Four Dissertations

Four Dissertations is a collection of four essays by the 18th-century Scottish Enlightenment philosopher David Hume, first published in 1757.[1] The four essays are:

  1. The Natural History of Religion
  2. Of the Passions
  3. Of Tragedy
  4. Of the Standard of Taste

The Natural History of Religion

In this essay, Hume offers a pioneering naturalist account of the causes, effects, and historical development of religious belief. Hume argues that a crude polytheism was the earliest religion of mankind and locates the origins of religion in emotion, particularly hope, fear, and the desire to control the future. He further argues that monotheism arises from competition between religions, as believers seek to distinguish their deities as superior to all rivals, magnifying those deities until they possess all perfections. Though an enlightened monotheism is more rationally defensible than a superstitious polytheism, in practice polytheism has many advantages. In particular, Hume argues, monotheistic religions tend to be more intolerant and hypocritical, result in greater intellectual absurdities, and foster socially undesirable "monkish virtues", such as mortification, abasement, and passive suffering.[2]

Hume concludes the "Natural History" on a note of characteristic skepticism:

The whole is a riddle, an aenigma, an inexplicable mystery. Doubt, uncertainty, suspence of judgment appear the only result of our most accurate scrutiny, concerning this subject. But such is the frailty of human reason, and such the irresistible contagion of opinion, that even this deliberate doubt could scarcely be upheld; did we not enlarge our view, and opposing one species of superstition to another, set them a quarrelling; while we ourselves, during their fury and contention, happily make our escape, into the calm, though obscure, regions of philosophy.[3]

Of the Passions

Hume begins the passions by giving a trite example of what Good and Evil are; Good being pleasure, Evil being pain. He then begins to analyze emotion as a reasoning faculty of the human mind. He argues that not only can emotions mix, they can also destroy one another. He also argues that our imagination and sentiments combine to create an impression of something/someone. For example, you see your grade on a test and it is good, you then attribute that good grade to having a good teacher, and even maybe an interest in the class as well. Hume tries to exclude religion from our reasoning faculty of right and wrong in that we make our decisions based on the over-riding passion during that moment. Your wife may divorce you, but I bet winning the lottery would make you forget about it. He concludes by saying that this mixture of emotion and sentiments give rise to hope and fear, which gives rise to religion in ancient society.

Of Tragedy

Of Tragedy is where Hume considered why we enjoy tragic drama. He was concerned with why spectators find pleasure in the sorrow and anxiety depicted in a tragedy. He decided that this was because the spectator is aware that he is witnessing a dramatic performance. There is pleasure in realizing that the terrible events that are being shown are actually fiction.[4]

Hume focuses on tragedy and its relationship with passions. So far Hume's view on this relationship has been formulated in many different ways, one of which is Hume's conversion theory. According to this theory, painful passions are turned into pleasurable ones using stylistic and formal rhetorical means. This view has been constantly proved, disproved, edited and changed by either its supporters or its critics. However, in most cases, the supporters or the critics agree that tragedy induces pleasure using poetic or rhetorical and stylistic means.[5]

Of the Standard of Taste

Of the Standard of Taste was a seminal essay on aesthetics that is innovative because it requires Hume to address the apparent relativity of taste, a conclusion that appears to follow from his own assumption that the "good" or "beauty" of a good work of art is identical with the positive human responses it generates. The essay's focus on the subject (the viewer, the reader) rather than the object (the painting, the book) is typical of the British "sentimentalists" or moral sense theorists of the eighteenth century. Unlike the French philosophers of the 18th century, who sought an objective definition of beauty, the British school tended to look for the connections between taste and aesthetic judgments.

Summary

Hume begins with the observation that there is much variety in people's taste (or the aesthetic judgments people make). However, Hume argues that there is a common mechanism in human nature that gives rise to, and often even provides justification for, such judgments. He takes this aesthetic sense to be quite similar to the moral sense for which he argues in his Book 3 of A Treatise of Human Nature (1739–1740) and in An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751). Furthermore, he argues that this still leaves room for the ability to refine one's aesthetic palate (Fieser, 2006, §2).

