"The Hanging Tree" received mostly positive reviews from music critics with some praising Lawrence's vocals, its elements of Appalachian music, and its effectiveness as a murder ballad. Commercially, the song garnered success on charts internationally, peaking atop record charts in several markets, including Austria, Hungary, and Germany. It debuted and peaked at number 12 on the Billboard Hot 100 and at number 20 in the United Kingdom's Official Charts Company. "The Hanging Tree" was eventually certified platinum in Canada and Germany as well as double platinum in the United States. To promote the song, a remix by producer Michael Gazzo was released.
Schultz revealed that director Francis Lawrence instructed him to create a melody that could be "hummed or sung by one person" or "by a thousand people"; he also informed Schultz not to make the song "overly complicated".[2] To Schultz, the song felt like an innocent nursery rhyme despite its dark undertones. Schultz and Fraites then submitted a "couple melodies in about a day and a half or two days" during the month of September 2013.[2] Lawrence later contacted both Schultz and Fraites via text message that the melody was chosen for the film, saying, "It worked out great in the movie. We just shot the scene. [Jennifer] was really nervous but it went great."[2]
The lead protagonist Katniss Everdeen performs the song in the film, which is also heard over the closing credits. Jennifer Lawrence revealed on Late Night with David Letterman that she was anxious about singing the song in the film, citing her fear of "singing in front of other people" as her reason; she also disclosed that she cried on set when filming the scene.[3] According to Francis, Jennifer Lawrence suggested that New Zealand singer Lorde could instead provide vocals and she could lip sync; Francis rejected this idea.[3][4] In preparation, Francis sent Jennifer Lawrence to a vocal coach, in an effort to provide the actress with confidence;[5] she recorded the scene in front of 150 crew members.[4]
"The Hanging Tree" was released as part of the film's score album on November 24, 2014;[6] it is accompanied by a B-side titled "The Mockingjay".[7] The track does not appear on the original release of the film's soundtrack. However, due to the success of "The Hanging Tree", it was later added to the digital extended edition of the soundtrack as the 15th track.[6] On 9 December 2014, "The Hanging Tree" was released as the second single from the soundtrack.[8]Michael Gazzo released a remix of the song—titled "The Hanging Tree" (Rebel remix)—on 15 December 2014.[9] In an interview with Yahoo! Music, Gazzo commented that despite the track's dark tonality, he envisioned the song "uplifting an entire group of people to rise up. To unite."[10]
Music critics compared "The Hanging Tree" to "Strange Fruit" by Billie Holiday (pictured left) (top for mobile phones) and the writings of Frederick Douglass (pictured right) (bottom for mobile phones).
In the novel's context, it is a song that Katniss learned from her father, and is used as a battle cry.[22][23] Katniss's mother prohibited the use of the song in her home after hearing Katniss and her sister Primrose chant the song while making necklaces.[5]Peeta Mellark, Katniss's love interest, associates "The Hanging Tree" with her father; Peeta heard her father sing the song once when he traded goods at Peeta's parents' bakery.[24]
According to Haymitch Abernathy, the song was the first memory Peeta associated with Katniss that did not trigger a "mental breakdown" after the Capitol propagandized him.[24] After realizing this, Katniss uses "The Hanging Tree" as a remedy for Peeta's "Capitol-implanted hatred". She reminds herself of the song once more after Peeta tells her to kill him, in an effort to prevent himself from harming members of their rescue team due to how the Capitol "reprogrammed" him.[24] In the adaption, however, Plutarch Heavensbee uses the film of Katniss singing as anti-Capitol propaganda and changes the lyrics from "necklace of rope" to "necklace of hope" to reduce some of the macabre undertones in the original song. Plutarch then uses the song as a rebel anthem.[16]
In the prequel novel The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes (2020), the song is revealed to have been penned by Lucy Gray Baird, the first Hunger Games victor from District 12.[25] According to Zegler, who plays Lucy Gray, the character is "a performer forced to fight" in contrast to Katniss, "a fighter forced to perform". Lucy Gray witnesses the execution of Arlo Chance at a hanging tree after he is accused of killing two Peacekeepers and a coal mine boss. His lover is arrested for protesting his innocence.[13][21]
Coriolanus Snow hears Lucy Gray singing "The Hanging Tree" with a guitar as they reunite in a field in District 12.[13] Their romance mirrors the song, as they meet up at the hanging tree to flee Panem. Lucy Gray is aware Snow is responsible for two deaths but runs away from him after realizing he is responsible for a third. This parallels the description of Chance's execution: "they strung up a man they say murdered three". She sings the song as she runs, leading mockingjays to repeat it.[21]
Reception and promotion
"The Hanging Tree" received positive reviews from music critics, with several critics complimenting its effectiveness as a murder ballad. Jeff Baker, writing for OregonLive.com called the song the best part of the film. Baker complimented Lawrence for turning the track into a "murder ballad that calls back to her Kentucky roots".[26]Stereogum writer Gabriella Tully Claymore called it a "creepy-as-hell take on classic Americana murder ballads".[27] Stephanie Merry from The Washington Post praised Lawrence's vocal delivery, commenting that her "raspy voice [matches] the dark narrative and Appalachian style of the music".[19]
"The Hanging Tree" debuted at number 12 on the US Billboard Hot 100 for the week of 13 December 2014 and debuted outside the 50 position (2.1 million U.S. streams) on Streaming Songs, charting at number two (200,000 downloads sold) on Digital Songs and received eight spins on U.S. radio. "The Hanging Tree" became the highest-charting song from The Hunger Games franchise on the chart, surpassing "Eyes Open" by Taylor Swift, which peaked at number 19.[28] Lawrence became one of 13 Academy Award-winning recipients to chart on the Hot 100;[28] the last female Academy Award winner to achieve this feat was Cher with "Believe" (1998).[29] The song peaked at number one in Austria, Germany[30] and Hungary;[31] it peaked in the top five in Australia.[32] It was certified platinum by Music Canada (MC) and double platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA).[33][34]
"The Hanging Tree" was performed live for the first time at "Hollywood in Vienna", a gala honoring excellence in music.[35] James Newton Howard performed with Edita Malovčić as a substitute for Lawrence;[35] it was conducted by Keith Lockhart of the Boston Pops Orchestra.[36] Howard was reportedly in tears after the performance and rose to his feet to give a standing ovation.[37] To promote the song, Howard embarked on a European tour called "3 Decades of Music for Hollywood"[38] and held a contest in search for a female vocalist, one for each tour date, that would sing Lawrence's verses.[39]
* Sales figures based on certification alone. ^ Shipments figures based on certification alone. ‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.
^The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes (Music From & Inspired By) (Media notes). Dave Cobb. Geffen Records. 2023.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^"ČNS IFPI" (in Slovak). Hitparáda – Singles Digital Top 100 Oficiálna. IFPI Czech Republic. Note: Select SINGLES DIGITAL - TOP 100 and insert 201450 into search. Retrieved 16 December 2014.