When Tomorrow Comes (film)

When Tomorrow Comes
Directed byJohn M. Stahl
Screenplay byDwight Taylor
Story by"A Modern Cinderella"
by James M. Cain
Produced byJohn M. Stahl
Starring
CinematographyJohn J. Mescall
Edited byMilton Carruth
Production
company
Universal Pictures
Distributed byUniversal Pictures
Release date
  • August 11, 1939 (1939-08-11) (United States)
Running time
90 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Budget$1 million[1][2]

When Tomorrow Comes is a 1939 American romantic melodrama film[3] directed by John M. Stahl, and starring Irene Dunne and Charles Boyer. The screenplay concerns a waitress who falls in love with a man who later turns out to be a married concert pianist. Bernard B. Brown won the Academy Award for Best Sound.[4]

A scene in the film where the two protagonists take refuge from a storm in a church was the subject of Cain v. Universal Pictures, a case in which the writer James M. Cain sued Universal Pictures, the scriptwriter and the director for copyright infringement. Judge Leon Rene Yankwich ruled that there was no resemblance between the scenes in the book and the film other than incidental "scènes à faire", or natural similarities due to the situation, establishing an important legal precedent.[5]

Plot

Philip Andre Chagal is a famous concert pianist who visits a restaurant struggling waitress Helen works at. Philip is immediately attracted to her and joins her at a union rally, and discovers Helen's left-wing political opinions when she suggests every union member goes on strike. After the meeting, Philip praises her speech and leadership skills, despite being anti-union himself, and they fall in love.

On a date in Long Island, the couple relax on Philip's boat when the weather turns violent. They disembark and take cover in Philip's summer home, but the storm becomes a hurricane. Helen and Philip kiss, and try to leave for the nearest town, eventually staying overnight in a church. Helen later discovers Philip is married and secretly leaves for the mainland. Philip tries to apologize and make Helen reconsider by introducing her to his wife Madeline. Helen hesitates, and Madeline pulls her aside, revealing she is heartbroken and guilty about a stillbirth she and Philip are still mourning five years later. Despite still being in love with the pianist, Helen ends the relationship.

Cast

Uncredited roles include Frances Robinson, Helen Lynd, Kitty McHugh, Florence Lake, Dorothy Granger, Mary Treen, Harry C. Bradley, Milton Parsons, Addison Richards, George Humbert, Milburn Stone, Frank Darien, Gaylord Pendleton, Mickey Kuhn, and Ed Peil.[6]

Development

Dunne, Boyer and Stahl between filming.
Further information: Love Affair (1939 film)

Charles Boyer and Irene Dunne had previously starred together in Love Affair, Leo McCarey's romantic dramedy distributed by RKO Pictures. It was a surprise hit,[7][8] despite its troubled production, and viewers enjoyed watching Dunne and Boyer's characters fall in love. Hollywood was excited about the newest popular team-up,[9] but Boyer was just announced to star in All This, and Heaven Too and was supposedly prepping for Intermezzo.[Note 1][10] Dunne was waiting for Universal Pictures to find a new project for her because she "owed" them a movie, and might have been the cause of Boyer abandoning his new films just as Universal revealed they were developing a new film that might be a contender for everyone's new favorite couple.[9] Dwight Taylor wrote an adaptation of A Modern Cinderella, an unpublished story James M. Cain had sold to Universal in November the year before,[5] but had rewritten the story in a style that could fit the Dunne-Boyer mold.[10] Boyer noticed his character shared allusions to Love Affair's Michel Marnet and only accepted the role if he would receive the same pay (estimated $100,000) for his appearance.[10]

Filming took place in spring and was more relaxed than the Love Affair set,[9] but Stahl was said to have lost 19 pounds (1.4 st) from the stress of retakes.[6]

