McDonough v. Smith

McDonough v. Smith
Supreme Court of the United States
Argued April 17, 2019
Decided June 20, 2019
Full case nameEdward G. McDonough v. Youel Smith, Individually and as Special District Attorney for the County of Rensselaer, New York (aka Trey Smith)
Docket no.18-485
Citations588 U.S. ___ (more)
139 S. Ct. 2149; 204 L. Ed. 2d 506
Case history
PriorMotion to dismiss granted, McDonough v. Smith, No. 1:15-cv-01505, 2016 WL 5717263 (N.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2016); motion for reconsideration denied, 2017 WL 1901962 (N.D.N.Y. May 8, 2017); affirmed, 898 F.3d 259 (2d Cir. 2018); cert, granted, 139 S. Ct. 915 (2019).
Holding
The statute of limitations for a §1983 fabricated-evidence claim began to run when the criminal proceedings end in the §1983 plaintiff's favor.
Court membership
Chief Justice
John Roberts
Associate Justices
Clarence Thomas · Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Stephen Breyer · Samuel Alito
Sonia Sotomayor · Elena Kagan
Neil Gorsuch · Brett Kavanaugh
Case opinions
MajoritySotomayor, joined by Roberts, Ginsburg, Breyer, Alito, Kavanaugh
DissentThomas, joined by Kagan, Gorsuch
Laws applied
42 U.S.C. § 1983

McDonough v. Smith, 588 U.S. ___ (2019), was a United States Supreme Court case from the October 2018 term. In a 6–3 ruling, the Court held that the 3-year statute of limitations for a fabrication of evidence civil lawsuit under section 1983 of the Civil Rights Act begins to run when the criminal case ends in the plaintiff's favor.[1]

This case was notable as a victory for criminal defendants; the precedent it set would make it easier to sue prosecutors and police for fabricating evidence against defendants.[2] The Court's ruling also resolves a circuit split between United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and other federal appeals courts.[3]

Case background

Case history

The Working Families Party (WFP) is a small political party in New York State. In September 2009, its Rensselaer County affiliate held a party primary to select its nominees for the upcoming Troy city council elections. During the primary, at least 50 absentee ballots were fraudulently obtained and cast by local political operatives attempting to gain control of the WFP's ballot line for the New York State Democratic Party. These ballots were submitted to Ed McDonough, who – as a commissioner of the Rensselaer County Board of Elections – was responsible for processing the applications.[4][5] The scandal was exposed after a local Republican Party official, Robert Mirch, funded an initial investigation into reports that some absentee ballots that were cast in the WFP primary were fraudulent.[6] Several residents swore affidavits claiming to have never filled out an absentee ballot application or to have never received or cast votes that were recorded in their name.[5]

A county judge appointed special prosecutor, Youel "Trey" Smith, to conduct the investigation following the recusal of the local District Attorney, a Democrat.[7][8] The resulting investigation led to eight indictments; of these, four individuals (two Democratic Party operatives, a city clerk, and a city councilman) pled guilty; the charges against two other former city councilmen were dropped). The two remaining defendants, former councilman Michael LoPorto and former Board of Elections Commissioner Ed McDonough, were tried twice; in their first trial, they were tried together and the jury deadlocked, necessitating a mistrial. In their second trials, which were conducted separately, both defendants were acquitted by their respective juries.[9]

In his lawsuit, which was first filed in 2015 (just under 3 years since he was acquitted), McDonough claimed that Smith had intentionally framed him, fabricating evidence to link him to the ballot fraud case.[10] According to McDonough, Smith falsified affidavits, coached witnesses to lie, and orchestrated a faulty DNA analysis to connect McDonough to the fraudulent ballot envelopes.[10][2] For example, McDonough points to one witness who did not implicate McDonough before the grand jury but changed his testimony after allegedly receiving a phone call from Smith directing him to do so.[11] McDonough alleged that Smith chose to frame him due to a political grudge that Smith had against his family.[11]

