James D. Whittemore

James David Whittemore
Senior Judge of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida
Assumed office
August 29, 2017
Judge of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida
In office
May 25, 2000 – August 29, 2017
Appointed byBill Clinton
Preceded byWilliam Terrell Hodges
Succeeded byThomas Barber
Judge of the Hillsborough County Circuit Court for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida
In office
1990–2000
Personal details
Born
James David Whittemore[1]

(1952-08-29) August 29, 1952 (age 72)[1]
Walterboro, South Carolina, U.S.[1]
SpouseMartha K. Watford[1]
EducationUniversity of Florida (BSBA)
Stetson University (JD)

James David Whittemore (born August 29, 1952) is a senior United States district judge serving in the Tampa division of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida. He was previously a Florida state trial court judge, a federal public defender, and an attorney in private practice who won a criminal case before the United States Supreme Court. As a federal judge, Whittemore presided over a number of high-profile cases, including a lawsuit against Major League Baseball to challenge its draft procedure, and the Terri Schiavo case, after the United States Congress had specifically given the Middle District of Florida jurisdiction to hear the seven-year-long fight over whether the brain-damaged Schiavo should be taken off life support.

Whittemore was born in Walterboro, South Carolina. He graduated with honors from the University of Florida in 1974 with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration degree, and then received his Juris Doctor from Stetson University Law School in 1977. He briefly worked at Bauer, Morlan & Wells, a small law firm in St. Petersburg, Florida, before becoming one of the original four federal public defenders in the Middle District of Florida in 1978. Whittemore returned to private practice in Tampa three years later as an associate at Whittemore & Seybold, and then at Whittemore & Campbell from 1982 until 1987. In 1985, Whittemore successfully argued before the United States Supreme Court in Wainwright v. Greenfield, 474 U.S. 284 (1986), that a criminal suspect's silence after he received the Miranda warning could not be used at trial to discredit his insanity defense. Whittemore's client had been convicted of sexual battery; the Court's ruling secured him a new trial. From 1987 until 1990, Whittemore was a sole practitioner in Tampa.

Judicial career

State judicial service

In 1990, Whittemore was elected to the bench of the Hillsborough County Circuit Court in the Florida Thirteenth Judicial Circuit, and remained on the court until 2000. He was named the 1998 Jurist of the Year by the Hillsborough County Bar Association, and Outstanding Jurist of 1999 by the Florida Bar's Young Lawyers Division.

Federal judicial service

After recommendation by both of Florida's United States Senators, Democrat Bob Graham and Republican Connie Mack III, he was nominated by President Bill Clinton to a new seat[note 1] in the Florida Middle District Court on October 20, 1999. Whittemore was confirmed unanimously by the United States Senate on May 24, 2000, and received his commission the following day. He assumed senior status on August 29, 2017.

Notable cases

On June 4, 2001, Whittemore ruled against Rolando Viera, a Cuban baseball pitcher who was attempting to enjoin Major League Baseball from including him in its amateur draft so that he could instead be a free agent. Viera, represented by attorney Alan Gura and agent Joe Kehoskie, had claimed that the MLB draft was discriminatory because it had a different residency requirement for Cubans, but Whittemore decided that whatever financial loss Viera suffered from being subject to the draft did not satisfy the federal injunction requirement of irreparable harm. Viera was picked by the Boston Red Sox that same week in the seventh round of the draft.

Whittemore presided over the criminal trial of Gerald and Betty Payne, the founders of Greater Ministries International Church. Over $450 million was bilked from church followers in the Paynes' fraudulent investment scheme, which was billed as one of the largest Ponzi schemes in United States history. Whittemore sentenced Gerald to 27 years for conduct he called "absolutely despicable." Betty was sentenced to over 12 years, which was increased from what Whittemore initially considered after she repeated a claim they were the innocent victims of government persecution and their religious freedoms were being violated. "It's one thing to have blind faith," Whittemore told her. "It's quite another to cast yourself as a martyr for no apparent good. I just deliberated a matter that you could serve 33 months less. What you've just done is throw that right back in my face."

