The 2004 College Football All-America Team is composed of the following All-American Teams: Associated Press (AP), Football Writers Association of America (FWAA), American Football Coaches Association (AFCA), Walter Camp Football Foundation, The Sporting News, Sports Illustrated, Pro Football Weekly, ESPN, CBS Sports, College Football News, and Rivals.com.

The College Football All-America Team is an honor given annually to the best American college football players at their respective positions. The original usage of the term All-America seems to have been to such a list selected by football pioneer Walter Camp in the 1890s. The NCAA officially recognizes All-Americans selected by the AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, and the WCFF to determine Consensus All-Americans.

Thirteen players were recognized as consensus All-Americans for 2004, 8 of them unanimously. Unanimous selections are followed by an asterisk (*)

• Matt Leinart, Southern California (AP, AFCA, WCFF, ESPN, Rivals)
• Alex Smith, Utah (FWAA, SN, SI, PFW, CBS, CFN, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Jason White, Oklahoma (AP-3)

• Adrian Peterson, Oklahoma (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCFF, SI, PFW, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• J. J. Arrington, California (AP, FWAA, SN, WCFF-2, SI, ESPN, CBS)
• Cedric Benson, Texas (WCFF, SI, ESPN, CFN, Rivals, AP-2)
• Cadillac Williams, Auburn (AFCA, AP-2)
• DeAngelo Williams, Memphis (PFW, AP-3)
• Jamario Thomas, North Texas (CBS, AP-3)
• Reggie Bush, USC (WCFF-2)

• Brian Leonard, Rutgers (PFW)

• Braylon Edwards, Michigan (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCFF, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Taylor Stubblefield, Purdue (AP, FWAA, SN, WCFF, ESPN, CBS, Rivals)
• Mark Clayton, Oklahoma (AFCA, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Roddy White, UAB (PFW, AP-3)
• Dante Ridgeway, Ball State (CFN, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Mike Hass, Oregon State (AP-3)

• Heath Miller, Virginia (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCF, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Alex Smith, Stanford (AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Trey Haverty, Texas Tech (AP-3)

• Jammal Brown, Oklahoma (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCFF, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Alex Barron, Florida State (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCFF, ESPN, CBS, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Elton Brown, Virginia (AP, AFCA, SN, WCFF, SI, ESPN, CBS, Rivals)
• David Baas, Michigan (AP, FWAA, WCFF, CBS)
• Chris Kemoeatu, Utah (FWAA, SI, PFW, CBS, CFN, AP-2)
• Vince Carter, Oklahoma (FWAA, WCFF, CBS, ESPN)
• Michael Muñoz, Tennessee (AP, AFCA, WCFF-2)
• Greg Eslinger, Minnesota (FWAA)
• Sam Mayes, Oklahoma State (SN, AP-3)
• Marcus McNeill, Auburn (SI, CBS, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Marvin Philip, California (SI, AP-2)
• Adam Snyder, Oregon (ESPN)
• D'Brickashaw Ferguson, Virginia (PFW)
• Dan Buenning, Wisconsin (PFW, AP-2)
• Mark Setterstrom, Minnesota (Rivals)
• Wesley Britt, Alabama (CFN, AP-3)
• Daryn Colledge, Boise State (CFN)
• Jason Brown, North Carolina (PFW)
• Sam Baker, Southern California (CBS)
• Jonathan Scott, Texas (AP-2)
• Max Jean-Gilles, Georgia (WCFF-2)
• Logan Mankins, Fresno State (WCFF-2)
• Rob Petitti, Pittsburgh (AP-3)
• Travis Leffew, Louisville (AP-3)

• Ben Wilkerson, LSU (AFCA, SN, AP-3, WCFF-2)

