Semantic externalism

In the philosophy of language, semantic externalism (the opposite of semantic internalism) is the view that the meaning of a term is determined, in whole or in part, by factors external to the speaker. According to an externalist position, one can claim without contradiction that two speakers could be in exactly the same brain state at the time of an utterance, and yet mean different things by that utterance -- that is, at the least, that their terms could pick out different referents.

Overview

The philosopher Hilary Putnam (1975/1985) proposed this position and summarized it with the statement "meanings just ain't in the head!"

Although he did not use the term "externalism" at the time, Putnam is thought to have pioneered semantic externalism in his 1975 paper "The Meaning of 'Meaning'". His Twin Earth thought experiment, from the aforementioned paper, is widely cited to illustrate his argument for externalism to this day. Alongside Putnam, credit also goes to Saul Kripke and Tyler Burge, both of whom attacked internalism for independent reasons, providing a foundation on which Putnam's attacks rested.

Externalism is generally thought to be a necessary consequence of any causal theory of reference; since the causal history of a term is not internal, the involvement of that history in determining the term's referent is enough to satisfy the externalist thesis. However, Putnam and many subsequent externalists have maintained that not only reference, but sense as well is determined, at least in part, by external factors (see sense and reference).

While it is common to shorten "semantic externalism" to "externalism" within the context of the debate, one must be careful in doing so, as there are several distinct debates in philosophy that employ the terms "externalism" and "internalism".

Arguments for externalism

Putnam presented a variety of arguments for the externalist position, the most famous being those that concerned Twin Earth. Subsequent philosophers have produced other, related thought experiments, most notably Donald Davidson's swamp man experiment. However, there have been numerous arguments for externalism that do not involve science-fiction scenarios.

Putnam pointed out, for instance, that he has no knowledge that could distinguish elm trees from beech trees. He has precisely the same concept of one as of the other: "a deciduous tree growing in North America". Yet when Putnam makes a statement containing the word "elm", we take him to be referring specifically to elms. If he makes a claim about a property of elm trees, it will be considered true or false, depending upon whether that property applies to those trees which are in fact elms. There is nothing "in the head" that could fix his reference thus; rather, he concluded, his linguistic community, containing some speakers who did know the difference between the two trees, ensured that when he said "elm", he referred to elms. Putnam refers to this feature of language as "the division of linguistic labor".

See also

References

  • Putnam, H. (1975/1985). "The Meaning of 'Meaning'". In Philosophical Papers, Vol. 2: Mind, Language and Reality. Cambridge University Press.

Read other articles:

Sampanahan

Peta Zuid en Ooster Afdeeling van Borneo, Lansdchap Sampanahan berbatasan di utara dengan Lansdchap Cengal-Manunggul dan di selatan dengan Landschap Bangkalaan Daerah Kepangeranan Sampanahan (sebelum 1841)[1][2][3]) atau Kerajaan Kepangeranan Sampanahan (1841-1845),[4] setelah bergabung dengan Hindia Belanda sejak 10 April 1845 disebut Landschap Sampanahan[5] adalah suatu wilayah pemerintahan swapraja di bawah Hindia Belanda sejak tahun 1841 yang dikepa...

 

 

Banjaran, Kota, Kediri

BanjaranKelurahanNegara IndonesiaProvinsiJawa TimurKotaKediriKecamatanKotaKode Kemendagri35.71.02.1012 Kode BPS3571020012 Luas... km²Jumlah penduduk... jiwaKepadatan... jiwa/km² Untuk tempat lain yang bernama sama, lihat Banjaran. Banjaran adalah sebuah kelurahan di wilayah Kecamatan Kota, Kota Kediri, Provinsi Jawa Timur. Kelurahan Banjaran terdiri dari 49 Rukun Tetangga (RT), 10 Rukun Warga (RW). Kelurahan Banjaran memiliki banyak potensi yang bisa dikembangkan dan memberikan dampak ...

