36°23′21″N 119°42′31″W / 36.38917°N 119.70861°W / 36.38917; -119.70861
The Mussel Slough Tragedy was a dispute over land titles between settlers and the Southern Pacific Railroad (SP) that took place on May 11, 1880, on a farm located 5.6 miles (9 km) northwest of Hanford, California, in the central San Joaquin Valley, leaving seven people dead.
The exact history of the incident has been the source of some disagreement, largely because popular anti-railroad sentiment in the 1880s interpreted the incident as a clear example of corrupt and cold-blooded corporate greed. Muckraking journalists and anti-railroad activists glorified the settlers and used the events as evidence and justification for their anti-corporate crusades.[2] Frank Norris' 1901 novel The Octopus: A Story of California was inspired by this incident, as was W. C. Morrow's 1882 novel Blood-Money. May Merrill Miller's novel First the Blade includes a fictionalized account of the conflict.
The site of the episode is now registered as California Historical Landmark #245.[1] A historical marker on the east side of 14th Avenue, 350 yards (320 m) north of Elder Avenue, memorializes the site.[3]
The region known in the late 19th century as the Mussel Slough country was mostly in what was then Tulare County, California, with a small portion in what was then Fresno County (later the entire area became part of Kings County after the latter was formed in 1893). The Mussel Slough country took its name from a slough which went from the Kings River to Tulare Lake. This area had remained unsettled as it was a broad, dry plain suitable only for cattle ranching, but could be easily irrigated from the slough. The Southern Pacific Railroad (SP) had originally planned to build its route between San Jose and Southern California along the coast, but in 1866 Congress authorized the railroad companies to build a line through the area, and created numbered lots of one square mile (2.6 km2; 640 acres) each. The SP then decided to reroute.[4] It received the odd-numbered sections of land, totaling about 25,000 acres (101 km2) worth. The even-numbered sections were given to homesteaders by the government and were not subject to the events which followed.[5] Given the SP's history of encouraging settlement and development along its lines, land prices were expected to appreciate considerably.[6] Furthermore, the SP's standard practice was to allow settlers to move in on its land as long as they agreed to purchase it when the time came.[7]
Lobbying by land speculators led Secretary of the Interior Orville Hickman Browning to reject the SP's route change, stating that it violated the company's original charter. However, despite his stated intentions to do so, Browning did not actually have the authority to revoke the SP's rights to the land (only Congress could do that). Meanwhile, settlers had already begun submitting applications for the railroad lands starting in 1869, in anticipation of the completion of the line. Others without claims began squatting in anticipation that the SP's title would be invalidated. Primary among this latter group was John J. Doyle, who advertised this and caused a land run in the Hanford area. After the railroad was purchased by the "Big Four" in 1868, the new owners were able by 1870 to have their altered route and land rights reconfirmed.[8]
Regardless, the squatting continued up through the early 1880s. The types of squatters varied wildly. There were Civil War refugees from the American South, owners of even-numbered lots who either sold their legitimate claims or were attempting to expand their holdings, merchants who lived in nearby towns, and land speculators. Doyle started a new business to help squatters challenge the SP for titles to the land, but because the SP's rights were never revoked, all of the settlers' claims were denied. Doyle and other leaders appealed to Congress and the California State Legislature, but were still rebuffed. The SP did not take any legal action against the squatters at this time, hoping to convert them into customers. It encouraged them to file applications so that they would be given the first option to purchase when sales began, but squatter leaders argued that doing so would affirm the company's rights, which they still believed to be invalid. Some submitted the applications, but most did not.[9]