After the movie's release, Photoplay magazine's October issue featured two essays written by Boyer and Dunne about each other, in the style of a parlor game where a player who briefly left the room guesses the secret noun other contestants chose by asking questions like "If I were that person, what kind of car would I be?"[11] The editor explained: "Surely, working together as they do and have done, and being analytical, intelligent people, each would give a clear-limned portrait of the other; unbiased, colorful, exciting."[11] Boyer's essay, "Irene: As Seen By Charles Boyer", described Dunne in prose,[12] while Dunne's essay, "Charles: As Seen By Irene Dunne", described Boyer under topical subtitles,[13] but Wes D. Gehring pointed out both essays' frequent references to fine art, as well as Dunne personifying Boyer through French impressionism.[14]

Controversy

After the film's release, James M. Cain sued Universal Pictures, Taylor and Stahl for copyright infringement, arguing Taylor's deviation from A Modern Cinderella had sneaked in the church scene from his 1937 story Serenade, a story previously called "unfilmable".[10][5] Taylor admitted he read Serenade during the time of its release but denied theft, whereas Stahl denied knowing of the story's existence. Cain lost the case in December 14, and Judge Leon Yankwich ruled there was no resemblance between the book’s scenes and those in the film.[5] Cain v. Universal Pictures Co. is noted as the first case in American law to use the scènes à faire doctrine.

Reception

The movie was Universal's most successful film of 1939.[9] Audiences appreciated seeing another film with the Boyer and Dunne pairing so soon after the first,[6] but critical reaction was mixed to negative, seemingly not blaming the actors for their disdain. Frank S. Nugent wrote, "Boyer, with the charm that has made him one of our few authentic Matinée idols, and Miss Dunne, always a pleasant and sincere performer, are unequal to the task of bringing life and conviction to James Cain's made-to-order script."[15] Philip Hartung called the ending "silly", but praised Barbara O'Neill for "doing an excellent piece of acting as the deranged wife."[16] Franz Hoellering wrote, "It is a confused Charles Boyer-Irene Dunne vehicle which makes one wish to see Boyer again in an important picture and Irene Dunne as the brilliant comedienne she is."[17] Time magazine bluntly wrote: "Cinemaddicts [sic] will not find it notable for novelty."[18]

Some critical reception showed optimism. "It carries a hefty appeal to women [but] also provides strong entertainment for general audiences," Variety wrote, "Miss Dunne and Boyer are ideally teamed to provide a sincere and understanding romance, despite the obstacles presented for a happy conclusion."[19] Daily Variety wrote, "It is the kind of love story, deep and rich and passionate, which John M. Stahl does better than any other producer-director in the business."[20] The Hollywood Reporter said, "It is a thoughtful, painstaking film in its execution and will undoubtedly make its appeal to feminine sentimentality. But the opposite sex, too, will react to the gentle tug of its poignancy."[21] Digest attempted—"Give John Stahl a triangle to play with, give him Irene Dunne and Charles Boyer for the sympathetic points of that triangle, and the result should spell money"—but then added: "It's just too bad that the writer, or writers, couldn't make up their minds what story they were telling."[22]

Expected comparisons to Love Affair also followed. The Kansas City Times wrote, "[When Tomorrow Comes] does not have as much comedy in it as when Miss Dunne and Mr. Boyer presented last season when they co-starred in Love Affair."[23] "There is something missing in When Tomorrow Comes[;] There isn't the sparkling wit of Love Affair," said The Brooklyn Daily Eagle. "It is the usual Hollywood Cinderella touch. And Charles Boyer and Irene Dunne, the leads, don't seem to miss it at all. [I]ndeed, [Stahl] has woven together the elements for a romance that is as near to actuality and as far from affection as that of the Love Affair starring effort of Boyer and Miss Dunne."[24]

Legacy

Although not an official remake, 1957's Interlude, directed by Douglas Sirk, was also based on Cain's story.[Note 2] It starred June Allyson and Rossano Brazzi.[26]

Notes

  1. ^ Boyer would not star or appear in Intermezzo, but All This, and Heaven Too would not be released until July the following year.
  2. ^ Sirk cited Serenade as the title of his inspiration, but critic Tom Ryan argued both movies were actually based on Cain's The Root of His Evil.[25]

