Criticism and self-criticism (Marxism–Leninism)

Criticism and self-criticism (Russian: Самокритика, Samokritika; Chinese: 自我批评, Zìwǒ pīpíng; Vietnamese: Tự phê bình) is a philosophical and political concept developed within the ideology of Marxism–Leninism and Maoism.^[1] The concept would be a major component of the political philosophy of Chinese Marxist leader Mao Zedong.

The concept of self-criticism is a component of some Marxist schools of thought, primarily that of Marxism–Leninism, Maoism and Marxism–Leninism–Maoism. The concept was first introduced by Joseph Stalin in his 1924 work The Foundations of Leninism^[2] and later expanded upon in his 1928 work Against Vulgarising the Slogan of Self-Criticism.^[3] The Marxist concept of self-criticism is also present in the works of Mao Zedong, who dedicates an entire chapter of The Little Red Book to the issue. Accordingly, many party members who had fallen out of favor with the nomenklatura were forced to undergo self-criticism sessions, producing either written or verbal statements detailing their ideological errors and affirming their renewed belief in the party line.

History

Soviet Union

According to David Priestland, the concept of politically enforced "criticism and self-criticism" originated during the 1921–1924 purges of academia within the Soviet Union. This would eventually develop into the practise of "criticism and self-criticism" campaigns in which intellectuals suspected of possessing counter-revolutionary tendencies were publicly interrogated as part of a policy of "proletariatization."^[1]

Joseph Stalin introduced the concept of self-criticism in his 1924 work The Foundations of Leninism.^[4] He would later expand this concept in his 1928 article "Against Vulgarising the Slogan of Self-Criticism".^[5] Stalin wrote in 1928^[6] "I think, comrades, that self-criticism is as necessary to us as air or water. I think that without it, without self-criticism, our Party could not make any headway, could not disclose our ulcers, could not eliminate our shortcomings. And shortcomings we have in plenty. That must be admitted frankly and honestly."^[7] For Stalin self-criticism was not supposed to be "temporary and transient"^[8] but an "indispensable and permanent weapon in the arsenal of Bolshevism".^[9]

However, Stalin posited that self-criticism "date[s] back to the first appearance of Bolshevism in our country". Stalin stated that self-criticism was needed even after obtaining power as failing to observe weaknesses "make things easier for their enemies" and that "without self-criticism there can be no proper education of the Party, the class, and the masses". Vladimir Lenin wrote in One Step Forward, Two Steps Back (1904) that the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party engages in "self-criticism and ruthless exposure of their own shortcomings". Lenin further discussed the idea in "Left-Wing" Communism: An Infantile Disorder (1920), "Frankly admitting a mistake, ascertaining the reasons for it, analysing the circumstances which gave rise to it, and thoroughly discussing the means of correcting it—that is the earmark of a serious party".^[10] Lenin again further elaborated at a later date (1922) that "All the revolutionary parties that have perished so far, perished because they grew conceited, failed to see where their strength lay, and feared to speak of their weaknesses. But we shall not perish, for we do not fear to speak of our weaknesses and shall learn to overcome them".^[11]

According to the official history of the October Revolution and Soviet Union produced under Stalin, The History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks), the concept is described briefly in the twelfth chapter,

In order to be fully prepared for this turn, the Party had to be its moving spirit, and the leading role of the Party in the forthcoming elections had to be fully ensured. But this could be done only if the Party organizations themselves became thoroughly democratic in their everyday work, only if they fully observed the principles of democratic centralism in their inner-Party life, as the Party Rules demanded, only if all organs of the Party were elected, only if criticism and self-criticism in the Party were developed to the full, only if the responsibility of the Party bodies to the members of the Party were complete, and if the members of the Party themselves became thoroughly active.^[12]

Following the death of Joseph Stalin in 1953, successor to Soviet premiership Nikita Khrushchev would reaffirm the Communist Party of the Soviet Union's ideological dedication to the concepts of "criticism and self criticism" in the conclusion to the 1956 speech before the 20th Party Congress, while also denouncing the policies and actions of Stalin.^[13]

