Media imperialism (sometimes referred to as cultural imperialism) is an area in the international political economy of communications research tradition that focuses on how "all Empires, in territorial or nonterritorial forms, rely upon communications technologies and mass media industries to expand and shore up their economic, geopolitical, and cultural influence."[1] In the main, most media imperialism research examines how the unequal relations of economic, military and cultural power between an imperialist country and those on the receiving end of its influence tend to be expressed and perpetuated by mass media and cultural industries.
In the 1970s, research on media imperialism was mainly concerned with the expansion of US-based news and entertainment corporations, business models, and products into postcolonial countries as related to the problems of communication and media sovereignty, national identity formation and democracy. In the 21st century, research on media imperialism probes the whole gamut of the media, for example, how an Empire's global economic, military and cultural expansion and legitimization is supported by "the news, telecommunications, film and TV, advertising and public relations, music, interactive games, and internet platforms and social media sites."[2]
The concept of media imperialism emerged in the 1970s when political leaders, media producers, and some citizens in postcolonial countries began to criticize the ownership and control Western and American media conglomerates wielded over much of the global communication and media system. Representatives of postcolonial countries proposed a New World Information and Communication Order (NWICO) at UNESCO to contest and counter-balance the enduring and enlarging global communication and media powers of old and new imperial countries (e.g., the United Kingdom and United States). Supported by the MacBride report, "Many Voices, One World", countries such as India, Indonesia, and Egypt argued that the large Western and American media corporations should have limited access to the fledgling communication and media systems of postcolonial countries. They argued that national cultural and communication sovereignty was integral to their broader national sovereignty and economic and social development projects. The assumption was that Western and American media corporations (and their products) would undermine or subvert the national development process of postcolonial countries by institutionalizing inappropriate media models, business practices and content. In response to the postcolonial countries' protest against media imperialism and proposal for a NWICO, the United States and United Kingdom left UNESCO.
Key theorists and definitions
Herbert I. Schiller
In Mass Communication and American Empire,Herbert I. Schiller emphasized the significance of the mass media and cultural industries to American imperialism, arguing that "each new electronic development widens the perimeter of American influence," and declaring that "American power, expressed industrially, militarily and culturally has become the most potent force on earth and communications have become a decisive element in the extension of United States world power."
In his 1976 book Communication and Cultural Domination, Schiller conveyed the very first definition of cultural imperialism, describing it as:
the sum processes by which a society is brought into the modern [U.S.-centered] world system and how its dominating stratum is attracted, pressured, forced, and sometimes bribed into shaping social institutions to correspond to, or even promote, the values and structures of the dominating centres of the system. The public media are the foremost example of operating enterprises that are used in the penetrative process. For penetration on a significant scale the media themselves must be captured by the dominating/penetrating power. This occurs largely through the commercialization of broadcasting.
For Schiller, cultural imperialism refers to the American Empire’s "coercive and persuasive agencies, and their capacity to promote and universalize an American ‘way of life’ in other countries without any reciprocation of influence." According to Schiller, cultural imperialism "pressured, forced and bribed" societies to integrate with the U.S.’s expansive capitalist model but also incorporated them with attraction and persuasion by winning "the mutual consent, even solicitation of the indigenous rulers." In some ways, Schiller's early definition of cultural imperialism is akin to Joseph Nye's more recent idea of soft power in international relations.[33]
The historical contexts, iterations, complexities, and politics of Schiller's foundational and substantive theorization of cultural imperialism in international communication and media studies are discussed in detail by political economy of communication researchers Richard Maxwell,[34] Vincent Mosco,[35] Graham Murdock,[20] and Tanner Mirrlees.[36]
Oliver Boyd-Barrett
In 1977, Oliver Boyd-Barrett described media imperialism as the unequal and asymmetrical power relationship between different countries and their media systems. Boyd-Barrett defined media imperialism as "a process whereby the ownership, structure, distribution or content of the media in any one country are singly or together subject to substantial pressure from the media interests of any other country or countries without proportionate reciprocation of influence by the country so affected."[5] Boyd-Barrett emphasized how the corporations that owned the mass media in imperial countries such as the United States (but not exclusively the United States) were also exerting ownership over the mass media in smaller countries while shaping their media business "models", production standards, and formats.[37] From the late 1970s to the 2020s, Boyd-Barrett authored and edited numerous books and volumes on continuity and change in media imperialism.[2][38][39]
Tom McPhail
In 1987, Tom McPhail defined cultural imperialism as "electronic colonialism",[40] or, "the dependency relationship established by the importation of communication hardware, foreign-produced software, along with engineers, technicians, and related information protocols, that establish a set of foreign norms, values, and expectations which, in varying degrees, may alter the domestic cultures and socialization processes."[41]
Paul Siu-Nam
In 1988, Paul Siu-Nam Lee observed that "communication imperialism can be defined as the process in which the ownership and control over the hardware and software of mass media as well as other major forms of communication in one country are singly or together subjugated to the domination of another country with deleterious effects on the indigenous values, norms and culture."