In 1872, the Central Pacific Railroad completed work to Goshen from the north and the Southern Pacific was to construct the southern portion (although not generally known by the public at the time, the two railroad systems were owned and operated by the same people although they were technically separate corporations[10]). The SP's brochures had stated the price of the land would be "$2.50 per acre and upwards",[11] leading many people to mistakenly believe that $2.50/acre was a set price. Furthermore, other brochures indicated that any improvements the settlers made to the land would not be counted when the prices were fixed.[2]However, when the settlers, who had spent a great deal of money and time in building their houses and farms, attempted to acquire their land, the asking price was significantly greater than that ($8–$20/acre[7]), which the SP attributed to rising property values because of the laying of the railroad, although many settlers believed it was due to their own improvements such as irrigation, housing, fences, and barns.[12][13] Some paid for their land, but most did not. Settlers protested against the railroads, but to no avail. A bill in the United States Congress that would have fixed the price at $2.50/acre failed to pass. The Southern Pacific then filed and won a lawsuit in 1878 against the settlers, amidst allegations of court bias (former California Governor Leland Stanford was also president of SP).[13]
The SP was convinced of its legal ownership of the land and felt it should have the freedom to set whatever prices it deemed fit for its property.[14] The U.S. Supreme Court finally settled the issue in Schulenberg v. Harriman 21 Wall. 44 (1874), ruling that the SP's change of route did not invalidate its charter. Thus, the SP was justified to reclaim the land without compensation unless the settlers were willing to pay their asking price, now up to $35/acre.[13] Still, the Settler's League, which was formed in 1878 in opposition to the SP's Mussel Slough actions,[12] even attempted to appeal directly to President Rutherford B. Hayes during his visit to San Francisco in 1880,[15] presenting him a petition which read,
Through sheer energy and perseverance by the investment of our means ... and relying firmly upon the rights we had acquired as American citizens, and upon the pledges of the Southern Pacific Railroad Company [in regard to low land prices], we converted a desert into one of the garden spots of the State.[16]
Besides the 1874 Supreme Court ruling, a critical moment came on December 15, 1879, when Judge Lorenzo Sawyer of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in Orton, 32 F. 457 (C.C.D. Cal. 1879), that the federal government controlled the railroad land grants, and more importantly, the state could not control ultra vires acts of corporations.[17]
Given the legal system's affirmation of its position, the SP began to forcibly remove some of the settlers. Their agents would attempt to serve eviction notices, but often would not find anyone at home, as homeowners knew they were coming. In these cases, the agents then tried removing the furniture from the homes, but the Settler's League would just put the furniture back after the agents' departure. Finally, it escalated to the point at which the agents would then disassemble the houses, but again, volunteers would just put them back together.[18] The settlers were not above their own brand of justice, either. The League harassed and threatened railroad agents and their sympathizers as well as those who had purchased land from the SP,[19] and in one case one farmer who had aligned with the SP had his house burned down.[20] Those supporting the railroads tended to be wealthier than the others, deriding the Settler's League as "a set of demagogues" who were "very anxious to get something for nothing."[21] By late 1879, the SP found that sales of its parcels had been severely reduced, despite having lowered the asking prices.[22]