Hume took as his premise that the great diversity and disagreement regarding matters of taste had two basic sources – sentiment, which was to some degree naturally varying, and critical facility, which could be cultivated. Each person is a combination of these of two sources, and Hume endeavours to delineate the admirable qualities of a critic, that they might augment their natural sense of beauty into a reliable faculty of judgment. There are a variety of qualities of the good critic that he describes, each of which contributes to an ultimately reliable and just ability to judge.

References and further reading

References

  1. ^ Hume, David (1757). Four Dissertations (1st ed.). London: A. Millar in the Strand. Retrieved 15 June 2015. david hume four dissertations. via Google Books
  2. ^ David Hume, The Natural History of Religion. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1956, p. 52.
  3. ^ Hume, Natural History, p. 76.
  4. ^ Schmidt, CM., David Hume: Reason in History, Penn State Press, 2010, pp. 325-326.
  5. ^ Roshani Payan M. (2017) Studying the Effects of Tragedy in Moral and Cognitive Judgments According to David Hume Kimia Honar; 6 (24) :75-86

Read other articles:

Keuskupan Agung DubuqueArchidioecesis DubuquensisKatolik LokasiNegara Amerika SerikatWilayah30 county di Iowa Timur LautProvinsi gerejawiDubuqueKoordinat42°29′06″N 90°40′31″W / 42.48500°N 90.67528°W / 42.48500; -90.67528Koordinat: 42°29′06″N 90°40′31″W / 42.48500°N 90.67528°W / 42.48500; -90.67528StatistikLuas17.400 sq mi (45.000 km2)Populasi- Total- Katolik(per 2013)998.638200,588 ...

 

Kepulauan Selayar pada Pekan Olahraga Provinsi Sulawesi Selatan 2022 Ketua kontingen TBA Warna kebanggaan  M E R A H  Peringkat sebelumnya 3 dari 24 kontingen Jumlah atlet TBA orang Jumlah cabang olahraga inti yang diikuti 15 cabang olahraga Jumlah cabang olahraga eksibisi yang diikuti TBA cabang olahraga Jumlah pendukung atlet (ofisial, pelatih, manajer) TBA orang Anggota kontingen 264 orang Total medali Emas18 Perak22 Perunggu19 59 (Urutan ke-7 ) Kontingen Kepulauan Selayar ...

 

American TV series or program Signing Time!GenreChildren's television seriesCreated byRachel ColemanEmilie BrownDirected byDamian DaytonStarringRachel ColemanLiam Coleman[1]Alex BrownAaron de AzevedoVoices ofClara PoulsenAlex BrownZachary BrownTheme music composerRachel ColemanOpening themeSigning Time! ThemeComposersRachel ColemanLex de AzevedoCountry of originUnited StatesOriginal languagesEnglishASL (vocabulary only)No. of seasons2No. of episodes26 (list of episodes)ProductionProd...

Public college in Toronto, Ontario, Canada This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article contains content that is written like an advertisement. Please help improve it by removing promotional content and inappropriate external links, and by adding encyclopedic content written from a neutral point of view. (August 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Th...

 

Rêya HeqîPir Sultan AbdalKitab suciQuran, Nahj al-Balagha, Makalat dan BuyruksPemimpinOcaxAjaran dariImam Ali, Pir Sultan AbdalWilayahTurkiBahasaBahasa Kurmanji, dan bahasa Zaza[1]LiturgiJem, SamāhKantor pusatProvinsi Tunceli, TurkiPendiriPir Sultan AbdalTerpisah dariSunni, Syiah Imamiyah dan Alevi TurkiNama lainAlevisme Kurdi Alevisme Kurdi[2] (bahasa Kurdi: Rêya Heqî, har. ''Jalan Tuhan/Kebenaran'')[2] mengacu pada praktik ritual unik, tempat su...

