According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the community has an area of 1.744 square miles (4.52 km2), all land.[4]
There is an actual creek by the name of Deer Creek, which when not dry, flows by this Village of Deer Creek. The remains of David Gowan, a well-known pioneer, were buried just where they were found beside the North Fork of Deer Creek, close to Bars Canyon. .[5] Today, the grave site is marked and preserved.
(There is a different Deer Creek in the Grand Canyon which flows into the Colorado River.)