People's Republic of China

Mao Zedong provides a significant focus on the idea of self-criticism, dedicating a whole chapter of the Little Red Book to the issue. Mao saw "conscientious practice" of self-criticism as a quality that distinguished the Chinese Communist Party from other parties. Mao championed self-criticism saying "dust will accumulate if a room is not cleaned regularly, our faces will get dirty if they are not washed regularly. Our comrades' minds and our Party's work may also collect dust, and also need sweeping and washing."^[14]

Mao saw the timing of self-criticism as important also, writing that "do it in good time; don't get into the habit of criticizing only after the event".^[15] Mao advocated "active ideological struggle" in the form of self-criticism while warning "we must not become complacent over any success. We should check our complacency and constantly criticize our shortcomings"^[16]^[17]

He said "inner-Party criticism is a weapon for strengthening the Party organization and increasing its fighting capacity"^[18] however he warned against criticism degenerating into personal attacks - "The method of correction is to help Party members understand that the purpose of criticism is to increase the Party's fighting capacity in order to achieve victory in the class struggle and that it should not be used as a means of personal attack".^[19]

In the People's Republic of China, self-criticism—called ziwo pipan (自我批判) or jiǎntǎo (检讨)—is an important part of Maoist practice. Mandatory self-criticism as a part of political rehabilitation common under Mao and ended by Deng Xiaoping, is known as a struggle session in reference to class struggle.^[20]^[21]

As General Secretary of the Communist Party of China, Xi Jinping has partially brought back the practice of self-criticism.^[22]^: 37

Vietnam

Vietnamese leader Ho Chi Minh made numerous references to the importance of self-criticism within the Vietnamese Communist Party.^[23] In 1956 he critically assessed the Communist Party as having leaders who did not practice self-criticism and that criticism from the lower levels of the party was also lacking.^[24]

Cambodia

In Democratic Kampuchea, self-criticism sessions were known as rien sot, meaning "religious education". In his memoir The Gate, François Bizot recalls observing the Khmer Rouge engaging in frequent self-criticism to reinforce group cohesion during his imprisonment in rural Cambodia in 1971:^[25]

Several evenings a week—every evening it didn't rain—the guards gathered for a collective confession. Douch (Kang Kek Iew) did not take part. I was a privileged witness to these circles, where they would sit on the ground under the direction of an elder. Military homilies alternated with simple, repetitive songs. "Comrades," began the eldest, "let us appraise the day that has passed, in order to correct our faults. We must cleanse ourselves of the repeated sins that accumulate and slow down our beloved revolution. Do not be surprised at this!"
"I," said the first one, "should have replaced the rattan rod today, the one north of the first shelter, which we use to dry clothes. I have done nothing about it... on account of my laziness." The man presiding over the session nodded with a frown, though not severely, only meaning to show that he knew how hard it was to combat inertia, so natural in man when he is not sustained by revolutionary convictions. He passed wordlessly onto the next man, indicating who this should be by pursing his lips in his direction.

North Korea

North Koreans are required to engage in saenghwal ch’onghwa sessions in which they confess to wrongdoings, transgressions, and deviations from Kim Il Sung's Ten Principles for the Establishment of a Monolithic Ideological System.^[26]^[27]^[28] They are required to attend self-criticism sessions from the age of 8.^[26] Members of the ruling Korean Workers' Party can be dismissed if they do not attend sessions for longer than three months.^[27] Inmates at North Korean kwalliso camps are required to engage in self-criticism sessions, which often lead to harsh collective punishments for entire work-units.^[29] The practice was introduced in 1962 during a series of ideological disputes with the Soviet Union.^[28]

Outside the Communist Bloc

French Marxist philosopher Louis Althusser wrote "Essays in Self-Criticism" focused on the issue of ideologically correcting ideas expressed in his prior works, most prominently For Marx and Reading Capital.^[30]