References

  1. ^ "1939 Hollywood Toppers". Variety. January 3, 1940. p. 28.
  2. ^ Dick, Bernard K. (2015). City of Dreams: The Making and Remaking of Universal Pictures. University Press of Kentucky. p. 116. ISBN 9780813158891.
  3. ^ Schatz, Thomas (1981). Hollywood Genres: Formulas, Filmmaking, and the Studio System. New York: Random House. p. 222. ISBN 0-394-32255-X.
  4. ^ "The 12th Academy Awards (1940) Nominees and Winners". oscars.org. Retrieved August 11, 2011.
  5. ^ a b c d Yankwich, Leon Rene (December 14, 1942). "CAIN v. UNIVERSAL PICTURES CO., Inc., et al". District Court, S. D. California, Central Division. Retrieved June 20, 2012.
  6. ^ a b c Schultz, Margie (1991). Irene Dunne: A Bio-bibliography. New York: Greenwood Press. pp. 95–97. ISBN 9780313273995.
  7. ^ "RADIO'S "LOVE AFFAIR" HITS AT BOX OFFICE; PARAMOUNT'S "MIDNIGHT" IN SECOND SPOT". Box Office Digest. Vol. 9, no. 9. April 3, 1939. p. 5.
  8. ^ Lasky, Betty (1984). RKO: The Biggest Little Major of Them All. Englewood Cliffs, N.J. p. 155. ISBN 9780137814510.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  9. ^ a b c d Swindell (1983), p. 147.
  10. ^ a b c d Swindell (1983), p. 146.
  11. ^ a b [Photoplay essays]. Vol. 53. October 1939. pp. 24–25, 87.
  12. ^ Boyer, Charles (October 1939). "Irene: As Seen by Charles Boyer". Photoplay (Interview). Vol. 53, no. 10. Interviewed by Photoplay staff. pp. 25, 87. Suppose we imagine a gracious house, designed by a master architect. It would sit atop a hill, and it would be beautifully furnished. Of course, the best room would be the music room, a cool place with great windows opening on a garden. Great music, and the best of good swing, and things by Gershwin would sound there always. The acoustics would be perfect. Guests in this house would be relaxed and happy but they would have to mind their manners. Irene Dunne is like that.
  13. ^ Dunne, Irene (October 1939). "Charles: As Seen by Irene Dunne". Photoplay (Interview). Vol. 53, no. 10. Interviewed by Photoplay staff. pp. 24, 87. Drink? Coffee Royal, laced with cognac. Cointreau, brandy and rum, in equal parts—the smoothest of cocktails [...] Appendum [sic]: You see, I judge Charles Boyer as a man of charm and intelligence and temperament
  14. ^ Gehring (2006), p. 104.
  15. ^ Nugent, Frank S. (August 17, 1939). "[When Tomorrow Comes review]". The New York Times. p. 16.
  16. ^ Hartung, Philip (September 1, 1939). "[When Tomorrow Comes review]". Commonweal. p. 439.
  17. ^ Hoellering, Franz (August 19, 1939). "[When Tomorrow Comes review]". Nation. p. 205.
  18. ^ "[When Tomorrow Comes review]". TIME. August 21, 1939. p. 41.
  19. ^ "Films Reviews: When Tomorrow Comes". Variety. August 16, 1939. p. 14.
  20. ^ "Film Previews: When Tomorrow Comes". Daily Variety. August 11, 1939. p. 3.
  21. ^ "[When Tomorrow Comes review]". The Hollywood Reporter. August 11, 1939. p. 3.
  22. ^ "[When Tomorrow Comes review]". Digest. August 16, 1939. p. 10.
  23. ^ "What's What in the Movies: A Big Week As Women Fans Promised in Coming Movies". The Kansas City Times. September 28, 1939. p. 6 – via Newspapers.com.
  24. ^ "Fantasies Omitted". The Brooklyn Daily Eagle. September 21, 1939. p. 19.
  25. ^ Ryan, Tom (March 19, 2014). "Film Adaptions analysis • Senses of Cinema". Senses of Cinema. Retrieved July 20, 2020.
  26. ^ Brody, Richard (September 18, 2014). "John M. Stahl's "When Tomorrow Comes"". The New Yorker. Retrieved July 20, 2020.

