Object–relational impedance mismatch

Object–relational impedance mismatch is a set of difficulties going between data in relational data stores and data in domain-driven object models. Relational Database Management Systems (RDBMS) is the standard method for storing data in a dedicated database, while object-oriented (OO) programming is the default method for business-centric design in programming languages. The problem lies in neither relational databases nor OO programming, but in the conceptual difficulty mapping between the two logic models. Both logical models are differently implementable using database servers, programming languages, design patterns, or other technologies. Issues range from application to enterprise scale, whenever stored relational data is used in domain-driven object models, and vice versa. Object-oriented data stores can trade this problem for other implementation difficulties.

The term impedance mismatch comes from impedance matching in electrical engineering.

Mismatches

OO mathematically is directed graphs, where objects reference each other. Relational is tuples in tables with relational algebra. Tuples are data fields grouped into a "row" with typed fields. Links are reversible (INNER JOIN is symmetric to follow foreign keys backwards), forming undirected graphs.

Object-oriented concepts

Encapsulation

Object encapsulation hides internals. Object properties only show through implemented interfaces. However, many ORMs expose the properties publicly to work with database columns. Metaprogramming ORMs avoid violating encapsulation.

Accessibility

"Private" versus "public" is need-based in relational. In OO it is absolutely class-based. This relativity versus absolutism of classifications and characteristics clashes.

Interface, class, inheritance and polymorphism

Objects must implement interfaces to expose internals. Relational uses views to vary perspectives and constraints. It lacks OO concepts like classes, inheritance and polymorphism.

Mapping to relational concepts

In order for an ORM to work properly, tables that are linked via Foreign Key/Primary Key relations need to be mapped to associations in object-oriented analysis.

Data type differences

Relational prohibits by-reference (e.g. pointers), while OO embraces by-reference. Scalar types differ between them, impeding mapping.

SQL supports strings with maximum lengths (faster than without) and collations. OO has collation only with sort routines and strings limited only by memory. SQL usually ignores trailing whitespace during comparison char, but OO libraries do not. OO does not newtype using constraints on primitives.

Structural and integrity differences

Objects can comprise other objects or specialize. Relational is unnested, and a relation (tuples with the same header) does not fit in OO.

Relational uses declarative constraints on scalar types, attributes, relation variables, and/or globally. OO uses exceptions protecting object internals.

Manipulative differences

Relational uses standardized operators for data manipulation, while OO uses per-class per-case imperative. Any OO declarative support is for lists and hash tables, distinct from the sets in relational.[citation needed]

Transactional differences

Relational's unit is the transaction which outsizes any OO class methods. Transactions include arbitrary data manipulation combinations, while OO only has individual assignments to primitive fields. OO lacks isolation and durability, so atomicity and consistency are only with primitives.

Solving impedance mismatch

Solutions start with recognizing the differences between the logic systems. This minimizes or compensates for the mismatch.[1]

Alternative architectures

  1. NoSQL. The mismatch is not between OO and DBMSes. Object-relational impedance mismatch is eponymously only between OO and RDBMSes. Alternatives like NoSQL or XML databases avoid this.
  2. Functional-relational mapping. Functional programming is a popular alternative to object-oriented programming. Comprehensions in functional programming languages are isomorphic with relational queries.[2] Some functional programming languages implement functional-relational mapping.[3] The direct correspondence between comprehensions and queries avoids many of the problems of object-relational mapping.

Minimization in OO

Object databases (OODBMS) to avoid the mismatch exist but only less successfully than relational databases. OO is a poor basis for schemas.[4] Future OO database research involves transactional memory.

Another solution layers the domain and framework logic. Here, OO maps relational aspects at runtime rather than statically. Frameworks have a tuple class (also named row or entity) and a relation class (a.k.a dataset).

Advantages

  • Straightforward to frameworks and automation around data transport, presentation, and validation
  • Smaller, faster, quicker code[citation needed]
  • Dynamic database schema
  • Namespace and semantic match
  • Expressive constraints
  • Avoids complex mapping

Disadvantages

  • No static typing. Typed accessors mitigate this.
  • Indirection performance cost
  • Ignores concepts like polymorphism

Compensation

Mixing OO levels of discourse is problematic. Mainly framework support compensates, by automating data manipulation and presentation patterns on the level of modelling. Reflection and code generation are used. Reflection addresses code as data to allow automatic data transport, presentation, and integrity. Generation turns schemas into classes and helpers. Both have anomalies between levels, where generated classes have both domain properties (e.g. Name, Address, Phone) and framework properties (e.g. IsModified).