The American New Left revolutionary organization Weather Underground dedicated a chapter of their work Prairie Fire to self-criticism of their prior revolutionary strategies.^[31] Likewise, the German Red Army Faction discussed the issues of self criticism in their publication The Urban Guerrilla Concept.^[32]

References

^ ^a ^b Priestland, David (2010). ""Men of Steel"". The Red Flag: A History of Communism. Groove Press. ISBN 9780802145123. Another way of discovering revolutionary commitment can be seen in the academic seminars of Communist universities. Academics were 'worked over', or subjected to aggressive questioning in public meetings; if they were discovered to be in error, they had to confess their sins. This was the root of the 'criticism and self-criticism' campaigns of the Stalinist period, and influenced the 'struggle sessions' used later by the Chinese Communist Party, experienced by the Chinese students of Moscow's Communist University of the Toilers of the East.37 Such confrontational methods of interrogation also had much in common with the 'agit-trial' – a form of theatrical propaganda developed in the Red Army. These mass spectacles in which, for instance, soldiers participated in 'trials' of actors playing capitalists and Whites, were to become the basis of the Stalinist show trial.38
^ Stalin, Joseph (1925). The Foundations of Leninism.
^ Stalin, Joseph (1928). Against Vulgarising the Slogan of Self-Criticism.
^ Stalin, J. V. (1975). The Foundations of Leninism. The United States: Foreign Language Press (Reprint by Red Star Publishers). p. 13. Fourthly, self-criticism within the proletarian parties, their education and training on the basis of their own mistakes; for only in this way can genuine cadres and genuine leaders of the Party be trained.
^ "Against Vulgarising the Slogan of Self-Criticism". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2019-01-11.
^ "The Work of the April Joint Plenum of the Central Committee and Central Control Commission". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2020-05-15.
^ Stalin, Joseph. Works. Moscow: Foreign Languages Pub. House, 1952, Vol. 11, p. 32
^ Baroni, Walter S. (2021). Autobiographical Cultures in Post-War Italy Life-Writing, Communism and Feminism. Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 15.
^ Wood, Elizabeth A. (2005). Performing Justice Agitation Trials in Early Soviet Russia. Cornell University Press. p. 196.
^ https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1928/06/26.html ^{[dead link]}
^ "Eleventh Congress Of The R.C.P.(B.)". Marxist Internet Archive.
^ "History of The Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks)". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2019-01-11.
^ Ali, Tariq (1984). The Stalinist Legacy. London: Pelican Publishing. p. 271.
^ "Quotations from Mao Tse Tung — Chapter 27". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2019-01-11.
^ Reddy, G. Ramachandhra (2007). Threats to Indian Republic. APH Publishing. p. 81.
^ Horner, Charles (2015). Rising China and Its Postmodern Fate, Volume II Grandeur and Peril in the Next World Order · Volume 2. Brill. p. 84.
^ Friedmann, John (1973). Retracking America A Theory of Transactive Planning. Anchor Press. p. 237.
^ Kau, Ying-Mau (2017). Revival: The People's Liberation Army and China's Nation-Building (1973). Taylor & Francis.
^ Mao's Road to Power: From the Jinggangshan to the establishment of the Jiangxi Soviets, July 1927-December 1930. M.E. Sharpe. 1992. p. 200.
^ Sullivan, Lawrence R. (2011). "Struggle sessions". Historical Dictionary of the Chinese Communist Party. p. 390.
^ Lu, Xing (2004). "Denunciation rallies". Rhetoric of the Chinese Cultural Revolution: The Impact on Chinese Thought, Culture, and Communication. pp. 140–141.
^ Šebok, Filip (2023). "Mao Zedong". In Kironska, Kristina; Turscanyi, Richard Q. (eds.). Contemporary China: a New Superpower?. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-03-239508-1.
^ Minh, Ho Chi (2007). Down with Colonialism. London: Verso. pp. 93, 147–148.
^ Mehta, Harish C. (2019). People's Diplomacy of Vietnam Soft Power in the Resistance War, 1965-1972. Cambridge Scholars Publisher. pp. 40–1.
^ Bizot, Francois (Vintage,2004). The Gate, pp. 52-54.
^ ^a ^b Fifield, Anna (2015-01-15). "North Korea begins brainwashing children in cult of the Kims as early as kindergarten". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2022-05-12.
^ ^a ^b Rohrlich, Justin (2014-02-26). "Lies and confessions: how some get through North Korea's self-criticism sessions | NK News". NK News - North Korea News. Retrieved 2022-05-12.
^ ^a ^b Weedon, Alan (2019-03-31). "'The ultimate form of social control': A look inside North Korea's rituals of self-criticism". ABC News. Retrieved 2022-05-12.
^ Cha, Victor D. (2013). The Impossible State: North Korea, Past and Future. Internet Archive. New York: Ecco. p. 174. ISBN 978-0-06-199850-8. LCCN 2012009517. OCLC 1244862785.
^ Jay, Martin (1984). Marxism and Totality The Adventures of a Concept from Lukács to Habermas. University of California Press. p. 397.
^ The Weather Underground (2006). Sing a Battle Song. New York: Seven Story Press. pp. 250–251.
^ Smith, J.; Moncourt, Andre (2009). The Red Army Faction: A Documentary History, Vol. 1: Projectiles for the People. PM Press. pp. 94, 99.