 

Voce principale: Alma Juventus Fano 1906. Fano CalcioStagione 1993-1994Sport calcio Squadra Fano Allenatore Alberto Cavasin Presidente Liliana Camissa (amministratore unico) Serie C24º posto nel girone B. Maggiori presenzeCampionato: Misefori (33) Miglior marcatoreCampionato: Marri (6) 1992-1993 1994-1995 Si invita a seguire il modello di voce Questa pagina raccoglie le informazioni riguardanti il Fano Calcio nelle competizioni ufficiali della stagione 1993-1994. Indice 1 Rosa 2 Risult...

رونالد كوس (بالإنجليزية: Ronald Harry Coase)‏    معلومات شخصية الميلاد 29 ديسمبر 1910 [1][2][3]  ويلسدن  [لغات أخرى]‏  الوفاة 2 سبتمبر 2013 (102 سنة) [4][1]  شيكاغو  مكان الدفن مقبرة غريسلاند  مواطنة المملكة المتحدة المملكة المتحدة لبريطانيا العظمى و�...

 

Details of the managers of Manchester City F.C Pep Guardiola is the most successful manager in club history with sixteen trophies won, including the first-ever European Cup title. This is a chronological list of Manchester City managers, comprising all those who have held the position of manager for the first team and its predecessors West Gorton (St. Marks) and Ardwick. In the Football League era the club has appointed 47 managers; including pre-league managers and temporary caretakers more ...

 

يتناول الإصلاح البيئي إزالة التلوث أو الملوثات من الوسائط البيئية مثل التربة أو المياه الجوفية أو الرواسب أو المياه السطحية. يخضع الإجراء التصحيحي عمومًا لمجموعة من المتطلبات التنظيمية، وقد يستند أيضًا إلى تقييم المخاطر على صحة الإنسان والمخاطر البيئية في حالة عدم وجود ...

Armored personnel carrier S600 SpecificationsMass12.5 tLength5,6 m (18.37 ft)Width2,45 m (8.04 ft)Height2,7 m (8.86 ft)Crew9-12MainarmamentOptional 12.7mm M2 machine gunEngineMercedes-Benz OM-366LA 6 cyl turbocharged Diesel Engine214 HP (157 KW)Suspension4×4 wheeledOperationalrange1000 km (621.37 mi)Maximum speed Road 108km/h (67.1 mph) The Shorland S600 is an armored personnel carrier developed in 1995 as a private venture by Short Brothers plc in Northern Ireland. Unlike the previous Shorl...

 

United States historic placeRichmond Carnegie LibraryU.S. National Register of Historic Places The building in 2010Show map of UtahShow map of the United StatesLocation6 West Main Street, Richmond, UtahCoordinates41°55′23″N 111°48′32″W / 41.92306°N 111.80889°W / 41.92306; -111.80889 (Richmond Carnegie Library)Arealess than one acreBuilt{1913Built byAugust S. SchowArchitectWatkins & BirchArchitectural styleClassical RevivalMPSCarnegie Libra...

 

هذه مقالة غير مراجعة. ينبغي أن يزال هذا القالب بعد أن يراجعها محرر؛ إذا لزم الأمر فيجب أن توسم المقالة بقوالب الصيانة المناسبة. يمكن أيضاً تقديم طلب لمراجعة المقالة في الصفحة المخصصة لذلك. (ديسمبر 2020) المعهد العالي لعلوم التمريض بتونسالمعهد العالي لعلوم التمريض بتونس (بالع�...