Schiavo ex rel. Schindler v. Schiavo

Whittemore was randomly assigned to hear the Terri Schiavo case, a longstanding conflict between Schiavo's husband, Michael Schiavo, and her parents, Robert and Mary Schindler, over whether she should be removed from life support. The Schindlers disputed that their daughter was in a persistent vegetative state or that she would have wanted to have life support withdrawn, but Schiavo, his expert witnesses, and court-appointed physicians had successfully argued the contrary before Florida trial court judge, George Greer. The case had worked its way through Florida state courts since 1998, was denied review four times by the United States Supreme Court, and was unsuccessfully challenged by the Florida Legislature before Schiavo's feeding tube was ordered removed for the third time by Judge Greer. Shortly after midnight on March 21, 2005, the United States Congress passed an unprecedented law that gave the Middle District of Florida jurisdiction over the matter without any regard to previous state court decisions.

While protesters demonstrated outside his courthouse, Whittemore conducted a hearing on the Schindler's amended complaint[note 2] the same day the law was passed, but adjourned without issuing any orders as Schiavo's feeding tube remained removed for the third day. On March 22, Whittemore issued a thirteen-page ruling that denied a temporary restraining order (TRO) to replace the tube. As appropriate for the federal standard of review for a TRO motion, his ruling avoided the issue of whether the Congressional grant of jurisdiction was unconstitutional, as Michael Schiavo and most legal scholars had argued. Though three of the four elements of the federal TRO standard, including irreparable harm, were clearly satisfied by Schiavo's imminent death, Whittemore did not believe the Schindlers ultimately had a substantial likelihood of prevailing, but instead found each of their claims "without merit." Because the due process and equal protection violations alleged in the Schindler's complaint were premised primarily on the procedures and orders in the Florida court proceedings, the state court history had to be considered by Whittemore despite the language of the congressional act, which called for a de novo review. Whittemore stated that the issues they raised had been "exhaustively litigated" and that Judge Greer had appropriately fulfilled his role as a judge under Florida and federal law. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed Whittemore's "carefully thought-out decision" in a 2-1 ruling on March 23,[2] and denied rehearing en banc later the same day, 10–2.[2] The United States Supreme Court also denied a stay without recorded dissent on March 24.[3]

The Schindlers returned to Whittemore's courtroom, again amended their complaint to add claims based on the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA), the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the Eighth Amendment, and filed an amended motion for a TRO. Whittemore conducted a hearing on the motion the evening of March 24. When one of the Schindlers' attorneys described the removal of the feeding tube as "murder", Whittemore responded "[t]hat is the emotional rhetoric of this case. It does not influence this court and cannot influence this court. I want you to know it, and I want the public to know it." During the hearing, the protesters that still surrounded the area outside the courthouse were temporarily evacuated, so that law enforcement could detonate a suspicious bag that turned out to be harmless. The hearing proceeded inside without interruption, and lasted around four hours.

In an order issued the morning of March 25, Whittemore denied the Schindlers' amended motion. Regarding their ADA claim, Whittemore wrote that the law was inapplicable because Mr. Schiavo and the hospice in care of Terri Schiavo did not fall under the Act's definition of "public entities", nor was the withdrawal of the feeding tube based on discrimination against Schiavo on the basis of her disability. Their claim under the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 was similarly flawed, in that no discrimination was present, and the United States Supreme Court had previously ruled that the Act did not apply to medical decisions. Their Eighth Amendment claim was also rejected by Whittemore, because the amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment did not apply outside of criminal sanctions. Whittemore closed his order by conveying the court's "appreciation for the difficulties and heartbreak the parties have endured through this lengthy process." A panel of the same three Circuit judges who heard the first appeal affirmed his decision once again on March 25, with the judge who had previously dissented concurring in this second opinion.[2] Rehearing was once again denied by the Eleventh Circuit on March 30,[2] and the Supreme Court also once again denied a stay the same day. The case ended with Schiavo's death on the morning of March 31.