[:0-1] Priestland, David (2010). ""Men of Steel"". The Red Flag: A History of Communism. Groove Press. ISBN 9780802145123. Another way of discovering revolutionary commitment can be seen in the academic seminars of Communist universities. Academics were 'worked over', or subjected to aggressive questioning in public meetings; if they were discovered to be in error, they had to confess their sins. This was the root of the 'criticism and self-criticism' campaigns of the Stalinist period, and influenced the 'struggle sessions' used later by the Chinese Communist Party, experienced by the Chinese students of Moscow's Communist University of the Toilers of the East.37 Such confrontational methods of interrogation also had much in common with the 'agit-trial' – a form of theatrical propaganda developed in the Red Army. These mass spectacles in which, for instance, soldiers participated in 'trials' of actors playing capitalists and Whites, were to become the basis of the Stalinist show trial.38

[2] Stalin, Joseph (1925). The Foundations of Leninism.

[3] Stalin, Joseph (1928). Against Vulgarising the Slogan of Self-Criticism.

[4] Stalin, J. V. (1975). The Foundations of Leninism. The United States: Foreign Language Press (Reprint by Red Star Publishers). p. 13. Fourthly, self-criticism within the proletarian parties, their education and training on the basis of their own mistakes; for only in this way can genuine cadres and genuine leaders of the Party be trained.

[5] "Against Vulgarising the Slogan of Self-Criticism". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2019-01-11.

[6] "The Work of the April Joint Plenum of the Central Committee and Central Control Commission". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2020-05-15.

[7] Stalin, Joseph. Works. Moscow: Foreign Languages Pub. House, 1952, Vol. 11, p. 32

[8] Baroni, Walter S. (2021). Autobiographical Cultures in Post-War Italy Life-Writing, Communism and Feminism. Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 15.

[9] Wood, Elizabeth A. (2005). Performing Justice Agitation Trials in Early Soviet Russia. Cornell University Press. p. 196.

[10] ttps://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1928/06/26.html ^{[dead link]}

[11] "Eleventh Congress Of The R.C.P.(B.)". Marxist Internet Archive.

[12] "History of The Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks)". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2019-01-11.

[13] Ali, Tariq (1984). The Stalinist Legacy. London: Pelican Publishing. p. 271.

[14] "Quotations from Mao Tse Tung — Chapter 27". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2019-01-11.

