Within a small American town on the Mexican border in 1923, a promiscuous, married woman is found dead in her bedroom. Her grieving, jealous and widely disliked husband Bryan Talbot is convicted of her murder and sentenced to hang on purely circumstantial evidence despite his fierce denials. The presiding judge, Hochstadter, departs for a fishing trip, leaving it to the inexperienced Mexican-American judge Ben Morealis Lewis to oversee the execution. Lewis has misgivings about mandatory sentencing and capital punishment in general, as well as about Talbot's guilt.
Talbot unintentionally kills his executioner while trying to avoid being hanged. Before of a replacement hangman arrives, another man confesses to killing Talbot's wife. Judge Lewis must negotiate various personal relationships, provincial attitudes and his faith in justice.
Filming began in May 1966 with six days of shooting on location in New Mexico[4] followed by six weeks of interior filming at the Warner Bros. studios.[5] Most of the New Mexico filming occurred at a historic ranch near the Black Mesa, north of Santa Fe. Approximately 70 local extras were employed as well as more than 50 Indians from the San Ildefonso Pueblo.[4]
Katy Jurado gained 25 pounds for her role and entered a hospital as soon as filming wrapped in order to lose the weight.[6]
Reception
In a contemporary review for The New York Times, critic Howard Thompson wrote: "A genuinely original idea for a drama weighing justice, prejudice and the human conscience is studiously frittered away ... [T]he film itself slips in to a devious, figure-eight treatment, siphoning out the action and even the characterizations."[7]