John Downing and Annabelle Sreberny-Mohammadi
In 1995, John Downing and Annabelle Sreberny-Mohammadi said: "Imperialism is the conquest and control of one country by a more powerful one. Cultural imperialism signifies the dimensions of the process that go beyond economic exploitation or military force. In the history of colonialism, (i.e., the form of imperialism in which the government of the colony is run directly by foreigners), the educational and media systems of many Third World countries have been set up as replicas of those in Britain, France, or the United States and carry their values. Western advertising has made further inroads, as have architectural and fashion styles. Subtly but powerfully, the message has often been insinuated that Western cultures are superior to the cultures of the Third World."
Needless to say, all these international communication and media studies researchers agree that cultural imperialism is undertaken by the world system's dominant imperial countries with and through the available and new means of communications and mass media, and often to the detriment of the countries on the receiving end of this process.
Tanner Mirrlees
In 2016, Tanner Mirrlees redefined media imperialism in a historical study of how the US national security State partners with US-based yet globalizing media corporations to spread media and cultural goods intended to organize trans-national consent to American foreign policy.[42] Building upon the political economy of communications scholarship of Herbert I. Schiller, Mirrlees argues that although the US government and media corporations pursue different interests on the world stage (the former, national security, and the latter, profit), they often collaborate to support the co-production and global distribution-exhibition of Empire-extolling media and popular cultural goods. Mirrlees focuses on four dimensions of media imperialism:[1] 1. a structural alliance and symbiotic relationship between the US nation-state (pursuing its geopolitical interests in world affairs) and US-headquartered media and cultural industries (pursuing their economic interests in world markets); 2. the US nation-state's geopolitical support for the trans-national economic dominance of the US-based media and cultural industries; 3. the US media and cultural industries' support for the US nation-state's international propaganda, "soft power" and public diplomacy campaigns in other countries; and, 4. American media and cultural products whose messages and imagery is intentionally or inadvertently functional to the glorification and legitimization of the US Empire. Although Mirrlees' study focuses on the specificity of American media imperialism and the role of the media and cultural industries to US economic, military and cultural-ideological power, the four dimensions of media imperialism it identifies may be evident in the practices of other old and new imperialist powers.
Dal Yong Jin
In 2015, Dal Yong Jin extended the concept of media imperialism to encompass the growing global power of US-based Internet and social media platform corporations such as Google, Apple, Facebook. Jin argues that a handful of corporations based in "Western countries are the world’s dominant digital platform owners and operators and a large number of non-Western countries are digital platform users."[43] In the book Digital Platforms, Imperialism and Political Culture, Jin conceptualizes "platform imperialism" as "an asymmetrical relationship of interdependence between the West, primarily the US, and many developing countries".[44] This asymmetrical platform relationship between the United States and the rest is "characterized in part by unequal technological exchanges and therefore capital flows" and reflects the "technological and symbolic domination of US-based platforms that have greatly influenced the majority of people and countries."
Criticism of the theory
Critics of the media imperialism "theory" have been around since the early 1980s.[45] Often, critics of the media imperialism theory tend to reject or deny that media imperialism exists, or alternately, present a meta-critique of one or more of the statements and claims made by the scholars associated with the media imperialism theory. As summarized by Tanner Mirrlees in Global Entertainment Media: Between Cultural Imperialism and Cultural Globalization,[46] critics of media imperialism theory tend to make one or more of the following points when dismissing media imperialism theory or criticizing it to complicate or revise in some way: 1. The US is not an imperialist power, ergo media imperialism doesn't exist; 2. postcolonial countries such as China and India headquarter large and internationalizing media corporations; the idea that postcolonial countries are victims of a US-centered media imperialism is simplistic and irrelevant in the 21st century; 3. the media and cultural trade relationship between the US and other countries may not be balanced, but there is more than a one way flow of media and cultural goods from the US to the rest: while the US exports a lot of media to the world, it also imports media from the world, suggesting a two-way or multi-directional flow of media goods; 4. consumers around the world are not forced or coerced to watch, listen to and read US media and cultural products; they may select and choose these "foreign" goods instead of "domestic" or nationally made and available media; 5. the texts of US media and cultural products do not communicate a one-dimensional American imperialist ideology to the world; they offer a multiplicity of competing narratives of America, warts and all; 6. the local and national reception contexts for US media and cultural products are complex, as consumers make a wide variety of interpretations of US media and sometimes adapt them to their own local and national cultural environments; 7. political and business elites in countries purportedly afflicted by US media imperialism may weaponize the concept for political ends: the censorship of unwanted or subversive ideas to maintain national propaganda regimes, the protection of fledgling or established national media corporations from international competition, and the promotion of the growth of national media oligopolies, first at home, then abroad.