[15] Reddy, G. Ramachandhra (2007). Threats to Indian Republic. APH Publishing. p. 81.

[16] Horner, Charles (2015). Rising China and Its Postmodern Fate, Volume II Grandeur and Peril in the Next World Order · Volume 2. Brill. p. 84.

[17] Friedmann, John (1973). Retracking America A Theory of Transactive Planning. Anchor Press. p. 237.

[18] Kau, Ying-Mau (2017). Revival: The People's Liberation Army and China's Nation-Building (1973). Taylor & Francis.

[19] Mao's Road to Power: From the Jinggangshan to the establishment of the Jiangxi Soviets, July 1927-December 1930. M.E. Sharpe. 1992. p. 200.

[Sullivan_2011-20] Sullivan, Lawrence R. (2011). "Struggle sessions". Historical Dictionary of the Chinese Communist Party. p. 390.

[Lu_2004-21] Lu, Xing (2004). "Denunciation rallies". Rhetoric of the Chinese Cultural Revolution: The Impact on Chinese Thought, Culture, and Communication. pp. 140–141.

[:92-22] Šebok, Filip (2023). "Mao Zedong". In Kironska, Kristina; Turscanyi, Richard Q. (eds.). Contemporary China: a New Superpower?. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-03-239508-1.

[23] Minh, Ho Chi (2007). Down with Colonialism. London: Verso. pp. 93, 147–148.

[24] Mehta, Harish C. (2019). People's Diplomacy of Vietnam Soft Power in the Resistance War, 1965-1972. Cambridge Scholars Publisher. pp. 40–1.

[25] Bizot, Francois (Vintage,2004). The Gate, pp. 52-54.

[:1-26] Fifield, Anna (2015-01-15). "North Korea begins brainwashing children in cult of the Kims as early as kindergarten". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2022-05-12.

[:2-27] Rohrlich, Justin (2014-02-26). "Lies and confessions: how some get through North Korea's self-criticism sessions | NK News". NK News - North Korea News. Retrieved 2022-05-12.

[:3-28] Weedon, Alan (2019-03-31). "'The ultimate form of social control': A look inside North Korea's rituals of self-criticism". ABC News. Retrieved 2022-05-12.

[29] Cha, Victor D. (2013). The Impossible State: North Korea, Past and Future. Internet Archive. New York: Ecco. p. 174. ISBN 978-0-06-199850-8. LCCN 2012009517. OCLC 1244862785.

[30] Jay, Martin (1984). Marxism and Totality The Adventures of a Concept from Lukács to Habermas. University of California Press. p. 397.

[31] The Weather Underground (2006). Sing a Battle Song. New York: Seven Story Press. pp. 250–251.

[32] Smith, J.; Moncourt, Andre (2009). The Red Army Faction: A Documentary History, Vol. 1: Projectiles for the People. PM Press. pp. 94, 99.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]

[20]

[21]

[22]

[23]

[24]

[25]

[26]

[27]

[28]

[29]

[30]

[31]

[32]

Criticism and self-criticism (Marxism–Leninism)

History

Soviet Union

People's Republic of China

Vietnam

Cambodia

North Korea

Outside the Communist Bloc

See also

References

Read other articles:

モレイ (潜水艦)

Eklil Ahmad Hakimi

Swimming at the 2016 Summer Olympics – Men's 1500 metre freestyle

Alençon (stad)

Несс

Фантазм (психоаналіз)

سابونارا

Sijamapolang, Humbang Hasundutan

Daftar Wakil Wali Kota Pekanbaru

Renny Setiowati

Hubert Dilger

احتياطيات النفط في الإمارات العربية المتحدة

List of Alberta provincial highways

Eliminatórias da Copa do Mundo FIFA de 2014 - África (terceira fase)

Traditional music of Korea

Distance sampling

Portable CD player

Coherent microwave scattering

Bandar Udara Internasional Ignacio Agramonte

Vermont Bar Association