Reviewing the book for The New York Times, Thomas Mallon said: "Combining actual and invented figures requires a particular sleight of hand, and in The Magician's Wife Moore accomplishes this mingling without giving any glimpse of a false bottom or secret compartment... The Magician's Wife, combining so many of Moore's longtime preoccupations and themes, proves to be one of his neatest tricks yet."[4] Brian St. Pierre in the San Francisco Chronicle described it as a "deft and absorbing novel".[2] John Muncie, reviewing the novel for the Baltimore Sun, said that The Magician's Wife "plays with French history and the power of illusion... Moore writes with propulsive clarity. The reader is immediately entangled."