Most research on media imperialism going back to the 1970s has focused on the significance of the United States and referred to it as the world's most significant media imperialist.[2] For instance, media corporations based in the United States exert media influence in other countries, especially those lacking strong media industries.[1] A major cultural influencer in other countries is television.[47] Specifically in relation to news and entertainment American TV has a strong presence in the international arena. American news networks like CNN often have large international staffs, and produce specialized regional programming for many nations.
Movies produced by major Hollywood studios and distributors have presence and popularity around the world. For example, Hollywood is a major producer of films, which tend to be high quality and are released internationally.[48] Hollywood relies on four capitalist strategies "to attract and integrate non-US film producers, exhibitors and audiences into its ambit: ownership, cross-border productions with subordinate service providers, content licensing deals with exhibitors, and blockbusters designed to travel the globe."[49] Hollywood's dominance is not total, as other countries have their own film industries: "Bollywood", for example, describes India's Hindi-language film industry, which is large and prosperous.[48]
Another form of mass media used for media imperialism is music.[48] Much of today's, and older, American music finds itself popular in other countries. However, in the "British Invasion" of the 1960s, British music became popular in the United States. Since then, there has not been such a large shift of imperialism.
Overall, American media imperialism can be seen as a positive and a negative. Negative views towards it stem from the negative connotation of the word 'imperialism'.[4] This word is associated with political imperialism, in which a large country creates an empire out of smaller ones. However, media imperialism can be seen as a positive when it is viewed as a way to create a consensus narrative. A consensus narrative is a result of "products that provide us with shared experiences".[48] By having similar experiences, it opens the gateway for communication and development of relationships. Yet, this can also become a problem when the cultural exchange is not balanced or reciprocated. American culture is being transmitted to other countries, but other cultures may not be[weasel words] received in return.
^ abBoyd-Barrett, Oliver (1977). Media imperialism: Towards an international framework for the analysis of media systems. London: Edward Arnold. ISBN978-0-7131-5939-4. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
^Mattelart, Armand (1979). Multinational corporations and the control of culture: The ideological apparatuses of imperialism (1st ed.). Brighton: Harvester.
^McChesney, Robert (2001). Global Media: The New Missionaries of Global Capitalism (1st ed.). London: Bloomsbury. ISBN978-0-8264-5819-3.
^Mirrlees, Tanner (2013). Global Entertainment Media: Between Cultural Imperialism and Cultural Globalization (1st ed.). New York: Routledge. ISBN9780415519823.
^Mirrlees, Tanner (2016). Hearts and Mines: The US Empire's Culture Industry (1st ed.). Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press. ISBN9780774830157.
^Boyd-Barrett, Oliver (1977). "Media imperialism: towards an international framework for the analysis of media systems". Mass Communication and Society: 116–135.
^Jin, Dal Yong (2020). Facebook's Platform Imperialism: The Economics and Geopolitics of Social Media. New York: Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 187–198. ISBN978-1538121559. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
José Francisco Robles OrtegaKardinal, Uskup Agung GuadalajaraPresiden Konferensi Waligereja MeksikoProvinsi gerejawiGuadalajaraTakhtaGuadalajaraPenunjukan7 Desember 2011Awal masa jabatan7 Februari 2012PendahuluJuan Sandoval ÍñiguezJabatan lainKardinal-Imam Santa Maria della PresentazioneImamatTahbisan imam20 Juli 1976oleh José Maclovio Vásquez SilosTahbisan uskup5 Juni 1991oleh Alfredo Torres RomeroPelantikan kardinal24 November 2007oleh Paus Benediktus XVIPeringkatKardinal-Ima...