Although the settlers received the benefit of a section of public opinion, politically and legally every decision was going the way of the railroad. In March 1880, Stanford himself attempted a reconciliation by appearing in Hanford and meeting with the Settler's League in an attempt to find some sort of compromise,[23] but this fell through as the settlers had demanded a 50% reduction in prices, which the SP refused to do.[24]
On May 11, 1880, a picnic was being held in Hanford which was to feature a speech by pro-settler former California Supreme Court Justice David S. Terry (who was actually unable to appear),[25] when word reached the picnickers that four "railroad men" - U.S. Marshal Alonso Poole, SP land appraiser William Clark, and two locals, Walter J. Crow and Mills Hartt - were actively evicting settlers on railroad lands, and a group of about twenty people, led by settlers James N. Patterson and William Braden, left to confront them (the historical marker indicates that the two local men were Deputy U.S. Marshals, which was not in fact the case). However, the rumors were only partially true; in addition to serving eviction notices, the group was also purchasing land (and any improvements) from settlers who had refused to pay SP's asking price.[13] This act was seen as a betrayal of Stanford's visit a mere two months earlier.[23]
The parties met at the homestead of Henry D. Brewer three miles (4.8 km) north of Grangeville (which is near Hanford), the marshal's group having just been at Braden's house. Later testimony from uninvolved parties indicated that the party of settlers were lightly armed and had every intention of persuading the railroad party to delay their actions until a pending court case could be resolved. However, there was bad blood between Walter J. Crow and one of the settler's party, James Harris, and Mills Hartt had previously threatened to kill any "sandlappers" (a derisive term for homesteaders, equivalent to the modern day "redneck"[26]), and an argument broke out between them. Hartt opened fire at Harris, who returned fire and fatally wounded Hartt.[13] Crow, a skilled marksman who was armed with a shotgun, jumped down from his wagon and opened fire, killing Harris and four other members of the settler's party.[13][27] After the initial exchange of gunfire ended, Crow fled the scene, but was shot in the back about 1.5 mi (2.4 km) away by an unknown assailant before he could reach safety.[28] Poole and Clark did not participate in the battle and left immediately after the incident, possibly defusing tensions enough to avoid further bloodshed.[29]
One of the survivors of the gunfight, settler Edwin Haymaker, died soon after of pneumonia, having apparently been weakened by wounds received in the shootout.[13] Afterwards, seventeen people were indicted by a federal grand jury and five were found guilty of willfully interfering with a marshal in performance of his duties (Braden, Patterson, Pryor, Purcell, and John J. Doyle, a leader in the Settler's League). They were convicted in federal court (with Judge Sawyer presiding) and sentenced to eight months in prison and fined $300 each.[30] Their time spent in imprisonment was hardly difficult. Three of the men's wives were allowed to live with them, and Susan Curtis, daughter of one of the jailers, fell in love with and later married Braden. Upon their release in September 1881, they were greeted by a joyous crowd of 3,000 in Hanford.[31] Such was the anti-railroad sentiment that the five were looked upon as heroes by many across California, and those killed were considered martyrs who had given their lives for a cause.[32]