Occurrence

Although object-relational impedance mismatches can occur with object-oriented programming in general, a particular area of difficulty is with object–relational mappers (ORMs).[5] Since the ORM is often specified in terms of configuration, annotations, and restricted domain-specific languages, it lacks the flexibility of a full programming language to resolve the impedance mismatch.

Contention

True RDBMS model

Christopher J. Date says a true relational DBMS overcomes the problem,[6][7][8] as domains and classes are equivalent. Mapping between relational and OO is a mistake.[9] Relational tuples relate, not represent, entities. OO's role becomes only managing fields.

Constraints and illegal transactions

Domain objects and user interfaces have mismatched impedances. Productive UIs should prevent illegal transactions (database constraint violations) to help operators and other non-programmers manage the data. This requires knowledge about database attributes beyond name and type, which duplicates logic in the relational schemata.

Frameworks leverage referential integrity constraints and other schema information to standardize handling away from case-by-case code.

SQL-specific impedance and workarounds

SQL, lacking domain types, impedes OO modelling.[disputeddiscuss] It is lossy between the DBMS and the application (OO or not). However, many avoid NoSQL and alternative vendor-specific query languages. DBMSes also ignore Business System 12 and Tutorial D.

Mainstream DBMSes like Oracle and Microsoft SQL Server solve this. OO code (Java and .NET respectively) extend them and are invokeable in SQL as fluently as if built into the DBMS. Reusing library routines across multiple schemas is a supported modern paradigm.

OO is in the backend because SQL will never get modern libraries and structures for today's programmers, despite the ISO SQL-99 committee wanting to add procedural. It is reasonable to use them directly rather than changing SQL. This blurs the division of responsibility between "application programming" and "database administration" because implementing constraints and triggers now requires both DBA and OO skills.

This contention may be moot. RDBMSes are not for modelling. SQL is only lossy when abused for modelling. SQL is for querying, sorting, filtering, and storing big data. OO in the backend encourages bad architecture as business logic should not be in the data tier.

Location of canonical copy of data

Relational says the DBMS is authoritative and the OO program's objects are temporary copies (possibly outdated if the database is modified concurrently). OO says the objects are authoritative, and the DBMS is just for persistence.

Division of responsibility

New features change both code and schemas. The schema is the DBA's responsibility. DBAs are responsible for reliability, so they refuse programmers' unnecessary modifications. Staging databases help but merely move the approval to release time. DBAs want to contain changes to code, where defects are less catastrophic.

More collaboration solves this. Schema change decisions should be from business needs. Novel data or performance boosts both modify the schema.

Philosophical differences

Key philosophical differences exist:

  • Declarative vs. imperative interfaces – Relational uses declarative data while OO uses imperative behavior. Few compensate for relational with triggers and stored procedures.
  • Schema bound – Relational limits rows to their entity schemas. OO's inheritance (tree or not) is similar. OO can also add attributes. New and few dynamic database systems unlimit this for relational.
  • Access rules – Relational uses standardized operators, while OO classes have individual methods. OO is more expressive, but relational has math-like reasoning, integrity, and design consistency.
  • Relationship between nouns and verbs – An OO class is a noun entity tightly associated with verb actions. This forms a concept. Relational disputes the naturalness or logicality of that tight association.
  • Object identity – Two mutable objects with the same state differ. Relational ignores this uniqueness, and must fabricate it with candidate keys but that is a poor practice unless this identifier exists in the real world. Identity is permanent in relational, but maybe transient in OO.
  • Normalization – OO neglects relational normalization. However, objects interlinked via pointers are arguably a network database, which is arguably an extremely denormalized relational database.
  • Schema inheritance – Relational schemas reject OO's hierarchical inheritance. Relational accepts more powerful set theory. Unpopular non-tree (non-Java) OO exists, but is harder than relational algebra.
  • Structure vs. behaviour – OO focuses on structure (maintainability, extensibility, reusable, safe). Relational focuses on behavior (efficiency, adaptability, fault-tolerance, liveness, logical integrity, etc.). OO code serves programmers, while relational stresses user-visible behavior. However it could be non-inherent in relational, as task-specific views commonly present information to subtasks, but IDEs ignore this and assume objects are used.
  • Set vs. graph relationships – Relational follows set theory, but OO follows graph theory. While equivalent, access and management paradigms differ.