River in New Hampshire, United StatesWest Branch Peabody RiverThe West Branch near its confluence with the Peabody RiverShow map of New HampshireShow map of the United StatesLocationCountryUnited StatesStateNew HampshireCountyCoosTownshipsThompson & Meserves Purchase, Greens GrantPhysical characteristicsSourceSpaulding Lake (Great Gulf) • locationThompson & Meserves Purchase • coordinates44°17′4″N 71°18′29″W / 44.28444°N ...

 

City in Idaho, United StatesKellogg, IdahoCityDrone view from Kellogg, IdahoLocation of Kellogg in Shoshone County, IdahoCoordinates: 47°32′18″N 116°7′31″W / 47.53833°N 116.12528°W / 47.53833; -116.12528CountryUnited StatesStateIdahoCountyShoshoneGovernment • MayorMac PoolerArea[1] • Total4.01 sq mi (10.39 km2) • Land3.97 sq mi (10.29 km2) • Water0.04 sq mi (0.0...

 

Football tournamentNorth American Nations CupOrganizing bodyNAFC(1947 & 1949)NAFU(1990 & 1991)Founded1947Abolished1991RegionNorth AmericaNumber of teams3Qualifier for1950 World CupPanamerican Championship (Only 1949 Edition)Related competitionsGold CupMost successful team(s) Mexico(3 titles) Tournaments 1947 1949 1990 1991 The North American Nations Cup and NAFC Championship were association football tournaments for teams in the area of North America. In 1947 and 1949, the NAFC C...

عرقمعلومات عامةالنوع anise drink (en) — flavored liquor (en) المكونات الرئيسية anise seed (en) القيمة الغذائيةنسبة الكحول 40 تعديل - تعديل مصدري - تعديل ويكي بيانات جزء من سلسلة مقالات حولالمطبخ العربي حسب البلد الجزيرة العربية البحرين الإمارات الكويت سلطنة عمان قطر السعودية اليمن المغرب الكبير...

 

Archaeological site in Bahrain This article is about the fortress in Riffa. For the geographic location, see Riffa. Riffa FortNative name Arabic: قلعة الرفاعLocationRiffa, BahrainBuilt1812-1818Restored1993 Riffa Fort (Arabic: قلعة الرفاع, romanized: Qal'at ar-Rifa') also known as, Shaikh Salman bin Ahmed Fateh Fort or Qal'at ar-Riffa, is a fort in Riffa, Bahrain. The fort is situated on a cliff overlooked the desert valley between East Riffa and West Riffa. History In...

 

Historic building in Venice, Italy The Fondaco dei Tedeschi before renovation. The new façade and the panoramic roof. The Fondaco dei Tedeschi (Venetian: Fòntego dei Todeschi, in literal English, warehouse of the Germans) is a historic building in Venice, northern Italy, situated on the Grand Canal near the Rialto Bridge. It was the headquarters and restricted living quarters of the city's German (Tedeschi) merchants. Name The word fondaco comes from the Arabic funduq (فُنْدُق), whic...

موسوعة موضوعالشعارمعلومات عامةموقع الويب universalis.fr (الفرنسية) تجاري؟ نعمنوع الموقع موسوعة إنترنتتاريخ الإطلاق 1966 (إطلاق ورقي)الوضع الحالي نشطالجوانب التقنيةاللغة الفرنسيةالتسجيل اختياريأهم الشخصياتالمالك موسوعة بريتانيكاالايرادات والعائداتالعائدات  القائمة ... 5.6 مل...

 

Norwegian actor, singer, and theater director Leif Amble-NæssLeif Amble-Næss in 1934Born(1896-05-08)May 8, 1896Bjarkøy, NorwayDiedJanuary 18, 1974(1974-01-18) (aged 77)Stockholm, SwedenNationalityNorwegianOccupation(s)Actor, singer, theater directorParent(s)Leonard Næss, Elise Amble Leif Amble-Næss (May 8, 1896 – January 18, 1974) was a Norwegian actor, singer, and theater director.[1][2][3] Amble-Næss debuted in 1916 at Oslo's Central Theater, where he mo...