• Erasmus James, Wisconsin, (AP, AFCA, FWAA, WCFF, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• David Pollack, Georgia (AP, AFCA, WCFF, SI, PFW, ESPN, CFN)
• Shaun Cody, Southern California (AP, FWAA, WCFF, SI, ESPN, CBS)
• Marcus Spears, LSU (AP, AFCA, WCFF, CFN)
• Johnathan Goddard, Marshall (FWAA, CBS, CFN, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Dan Cody, Oklahoma (FWAA, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Mathias Kiwanuka, Boston College (AFCA, SN, Rivals, AP-3)
• Ryan Riddle, California (SN, SI, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Mike Patterson, Southern California (SN, SI, Rivals, AP-3)
• Jesse Mahelona, Tennessee (SN)
• Travis Johnson, Florida State (PFW, ESPN, CBS, Rivals, AP-3)
• Luis Castillo, Northwestern (PFW)
• Matt Roth, Iowa (AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Jonathan Babineaux, Iowa (AP-3)

• Derrick Johnson, Texas (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCFF, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Matt Grootegoed, Southern California (AP, AFCA, WCFF)
• A. J. Hawk, Ohio State (AP, SN, WCFF, SI, CBS, Rivals)
• Kevin Burnett, Tennessee (AFCA, AP-2)
• Michael Boley, Southern Mississippi (FWAA, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Lofa Tatupu, Southern California (SI, AP-3)
• Ahmad Brooks, Virginia (SN, PFW, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Channing Crowder, Florida (ESPN)
• Ernie Sims, Florida State (ESPN)
• Chad Greenway, Iowa (PFW)
• Spencer Havner, UCLA (CBS, CFN, WCFF-2)
• Leroy Hill, Clemson (Rivals, AP-3)
• D'Qwell Jackson, Maryland (CFN)
• Barrett Ruud, Nebraska (AP-3)

• Antrel Rolle, Miami (FL) (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCFF, SI, PFW, Rivals)
• Carlos Rogers, Auburn (AP, FWAA, WCFF, SI, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Marlin Jackson, Michigan, (AP, AFCA, SN, FWAA, ESPN, WCFF-2)
• Ernest Shazor, Michigan (AP, FWAA, WCFF, SI, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Thomas Davis Sr., Georgia (AFCA, SN, WCFF, PFW, CFN, Rivals, AP-2)
• Corey Webster, LSU (AFCA, SN, AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Junior Rosegreen, Auburn (SI, CBS, AP-2)
• Mitch Meeuwsen, Oregon State (ESPN, AP-3)
• Eric Green, Virginia Tech (PFW)
• Jim Leonhard, Wisconsin (PFW)
• Morgan Scalley, Utah (CBS, AP-2)
• Adam "Pacman" Jones, West Virginia (CFN)
• Brandon Payne, New Mexico (WCFF-2)
• Jim Leonhard, Wisconsin (WCFF-2)
• Jamaal Brimmer, UNLV (AP-3)
• Charles Gordon, Kansas (AP-3)
• Jason Allen, Tennessee (AP-3)

• Mike Nugent, Ohio State (AP, AFCA, FWAA, SN, WCFF, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals)
• Tyler Jones, Boise State (AP-2, WCFF-2)
• Andrew Wellock, Eastern Michigan (AP-3)

• Brandon Fields, Michigan State (AP, FWAA, WCFF, SI, CBS, CFN)
• Matt Payne, BYU (AFCA, SN, Rivals, AP-2)
• John Torp, Colorado (ESPN)
• Daniel Sepulveda, Baylor (PFW, AP-3, WCFF-2)

• Reggie Bush, Southern California (AP-All-Purpose, AFCA, FWAA, SN-PR, SI-All-Purpose, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals-Utility)
• Devin Hester, Miami (FL) (SN-KR, WCFF)
• Ashlan Davis, Tulsa (SI-KR, PFW-KR, Rivals-KR, WCFF-2)
• Ted Ginn Jr., Ohio State (SI-PR, PFW-PR, Rivals-PR, AP-3)
• Chad Owens, Hawaii (AP-2)

• 2005 All-Atlantic Coast Conference football team
• 2004 All-Big Ten Conference football team
• 2004 All-Big 12 Conference football team
• 2004 All-Pacific-10 Conference football team
• 2004 All-SEC football team