 

 

Marconi Company

Halaman ini berisi artikel tentang sejarah Marconi Company (1897–2006). Untuk sejarah perusahaan induknya (1886–2006), lihat General Electric Company plc. Untuk perusahaan yang didirikan pada tahun 1999 sebagai penerus GEC, lihat Marconi plc. Wireless Telegraph & Signal Company dan Marconi's Wireless Telegraph Company dialihkan ke halaman ini. Untuk bisnis lain yang bernama Marconi, lihat Marconi. Artikel ini sudah memiliki referensi, tetapi tidak disertai kutipan yang cukup. Anda dap...

Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1991

Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1991Kompilasi karya Various ArtistDirilis1991Direkam?GenrePopDurasi?LabelFlower SoundSeries Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1990 (1990)'Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1990'1990 Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1991 (1991) Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1992 (1992)'Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1992'1992 Festival Lagu Populer Indonesia 1991 adalah Album kompilasi yang dirilis pada tahun 1991. Album ini menjadi album terakhir dari penyelenggaraan Festival ...

 

 

Синелобый амазон

Синелобый амазон Научная классификация Домен:ЭукариотыЦарство:ЖивотныеПодцарство:ЭуметазоиБез ранга:Двусторонне-симметричныеБез ранга:ВторичноротыеТип:ХордовыеПодтип:ПозвоночныеИнфратип:ЧелюстноротыеНадкласс:ЧетвероногиеКлада:АмниотыКлада:ЗавропсидыКласс:Пт�...

 

 

Fall of the Western Roman Empire

Loss of central political control in the Western Roman Empire in late antiquity Fall of Rome redirects here. For other uses, see Fall of Rome (disambiguation). The fall of the Roman Empire redirects here. For the film, see The Fall of the Roman Empire (film). For the Italian film, see The Fall of Rome (film). Map of Roman territory  Republic  Principate/Dominate  Eastern/Byzantine Empire  Western Empire vteFall of the Western Roman Empire Gothic War (37...

Women's surfing

This article is written like a personal reflection, personal essay, or argumentative essay that states a Wikipedia editor's personal feelings or presents an original argument about a topic. Please help improve it by rewriting it in an encyclopedic style. (October 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Women's surfingCoco Ho surfing at the 2015 U.S. OpenHighest governing bodyInternational Surfing AssociationCharacteristicsMixed-sexYes, separate competitionsPresenceCountry or&#...

 

 

Courage

Pour les articles homonymes, voir courage (homonymie). Le courage dans les représentations collectives : départ du chevalier à la guerre, encouragé par la souveraine (Godspeed par Edmund Leighton, 1900) Le courage (dérivé de cœur[1]) est une vertu qui permet d'entreprendre des choses difficiles en surmontant la peur, et en affrontant le danger, la souffrance, la fatigue[2]. Depuis l'antiquité et dans la plupart des civilisations, le courage est considéré comme l'une des princi...

 

 

Trent Oeltjen

Australian baseball player (born 1983) Baseball player Trent OeltjenOeltjen with the Los Angeles DodgersOutfielderBorn: (1983-02-28) 28 February 1983 (age 41)Sydney, New South WalesBatted: LeftThrew: LeftMLB debut6 August, 2009, for the Arizona DiamondbacksLast MLB appearance28 September, 2011, for the Los Angeles DodgersMLB statisticsBatting average.220Home runs5Runs batted in11Stolen bases9 Teams Arizona Diamondbacks (2009) Los Angeles Dodgers (2010–2011...

Rubab

Rubab Rubab, robab atau rabab (Pashto: روباب, Persia: رُباب, Hindi: रुबाब, bahasa Azerbaijan: Rübab, Turki: Rübab, bahasa Tajik dan bahasa Uzbek рубоб) adalah sebuah alat musik seperti kecapi yang digunakan di Asia Tengah dan Barat.[1] Rubab adalah salah satu alat musik nasional Afganistan.[2] Alat musik ini berkembang di seluruh Asia Barat, Tengah, Selatan dan Tenggara.[3] Sejak diperkenalkannya aksara Arab dalam bahasa-bahas...

 

 

كأس رابطة الأندية الإنجليزية المحترفة 1974–75

كأس رابطة الأندية الإنجليزية المحترفة 1974–75 تفاصيل الموسم كأس رابطة الأندية الإنجليزية المحترفة  النسخة 15  البلد المملكة المتحدة  التاريخ بداية:19 أغسطس 1974  نهاية:1 مارس 1975  المنظم دوري كرة القدم الإنجليزية  البطل أستون فيلا  عدد المشاركين 92   كأس رابطة �...

