while the third one is owned by valnet, it actually meets its criterion for reliability, but is still not about...

it's enough. CBR is also Valnet which is unreliable. PARAKANYAA (talk) 18:39, 16 November 2024 (UTC) Yeah, listicle + Valnet is not a great combo. Only...

the idea on building a list up on primarily valnet lists Piotrus...and I'm usually in favor of using Valnet as a source.--Kung Fu Man (talk) 03:42, 13...

TWL) A character from DC Comics. A search yields largely plot summary or VALNET sources. I did find one solid Comicbook.com hit [29] but beyond that it's...

and fantasy. ᴢxᴄᴠʙɴᴍ (ᴛ) 17:41, 14 May 2026 (UTC) Comment - I added the Valnet sources in an attempt to add more references to the article, as it has had...

since 2023 having been declared unreliable. The rest of the sources are WP:VALNET sources, which cannot be used to establish notability. Google News searches...

reliable sources. Every single source used in the article at present is a WP:VALNET source, which cannot be used to establish notability in most cases. And...

shallow in coverage. For example, most of the reception is either cited to WP:VALNET sources (which cannot establish notability) (e.g. GameRant, Collider), or...

(talk) 19:53, 21 September 2024 (UTC) Comment Valnet sources do not contribute to notability per Wikipedia:VALNET. Has one ever considered Magneton? Pokelego999...

known for producing situational to unreliable sources like Fox. (See WP:VALNET) Without any evidence to prove that Valent's unreliable practices had trickled...

is almost entirely WP:ROUTINE announcements regarding the character, WP:VALNET sources, which do not provide notability, or brief listicle rankings without...

(talk) 14:59, 15 December 2024 (UTC) This source falls under Wikipedia:VALNET and is not helpful in demonstrating notability Magneton Considerer: Pokelego999...

rest of the sources aren't much better, since we have several sources from Valnet-owned publications that can't be used to contribute towards notability....

inadequate. These sources seemed to in the same camp as sites like the Valnet properties in which the focus more on entertaining than informing an audience...

primary sources, with the exception of an article that was published by a Valnet-owned publisher. Furthermore, it might not be a valid search term, as a...

BLAR'd by the author after it was determined that it relied too heavily on Valnet-published sources, which suggested weak claims to notability. No Chansey...

Fails GNG; and a WP:BEFORE search turned up pretty much nothing except for Valnet sources which do not contribute to notability anyways. Merge as ATD per...

I think a bit problem is so much of it relies on questionable refs and Valnet, and some of the former are interwoven into the article, concerns I brought...

considered questionable sources in the past, with TheGamer being until the Valnet umbrella which are generally seen as not suitable for BLP claims (Screen...

coverage there. Jclemens (talk) 00:37, 19 April 2024 (UTC) According to WP:VALNET: "In general, these sites should not be used to demonstrate notability outside...

sources are either plot summary or hail from trivial mentions or Wikipedia:VALNET. There's little in the way of SIGCOV or an actual indication of the importance...

well known character doesn't mean the character is automatically notable. Valnet sources lile ScreenRant doesn't help its notability. GreenishPickle! (🔔)...

(talk) 12:12, 8 December 2025 (UTC) Delete Sources are either WP:ROUTINE, WP:VALNET, or don't have WP:SIGCOV. Mikeycdiamond (talk) 13:19, 8 December 2025 (UTC)...

closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – Collider (website) proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 26 Sep 2024 – Effects of Hurricane Ida...

Valum only a part of it, while CBR has no bearing on notability per WP:VALNET. The development is entirely about the script, with the Polygon source and...

Rant — Source associated with Valnet, a dubious publishing company. See WikiProject Video games' assessment of Valnet and this discussion. Cartoon Brew...

date range. Further checks: WP:VALNET: @BP! makes a good point below. Valnet sources are generally of low quality. All Valnet sources, with the exception...

but I'm skeptical about putting it in because of WP:VALNET. I've put it in for now and if needed, can take it out later. It doesn't...

Game Rant list (that CAN be used to expand the article, that's what WP:VALNET clearly states). Among missing titles in the list is Doctor Whore (https://www...

was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – Screen Rant proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 24 Jul 2024 – Wenis proposed for merging...

Rant and CBR, but seeing as how they've been quite divisive here owing to Valnet, I'd understand omitting them for proving notability (besides perhaps CBR)...

closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – Collider (website) proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 26 Sep 2024 – Savings Bank of South Australia...