BanyutowoDesaNegara IndonesiaProvinsiJawa TengahKabupatenPatiKecamatanDukuhsetiKode pos59158Kode Kemendagri33.18.20.2007 Luas... km²Jumlah penduduk... jiwaKepadatan... jiwa/km² Banyutowo adalah sebuah desa di kecamatan Dukuhseti, Pati, Jawa Tengah, Indonesia.[1] Banyutowo adalah desa pesisir dan memiliki sebuah dermaga yang merupakan tempat transit bagi kapal-kapal nelayan setempat maupun kapal dari daerah lain. Selain itu, dermaga di Banyutowo merupakan tempat rekreasi pendudu...
دقيق القمح, حبوب كاملة القيمة الغذائية لكل (100 غرام) الطاقة الغذائية 1,418 كـجول (339 ك.سعرة) الكربوهيدرات 72.57 g السكر 0.41 g ألياف غذائية 12.2 g البروتين بروتين كلي 13.70 g الدهون دهون 1.87 g الفيتامينات الثيامين (فيتامين ب١) 0.447 مليغرام (34%) الرايبوفلافين (فيتامين ب٢) 0.215 مليغرام (14%) ...
Metro station in Barcelona, Spain This article includes a list of references, related reading, or external links, but its sources remain unclear because it lacks inline citations. Please help improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (April 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Inside the station. Entrance to the station. Verneda is a Barcelona Metro station in the Verneda neighbourhood of Sant Adrià de Besòs, a suburb of Barcelona. It's served by L2. ...
муниципальный районВерхнехавский район Флаг Герб 51°50′20″ с. ш. 39°56′30″ в. д.HGЯO Страна Россия Входит в Воронежскую область Включает 17 муниципальных образований Адм. центр село Верхняя Хава Глава района Пермяков Антон Геннадьевич Глава администрации В...
Town in Rhineland-Palatinate, GermanyBingen am Rhein Town Coat of armsLocation of Bingen am Rhein within Mainz-Bingen district Bingen am Rhein Show map of GermanyBingen am Rhein Show map of Rhineland-PalatinateCoordinates: 49°58′N 7°54′E / 49.967°N 7.900°E / 49.967; 7.900CountryGermanyStateRhineland-PalatinateDistrictMainz-Bingen Subdivisions8Government • Lord mayor (2019–27) Thomas Feser[1] (CDU)Area • Total37.74 km2 ...
Не следует путать с Рострудом — Федеральной службой по труду и занятости. Министерство труда и социальной защиты Российской Федерациисокращённо: Минтруд России Общая информация Страна Россия Юрисдикция Россия Дата создания 21 мая 2012 года Предшественник Министер�...
Peninsula in Massachusetts, USA View looking SSW from Nut Island toward homes on Great Hill in the Houghs Neck neighborhood of Quincy, Massachusetts. Houghs Neck /ˈhaʊz/ is a one-square-mile (2.6 km2) peninsula in Quincy, Massachusetts. It is surrounded by Quincy Bay, Hingham Bay and Rock Island Cove. It is lined by Perry Beach, which runs along Manet Avenue; Nut Island, which is just beyond Great Hill at the very end of the peninsula; and Edgewater Drive. Houghs Neck is commonly refer...
Glenn Morshower al Dallas International Film Festival 2011 Glenn Grove Morshower (Dallas, 24 aprile 1959) è un attore e scrittore statunitense, attivo in campo cinematografico e televisivo. Indice 1 Biografia 1.1 The Extra Mile 2 Filmografia 2.1 Cinema 2.2 Televisione 3 Doppiatori italiani 4 Altri progetti 5 Collegamenti esterni Biografia Conosciuto soprattutto per aver recitato nel ruolo dell'Agente dei Servizi Segreti Aaron Pierce, nella serie TV della Fox, 24. Il suo personaggio ha ricevu...
Tender of the United States Navy USS Pelias on 15 November 1941 History United States NamesakePelias Builder Sun Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Company, Chester, Pennsylvania Converted by Bethlehem Steel Company, Brooklyn, New York Launched8 May 1939 Acquired1940 Commissioned5 September 1941 Decommissioned14 June 1970 Stricken1 August 1972 FateDisposed of, sold by Defense Reutilization and Marketing Service (DRMS) for scrapping, 1 October 1973 General characteristics Class and typeConverted Type...