Notes

  1. ^ Whittemore was appointed to a new seat that was one of four created in the Middle District of Florida by Sec. 309 of 113 Stat. 1501; 106 P.L. 113, enacted November 29, 1999. Some online and media sources erroneously reported that he replaced the "retiring" Judge William Terrell Hodges. Hodges did not retire, however, but instead assumed senior status on May 2, 1999, and as of 2017 remains active on the court in the Ocala Division.
  2. ^ The first complaint filed by the Schindlers was based on habeas corpus and was amended prior to the hearing.

References

  1. ^ a b c d Confirmation hearings on federal appointments : hearings before the Committee on the Judiciary, United States Senate, One Hundred Sixth Congress, first session, on confirmation of appointees to the federal judiciary. pt.2 (2000)
  2. ^ "US Supreme Court Orders - FindLaw".

Sources

Schiavo ex rel. Schindler v. Schiavo

Legal offices
Preceded by Judge of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida
2000–2017
Succeeded by

Read other articles:

Angsana Resort & SpaLua error in Modul:Location_map at line 439: Tidak ada nilai yang diberikan untuk garis bujur.Informasi umumLokasiBintan, Kepulauan Riau, IndonesiaInformasi lainJumlah kamar106Situs webAngsana Resort & Spa Angsana Resort & Spa adalah sebuah resor 5-bintang di Bintan, Indonesia yang berada di Teluk Tanjung Said sekitar 45 menit dengan feri dari Singapura. Referensi Pranala luar Angsana Resort & Spa di situs Agoda Artikel bertopik penginapan ini adalah sebuah...

 

Chip InPoster promosiHangul십시일반 Hanja十匙一飯 GenreDrama Misteri Komedi hitamDitulis olehChoi KyungSutradaraJin Chang-kyuPemeranKim Hye-jun Oh Na-ra Kim Jung-young Nam Moon-chul Lee Yoon-hee Nam Mi-jung Han Sung-chun Choi Kyu-jin Kim Si-eunNegara asalKorea SelatanBahasa asliKoreaJmlh. episode16ProduksiPengaturan kameraSingle cameraDurasi35 menitRumah produksiMBC Drama ProductionDistributorMBCRilis asliJaringanMBC TVFormat gambar1080i (HDTV)Format audioDolby DigitalRilis22 Juli...

 

Serie C 1936-1937 Competizione Serie C Sport Calcio Edizione 2ª Organizzatore Direttorio Divisioni Superiori Date dal 13 settembre 1936al 16 maggio 1937 Luogo  Italia Partecipanti 76 Formula 5 gironi Risultati Promozioni Anconitana-BianchiPadovaSanremeseTarantoVigevano Retrocessioni (le squadre scritte in corsivo sono poi state riammesse) Pro Gorizia, Fortitudo Trieste; Legnano, Crema; Cusiana, Gallaratese; Andrea Doria, Carrarese P. Binelli; Acqui, Derthona; Forlì, Forlimpopo...

Ne doit pas être confondu avec Thillot. Le Thillot L'église Saint-Jean-Baptiste. Blason Administration Pays France Région Grand Est Département Vosges Arrondissement Épinal Intercommunalité Communauté de communes des Ballons des Hautes-Vosges(siège) Maire Mandat Isabelle Canonaco 2023-2026 Code postal 88160 Code commune 88468 Démographie Gentilé Thillotins Populationmunicipale 3 257 hab. (2021 ) Densité 215 hab./km2 Population agglomération 14 694 hab. (2...