Bearcat was closed as delete by Liz on 28 Jul 2023; discussion 06 Jul 2023 – Valnet Inc. AfDed by Alexandermcnabb was closed as delete by Spartaz on 29 Jul...

found one from Christian Today and Game Rant (before being purchased by Valnet, no less). I think there's more than enough here, especially when you consider...

closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – XDA Developers proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 17 Jul 2024 – CompuServe Information Manager...

Bearcat was closed as delete by Liz on 28 Jul 2023; discussion 06 Jul 2023 – Valnet Inc. AfDed by Alexandermcnabb was closed as delete by Spartaz on 29 Jul...

majority of these sources are unreliable (fansites like Tohokingdom or WP:VALNET sites like GameRant), literal pieces of fiction (various comic books), or...

Beyond that, though, is very little. There's some trivia articles from Valnet, which generally don't count for notability, but that's about it, and none...

publication" on VGRS TheGamer is noted as a "situational source" on VGRS (see: WP:VALNET) Cracked.com is noted as "generally unreliable" on RS/PS Medium is a self-published...

(talk) 01:59, 7 April 2026 (UTC) WPVG already has a dedicated table: WP:VALNET. SuperGrey (talk) 11:28, 7 April 2026 (UTC) Thanks for the link. So, if...

Self-Hosted Read-It-Later App from "Make use of" (Owned by Canadian media company Valnet) How I Turned My Raspberry Pi Into a Private Internet Archive from "make...

was closed; discussion 10 Sep 2024 – Screen Rant proposed for merging to Valnet by BD2412 was closed; discussion 04 Oct 2024 – Sora Ltd. proposed for merging...

20:25, 21 February 2023 (UTC) Judging by the layout, this seems to be a Valnet source. Note that other sources of this company such as Screen Rant and...

2020, meaning it provides as much notability to the subject as an average Valnet source. Beyond that, Game Rant briefly discussed it, but it also does not...

reporter minor award again ✘ No eonline minor award again ✘ No GameRant valnet property + pseudonymous author = no accountability ✘ No Polygon WP:RSP:...

Wikipedia:WikiProject Video games/Sources, the Game Rant article is a listicle at a WP:VALNET site, and the The Record is a literal one-sentence mention (in passing)...

TheGamer, which is another source that can't demonstrate notability per WP:VALNET. There is no actual material or sourcing present in this article that leads...

yields quite literally nothing bar trivial mentions in announcements and VALNET listicles, and the current article cites no sources whatsoever. Clearly...

WP:FIXTHEPROBLEM. Sparks19923 (talk) 09:39, 4 March 2026 (UTC) @Sparks19923 CBR is a Valnet source, which does not contribute notability, and is additionally considered...

receotion were mostly filled with listicle-type articles. Unfortunately, valnet source like this [12] doesn't help its notability, an IGN source, which...

thing I found was an entry in a ScreenRant list: [23], ScreenRant is a WP:VALNET site. Suggesting a merge to Land of Oz#Gillikin Country. See also previous...

unwarranted. Pokelego999 (talk) 22:08, 4 September 2023 (UTC) Movieweb, Valnet and Dreadcentral sources doesn't contribute WP:GNG. Metro and Bvtack are...

consensus (Dexerto, Sportskeeda, Odyssey per USERGEN). GameRant is a WP:VALNET site and can't be used as evidence for SIGCOV. The others are simply coverage...

Trying to dig deeper shows not much unfortunately other than a lot of Valnet. I could see individual articles perhaps (especially Astolfo), but the list...

of what is available. - Cukie Gherkin (talk) 21:02, 23 March 2024 (UTC) Valnet, but [52] [53] both discuss the character in the film to a significant extent...

(talk) 07:48, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Comment: VALNET should target Valnet (disambiguation) instead -- 64.229.90.172 (talk) 03:43, 12 June...

not those sources"? BoomboxTestarossa (talk) 19:52, 22 August 2023 (UTC) Valnet sources are widely known as content farms, it's telling that the main source...

believe the sources are also of high quality, though I'd draw attention to Valnet sources. While I agree that they offer minimal value for the sake of notability...

for you: Ref 1: isn't asking for a paid subscription from me? Ref 7: a WP:VALNET source, is there anything better available? Cut Ref 10: VIDEO --> Video...