Order of Eudicot flowering plants in the Superrosid clade SaxifragalesTemporal range: 89.5–0 Ma PreꞒ Ꞓ O S D C P T J K Pg N Turonian - Recent Saxifraga granulata L.meadow saxifrage Scientific classification Kingdom: Plantae Clade: Tracheophytes Clade: Angiosperms Clade: Eudicots Clade: Core eudicots Clade: Superrosids Order: SaxifragalesBercht. & J.Presl[1] Type genus SaxifragaL. Families[1] Altingiaceae Lindl., nom. cons. Aphanopetalaceae Doweld Cercidiphyllace...
British theatre set and costume designer This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This biography of a living person needs additional citations for verification. Please help by adding reliable sources. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libelous.Find s...
Memorial to astronauts who died in the line of duty Space Mirror Memorial The Space Mirror Memorial, which forms part of the larger Astronauts Memorial, is a National Memorial on the grounds of the John F. Kennedy Space Center Visitor Complex on Merritt Island, Florida. It is maintained by the Astronauts Memorial Foundation (AMF), whose offices are located in the NASA Center for Space Education next door to the Visitor Complex. The memorial was designed in 1987 by Holt Hinshaw Pfau Jones, and...
Pemilihan umum Bupati Jayawijaya 20242018202927 November 2024Kandidat Peta persebaran suara Peta Provinsi Papua Pegunungan yang menyoroti Kabupaten Jayawijaya Bupati petahanaSumule Tumbo (Penjabat) Bupati & Wakil Bupati terpilih Belum diketahui Pemilihan umum Bupati Jayawijaya 2024 dilaksanakan pada 27 November 2024 untuk memilih Bupati Jayawijaya periode 2024–2029.[1] Pemilihan Bupati Jayawijaya tahun tersebut akan diselenggarakan setelah Pemilihan umum Presiden Indonesia 2024...
Chế phẩm bổ sung dạng một viên thuốc Chế phẩm bổ sung dạng một viên nang Chế phẩm bổ sung dạng một viên nén Chế phẩm bổ sung dạng một viên nang mềm dùng cho dầu cá hoặc một lượng lớn vitamin E Chế phẩm bổ sung dạng bột lắc và đóng chai Sản xuất dầu gan cá tuyết, một trong những chế phẩm bổ sung chế độ ăn uống đầu tiên được sản xuất trong thế kỷ 18 [1] Chế phẩm b�...
Stasiun Shiozawa塩沢駅Stasiun Shiozawa pada Desember 2017Lokasi1229-2 Shioawa, Minamiuonuma-shi, Niigata-ken 949-6408JepangKoordinat37°02′29″N 138°50′55″E / 37.04139°N 138.84861°E / 37.04139; 138.84861Ketinggian189.5 m[1]Operator JR EastJalur■ Jalur JoetsuLetak107.9 km dari TakasakiJumlah peron1 peron samping + 1 peron pulauJumlah jalur2Informasi lainStatusMemiliki stafSitus webSitus web resmiSejarahDibuka18 November 1923PenumpangFY2017575 per ...
Peta menunjukan lokasi San Isidro Data sensus penduduk di San Isidro Tahun Populasi Persentase 199516.043—200018.6033.23%200721.3871.94% San Isidro adalah munisipalitas yang terletak di provinsi Isabela, Filipina. Pada tahun 2010, munisipalitas ini memiliki populasi sebesar 24.273 jiwa atau 5.329 rumah tangga. Pembagian wilayah Secara administratif San Isidro terbagi menjadi 13 barangay, yaitu: Camarag Cebu Gomez Gud Nagbukel Patanad Quezon Ramos East Ramos West Rizal East (Pob.) Rizal West...
Region spanning Europe and Asia This article is about the geographic region in Eurasia. For other uses, see Caucasus (disambiguation) and Caucasia (disambiguation). For a meeting of party supporters, see Caucus. CaucasusTopography of the CaucasusCoordinates42°15′40″N 44°07′16″E / 42.26111°N 44.12111°E / 42.26111; 44.12111Countries[1][2] Armenia Azerbaijan Georgia Russia Related areas Iran Turkey De facto state...
Irish people in indentured servitude in British Empire overseas territories This article is about the history of Irish indentured servants. For the myth that some of these servants were slaves, see Irish slaves myth. For indentured servitude more generally, see Indentured servitude. Modern map of the Caribbean. The Irish went to Barbados, Jamaica and the Leeward Islands. Irish indentured servants were Irish people who became indentured servants in territories under the control of the British ...