Al-Asma' wa al-Sifat

Al-Asma' wa al-Sifat
Edited by Anas Muhammad Adnān al-Sharafāwi, with commentaries by Muhammad Zahid al-Kawthari, and forward by Muhammad 'Awwamah [ar]
AuthorAl-Bayhaqi
LanguageArabic
SubjectAqidah, Hadith, Kalam
PublisherDar al-Taqwa, Damascus

Al-Asma' wa al-Sifat (Arabic: الأسماء والصفات, romanized: Divine names and attributes), is a major classic of Islamic theology authored by Al-Bayhaqi. It was said such a book had never existed like this before and for this reason the author was considered a pioneer in this field.[1]

Content

Al-Bayhaqi was primarily a student of Hadith rather than a speculative theologian, despite being recognised as an Ash'arite theologian. This made his defence of Ash'arism extremely valuable because he was universally accepted as a prominent authority in Hadith. His 'Book of Names and Attributes' is largely made up of quotations from the Quran, Hadith, and Athar (the statements of the pious predecessors) which provide as evidence for the different names and attributes attributed to God. He demonstrates through textual evidence that the Ash'ari creed is in line with the beliefs of the early Muslims. Despite the book largely being a compilation of narrations. Michel Allard's thorough analysis has demonstrated, his exposition is grounded in a number of rational premises, which elevates the book to the status of a theological work.[2] In that he not only provides transmission but also clarification and elaboration on difficult points of certain narrations he presents.[3]

Al-Bayhaqi, in the Ash'arite tradition, acknowledged the difference between the essential and active attributes, but he primarily guided a middle path between sects who indulge in two extreme methodologies namely those who engage in extreme literalism that liken God with his creation (tashbih) and those that engage in extreme figurativeness by distorting the meaning (tahrif), negating the distinct attributes (ta'til) and rejecting authentic prophetic traditions. To put it another way, the names of God that are duly attested in the sources signify real existing attributes, such as alim (knowing) and ilm (knowledge), but it is inappropriate to perceive them in a literal material sense or in an entirely metaphorical sense. All of this holds true when referring to God using terms like "Hand," "Face," and "Eye." Of the Ash'arites in this non-speculative line, Al-Bayhaqi stands out as the most significant representative.[2][4]

Divine attribute of laughter

In one example of Al-Bayhaqi's massive compilation of anthropomorphic traditions (Al-Asma' wa al-Sifat), he dedicated an entire chapter on ahadith that mention the divine 'Laughter'. Al-Bayhaqi narrates that Al-Bukhari said regarding the hadith, “Allah laughs at two men, one of them kills the other and both of them enter Paradise,” that laughing is interpreted as “mercy” meaning “Allah shows mercy to both of them.”[5] Al-Bayhaqi further expands on this through his mastery of the Arabic language and explains that the laughter means "revealing" and "uncovering" based on the classical Arabic language: "The Bedouins: say "the earth laughs when the plants grow", because the earth reveals the beauty of the plants and uncovers the flowers". According to al-Bayhaqi, God did not literally laugh but revealed his benevolence.[6]

In spite of al-Bayhaqi's textual proof and linguistic support for the interpretation of the divine laughter. Al-Bayhaqi presents a different viewpoint on how the bulk of early Muslims handled the unclear ahadiths (attributes) by doing tafwid (relegating the meaning to Allah). Al-Bayhaqi states:[7]

The ancients (salaf) from our school were inspired by these Hadiths to awaken [in themselves and in their disciples] the ambition to do good deeds and works, and [to contemplate] on God's grace. They were not preoccupied with interpreting God's laughter. [This was] in conformity with their conviction that God does not possess body organs and articulators. It is impossible to describe Him as baring His teeth or opening His mouth.

Reception

Al-Dhahabi said: "Nothing like it has been transmitted."[3]

Ibn al-Subki highly praised this book and said: “I do not know anything that compares to it.”[1]

References

  1. ^ a b Al-Bayhaqi (1999). Allah's Names and Attributes. Vol. 4 of Islamic Doctrines & Beliefs. Translated by Gibril Fouad Haddad. Islamic Supreme Council of America. p. 6. ISBN 9781930409033.
  2. ^ a b Watt, W. Montgomery (8 August 2019). Islamic Philosophy and Theology. Edinburgh University Press. p. 81. ISBN 9781474473477.
  3. ^ a b "Al Asma wa al-Sifat : Arabic". islam786books.com.
  4. ^ Brown, Jonathan (30 September 2007). The Canonization of Al-Bukhārī and Muslim The Formation and Function of the Sunnī Ḥadīth Canon. Brill. pp. 219–220. ISBN 9789047420347.
  5. ^ "The Ta'wil of Imam al-Bukhari on the Hadith of Allah's Dahik ('Laughter'"): A manuscript analysis of its validity". darultahqiq.com.
  6. ^ Al Ghouz, Abdelkader (12 November 2018). Islamic Philosophy from the 12th to the 14th Century. Bonn University Press. p. 449. ISBN 9783847009009.
  7. ^ Classen, Albrecht (22 September 2010). Laughter in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Times - Epistemology of a Fundamental Human Behavior, Its Meaning, and Consequences. De Gruyter. p. 185. ISBN 9783110245486.