Williams v The Queen

Williams v The Queen
CourtHigh Court of Australia
Full case name Williams v The Queen
Decided26 August 1987
Citation[1986] HCA 88
Case history
Prior actionsHobart, 1986, March 5, 6; Adelaide, 1987, August 26. 26:8:1987 APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Tasmania
Court membership
Judges sittingGibbs CJ, Mason, Wilson, Brennan, and Dawson JJ
Case opinions
Arrest – Arrested person to be taken before a justice as soon as practicable – Delay – Desire of arresting officer to question arrested person.

Williams v The Queen was a decision handed down by the High Court of Australia on 26 August 1987, concerning the common law right to personal liberty.

The applicant, Williams, was indicted before the Supreme Court of Tasmania on 29 charges—15 of burglary and 14 of stealing. At the commencement of the trial, counsel for Williams objected to the admission in evidence of a number of records of interview containing confessions allegedly made to the police by Williams. He argued that Williams had been detained unlawfully, because he ought to have been brought before a judge and formally charged as soon as reasonably practicable after his arrest. Instead, he was detained in police custody for 28 hours, and questioned about his role in a variety of burglaries across northern Tasmania. After a voir dire, the trial judge ruled that the records of interview which related to 26 of the charges should not be admitted in evidence, because they were obtained unlawfully through Williams' extended detention. As a result, the trial proceeded with no evidence being tendered by the prosecution in respect of those 26 charges, and the jury was directed to return a verdict of not guilty. Williams pleaded guilty to the remaining three charges.

The Attorney-General for Tasmania appealed to the Tasmanian Court of Criminal Appeal against the applicant's acquittal on the 26 charges. The Court upheld the appeal, and ordered that Williams must be re-tried on the 26 charges. Williams then appealed to the High Court.

The High Court unanimously (5:0) upheld Williams' appeal, finding that, in the absence of a clear statutory power, the police could not detain Williams for longer than it took to take him before a judge, and could not detain him solely for the purpose of questioning him. The purpose of detention in police custody was purely to take an accused before a judge, once the police were reasonably certain a crime had been committed.

Chief Justice Gibbs said:

The critical question is whether the arrested person was detained longer than was reasonably necessary to enable him to be brought before a justice. If he is detained for the purpose of enabling him to be brought before a justice, the fact that he is questioned, whether about the offence for which he was arrested, or about other offences, will not necessarily mean that there has been a failure to bring him before a justice as quickly as was reasonably practicable. On the other hand, if he is detained, not for that purpose, but solely for the purpose of questioning him, the detention will be unlawful. The line may be a fine one, as it often is when a discretion has to be exercised in sensitive matters.[1]

Justices Mason and Brennan said:

The right to personal liberty is, as Fullagar J described it, "the most elementary and important of all common law rights" (Trobridge v Hardy (1955) 94 CLR 147, at p. 152). Personal liberty was held by Blackstone to be an absolute right vested in the individual by the immutable laws of nature and had never been abridged by the laws of England "without sufficient cause" (Commentaries on the Laws of England (Oxford), Bk.1, pp. 120–121, 130–131)... The right to personal liberty cannot be impaired or taken away without lawful authority and then only to the extent and for the time which the law prescribes.[2]

Justices Wilson and Dawson said:

A person is not to be imprisoned otherwise than upon the authority of a justice or a court except to the extent reasonably necessary to bring him before the justice to be dealt with according to law. That, as we conceive it, it one of the foundations of the common law.[3]

As a result, the decision of the Tasmanian Court of Criminal Appeal was set aside, and the verdict of acquittal on the 26 charges was restored.

There is an onus on a person under Section 34A(1) of the Justices Act 1959 Tasmania, to be brought before a justice as soon as practical once taken into custody for an offence. In the ordinary case of an arrest on suspicion, the arresting officer must have satisfied himself at the time of the arrest that there are reasonable grounds for suspecting the guilt of the person arrested[4] although the grounds of suspicion need not consist of admissible evidence.[5] If the arresting officer believes the information in his possession to be true, if the information reasonably points to the guilt of the arrested person and if the arresting officer thus believes that the arrested person is so likely to be guilty of the offence for which he has been arrested that on general grounds of justice a charge is warranted, he has reasonable and probable cause for commencing a prosecution.

References

  1. ^ Gibbs CJ, at 285.
  2. ^ Mason and Brennan JJ, at 292.
  3. ^ Wilson and Dawson JJ, at 306.
  4. ^ Dumbell v. Roberts (1944) 1 All ER 326, at p 329
  5. ^ Hussien v. Chong Fook Kam (1970) AC 942, at pp 948–949

Read other articles:

SinnersKartu lobiSutradaraKenneth WebbDaniel Pennell (asisten sutradara)ProduserRealart PicturesDitulis olehOwen Davis (sandiwara)PemeranAlice BradyJames L. CraneSinematograferGeorge J. FolseyDistributorRealart PicturesTanggal rilis15 Maret 1920Durasi50 menitNegaraAmerika SerikatBahasaBisu (intertitel Inggris) Cuplikan film Sinners adalah sebuah film drama bisu Amerika Serikat tahun 1920 yang hilang. Film tersebut berdasarkan pada sebuah sandiwara bernama sama karya Owen Davis yang diproduksi...