Bibliography

  • Gehring, Wes D. (2006). Irene Dunne: First Lady of Hollywood. Scarecrow Press. ISBN 978-0810858640.
  • Swindell, Larry (1983). Charles Boyer: The Reluctant Lover. Doubleday. ISBN 0385170521.
Wikimedia Commons has media related to When Tomorrow Comes.

Read other articles:

Alesheim

Alesheim. Alesheim adalah kota yang terletak di distrik Weißenburg-Gunzenhausen di Bavaria, Jerman. Kota Alesheim memiliki luas sebesar 20.45 km² . Alesheim pada tahun 2006, memiliki penduduk sebanyak 1.020 jiwa. lbsKota dan kotamadya di Weissenburg-GunzenhausenAbsberg | Alesheim | Bergen | Burgsalach | Dittenheim | Ellingen | Ettenstatt | Gnotzheim | Gunzenhausen | Haundorf | Heidenheim | Höttingen | Langenaltheim | Mar...

 

Ked-Air

Ked-Air merupakan sebuah maskapai penerbangan yang berbasis di Alor Star, Kedah, Malaysia. Maskapai ini mengoperasikan penerbangan domestik.[1] Sejarah Maskapai penerbangan ini diresmikan pada Januari 2004 dan memulai operasinya pada 20 Januari 2004.[1] Maskapai ini juga berusaha membeli maskapai penerbangan tua milik Malaysia, Pelangi Air.[2] Penerbangan Ked-Air mengoperasikan penerbangan antara Alor Star dan Medan, Indonesia.[1] Bagaimanapun, pada tahun 2006,...

 

Mei Nagano

Mei NaganoNama asal永野 芽郁Lahir24 September 1999 (umur 24)Tokyo, JepangPekerjaanAktris, PeragawatiTahun aktif2009–sekarangAgenStardust PromotionSitus webProfil Mei Nagano (永野 芽郁code: ja is deprecated , Nagano Mei, kelahiran 24 September 1999 di Tokyo, Jepang) adalah seorang aktris dan model Jepang. Drama televisi Yae no Sakura (NHK, 2013), sebagai Tokiwa Yamakawa[1] Itsuka Kono Koi o Omoidashite Kitto Naite Shimau (Fuji TV, 2016), sebagai Remi Funakawa&...

Bronze (color)

Metallic brown resembling the alloy bronze This article is about the colour. For other uses, see Bronze (disambiguation). Bronze      Color coordinatesHex triplet#CD7F32sRGBB (r, g, b)(205, 127, 50)HSV (h, s, v)(30°, 76%, 80%)CIELChuv (L, C, h)(60, 81, 39°)Source[1]/Maerz and Paul[1]ISCC–NBS descriptorStrong orangeB: Normalized to [0–255] (byte) Bronze statue of the Roman Emperor Augustus Bronze is a metallic brown colour which resembles the metal alloy bronze...

 

Pishva

City in Tehran province, Iran For the administrative divisions, see Pishva County and Pishva Rural District. City in Tehran, IranPishva Persian: پيشواCityThe city of PishvaPishvaCoordinates: 35°18′24″N 51°43′14″E / 35.30667°N 51.72056°E / 35.30667; 51.72056[1]CountryIranProvinceTehranCountyPishvaDistrictCentralElevation937 m (3,074 ft)Population (2016)[2] • Total59,184Time zoneUTC+3:30 (IRST) Historical Popula...

 

Jari Litmanen

Jari Litmanen Informasi pribadiNama lengkap Jari Olavi LitmanenTanggal lahir 20 Februari 1971 (umur 53)Tempat lahir Hollola, FinlandiaTinggi 1,82 m (5 ft 11+1⁄2 in)Posisi bermain StrikerAttacking midfielder Second strikerInformasi klubKlub saat ini FC LahtiNomor 10Karier junior1977–1987 ReipasKarier senior*Tahun Tim Tampil (Gol) 1987–1990 1991 1992 1992–1999 1999–2001 2001–2002 2002–2004 2004 2005 2005–2007 2008 2008- Reipas HJK MyPa Ajax FC Barcelona ...