Therefore, partisans argue the other's technology should be abandoned.[10] Some RDBMS DBAs even advocate procedural over OO, namely that objects should not outlive transactions. OO retorts with OODBMS technology to be developed replacing relational. However, most programmers abstain and view the object–relational impedance mismatch as just a hurdle.

ORMs situationally offer advantages. Skeptics cite drawbacks, and little value when blindly applied.[11]

See also

References

  1. ^ A classification of object–relational impedance mismatch. Ireland, Christopher; Bowers, David; Newton, Mike and Waugh, Kevin (2009). A classification of object–relational impedance mismatch. In: First International Conference on Advances in Databases, Knowledge, and Data Applications (DBKDA), 1-6 Mar 2009, Cancun, Mexico.
  2. ^ "Jupyter Notebook Viewer".
  3. ^ "Introduction · Slick".
  4. ^ C. J. Date, Relational Database Writings
  5. ^ Object–Relational Mapping Revisited - A Quantitative Study on the Impact of Database Technology on O/R Mapping Strategies. M Lorenz, JP Rudolph, G Hesse, M Uflacker, H Plattner. Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS), 4877-4886 (DOI:10.24251/hicss.2017.592)
  6. ^ Date, Christopher ‘Chris’ J; Pascal, Fabian (2012-08-12) [2005], "Type vs. Domain and Class", Database debunkings (World Wide Web log), Google, retrieved 12 September 2012.
  7. ^ ——— (2006), "4. On the notion of logical difference", Date on Database: writings 2000–2006, The expert’s voice in database; Relational database select writings, USA: Apress, p. 39, ISBN 978-1-59059-746-0, Class seems to be indistinguishable from type, as that term is classically understood.
  8. ^ ——— (2004), "26. Object/Relational databases", An introduction to database systems (8th ed.), Pearson Addison Wesley, p. 859, ISBN 978-0-321-19784-9, ...any such rapprochement should be firmly based on the relational model.
  9. ^ Date, Christopher ‘Chris’ J; Darwen, Hugh, "2. Objects and Relations", The Third Manifesto, The first great blunder
  10. ^ Neward, Ted (2006-06-26). "The Vietnam of Computer Science" (PDF). Interoperability Happens. Retrieved 2010-06-02.
  11. ^ Johnson, Rod (2002). J2EE Design and Development. Wrox Press. p. 256. ISBN 9781861007841.

Read other articles:

Living ThingsAlbum studio karya Linkin ParkDirilis20 Juni 2012DirekamMaret 2011 – April 2012StudioNRG Recording Studios(North Hollywood, California, Amerika Serikat)Genre Alternative rock electronic rock rap rock Durasi36:59Label Warner Bros. Machine Shop Produser Rick Rubin Mike Shinoda Kronologi album Linkin Park A Thousand Suns(2010)A Thousand Suns2010 Living Things(2012) The Hunting Party (2014)The Hunting Party2014 Singel dalam album Living Things Burn It DownDirilis: 16 April 2012...

Nimrod Un Nimrod MR2. Tipo Avión de patrulla marítimaAvión ELINTFabricante Hawker Siddeley / BAE SystemsPrimer vuelo Mayo de 1967Introducido Octubre de 1969Retirado 28 de junio de 2011[1]​Estado RetiradoUsuario principal Royal Air ForceN.º construidos 49 (+2 prototipos)Desarrollo del de Havilland CometVariantes British Aerospace Nimrod AEW3BAE Systems Nimrod MRA4[editar datos en Wikidata] El Hawker Siddeley Nimrod es un avión militar desarrollado y fabricado en el Reino U...

Tafalla Gemeente in Spanje    Situering Autonome regio Navarra Provincie Navarra Coördinaten 42° 32′ NB, 1° 40′ WL Algemeen Oppervlakte 98,08 km² Inwoners (1 januari 2016) 10.660 (109 inw./km²) Provincie- engemeentecode 31.227 Detailkaart Ligging in Navarra Portaal    Spanje Tafalla is een gemeente in de Spaanse provincie en regio Navarra met een oppervlakte van 98,08 km². Tafalla telt 10.660 inwoners (1 januari 2016). Geboren José Vicente García A...