 

Різдвяна версія логотипу Львова Шопка перед ратушею (2011) Ялинка перед Оперним театром (2011) Різдво Христове у Львові — одне з головних та найшанованіших свят. У місті збереглися автентичні українські традиції його святкування, поруч з якими відбуваються також сучасні �...

 

Arla FoodsJeniskoperasi pertanianDidirikan2000Kantor pusat ÅrhusOrang pentingPeder Tuborgh (CEO)Ove Møberg (Pimpinan)Wilayah pelayananSeluruh DuniaAnggota aktif8 522IndustriPeternakanPendapatan 47.7 Milyar DKK (2007)Pendapatan operasi 1.52 Milyar DKK (2007)Pendapatan net 938 Juta DKK (2007)Karyawan16 559 (2007)Situs webwww.arlafoods.com Arla Foods adalah sebuah koperasi yang berpusat di Århus, Denmark, dan produsen terbesar produk peternakan di Skandinavia. Arla dibentuk sebagai hasil dari...

Artikel ini perlu diwikifikasi agar memenuhi standar kualitas Wikipedia. Anda dapat memberikan bantuan berupa penambahan pranala dalam, atau dengan merapikan tata letak dari artikel ini. Untuk keterangan lebih lanjut, klik [tampil] di bagian kanan. Mengganti markah HTML dengan markah wiki bila dimungkinkan. Tambahkan pranala wiki. Bila dirasa perlu, buatlah pautan ke artikel wiki lainnya dengan cara menambahkan [[ dan ]] pada kata yang bersangkutan (lihat WP:LINK untuk keterangan lebih lanjut...

 

U.S. Army Map ServiceLogo USACE.Aktif1941–68Negara Amerika SerikatAliansi Angkatan Darat Amerika Serikat Army Map Service (AMS) adalah perusahaan kartografi militer Departemen Pertahanan Amerika Serikat dari tahun 1941 hingga 1968, di bawah Korps Insinyur Angkatan Darat Amerika Serikat. Pada 1 September 1968, AMS diubah namanya menjadi U.S. Army Topographic Command (USATC) dan tetap beroperasi sebagai organisasi independen hingga 1 Januari 1972, kemudian digabung menjadi Defense Mapping Age...

 

  لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع عدالة (توضيح). العدالة هي مفهوم تعني عدم الانحياز في محاكمة أي إنسان لأي أمر، وهي رؤية إنسانیة للمحيط الذي يعيش فیه‌ کل فرد شرط أن ینظم هذه‌ الرؤیة قانون وضعي یشارك فی صياغتها الکل بعيدا عن التحکم. والعدالة عكس الظلم والجور والتطرف، أهداف العدالة ال...

Beauty pageant For the regional pageant in French Guiana, also known as Miss Guyane, see Miss French Guiana. Guyana's Miss WorldFormation1966TypeBeauty pageantHeadquartersGeorgetownLocationGuyanaMembership Miss WorldMiss SupranationalOfficial language EnglishLicense HolderNatasha MartindaleWebsite[1] Miss Guyana is the national Beauty pageant in Guyana where the Titleholder/National Winner represents Guyana at the Miss World competition. Guyana first placed at the Miss World competition in 19...

 

1924 film The Back TrailDirected byGeorge MarshallClifford SmithWritten byIsadore BernsteinWalter J. CoburnGeorge HoagProduced byCarl LaemmleStarringJack HoxieEugenia GilbertAl HoxieCinematographyHarry NeumannProductioncompanyUniversal PicturesDistributed byUniversal PicturesRelease dateJune 16, 1924Running time50 minutesCountryUnited StatesLanguagesSilentEnglish intertitles The Back Trail is a 1924 American silent Western film directed by George Marshall and Clifford Smith and starring Jack ...

 

Cet article est une ébauche concernant une localité italienne et le Trentin-Haut-Adige. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?) selon les recommandations des projets correspondants. Ossana Administration Pays Italie Région Trentin-Haut-Adige  Province Trentin   Code postal 38026 Code ISTAT 022131 Code cadastral G173 Préfixe tel. 0463 Démographie Population 819 hab. (1er janvier 2023[1]) Densité 33 hab./km2 Géographie Coordonnées ...

Koordinat: 1°21′0″S 100°34′0″E / 1.35000°S 100.56667°E / -1.35000; 100.56667 PainanIbu kota kabupatenPemandangan Painan dari ketinggianNegara IndonesiaProvinsiSumatera BaratKabupatenPesisir SelatanKecamatanIV JuraiKode area telepon+62 756 Painan adalah sebuah nagari dan kota kecil yang menjadi ibu kota dari kabupaten Pesisir Selatan, Sumatera Barat, Indonesia. Kota ini masuk ke dalam wilayah Kecamatan IV Jurai yang dapat diakses melalui Jalan Raya Lint...

