Ptolemy's intense diatonic scale

Diatonic scale on C, equal tempered Playⓘ and Ptolemy's intense or just Playⓘ.

Ptolemy's intense diatonic scale, also known as the Ptolemaic sequence,[1] justly tuned major scale,[2][3][4] Ptolemy's tense diatonic scale, or the syntonous (or syntonic) diatonic scale, is a tuning for the diatonic scale proposed by Ptolemy,[5] and corresponding with modern 5-limit just intonation.[6] While Ptolemy is famous for this version of just intonation, it is important to realize this was only one of several genera of just, diatonic intonations he describes. He also describes 7-limit "soft" diatonics and an 11-limit "even" diatonic.

This tuning was declared by Zarlino to be the only tuning that could be reasonably sung, it was also supported by Giuseppe Tartini,[7] and is equivalent to Indian Gandhar tuning which features exactly the same intervals.

It is produced through a tetrachord consisting of a greater tone (9:8), lesser tone (10:9), and just diatonic semitone (16:15).[6] This is called Ptolemy's intense diatonic tetrachord (or "tense"), as opposed to Ptolemy's soft diatonic tetrachord (or "relaxed"), which is formed by 21:20, 10:9 and 8:7 intervals.[8]

Structure

The structure of the intense diatonic scale is shown in the tables below, where T is for greater tone, t is for lesser tone and s is for semitone:

Note Name C D E F G A B C
Solfege Do Re Mi Fa Sol La Ti Do
Ratio from C 1:1 9:8 5:4 4:3 3:2 5:3 15:8 2:1
Harmonic 24ⓘ 27ⓘ 30ⓘ 32ⓘ 36ⓘ 40ⓘ 45ⓘ 48ⓘ
Cents 0 204 386 498 702 884 1088 1200
Step Name   T t s T t T s
Ratio 9:8 10:9 16:15 9:8 10:9 9:8 16:15
Cents 204 182 112 204 182 204 112
Note Name A B C D E F G A
Ratio from A 1:1 9:8 6:5 4:3 3:2 8:5 9:5 2:1
Harmonic of Fundamental B♭ 120 135 144 160 180 192 216 240
Cents 0 204 316 498 702 814 1018 1200
Step Name   T s t T s T t
Ratio 9:8 16:15 10:9 9:8 16:15 9:8 10:9
Cents 204 112 182 204 112 204 182

Comparison with other diatonic scales

Ptolemy's intense diatonic scale can be constructed by lowering the pitches of Pythagorean tuning's 3rd, 6th, and 7th degrees (in C, the notes E, A, and B) by the syntonic comma, 81:80. This scale may also be considered as derived from the just major chord (ratios 4:5:6, so a major third of 5:4 and fifth of 3:2), and the major chords a fifth below and a fifth above it: FAC–CEG–GBD. This perspective emphasizes the central role of the tonic, dominant, and subdominant in the diatonic scale.

In comparison to Pythagorean tuning, which only uses 3:2 perfect fifths (and fourths), the Ptolemaic provides just thirds (and sixths), both major and minor (5:4 and 6:5; sixths 8:5 and 5:3), which are smoother and more easily tuned than Pythagorean thirds (81:64 and 32:27) and Pythagorean sixths (27:16 and 128/81),[9] with one minor third (and one major sixth) left at the Pythagorean interval, at the cost of replacing one fifth (and one fourth) with a wolf interval.

Intervals between notes (wolf intervals bolded):

   C D E F G A B C′ D′ E′ F′ G′ A′ B′ C″
C 1:1 9:8 5:4 4:3 3:2 5:3 15:8 2:1 9:4 5:2 8:3 3:1 10:3 15:4 4:1
D 8:9 1:1 10:9 32:27 4:3 40:27 5:3 16:9 2:1 20:9 64:27 8:3 80:27 10:3 32:9
E 4:5 9:10 1:1 16:15 6:5 4:3 3:2 8:5 9:5 2:1 32:15 12:5 8:3 3:1 16:5
F 3:4 27:32 15:16 1:1 9:8 5:4 45:32 3:2 27:16 15:8 2:1 9:4 5:2 45:16 3:1
G 2:3 3:4 5:6 8:9 1:1 10:9 5:4 4:3 3:2 5:3 16:9 2:1 20:9 5:2 8:3
A 3:5 27:40 3:4 4:5 9:10 1:1 9:8 6:5 27:20 3:2 8:5 9:5 2:1 9:4 12:5
B 8:15 9:15 2:3 32:45 4:5 8:9 1:1 16:15 6:5 4:3 64:45 8:5 16:9 2:1 32:15
C′ 1:2 9:16 5:8 2:3 3:4 5:6 15:16 1:1 9:8 5:4 4:3 3:2 5:3 15:8 2:1
Pythagorean diatonic scale on C Playⓘ. Johnston's notation; + indicates the syntonic comma.

Note that D–F is a Pythagorean minor third or semiditone (32:27), its inversion F–D is a Pythagorean major sixth (27:16); D–A is a wolf fifth (40:27), and its inversion A–D is a wolf fourth (27:20). All of these differ from their just counterparts by a syntonic comma (81:80). More concisely, the triad built on the 2nd degree (D) is out-of-tune.

F-B is the tritone (more precisely, an augmented fourth), here 45:32, while B-F is a diminished fifth, here 64:45.

References

  1. ^ Partch, Harry (1979). Genesis of a Music, pp. 165, 173. ISBN 978-0-306-80106-8.
  2. ^ Murray Campbell, Clive Greated (1994). The Musician's Guide to Acoustics, pp. 172–73. ISBN 978-0-19-816505-7.
  3. ^ Wright, David (2009). Mathematics and Music, pp. 140–41. ISBN 978-0-8218-4873-9.
  4. ^ Johnston, Ben and Gilmore, Bob (2006). "A Notation System for Extended Just Intonation" (2003), "Maximum clarity" and Other Writings on Music, p. 78. ISBN 978-0-252-03098-7.
  5. ^ see Wallis, John (1699). Opera Mathematica, Vol. III. Oxford. p. 39. (Contains Harmonics by Claudius Ptolemy.)
  6. ^ a b Chisholm, Hugh (1911). The Encyclopædia Britannica, Vol.28, p. 961. The Encyclopædia Britannica Company.
  7. ^ Dr. Crotch (October 1, 1861). "On the Derivation of the Scale, Tuning, Temperament, the Monochord, etc.", The Musical Times, p. 115.
  8. ^ Chalmers, John H. Jr. (1993). Divisions of the Tetrachord. Hanover, NH: Frog Peak Music. ISBN 0-945996-04-7 Chapter 2, Page 9
  9. ^ Johnston, Ben; Gilmore, Bob (2006). 'Maximum Clarity' and Other Writings on Music. p. 100. ISBN 978-0-252-03098-7.