Nevertheless, the affair brought such a shock that people were sobered. The legal battle had been lost, the railroad had won, and there was not enough public support for changing the policy of granting public lands to railroads. The only concession SP made was to reduce the land price slightly. In the end, most people (including Doyle, who later reconciled and became good friends with Collis Potter Huntington, one of the SP's leaders[33]) simply stayed where they were and purchased the land.[13] Squatting continued for years, though, despite the SP's best attempts to squash it.[34]
The Mussel Slough affair was seized upon by newspaper editors as well as a number of popular writers soon after the tragic shootout, as an example of corporate greed and the abuses of freewheeling market capitalism around the start of the 20th century. Muckraking novels such as W. C. Morrow's Blood-Money (1882) and Charles Cyril Post's Driven from Sea to Sea; or, Just A' Campin' (1884) exaggerate the fault of the railroad for the events as they unfolded in San Joaquin and romanticize the ranchers according to a Jeffersonian agrarian ideal. Ambrose Bierce attempted to lionize Crow, calling him "this bravest of Americans."[35]
Later novels depicting the affair, such as the philosopher Josiah Royce's The Feud of Oakfield Creek (1887) and novelist Frank Norris' The Octopus (1901) are slightly less hagiographic in their portrayals of the Mussel Slough ranchers, but nevertheless give a fairly one-sided, anti-railroad view of the Mussel Slough affair. Richard Orsi's suggests in his history of the Southern Pacific, Sunset Limited that some common misconceptions about the Mussel Slough affair have been perpetuated through the mythic retellings of Morrow, Post, Royce, and Norris, among others.[36]
The significance of the Mussel Slough myth in the history of California and the Southern Pacific Railroad is evident from a quote by Theodore Roosevelt, who as president focused considerable time and energy in redressing the wrongs and abuses of corporate monopolies throughout the U.S. After reading Norris' The Octopus, Roosevelt stated he was "inclined to think [...] that conditions were worse in California than elsewhere."[37] These mythic narratives about Mussel Slough helped bolster public anti-railroad sentiments, and encouraged continued rebellion among homesteaders, squatters and poachers against railroad land agents, who "came to accept squatters as an ordinary, if disagreeable, part of the land business".[34]
Despite the nationwide attention the incident received, the Mussel Slough Tragedy is not remembered much today as well as later gunfights such as the gunfight at the O.K. Corral. Richard Maxwell Brown argues in No Duty to Retreat that the Mussel Slough shootout did not fit the mold of the gunfight/hero myth, which usually ignores such factors as ideology, and social and economic conflict, thus not implanting it in the lore of the American Old West.[38]
Six victims of the shooting were carried to the porch of the Brewer house, which was shaded by a tall oak tree. The tree became famously known as the Tragedy Oak. It blew down in a storm in the early 1990s. A piece of the tree was saved as a memorial and is on display at nearby Pioneer Elementary School in Hanford.[39]
1920 painting by George Washington Lambert A Sergeant of the Light HorseArtistGeorge Washington LambertYear1920Mediumoil on canvasDimensions77.0 cm × 62.0 cm (30.3 in × 24.4 in)LocationNational Gallery of Victoria, MelbourneWebsitehttp://www.ngv.vic.gov.au/col/work/5822 A Sergeant of the Light Horse is a 1920 painting by Australian artist George Washington Lambert. The portrait depicts an Australian soldier in Palestine during World War I. The National…
Martin MutschmannMutschmann in 1937Landesleiter/Gauleiter of Gau SaxonyIn office27 March 1925 – 8 May 1945Preceded byPosition createdSucceeded byPosition abolishedReichsstatthalter of SaxonyIn office5 May 1933 – 8 May 1945Prime MinisterManfred Freiherr von KillingerPreceded byPosition createdSucceeded byPosition abolishedMinister-President of SaxonyIn office28 February 1935 – 8 May 1945Preceded byManfred Freiherr von KillingerSucceeded byRudolf Friedrichs Persona…