 

بطولة اتحاد غرب آسيا لكرة القدم 2012بطولة اتحاد غرب آسيا السابعة للرجال[1]تفاصيل المسابقةالبلد المضيفالكويتالتواريخ8–20 ديسمبرالفرق11 (من 1 اتحاد كونفدرالي)الأماكن2 (في مدينتين مضيفتين)المراكز النهائيةالبطل سوريا (أول لقب)الوصيف العراقالمركز الثالث عمانال�...

 

Questa voce sugli argomenti allenatori di calcio e calciatori congolesi (Rep. Dem. del Congo) è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti dei progetti di riferimento 1, 2. Adelard Mayanga Maku Adelard Mayanga Maku in 1974. Nazionalità  Zaire Altezza 178 cm Calcio Ruolo Allenatore (ex attaccante) Termine carriera 1982 - giocatore 2001 - allenatore Carriera Squadre di club1 1968-1982 Vita Club? (?) Nazionale 1970-1979...

47th Flying Training Wing Descrizione generaleNazione Stati Uniti ServizioUnited States Air Force TipoStormo da addestramento Parte di Air Education and Training Command ComandantiColonnelloCharles M. Velino SimboliTail codeXL Fonti indicate nel testo Voci su unità militari presenti su Wikipedia T-6A dello Stormo T-1A dello Stormo Il 47th Flying Training Wing è uno Stormo da addestramento dell'Air Education and Training Command, inquadrato nella Nineteenth Air Force. Il suo quartier ge...

 

Cet article est une ébauche concernant un film américain. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?) selon les conventions filmographiques. Balles de feu Données clés Titre québécois Balles en feu Titre original Balls of Fury Réalisation Robert Ben Garant Scénario Thomas Lennon et Robert Ben Garant Acteurs principaux Dan FoglerChristopher WalkenGeorge LopezMaggie QJames Hong Pays de production États-Unis Genre Comédie Durée 90 minutes Sortie 2007 Po...

 

Sanskrit term denoting Jain pilgrimage sites This article is about the Jainism term. For other uses, see Tirtha (disambiguation). Part of a series onJainism Jains History Timeline Index Philosophy Anekantavada Cosmology Ahimsa Karma Dharma Mokṣa Kevala Jnana Dravya Tattva Brahmacarya Aparigraha Gunasthana Saṃsāra EthicsEthics of Jainism Mahavratas (major vows) Ahiṃsā (non-violence) Satya (truth) Asteya (non-stealing) Brahmacarya (chastity) Aparigraha (non-possession) Anuvratas (furthe...

Pomf et Thud Pomf (à gauche) et Thud (à droite) à la Japan Expo Sud en février 2011. Données clés Nationalité Française Pays de résidence France Activité principale Commentateurs de StarCraft II modifier Pomf et Thud, de leurs vrais noms Alexandre Noci et Hadrien Noci, sont deux frères[1] commentateurs français[2] de StarCraft II qui commentent des matchs entre joueurs professionnels ou semi-professionnels. Ces matchs sont commentés à partir de replays et sont diffusés sur leu...

 

Highway in Kansas K-14K-14 highlighted in red, K-14 Truck highlighted in blueRoute informationMaintained by KDOT and the cities of Kingman, Sterling, Lyons, Ellsworth and BeloitLength219.276 mi[2] (352.891 km)Existed1926[1]–presentMajor junctionsSouth end US-160 / K-2 in HarperMajor intersections US-54 / US-400 through Kingman County K-96 near South Hutchinson US-50 / K-61 in South Hutchinson US-56 / K-96 in Lyons K-156 in Ellsworth I...

 

本條目存在以下問題,請協助改善本條目或在討論頁針對議題發表看法。 此條目需要編修,以確保文法、用詞、语气、格式、標點等使用恰当。 (2013年8月6日)請按照校對指引,幫助编辑這個條目。(幫助、討論) 此條目剧情、虛構用語或人物介紹过长过细,需清理无关故事主轴的细节、用語和角色介紹。 (2020年10月6日)劇情、用語和人物介紹都只是用於了解故事主軸,輔助�...