In lower courts

McDonough's case was filed in the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York under 42 USC 1983. He asserted two separate constitutional violations: denial of due process because of fabrication of evidence and malicious prosecution, which are violations of the Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution.[12] In late 2016, District Court dismissed the malicious prosecution claim because Smith had prosecutorial immunity.[13] It then dismissed the fabricated-evidence claim due to the statute of limitations.[14][12]

McDonough appealed his case to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, which heard the case in late 2017. The case was heard by a three-judge panel consisting of Judges Christopher F. Droney, Reena Raggi, and Dennis Jacobs. Writing for the Second Circuit, Judge Droney upheld the District Court's ruling dismissing the lawsuit against Smith.[15] The Second Circuit found that the statute of limitations on a fabricated-evidence claim runs when the plaintiff becomes aware of the fabricated evidence and has been deprived of liberty in some way. Under this framework, the statute of limitations began to run during McDonough's first trial, which took place more than three years before he filed his lawsuit.[12] This approach created a circuit split since it contradicted the approaches taken by the Third, Ninth, and Tenth Circuits, each of which had held that the statute of limitations begins when the criminal proceedings ended.[12][3]

McDonough appealed his case again, this time to the United States Supreme Court. He filed a writ of certiorari requesting that they hear the case in October 2018. The justices granted the writ, agreeing to hear the case in January 2019. In oral arguments before the Court, which took place in April 2019, McDonough was represented by Neal Katyal, former acting United States Solicitor General under President Barack Obama. Thomas O'Connor, from the Albany law firm Napierski, VanDenburgh, Napierski, & O'Connor, represented Smith.[11]

Supreme Court opinion

Majority opinion

In a 6–3 opinion written by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the Supreme Court held that the three-year statute of limitations for fabricated-evidence claims under section 1983 of the Civil Rights Act did not begin until the case had been favorably adjudicated in favor of the plaintiff.[16] Under common law, a statute of limitations usually begins to run once the plaintiff has a complete and present cause of action (e.g. once all elements of the tort have taken place). However, under certain circumstances, a claim can't be realistically filed while the violation is ongoing; under those circumstances, the statute of limitations may be delayed until a later time. In determining what common law principles to apply, the Supreme Court drew an analogy between McDonough's Constitutional fabricated-evidence claim and the common law tort known as malicious prosecution, which the Court found to be the tort most similar to McDonough's allegation. For malicious prosecution cases, the statute of limitations does not begin to run until the case is resolved in favor of the plaintiff.[16][2] The Supreme Court opinion noted that the common law rule for malicious prosecution had a pragmatic purpose as well, to ensure that criminal and civil cases over the same subject matter would not overlap or result in conflicting determinations.[17]

Dissent

The dissent, authored by Justice Clarence Thomas and joined by Justices Elena Kagan and Neil Gorsuch, argued that the Supreme Court should not have granted McDonough's petition for a writ of certiorari. The dissent noted that the nature and elements of his claim (e.g. the specific Constitutional rights he claims were violated) were not clearly defined, making it difficult to determine which common law principles should be applied.[16]

Effect

The Supreme Court overturned the Second Circuit's initial decision against McDonough and allowed his case to go forward.[16] Following the ruling, the Second Circuit issued an order returning the case to the Northern District in New York for further litigation.[18]