Diósviszló   Município   Símbolos Brasão de armas Localização DiósviszlóLocalização de Diósviszló na Hungria Coordenadas 45° 52' 37 N 18° 10' 14 E País Hungria Condado Baranya Características geográficas Área total 15,81 km² População total (2019) 662 ​​​​ hab. Código postal 7817 Diósviszló é um município da Hungria, situado no condado de Baranya. Tem 15,81 km² de área e sua população em 2019 foi estimada em ...

Millburn Downtown Millburn, vom South Mountain Reservation Lage in New Jersey Basisdaten Gründung: 20. März 1857 Staat: Vereinigte Staaten Bundesstaat: New Jersey County: Essex County Koordinaten: 40° 44′ N, 74° 19′ W40.733888888889-74.32027777777893Koordinaten: 40° 44′ N, 74° 19′ W Zeitzone: Eastern (UTC−5/−4) Einwohner: 21.710 (Stand: 2020) Haushalte: 6.730 (Stand: 2020) Fläche: 25,6 km² (ca. 10 mi²)d...

2015 Indian filmThithiThithi Kannada PosterDirected byRaam ReddyScreenplay byEregowda Raam ReddyProduced byPratap Reddy Sunmin ParkStarringThammegowda S. Channegowda Abhishek H. N. Pooja S.M.CinematographyDoron TempertEdited byJohn Zimmerman Raam ReddyProductioncompaniesPrspctvs Productions MaxmediaRelease dates 10 August 2015 (2015-08-10) (Locarno Film Festival) 6 May 2016 (2016-05-06) (India) 9 March 2017 (2017-03-09) (Netflix) Runnin...

This biography of a living person needs additional citations for verification. Please help by adding reliable sources. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libelous.Find sources: Nacha Guevara – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (January 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Nacha GuevaraNacha...

Yemeni alleged Al-Qaeda associate (born 1974) Sharqawi Abdu Ali al-HajjSharqawi Abdu Ali al-Hajj official Guantanamo portrait, showing him wearing the white uniform issued to compliant captives.Born (1974-05-26) May 26, 1974 (age 49)[1][2]Taiz, YemenArrestedFebruary 2002Karachi, PakistanDetained at CIA's black sitesGuantanamoISN1457StatusStill held in Guantanamo Sharqawi Abdu Ali al-Hajj (born May 26, 1974 in Taiz, Yemen), also known as Riyadh the Facilitator, is a Y...

Teknik piramida untuk memproduksi perpustakaan kimia kombinatorial besar Kimia kombinatorial adalah suatu pendekatan dalam ilmu kimia yang melibatkan sintesis berbagai jenis molekul yang berjumlah banyak tetapi erat terkait satu sama lain. Proses ini dibantu oleh simulasi dengan komputer dan peralatan robotik.[1] Kimia kombinatorial melibatkan metode sintesis kimia yang memungkinkan untuk mempreparasi senyawa dalam jumlah yang besar (puluhan hingga ribuan atau bahkan jutaan) dalam sua...

Shipra ExpressOverviewService typeSuperfastLocaleMadhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand & West BengalCurrent operator(s)Western RailwayRouteTerminiIndore Junction (INDB)Howrah Junction (HWH)Stops34Distance travelled1,738 km (1,080 mi)Average journey time31 hours 50 minutesService frequencyTri-weeklyTrain number(s)22911 / 22912On-board servicesClass(es)AC 2 Tier, AC 3 Tier, Sleeper Class, General UnreservedSeating arrangementsYesSleeping arrangementsYesCatering facilitie...

1957 studio album by Bob BrookmeyerBrookmeyerStudio album by Bob BrookmeyerReleased1957RecordedSeptember 19 and October 9 & 15, 1956StudioWebster Hall, New York CityGenreJazzLabelVikLX 1071Bob Brookmeyer chronology Jimmy Raney featuring Bob Brookmeyer(1956) Brookmeyer(1957) Traditionalism Revisited(1957) Brookmeyer (also released as Bob Brookmeyer and his Orchestra) is an album by jazz trombonist and arranger Bob Brookmeyer recorded in 1956 for the RCA Records subsidiary Vik label...

Shopping centre in Norway This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (August 2021) City Syd. Interiors in City Syd City Syd is one of the largest shopping centres in Norway, and the largest in Midt-Norge, with a turnover of NOK 1.7 billion in 2004. It is located in Tiller, in the Heimdal area of Trondheim. City Syd opened in 1987 and was remodeled and expanded in 2000. It is now 38,000 m2 and has 72 stores on...