The Easiest Way

1931 film Not to be confused with The Easiest Way (1917 film). The Easiest WayOpening titlesDirected byJack ConwayWritten byEdith EllisBased onThe Easiest Way1909 playby Eugene WalterProduced byHunt StrombergStarringConstance BennettAdolphe MenjouRobert MontgomeryAnita Page Marjorie RambeauClark GableCinematographyJohn J. MescallEdited byFrank SullivanDistributed byMetro-Goldwyn-MayerRelease date February 7, 1931 (1931-02-07) Running time73 minutesCountryUnited StatesLanguageEn...

 

Gubernur Akademi Militer

Gubernur Akademi MiliterLambang Akademi MiliterPetahanaMayjen. TNI R. Sidharta Wisnu Graha, S.E.sejak 17 Juli 2023TNI Angkatan DaratKantorMarkas Akademi Militer, Kota Magelang, Jawa TengahDibentuk31 Oktober 1945Pejabat pertamaMayjen TNI SoewardiSitus webwww.akmil.ac.id Gubernur Akademi Militer adalah pimpinan tertinggi Akademi Militer (Akmil), sekolah pendidikan TNI Angkatan Darat di Magelang, Jawa Tengah, Indonesia. Akademi Militer sebagai Badan Pelaksana Pusat di tingkat mabes TNI-AD, ...

 

Jonne Aaron

Si ce bandeau n'est plus pertinent, retirez-le. Cliquez ici pour en savoir plus. Cet article ne cite pas suffisamment ses sources (septembre 2015). Si vous disposez d'ouvrages ou d'articles de référence ou si vous connaissez des sites web de qualité traitant du thème abordé ici, merci de compléter l'article en donnant les références utiles à sa vérifiabilité et en les liant à la section « Notes et références ». En pratique : Quelles sources sont attendues ?...

Cormicy

Cormicycomune Cormicy – Veduta LocalizzazioneStato Francia RegioneGrand Est Dipartimento Marna ArrondissementReims CantoneBourgogne TerritorioCoordinate49°22′N 3°54′E / 49.366667°N 3.9°E49.366667; 3.9 (Cormicy)Coordinate: 49°22′N 3°54′E / 49.366667°N 3.9°E49.366667; 3.9 (Cormicy) Superficie24,03 km² Abitanti1 445[1] (2009) Densità60,13 ab./km² Altre informazioniCod. postale51220 Fuso orarioUTC+1 Codice INSEE5...

 

Romolo

Disambiguazione – Se stai cercando altri significati, vedi Romolo (disambigua). RomoloRomolo e suo fratello Remo da un fregio del XV secolo, Certosa di Pavia1º Re di RomaIn carica753 a.C.[1] –717 a.C.[2] Predecessorecarica creata SuccessoreNuma Pompilio[3][4] NascitaAlba Longa, 24 marzo 771 a.C.[1] MorteRoma, 5[5] o 7 luglio 716 a.C.[2] Casa realedi Alba Longa DinastiaRe latino-sabini PadreMarte[1][6][...

 

Дело «Запасного правотроцкистского центра контрреволюционной националистической организации»

Дело «Запасного правотроцкистского центра контрреволюционной националистической организации» (ЗПЦКНО) (азерб. “Sağ-trotskiçi ehtiyat mərkəzinin əksinqilabi milliyətçi təşkilatı” rəhbərlərinin işi, 1938-1956) — сфабрикованное высшим руководством Азербайджанской ССР политическое дело, по которому было...

2021 NCAA Division I FCS football season

American college football season For the FCS season contested during fall 2020/spring 2021, see 2020–21 NCAA Division I FCS football season. 2021 NCAA Division I FCS seasonRegular seasonNumber of teams128DurationAugust 28 – November 27Payton AwardEric Barriere, QB, Eastern WashingtonBuchanan AwardIsaiah Land, DL, Florida A&MPlayoffDurationNovember 27 – December 18Championship dateJanuary 8, 2022Championship siteToyota Stadium, Frisco, TexasChampionNorth Dakota StateNCAA Division I F...