References

  1. ^ McDonough v. Smith, No. 18-485, 588 U.S. ___ (2019).
  2. ^ a b c Holland, Jake; Strawbridge-Robinson, Kimberly (June 20, 2019). "Justices Make It Easier to Sue Bad Prosecutors, Police". Bloomberg News. Retrieved December 19, 2019.
  3. ^ a b McGlothlin, John (April 2, 2019). "McDonough v. Smith: Why SCOTUS Should Revisit the Statute of Limitations for Fabrication of Evidence". The Cause of Action Institute. Retrieved December 19, 2019.
  4. ^ Randall, Michael (March 19, 2012). "Candidate defends questionable GOP campaign mailer". The Times Herald-Record. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  5. ^ a b Franco, James; Canfield, Dave (September 27, 2009). "Voter fraud alleged in Troy". The Troy Record. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  6. ^ Crowe, Kenneth (April 13, 2019). "Troy political fallout has its day in nation's highest court". The Times Union. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  7. ^ Dicker, Frederic (September 30, 2009). "WFP, Dems in fraud probe". The New York Post. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  8. ^ Canfield, Dave (September 29, 2009). "In hands of special prosecutor". The Troy Record. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  9. ^ Sweeney, Charles (April 9, 2013). "Judge orders county to pay ballot fraud legal costs". The Troy Record. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  10. ^ a b Sorenson, Lisa (June 25, 2019). "Local government official loses fabrication of evidence statute of limitations SCOTUS case". National Conference of State Legislatures. Archived from the original on December 19, 2019. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  11. ^ a b c Ryan, Tim (April 17, 2019). "Justices Consider Time Limits for Fabricated Evidence Claims". Courthouse News Service. Retrieved December 19, 2019.
  12. ^ a b c d Wasserman, Howard (April 10, 2019). "Argument preview: Searching for an accrual rule when the government fabricates evidence in a criminal proceeding". SCOTUSBlog. Retrieved December 19, 2019.
  13. ^ McDonough v. Smith, No. 1:15-cv-01505 114 (N.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2016).
  14. ^ McDonough v. Smith, No. 1:15-cv-01505 141 (N.D.N.Y. May 8, 2017).
  15. ^ McDonough v. Smith, 898 F.3d 259 (2d Cir. 2018).
  16. ^ a b c d Wasserman, Howard (June 20, 2019). "Opinion analysis: Fabricated-evidence claims accrue only on favorable termination of prosecution". SCOTUSBlog. Retrieved December 19, 2019.
  17. ^ Griffin, Teresa; Webber, Charles (June 21, 2019). "Supreme Court Decides McDonough v. Smith". JD Supra. Retrieved December 23, 2019.
  18. ^ Crowe, Kenneth (November 6, 2019). "Troy ballot fraud lawsuit heads back to federal court". The Times-Union. Retrieved December 26, 2019.

Read other articles:

Jürgen Mossack

Jürgen MossackLahir20 Maret 1948 (umur 75)Fürth, Bayern, JermanTempat tinggalPanama City, PanamaAlmamaterUniversidad Católica Santa María La AntiguaDikenal atasPendiri Mossack FonsecaOrang tuaErhard Mossack Jürgen Mossack (lahir 20 Maret 1948) adalah pengacara asal Panama dan pendiri Mossack Fonseca, firma hukum yang berpusat di Panama City dengan 40 cabang di seluruh dunia. Kehidupan Mossack lahir di Fürth, Bayern, Jerman, pada tanggal 20 Maret 1948.[1] Bapaknya, Erhard M...

 

KTCK (AM)

Radio station in Dallas, TexasKTCKDallas, TexasBroadcast areaDallas–Fort Worth MetroplexFrequency1310 kHzBrandingSportsRadio 96.7 & 1310 The TicketProgrammingLanguage(s)EnglishFormatSports radioAffiliationsFox Sports RadioWestwood One SportsDallas StarsOwnershipOwnerCumulus Media Inc.(Cumulus Licensing Holding Company LLC)Sister stationsKLIF, KPLX, KSCS, KTCK-FM, WBAP, WBAP-FMHistoryFirst air dateMarch 1, 1922; 102 years ago (1922-03-01)[1]Former call signsWRR...

 

National Register of Historic Places listings in Craig County, Virginia

Location of Craig County in Virginia This is a list of the National Register of Historic Places listings in Craig County, Virginia. This is intended to be a complete list of the properties and districts on the National Register of Historic Places in Craig County, Virginia, United States. The locations of National Register properties and districts for which the latitude and longitude coordinates are included below, may be seen in an online map.[1] There are 6 properties and districts ...

العلاقات البوسنية الهندوراسية

العلاقات البوسنية الهندوراسية البوسنة والهرسك هندوراس   البوسنة والهرسك   هندوراس تعديل مصدري - تعديل   العلاقات البوسنية الهندوراسية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين البوسنة والهرسك وهندوراس.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عا...

