In 1991, Walmart and Sam's Club opened across the street from the mall. Walmart moved to Olympia Fields in 2016, while Sam's Club officially closed on January 26, 2018. A year later in 1992, Best Buy opened in the surrounding area of the mall; the store closed in 2012. The mall underwent a renovation in 1993 which included a new glass elevator. In 1995, Sears opened in the former Wieboldt's location. Montgomery Ward closed their store in 1999 and went bankrupt soon after. In 2000, JCPenney closed their location in Lincoln Mall.[2] Due to the loss of two anchors, mall traffic declined and many stores began to vacate.
A $115-million redevelopment process started in 2006 with hopes of attracting more retailers. This plan included a multi-screen cinema and a four-lane road to connect Cicero Avenue and Lincoln Highway. It included the demolition of existing outparcels and the section where Montgomery Ward and JCPenney had been. In July of 2007, Target opened with a 126,000-square-foot (11,700 m2) store built on an outparcel, and JCPenney returned in October of 2007 with a 104,000-square-foot (9,700 m2) store, also built on an outparcel.
Sears began a store-closing sale on May 11, 2012.[3] On June 1, 2012, Lincoln Mall was scheduled for a court ordered sale by auction.
In August of 2013, representatives of Matteson attempted to sue the mall owners and order that the mall be closed, due to safety and building code violations including exposed electrical wiring, an inoperative sprinkler system, blocked fire exits, a crumbling roof, and a damaged foundation.[4]
On November 11, 2014, Cook County Judge Thomas Condon ordered that the mall be closed permanently as of January 7, 2015, with the exception of Carson's (whose building is owned separately by its parent company), which was to remain open. Operating funds that owner Michael Kohan initially provided for the mall's upkeep had been depleted and nothing remained to keep the mall operating after December. Kohan provided a court-appointed receiver with only $100,000 in the preceding 15 months to pay for repairs, maintenance, and staffing, while the number of remaining tenants' rent was insufficient to sustain daily operations. The mall would have needed to replace several exits and repair electrical and air conditioning systems in order to be brought up to code.[5]
In late 2016, photos of the abandoned mall surfaced, as part of a photo project by photographer Seph Lawless.[6][7]
In February of 2017, a Cook County Circuit Judge ordered immediate demolition of the mall. On March 17, 2017, news outlets reported the Village of Matteson had agreed with the court-appointed receiver on final demolition costs, with demolition projected to begin shortly after it received the judge's approval.[8][9] Demolition began May 8, 2017.[10] Demolition was completed by the end of summer 2017.
On November 7, 2017, it was announced that Target would be closing as part of a plan to close 12 stores nationwide. The store closed in February 2018.[11]
The mall itself, which closed in 2014, was demolished by 2018.[12]
On March 4, 2018, Carson Pirie Scott abruptly closed its Lincoln Mall store, leaving JCPenney the only remaining tenant.[13] In November 2019, demolition of the former Carson's building commenced.[14] On January 30, 2020, The City of Matteson approved a casino on the mall site, proposed by South Suburban Development LLC.[15]
On July 31, 2020, JCPenney put 21 stores up for sale (including the Lincoln Mall location) as part of their bankruptcy.[16]
Anchors
Current
JCPenney — Opened in 2006 outside the mall as an outparcel.
Former
Carson's — Opened in 1973, closed in 2018, building was demolished
^"Officials Reveal What Will Replace Now-Demolished Lincoln Mall; The new project will be called Market Square Crossing", WMAQ-TV, December 17, 2018. Accessed September 29, 2023. "Nearly four years after it closed for good, the site that once held the now-demolished Lincoln Mall in Matteson is getting a 'major new redevelopment.' Village officials announced Monday that the 60-acre site southeast of U.S. 30 and Cicero Avenue will now be home to commercial businesses, residential condos and townhomes, recreational facilities, entertainment and pedestrian paths. The new project will be called Market Square Crossing."