 

Новотитаровское сельское поселение

Сельское поселение России (МО 2-го уровня)Новотитаровское сельское поселение Флаг[d] Герб 45°14′09″ с. ш. 38°58′16″ в. д.HGЯO Страна  Россия Субъект РФ Краснодарский край Район Динской Включает 4 населённых пункта Адм. центр Новотитаровская Глава сельского пос�...

 

Laut Jawa

Laut JawaLokasi Laut JawaLaut JawaLetakPaparan SundaKoordinat5°16′00″S 111°43′52″E / 5.26667°S 111.73111°E / -5.26667; 111.73111Jenis perairanLautTerletak di negaraIndonesiaPanjang maksimal1.600 kilometer (990 mi)Lebar maksimal380 kilometer (240 mi)Area permukaan320.000 kilometer persegi (120.000 sq mi)Kedalaman rata-rata46 meter (151 ft)Suhu tertinggi31 °C (88 °F)Suhu terendah27 °C (81 °F)KepulauanSunda besa...

Dacre Montgomery

Dacre MontgomeryMontgomery di San Diego Comic-Con 2017LahirDacre Montgomery22 November 1994 (umur 29)Perth, Australia BaratAlmamaterUniversitas Edith Cowan (BA)PekerjaanAktorTahun aktif2011–sekarang Dacre Montgomery (lahir 22 November 1994) adalah seorang aktor asal Australia. Dia terkenal karena perannya sebagai Jason Scott, Red Ranger di film Power Rangers;[1] dan Billy Hargrove di musim kedua Stranger Things. Kehidupan Awal Montgomery lahir di Perth, Australia Barat da...

 

Potassium formate

Potassium formate[1] Names Preferred IUPAC name Potassium formate Identifiers CAS Number 590-29-4 Y 3D model (JSmol) Interactive image ChemSpider 11054 N ECHA InfoCard 100.008.799 PubChem CID 11539 UNII 25I90B156L Y CompTox Dashboard (EPA) DTXSID6029626 InChI InChI=1S/CH2O2.K/c2-1-3;/h1H,(H,2,3);/q;+1/p-1 NKey: WFIZEGIEIOHZCP-UHFFFAOYSA-M NInChI=1/CH2O2.K/c2-1-3;/h1H,(H,2,3);/q;+1/p-1Key: WFIZEGIEIOHZCP-REWHXWOFAK SMILES C(=O)[O-].[K+] Properties Ch...

 

Bioenergy

Renewable energy made from biomass This article is about technology aspects to produce a type of renewable energy. For production of biomass for bioenergy generation, see biomass (energy). This article may be unbalanced toward certain viewpoints. Please improve the article by adding information on neglected viewpoints, or discuss the issue on the talk page. (May 2023) Sugarcane plantation to produce ethanol in BrazilA CHP power station using wood to supply 30,000 households in France Bioenerg...

Monte Bondone

Monte BondoneLa cima Palon del monte Bondone visto da GiovoStato Italia Regione Trentino-Alto Adige Provincia Trento ComuneTrento, Vallelaghi, Madruzzo, Cavedine, Garniga, Cimone Altezza2 180 m s.l.m. Prominenza1 679 m Isolamento16,48 km CatenaAlpi Coordinate45°59′17″N 11°01′51″E45°59′17″N, 11°01′51″E Altri nomi e significatiMontagna di TrentoBondon (dialetto locale) Mappa di localizzazioneMonte Bondone Dati SOIUSAGrande ParteAlpi Or...

 

الأشمونين

الأشمونين  -  قرية مصرية -    تقسيم إداري البلد  مصر[1] التقسيم الأعلى مركز ملوي  المسؤولون خصائص جغرافية إحداثيات 27°46′28″N 30°48′04″E / 27.774438888889°N 30.801111111111°E / 27.774438888889; 30.801111111111   الارتفاع 44 متر[2]  معلومات أخرى التوقيت ت ع م+02:00  الرمز...