 

Betalain

Warna merah bit berasal dari pigmen betalain. Betalain adalah pigmen tumbuhan yang memberi warna kuning, jingga, merah, dan ungu pada bagian daun dan buah.[1] Salah satu contohnya adalah betasianin yaitu pigmen merah bit yang termasuk kelompok pigmen betalain merah dan kuning yang sejak lama dianggap berkaitan dengan antosianin, walaupun betalain mengandung nitrogen tidak seperti antosianin.[1] Baik betasianin merah maupun pigmen betalain lainnya, yaitu betaxantin kuning, rumu...

 

Boku wa Ikemen

Japanese manga series Boku wa IkemenFirst tankōbon volume coverボクはイケメンGenreRomantic comedy[1] MangaWritten byNanki SatōIllustrated byAkira KidukiPublished byHakusenshaImprintYoung Animal ComicsMagazineYoung AnimalDemographicSeinenOriginal runNovember 25, 2016 – April 27, 2018Volumes4 Boku wa Ikemen (ボクはイケメン, I'm Handsome) is a Japanese manga series written by Nanki Satō and illustrated by Akira Kiduki. It was serialized in Hakusensha's s...

Ray Dodge

American middle-distance runner Ray DodgePersonal informationBornAugust 4, 1900Woodburn, Oregon, U.S.DiedMarch 28, 1985 (aged 84)Key Biscayne, Florida, U.S.Height181 cm (5 ft 11 in)Weight78 kg (172 lb)SportSportAthleticsEvent(s)800 m, 1500 m, mileClubOregon State Beavers, CorvallisMultnomah ACAchievements and titlesPersonal best(s)800 m – 1:53.9 (1924)1500 m – 4:01.6 (1925)Mile – 4:20.9 (1925)[1] Raymond Edgar Dodge (August 4, 1900 – March 28, 1985) wa...

 

Синелобый амазон

Синелобый амазон Научная классификация Домен:ЭукариотыЦарство:ЖивотныеПодцарство:ЭуметазоиБез ранга:Двусторонне-симметричныеБез ранга:ВторичноротыеТип:ХордовыеПодтип:ПозвоночныеИнфратип:ЧелюстноротыеНадкласс:ЧетвероногиеКлада:АмниотыКлада:ЗавропсидыКласс:Пт...

 

List of Oakland Designated Landmarks

Oakland, California began a program of designating the city's historic landmarks and properties starting in 1973.[1] Many of the properties have also received recognition at the federal level by inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places or by designation as National Historic Landmarks.[2] Color markings (highest noted listing) Map all coordinates using OpenStreetMap Download coordinates as: KML GPX (all coordinates) GPX (primary coordinates) GPX (secondary coordin...

Alfred Rosenberg

Alfred Rosenberg BiografiKelahiran12 Januari 1893 Tallinn Kematian16 Oktober 1946 (53 tahun)Nürnberg Penyebab kematianHanging Member of the Reichstag of the Weimar Republic Member of the Reichstag of Nazi Germany Data pribadiAgamaGereja Lutheran dan Paganisme modern PendidikanRiga Technical University Bauman Moscow State Technical University Universitas Latvia KegiatanPekerjaanwartawan, guru, administrator, penulis opini, filsuf, politikus, penulis, arsitek, N...

 

Пугачёва, Алла Борисовна

Запрос «Пугачёва» перенаправляется сюда; см. также другие значения. Алла Пугачёва На фестивале «Славянский базар в Витебске», 2016 год Основная информация Полное имя Алла Борисовна Пугачёва Дата рождения 15 апреля 1949(1949-04-15) (75 лет) Место рождения Москва, СССР[1]...

 

Christopher Michel

American photographer, entrepreneur, and investor A major contributor to this article appears to have a close connection with its subject. It may require cleanup to comply with Wikipedia's content policies, particularly neutral point of view. Please discuss further on the talk page. (September 2021) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Michel in San Francisco, in 2021. Christopher P. Michel is an American photographer and entrepreneur, who founded Military.com.[1] He is the cur...