2017 single by Ai Justice Will Prevail at LastSingle by Aifrom the album Wa to Yo LanguageJapaneseEnglishB-sideFeel ItReleasedMay 9, 2017 (2017-05-09)GenreJ-popelectropopLength4:04LabelEMIUniversalSongwriter(s)Ai UemuraProducer(s)UtaUemuraAi singles chronology Happy Christmas / Heiwa / Miracle (2016) Justice Will Prevail at Last (2017) Kira Kira (2017) Music videoJustice Will Prevail at Last on YouTube Justice Will Prevail at Last (最後は必ず正義が勝つ, Saigo wa Kanar...

Botswana padaOlimpiadeKode IOCBOTKONKomite Olimpiade Nasional BotswanaMedali 0 1 1 Total 2 Penampilan Musim Panas19801984198819921996200020042008201220162020 Botswana telah berkompetisi dalam 11 Olimpiade Musim Panas. Debut Botswana adalah pada Olimpiade Musim Panas 1980 di Moskwa. Negara tersebut tak pernah tampil dalam Olimpiade Musim Dingin. Botswana memenangkan medali pertamanya dalam Olimpiade Musim Panas 2012 dengan Nijel Amos meraih perak dalam cabang olahraga 800m. Pranala luar Botswa...

Bài này không có nguồn tham khảo nào. Mời bạn giúp cải thiện bài bằng cách bổ sung các nguồn tham khảo đáng tin cậy. Các nội dung không có nguồn có thể bị nghi ngờ và xóa bỏ. Nếu bài được dịch từ Wikipedia ngôn ngữ khác thì bạn có thể chép nguồn tham khảo bên đó sang đây. Thất Tiên NữHình quảng bá phimThể loạiPhim truyền hình thần thoại Trung QuốcDiễn viênHoắc Tư Yến, Tưởng HânQ...

Protein-coding gene in the species Homo sapiens GRK3IdentifiersAliasesGRK3, BARK2, ADRBK2, Beta adrenergic receptor kinase-2, G protein-coupled receptor kinase 3External IDsOMIM: 109636 MGI: 87941 HomoloGene: 21072 GeneCards: GRK3 Gene location (Human)Chr.Chromosome 22 (human)[1]Band22q12.1Start25,564,675 bp[1]End25,729,294 bp[1]Gene location (Mouse)Chr.Chromosome 5 (mouse)[2]Band5 F|5 55.29 cMStart113,058,348 bp[2]End113,163,657 bp[2]RNA e...

For other uses, see The Bet (disambiguation). This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: The Bet 1997 film – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2015) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 1997 filmThe BetDirected byDidier Bourdon Bernard CampanWritten byDidier Bour...

American judge (born 1938) Marilyn Jean Kelly67th Chief Justice of the Michigan Supreme CourtIn officeJanuary 8, 2009 – January 1, 2011Preceded byClifford TaylorSucceeded byRobert P. Young, Jr.Justice of the Michigan Supreme CourtIn officeJanuary 1, 1997 – January 1, 2013Preceded byCharles LevinSucceeded byBridget Mary McCormackJudge of the Michigan Court of AppealsIn officeJanuary 1, 1989 – January 1, 1997 Personal detailsBorn (1938-04-15) April 15, 1938 (age...

У этого термина существуют и другие значения, см. Мадейра (значения). Автономный регионМадейрапорт. Região Autónoma da Madeira Флаг Герб Гимн ПортугалииГимн Мадейры 32°44′ с. ш. 16°58′ з. д.HGЯO Страна Португалия Включает 11 муниципалитетов Адм. центр Фуншал Президент Мигел Алб�...

2011 film by Gavin O'Connor WarriorTheatrical release posterDirected byGavin O'ConnorScreenplay by Gavin O'Connor Anthony Tambakis Cliff Dorfman Story by Gavin O'Connor Cliff Dorfman Produced by Gavin O'Connor Greg O'Connor David Mimran Jordan Schur[1] Starring Joel Edgerton Tom Hardy Jennifer Morrison Frank Grillo Nick Nolte CinematographyMasanobu TakayanagiEdited by John Gilroy Sean Albertson Matt Chesse Aaron Marshall Music byMark IshamProductioncompanies Mimran Schur Pictures Sola...