Gua LayyaeLeang LayyaeLokasiKabupaten Maros, Sulawesi Selatan, IndonesiaKedalaman135 mGeologikarst / batu kapur / batu gampingSitus webvisit.maroskab.go.idcagarbudaya.kemdikbud.go.id Gua Layyae atau Leang Layyae (Inggris: Layyae Cave ) adalah sebuah gua di Kawasan Karst Maros-Pangkep, Taman Nasional Bantimurung-Bulusaraung, wilayah administratif Kabupaten Maros, Sulawesi Selatan, Indonesia. Gua ini adalah jenis gua alam dan gua vertikal dengan kedalaman 135 meter. Secara morfologis, gua ini…
Опис файлу Опис Постер до фільму «Старий Хотабич» Джерело Old_Khottabych.jpg (англ. вікі) Час створення 1956 Автор зображення Авторські права належать дистриб'ютору, видавцю фільму або художнику цього постера. Ліцензія див. нижче Обґрунтування добропорядного використання для с…
Горт Hoort — громада — Вид Горт Координати: 53°28′ пн. ш. 11°22′ сх. д. / 53.467° пн. ш. 11.367° сх. д. / 53.467; 11.367 Країна Німеччина Земля Мекленбург-Передня Померанія Район Людвігслуст-Пархім Об'єднання громад Гагенов-Ланд Площа -
Alfred Sotier Alfred Sotier (* 21. September 1833 in Münnerstadt, Unterfranken; † 19. November 1902 in Bad Kissingen, Unterfranken) war ein deutscher Arzt. Leben Sotier besuchte das Gymnasium in Münnerstadt. Sein Medizin-Studium schloss er 1858 mit dem Staatsexamen ab und eröffnete seine erste Arztpraxis 1859 in Aschach. Doch schon 1865 ließ er sich in Bad Kissingen nieder. Im Deutschen Krieg von 1866 war er als Zivilarzt tätig, wobei er auch mit Prof. Johann Nepomuk Nußbaum in München …
Motorwagens 1 en 8 op de lijnen 1 en 2 bij Østbanetorvet (Oostbaanstation); 27 juli 1968. Motorwagen 1 op de Marienlunds Allé op 8 augustus 1969. De tram van Aarhus was een trambedrijf in de Deense stad Aarhus. Tussen 1884 en 1971 reden hier trams. Sinds 2017 is er een nieuw trambedrijf.[1] Van 31 mei 1884 tot 23 mei 1895 werd met een paardentram gereden op een spoorwijdte van 1.435 mm (normaalspoor) tussen de Store Torv en het Hoofdstation (Jernbanestationen). In september 1903 w…
Cet article est une ébauche concernant une synagogue et Londres. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?) selon les recommandations des projets correspondants. Synagogue de Western Marble ArchPrésentationType SynagogueLocalisationLocalisation cité de Westminster, Grand Londres, Angleterre Royaume-UniCoordonnées 51° 30′ 54″ N, 0° 09′ 33″ Omodifier - modifier le code - modifier Wikidata La Synagogue de Western Marbl…
State park in Merrimack County, New Hampshire Bear Brook State ParkBeaver Pond as seen from the Beaver Pond Trail near the campgroundLocationAllenstown and Hooksett in Merrimack County;Deerfield and Candia in Rockingham County,New HampshireCoordinates43°06′25″N 71°21′07″W / 43.107°N 71.352°W / 43.107; -71.352[1]Area10,083 acres (4,080 ha)[2]Elevation617 feet (188 m)[1]Established1943[3]Administered byNew Hampshire…
Polish writer (1930–1994) Bogdan-Dawid WojdowskiBornDawid Wojdowski(1930-11-30)30 November 1930Warsaw, PolandDied21 April 1994(1994-04-21) (aged 63)Warsaw, PolandPen nameBogdan KamińskiOccupationWriter Bogdan-Dawid Wojdowski (Yiddish: בוגדאן-דוד ווידובסקי,30 November 1930 –21 April 1994)[1] was a Polish-Jewish writer of Yiddish (that is, Ashkenazic) background. Name The writer was born Dawid Wojdowski. During World War II, under German occupation, he used an '…
Chantal-Line CarpentierBornCanadaNationalityCanadianEducationMcGill University Chantal-Line Carpentier is a Canada-born Chief of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) in New York. She has been a strong supporter of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals and in particular SDG12 concerned with responsible and sustainable prodiction. Life Carpentier was born in Canada. She took her first and master's degrees at McGill University in the economics of agriculture be…
