Online music magazine Pitchfork placed Immer at number 116 on its list of the top 200 albums of the 2000s.[3]
In 2010, Resident Advisor placed Immer at number 1 on its list of top 50 mix CDs of the 2000s.[4] In 2012, Rolling Stone ranked it at number 18 on its list of the 30 greatest EDM albums of all time.[5] Writing for the AV Club, Andy Battaglia called Immer "an impeccably sequenced journey through techno's most brooding reaches."[6]