Halaman ini berisi artikel tentang bangsa dan masyarakat Franka. Untuk perkembangan politik orang Franka, lihat Negeri Franka. Orang FrankaFranciBekal kubur bangsawan Franka dari zaman wangsa MerovingBahasaBahasa Franka LamaAgamaKepercayaan leluhur orang Franka, Katolik RomaKelompok etnik terkaitSuku-suku bangsa Jermani, bangsa Prancis Orang Franka (bahasa Latin: Franci, tunggal: Francus) atau suku Franka (bahasa Latin: Gens Francorum) adalah sebutan bagi sekumpulan suku dari rumpun J...

 

بلاد الشام في القرن السابع خارطة سوريا الطبيعية في أدبيات الحزب السوري القومي الاجتماعي سوريا الطبيعية أو سوريا الكبرى (باللاتينية: Syria Salutari) مصطلح معروف أيضاً في السياق التاريخي بلاد الشام، أو سوريا كما عُرف في العصر الحديث حتى بداية القرن العشرين، أو الأقطار السورية أو ا...

 

1954–2011 international organisation and military alliance WEU redirects here. For the women's rights organization, see Women's Emancipation Union. For the ISO 639-3 code weu, see Welaung language. Western European UnionUnion de l'Europe occidentale1954–2011 Flag (1995–2011)1954–19901990–19951995–2011StatusAllianceCapitalBrusselsHistorical eraCold War• Modified Brussels Treaty 23 October 1954• Cultural tasks transf. to CoE 1 January 1960• Rome Declaration 27 O...

Infinite integer series where the next number is the sum of the two preceding it Not to be confused with Lucas sequences, the general class of sequences to which the Lucas numbers belong. This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (December 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this message) The Lucas spiral, made with quarter-arcs, is a good approximation ...

 

Greek freedom fighter and government leader Andreas ZaimisΑνδρέας ΖαΐμηςPresident of the Provisional Administration of GreeceIn office18 April 1826 – 26 March 1827 (o.s.)Preceded byGeorgios KountouriotisSucceeded byVice-gubernatorial Committee of 1827 Ioannis Kapodistrias (as Governor of Greece) Personal detailsBorn1791Kerpini, Kalavryta, Ottoman EmpireDied4 May 1840 (aged 49)Athens, GreeceSpouseEleni Deligianni Andreas Asimakis Zaimis (Greek: Ανδρέας Ζαΐμη...

 

American football player (born 1951) American football player Nat MooreMoore in 2014No. 89Position:Wide receiverPersonal informationBorn: (1951-09-19) September 19, 1951 (age 72)Tallahassee, Florida, U.S.Height:5 ft 9 in (1.75 m)Weight:184 lb (83 kg)Career informationHigh school:Edison (Miami, Florida)College:Florida (1972–1973)NFL draft:1974 / Round: 3 / Pick: 78Career history Miami Dolphins (1974–1986) Career highlights and awards First-...

Power spectrum of a noise signal Black noise redirects here. For other uses, see Black Noise. This article may be confusing or unclear to readers. Please help clarify the article. There might be a discussion about this on the talk page. (December 2021) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Colors of noise White Pink Red (Brownian) Purple Grey vte In audio engineering, electronics, physics, and many other fields, the color of noise or noise spectrum refers to the power spectrum of a nois...

 

Primera División Uruguaya 1950 Competizione Primera División Uruguaya Sport Calcio Edizione 47ª Organizzatore AUF Luogo  Uruguay Partecipanti 10 Formula 1 girone all'italiana Risultati Vincitore  Nacional(21º titolo) Statistiche Miglior marcatore Juan Orlandi (14) Incontri disputati 90 Gol segnati 322 (3,58 per incontro) Cronologia della competizione 1949 1951 Manuale Il campionato era formato da dieci squadre e il Nacional vinse il titolo. Classifica finale Pos. Squa...