Jonathan Baumbach of The New York Times wrote that the words in the English translation were "a mix of modern idiom and literary diction".[1]
Story
The book portrays four, not three magi, with one having a late arrival to important events. This fourth prince eventually goes to Sodom.[2]
Reception
John Weightman of The Observer stated that there was "symbolic magnification" in this book; he argued that it had "incidental good things" though he felt overall it was "a luscious, rather over-loaded fairy-tale".[2]
Kirkus Reviews stated that compared to Gemini, the Four Wise Men has more "more narrative enchantment" thematically, and is not as "dense".[3]Kirkus concluded that this is one of the "better" books by the author.[3]
The Washington Post stated that of the novels by the author, this one "may be the most inviting".[4]
Phoebe-Lou Adams of The Atlantic wrote that the work has "a real touch of magic".[5]