WP:GNG? How do such interviews with that winner count for GNG? Also, per WP:VALNET, Collider has some churnalism, but its reliability is "situational" so far...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) No sources with SIGCOV besides two IMDB and WP:VALNET articles. Mikeycdiamond (talk) 14:00, 20 September 2025 (UTC) Note: This...

requirements. Siliconera is the only source [40] providing WP:SIGCOV? While the Valnet sources do not contribute to notability, and the Chinese sources appear...

press releases are considered primary sources. GameRant article is by WP:VALNET so it shouldn't be used for notability but it's also fairly standard coverage...

my! (Mushy Yank) 16:29, 5 October 2024 (UTC) Lets take a look: CBR: WP:VALNET WBUR: Local NPR affiliate, pretty plot based but does have some COV. if...

What makes Programming Insider a reliable source? I usually gripe with WP:VALNET sources, are there any better sources that could cover the Collider references...

already in the article do not count towards SIGCOV due to being owned by WP:VALNET. I think this should probably be redirected to List of Star Wars planets...

three sources, two of which are unreliable and the third of which is WP:VALNET. No sources have been demonstrated showcasing why this version meets notability...

article from Screen Rant (not a source we should be using here, see WP:RSP/VALNET), this article from The Daily Telegraph about the show Disenchantment that...

comic book character who has literally no SIGCOV, only being referenced in Valnet sources. There is no possible notability I can find for this character,...

up WP:ROUTINE coverage of the role's various changes in the comics, WP:VALNET sources that don't contribute to notability, or summary style articles that...

summary hit from Nerdist but every other hit has been trivial mentions or Valnet. There's a perfectly valid section to contain this info, as even with Nerdist...

Hydrangeans (she/her | talk | edits) 04:35, 28 March 2024 (UTC) I believe Valnet sources like CBR doesn't contribute to GNG after checking WP:RSP. But, I...

time to find sigcov on a quick google search. Article mostly relies on Valnet sources at reception, thus failing WP:GNG. SyFy Wire is the only valuable...

fact weakly pass GNG, and that's when you ignore the dozens of mentions in Valnet sites like CBR and GameRant. I do think the sourcing is relatively weak...

reliability. A WP:BEFORE search only yielded a Game Rant article, which is a Valnet content farm with also questionable reliability. There are no critic reviews...

article discussing the factions [25], and there's [26] and [27] if you like Valnet, but there's less out there than I would have guessed. The thing stopping...

worth merging (the only secondary source being used for "Reception" is a Valnet site "Top Ten" style list) but the history will be there if anyone wants...

From my WP:BEFORE search, the only sources covering this as a group are WP:VALNET sources, which do not confer notability per our guidelines. Most hits for...

the mochii (talk) 21:00, 16 July 2023 (UTC) Sadly, that site was sold to Valnet in 2016 so reliability is iffy: discussion about CBR from a year ago, and...

of SIGCOV or significant discussion, even in content farm sources like Valnet. Would support a redirect to Companion (Doctor Who) or List of Doctor Who...

(2015) p.84-86, and this article in CBR (which is considered reliable pre Valnet purchase, and the site was relaunched in August 2016 - the article is from...

used for controversial statements related to living persons. See also: WP:VALNET 1   Scribd 1 2 3 4 2016 Scribd operates a self-publishing platform for documents...

"Soundtrack of Crazy Bus" article, I'm not even seeing coverage for that in non-Valnet sites. Just random notoriety and popularity. Which doesn't equal notability...

The most prevalent source in the article, Comic Book Resources and other Valnet sites, are not reliable sources. --Mika1h (talk) 16:29, 26 October 2023...

(which ultimately proved to be untrue) from unreliable sources like WP:VALNET sites, or simple plot recaps where the crown appears to fill out a "list...

the not-outright-unreliable or user-generated sources here are from WP:VALNET, and most of the rest are just from Anime News Network. The current state...

two sources. PCGamer is reliable, so that's good. But Gamerant, part of Valnet's suite, is considered unsuitable for WP:N questions. So this entire list...

these comics. I did search to find a bit of reception, but I can only find Valnet sources, which are not reliable, and even those are limited. Di (they-them)...

TWL) There are no sources with WP:SIGCOV, with the exception of one WP:VALNET source (ScreenRant). Mikeycdiamond (talk) 18:09, 19 September 2025 (UTC)...

attributed more to the game than the guy itself. While I'm not opposed to using Valnet for notability, those are just too weak to do the job.--Kung Fu Man (talk)...