 

Torneo di Wimbledon 1973Doppio maschile Sport Tennis Vincitori Jimmy Connors Ilie Năstase Finalisti John Cooper Neale Fraser Punteggio 3–6, 6–3, 6–4, 8(3)–9, 6–1 Tornei Singolare uomini donne   ragazzi ragazze Doppio uomini donne misto 1972 1974 Voce principale: Torneo di Wimbledon 1973. I detentori del titolo erano Bob Hewitt e Frew McMillan ma hanno deciso di partecipare a un boicottaggio dell'evento rinunciando così a difendere il titolo, 80 tra i giocatori più forti del...

 

This is a dynamic list and may never be able to satisfy particular standards for completeness. You can help by adding missing items with reliable sources.This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: List of largest mosques – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2024) (Learn how and when to re...

The New England Ragtime Ensemble (originally The New England Conservatory Ragtime Ensemble) was a Boston chamber orchestra dedicated to the music of Scott Joplin and other ragtime composers. History Conservatory president Gunther Schuller created the 12-member student ensemble in 1972 for a festival of romantic American music, at which the group performed some of Schuller's own editions of orchestrated versions of Joplin's piano rags. These period arrangements from the collection Standard Hig...

 

Recording studio This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article contains content that is written like an advertisement. Please help improve it by removing promotional content and inappropriate external links, and by adding encyclopedic content written from a neutral point of view. (July 2011) (Learn how and when to remove this message) This article needs additional citations...

 

Cung điện Buckingham (năm 2007) Quang cảnh Cung điện Buckingham trong Lễ kỷ niệm Sinh nhật lần thứ 90 của Nữ hoàng (2016) Điện Buckingham là một dinh thự của Vua (hoặc Nữ vương) Vương quốc Anh ở Luân Đôn, nơi ở chính thức và cũng là nơi làm việc chính của Vương thất Anh.[1] Cung điện này được xây dựng từ năm 1703 cho công tước Buckingham và được ba công viên bao bọc, trong đó có Công ...

2000 film by Gregory Hoblit FrequencyTheatrical release posterDirected byGregory HoblitWritten byToby EmmerichProduced by Gregory Hoblit Hawk Koch Toby Emmerich Bill Carraro Starring Dennis Quaid Jim Caviezel Andre Braugher Elizabeth Mitchell Noah Emmerich CinematographyAlar KiviloEdited byDavid RosenbloomMusic byMichael KamenDistributed byNew Line CinemaRelease date April 28, 2000 (2000-04-28) Running time118 minutesCountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglishBudget$31 million[1 ...

 

Town in New York, United StatesCarmel, New YorkTownTown of CarmelCarmel Hamlet seen from Lake Gleneida to the west SealLocation of Carmel in New York stateCoordinates: 41°23′6″N 73°43′46″W / 41.38500°N 73.72944°W / 41.38500; -73.72944CountryUnited StatesStateNew YorkCountyPutnamArea[1] • Total40.69 sq mi (105.39 km2) • Land35.91 sq mi (93.00 km2) • Water4.79 sq mi (12.40...

 

Small, herbivorous mammals in the order Hyracoidea For the dental device, see Palatal expander. HyraxesTemporal range: Eocene–recent 55.8–0 Ma PreꞒ Ꞓ O S D C P T J K Pg N Rock hyrax (Procavia capensis)Erongo, Namibia Scientific classification Domain: Eukaryota Kingdom: Animalia Phylum: Chordata Class: Mammalia Superorder: Afrotheria Clade: Paenungulatomorpha Grandorder: Paenungulata Order: HyracoideaHuxley, 1869 Subgroups Dendrohyrax Heterohyrax Procavia For extinct genera, see t...

American football player (born 1943) American football player Bob TimberlakeTimberlake (left) with Bump Elliott, 1964No. 18Position:PlacekickerPersonal informationBorn: (1943-10-18) October 18, 1943 (age 80)Middletown, Ohio, U.S.Height:6 ft 4 in (1.93 m)Weight:220 lb (100 kg)Career informationHigh school:Franklin (OH)College:MichiganNFL draft:1965 / Round: 3 / Pick: 33AFL draft:1965 / Round: 13 / Pick: 104(by the Buffalo Bi...

 

Cette page concerne l'année 1364 du calendrier julien. Pour l'année 1364 av. J.-C., voir 1364 av. J.-C. Chronologies 19 mai : couronnement de Charles V et de Jeanne de Bourbon à Reims.Données clés 1361 1362 1363  1364  1365 1366 1367Décennies :1330 1340 1350  1360  1370 1380 1390Siècles :XIIe XIIIe  XIVe  XVe XVIeMillénaires :-Ier Ier  IIe  IIIe Chronologies thématiques Religion (,)   Science () et Santé et médecine ...