René Clérel de Tocqueville

Pour les autres membres de la famille, voir Famille Clérel de Tocqueville. René Clérel de TocquevilleFonctionsDéputé de la Manche5 mars 1876 - 25 juin 1877Maire de Tourlaville1870-1877Conseiller général de la Manche1869-1909BiographieNaissance 1er septembre 1834Le PecqDécès 14 janvier 1917 (à 82 ans)Le TréportNationalité françaiseActivité Homme politiqueFamille Famille Clérel de TocquevillePère Édouard de Tocqueville (d)Autres informationsPropriétaire de Château des R...

 

Франц (герцог Саксен-Кобург-Заальфельдский)

Франц Саксен-Кобург-Заальфельдскийнем. Franz von Sachsen-Coburg-Saalfeld герцог Саксен-Кобург-Заальфельдский 8 сентября 1800 — 9 декабря 1806 Предшественник Эрнст Фридрих Саксен-Кобург-Заальфельдский Преемник Эрнст I Саксен-Кобург-Заальфельдский Рождение 15 июля 1750(1750-07-15)Кобург, Сакс...

 

Toyota RAV4

Toyota RAV4Descrizione generaleCostruttore Toyota Tipo principaleSport Utility Vehicle Produzionedal 1994 Altre caratteristicheDimensioni e massaLunghezza3720-4160 mm Larghezza1695-1700 mm Altezza1655-1660 mm Passo2200-2410 mm Massa1210-1260 kg AltroStessa famigliaToyota Corolla Auto similiChevrolet CaptivaKia SorentoHonda CR-VMitsubishi OutlanderNissan QashqaiPeugeot 4007Subaru ForesterSuzuki Grand Vitara Toyota RAV4 (acronimo di Recreational Activity Vehicle 4-...

أتراك

هذه المقالة عن المجموعة العرقية الأتراك وليس عن من يحملون جنسية الجمهورية التركية أتراكTürkler (بالتركية) التعداد الكليالتعداد 70~83 مليون نسمةمناطق الوجود المميزةالبلد  القائمة ... تركياألمانياسورياالعراقبلغارياالولايات المتحدةفرنساالمملكة المتحدةهولنداالنمساأسترالي...

 

Pomeranian Voivodeship

Province in northwestern Poland For the historic voivodeship of the Polish Crown, see Pomeranian Voivodeship (1466–1772). For the voivodeship of the Second Polish Republic, see Pomeranian Voivodeship (1919–1939). Voivodeship in PolandPomeranian Voivodeship Województwo pomorskie (Polish)Pòmòrsczé wòjewództwò (Kashubian)Voivodeship FlagCoat of armsBrandmarkLocation within PolandCoordinates: 54°12′N 18°01′E / 54.200°N 18.017°E / 54.200; 18.017...

 

國立臺南大學附屬啟聰學校

國立臺南大學附屬啟聰學校地址臺南校區：700臺南市中西區北門路一段109號新化校區：712臺南市新化區信義路52號其它名称The Affiliated School for Students with Hearing Impairments of National University of Tainan类型特殊學校隶属國立臺南大學创办日期1891年学区 中華民國臺南市校長陳秀雅教師人數特教合格教師：62人一般合格教師：6人职员人数55年级幼兒部：4班國小部：8班國中部：4班高...

Drama

Artwork intended for performance, formal type of literature For the film genre, see Drama (film and television). For other uses, see Drama (disambiguation). Depiction of a scene from Shakespeare's play Richard III Literature Oral literature Folklore fable fairy tale folk play folksong heroic epic legend myth proverb Oration Performance audiobook spoken word Saying Major written forms Drama closet drama Poetry lyric narrative Prose Nonsense verse Ergodic Electronic Long prose fiction Anthology...

 

Attignéville

Peta infrastruktur dan tata guna lahan di Komune Attignéville.  = Kawasan perkotaan  = Lahan subur  = Padang rumput  = Lahan pertanaman campuran  = Hutan  = Vegetasi perdu  = Lahan basah  = Anak sungaiAttignéville merupakan sebuah komune di departemen Vosges yang terletak pada sebelah timur laut Prancis. Lihat pula Komune di departemen Vosges Referensi INSEE lbsKomune di departemen Vosges Les Ableuvenettes Ahéville Aingeville Ainvelle Allarmont Ambac...