Selección de fútbol playa de los Países Bajos Datos generalesPaís Países BajosCódigo FIFA NEDFederación KNVBConfederación UEFASeleccionador Niels KokmeijerEquipaciones Primera Segunda Mejor(es) resultado(s) Sin datosPeor(es) resultado(s) Sin datosCopa Mundial de Fútbol Playa de FIFAParticipaciones 1 (primera vez en 2013)Mejor resultado Fase de Grupos (2013)Euro Beach Soccer LeagueParticipaciones 13 (primera vez en 2000)Mejor resultado (2008)[editar datos en Wikidata] La …
Cagayan de Oro's 1st congressional districtConstituencyfor the House of Representatives of the PhilippinesLocation of Cagayan de Oro within Misamis OrientalCityCagayan de OroRegionNorthern MindanaoPopulation383,945 (2020)[1]Electorate177,163 (2022)[2]Major settlements 25 barangays Barangays Baikingon Balulang Bayabas Bayanga Besigan Bonbon Bulua Calaanan Canitoan Carmen Dansolihon Iponan Kauswagan Lumbia Mambuaya Pagalungan Pagatpat Patag Pigsag-an San Simon Taglimao Tagpangi Tig…
2017 soundtrack album by A. R. Rahman Kaatru VeliyidaiSoundtrack album by A. R. RahmanReleased20 March 2017Recorded2016—2017StudioPanchathan Record Inn and AM Studios, ChennaiGenreFeature film soundtrackLength25:23LanguageTamilLabelSony MusicProducerA. R. RahmanA. R. Rahman chronology OK Jaanu(2017) Kaatru Veliyidai(2017) Sachin: A Billion Dreams(2017) Singles from Kaatru Veliyidai AzhagiyeReleased: 2 February 2017[1] VaanReleased: 14 February 2017[2] Saarattu VandiyilaRele…
West African ethnic group Not to be confused with the larger Mandé peoples or the unrelated Dinka people of Sudan. MandinkaMansa Musa's visit to Mecca in 1324 CE with large amounts of gold attracted Middle Eastern Muslims and Europeans to Mali.[1][2]Total populationc. 11 million[3]Regions with significant populations Guinea3,786,101 (29.4%)[4] Mali1,772,102 (8.8%)[5] Senegal900,617 (5.6%)[6] The Gambia700,568 (34.4%)[7]…
Novel by Naomi Novik Uprooted AuthorNaomi NovikCover artistScott McKowenCountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglishSeriesStand-aloneGenreFantasySet inThe Middle Ages, in a land reminiscent of PolandPublished2015PublisherDel ReyMedia typePrint (hardcover)Pages448Awards 2015 Nebula Award 2016 Locus Award 2016 Mythopoeic Award ISBN978-0804179034Followed bySpinning Silver Uprooted is a 2015 high fantasy novel by Naomi Novik, based on Polish folklore. The story tells of a village gi…
Polynomial equation In mathematics, a quartic equation is one which can be expressed as a quartic function equaling zero. The general form of a quartic equation is Graph of a polynomial function of degree 4, with its 4 roots and 3 critical points. a x 4 + b x 3 + c x 2 + d x + e = 0 {\displaystyle ax^{4}+bx^{3}+cx^{2}+dx+e=0\,} where a ≠ 0. The quartic is the highest order polynomial equation that can be solved by radicals in the general case (i.e., one in which the coefficients can …
Map all coordinates using: OpenStreetMap Download coordinates as: KML GPX (all coordinates) GPX (primary coordinates) GPX (secondary coordinates) Suburb of Brisbane, Queensland, AustraliaCamp HillBrisbane, QueenslandPlayground in Whites Hill Reserve, Camp HillCamp HillCoordinates27°30′00″S 153°04′45″E / 27.5°S 153.0791°E / -27.5; 153.0791 (Camp Hill (centre of suburb))Population12,145 (2021 census)[1] • Density2,530/km2 (6,550/…
This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (October 2018) 2018 (2018) United Kingdom budgetPresentedMonday 29 October 2018Parliament57thPartyConservative PartyChancellorPhilip HammondTotal revenue£810 billionTotal expenditures£842 billionDeficit£32 billionWebsiteBudget 2018‹ November 20172020 › Chancellor Philip Hammond delivering his Budget Statement The 2018 United Kingdom budget was delivered…
Indian popular singer and politician Babul SupriyoSupriyo in 2018Cabinet Minister, Government of West BengalIncumbentAssumed office 3 August 2022GovernorLa. GanesanC. V. Ananda BoseChief MinisterMamata BanerjeeMinistry and DepartmentInformation Technology and ElectronicsPreceded byPartha ChatterjeeMember of the West Bengal Legislative AssemblyIncumbentAssumed office 16 April 2022Preceded bySubrata MukherjeeConstituencyBallygungeMajority20,030Minister of State, Government of IndiaIn offic…
Lokasi Pengunjung: 18.188.126.29