On May 26, 2020, Appalachian State discontinued varsity sports including men's soccer due to the financial impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.[1][2] As a result of the men's soccer team being cut, head coach Jason O'Keefe and a soccer executive Michael Hitchcock joined up with a group of local business owners to create the team.[3]
On November 5, 2020, Appalachian FC joined the National Premier Soccer League (NPSL), considered the fourth tier of the United States soccer pyramid and roughly equal to USL League Two.[4] Appalachian FC played their first game on May 1, 2021, ending in a 1–1 draw with Metro Louisville FC.[5] Appalachian FC finished the 2021 season third in their conference and advanced to the Southeast Conference playoffs. They finished the season with a 2–1 loss to Georgia Storm in the semifinals on July 14, 2021.
In just their second season, Appalachian FC finished the 2022 regular season as the #1 seed in the Southeast Conference playoffs. Appalachian FC would ride that momentum through the playoffs, winning the Southeast Conference championship 6-2 against North Alabama Soccer Coalition on July 16, 2022.[6] Appalachian FC would go on to win their 2022 NPSL East Region semifinal matchup 2-1 against the Alexandria Reds before falling to Keystone Conference and eventual National Champion, FC Motown 3-0.[7] Head Coach, Dale Parker, would earn NPSL Coach of the Year honors as a result of the team's 2022 campaign.[8]
As a result of their success in 2022, Appalachian FC earned a berth into the 2023 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup tournament. On March 22, 2023, Appalachian FC would make club history earning their first U.S. Open Cup victory against NC Fusion U-23s. The contest would remain tied through stoppage and extra time before ultimately being decided by penalty kicks.[9] Appalachian FC's U.S. Open Cup run would end in the second round at the hands of USL League One side, Charlotte Independence.[10]