Schwartz founded his film production company, Crispy Films, in 2004.[1] Utilizing his connections established through his career at HBO, NBC, ICM and Real World Studios, Schwartz managed to establish a number of major studio projects, including an adaptation of Thomas Hauser's novel Mark Twain Remembers, with James Franco attached to star. However, said production fell into a state of development hell, prompting Schwartz to pursue smaller, independent productions. The studio's breakthrough came with Wristcutters: A Love Story, a black comedyroad movie that premiered at the 2006 Sundance Film Festival.[4] In 2007, Schwartz co-produced Funny Games, an American remake of the 1997 Austrian psychological thriller of the same name.[5]
In 2008, Schwartz was introduced to a number of his future long-term collaborators, including fellow film producer Andrea Sperling, following the recommendation of a sales agent with Creative Artists Agency. Schwartz and Sperling became producing partners and Crispy Films was subsequently renamed Super Crispy Entertainment, with the Wilfs financing their projects.[1] That same year, an agent also arranged for Schwartz to be introduced at a Starbucks coffee shop to the up and coming director Drake Doremus. Schwartz's next two projects included Doremus' comedy-drama films Spooner, which premiered at the Slamdance Film Festival in 2009, as well as Douchebag, which premiered at the 2010 Sundance Film Festival.[2] Schwartz and Sperling executive produced the science fictionmysteryfantasycomedy filmKaboom, which premiered at the 2010 Cannes Film Festival and was awarded the first Queer Palm award.[6][7]
Schwartz collaborated again with Sperling as his producing partner and Doremus as director on the film Like Crazy, which premiered at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival. The film won the festival's Grand Jury Prize and helped launch the careers of Felicity Jones and Jennifer Lawrence.[8][9] At the 2012 Sundance Film Festival, Schwartz and Sperling were awarded the U.S. Dramatic Special Jury Prize for Excellence in Independent Film Producing.[10] The final collaboration to date between Schwartz and Doremus was Breathe In, which premiered at the 2013 Sundance Film Festival and subsequently released by the Cohen Media Group.[6][11]
Schwartz partnered with Logan Lerman, the lead actor and executive producer of The Vanishing of Sidney Hall, to produce reportedly numerous subsequent films. The partnership began with Press Play, written and directed by Greg Björkman, which was released in June 2022.[18][19][20] Schwartz and Lerman were announced to be executive producers on the film Rothko, directed by Sam Taylor-Johnson, and set to begin production in summer 2021.[21] In June 2023, Lerman and Schwartz were announced as producers alongside Andrea Iervolino & Monika Bacardi on the Hollywood thriller Skincare, directed by Austin Peters.[22]