 

 

Presidium Dewan Papua

artikel ini perlu dirapikan agar memenuhi standar Wikipedia. Tidak ada alasan yang diberikan. Silakan kembangkan artikel ini semampu Anda. Merapikan artikel dapat dilakukan dengan wikifikasi atau membagi artikel ke paragraf-paragraf. Jika sudah dirapikan, silakan hapus templat ini. (Pelajari cara dan kapan saatnya untuk menghapus pesan templat ini) Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menamba...

الإسهام الأسترالي في غزو العراق 2003

يهنئ النقيب بالبحرية الأمريكية جورج كوكس ، رئيس أركان القوات البحرية المشتركة ، العميد البحري الأسترالي آلان دو توا . دعمت حكومة هاورد نزع سلاح العراق خلال أزمة نزع السلاح العراقي. وفرت أستراليا لاحقًا إحدى أربع الفرق القتالية شديدة الأهمية خلال غزو العراق عام 2003، وذلك في ...

 

 

نادي النصر (الكويت)

  لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع نادي النصر (توضيح). النصر شعار نادي النصر الاسم الكامل نادي النصر الرياضي اللقب العنابي[1] تأسس عام 13 يونيو 1965 الملعب ملعب علي صباح السالم الفروانية، الكويت(السعة: 10,000) البلد الكويت  الدوري الدوري الكويتي الإدارة الرئيس خالد شريدة المطيري المد...

 

 

Mongol invasion of Kievan Rus'

13th-century Mongol military campaign in Europe This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Mongol invasion of Kievan Rus' – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Mongol invasion of Kievan Rus'Part of the Mongol invasion of EuropeThe Mongol inv...

Siaosi Tukuʻaho

Prime Minister of Tonga For the similarly named crown prince of Tonga, see Tupoutoʻa ʻUlukalala. Siaosi Tukuʻaho3th Prime Minister of TongaIn officeJuly 1890 – 1893MonarchGeorge Tupou IPreceded byShirley Waldemar BakerSucceeded bySiosateki Veikune Personal detailsChildrenViliami Tungī Mailefihi Siaosi Tukuʻaho was a politician from Tonga who served as Prime Minister of Tonga from July 1890 to 1893.[1][2] References ^ Tonga. World Statesmen Encyclopedia. ^ C...

 

 

Sistem Pemosisi Global

Sistem Pemosisi Global (GPS)Negara asalAmerika SerikatOperatorAngkatan Antariksa Amerika SerikatTipeMiliter, sipilStatusOperasionalJangkauanGlobalAkurasi500–30 cm (20–1 ft)KonstelasiJumlah total satelit33Satelit di orbit31Peluncuran pertamaFebruari 1978; 46 tahun lalu (1978-02)Jumlah peluncuran72Karakteristik orbitSistem orbit6x bidang orbit MEOKetinggian orbit20.180 km (12.540 mi) Gambaran satelit GPS di orbit Sistem Pemosisi Global [1] (bahasa Inggris: G...

 

 

Statius

1st-century AD Roman poet For the personal name, see Statius (praenomen). For other uses, see Statius (disambiguation). Publius Papinius StatiusBornc. 45 CENaples, Roman EmpireDiedc. 96 CE (aged c. 51)Naples, Roman EmpireOccupationPoetNationalityRoman (of Greek origin) Publius Papinius Statius (Greek: Πόπλιος Παπίνιος Στάτιος; /ˈsteɪʃiəs/, Latin: [ˈstaːtiʊs];[a] c. 45 – c. 96) was a Latin poet of the 1st century CE. His su...

طواف فيرزين 2021

طواف فيرزين 2021 تفاصيل السباقسلسلة100. طواف فيرزينمسابقاتسلسلة سباقات الاتحاد الدولي للدراجات للمحترفين 2021 1.Pro‏كأس إيطاليا لركوب الدراجات على الطريق 2021التاريخ5 أكتوبر 2021المسافات196٫7 كمالبلد إيطاليانقطة البدايةبوستو أرسيتسيونقطة النهايةفَرِيزةالفرق24عدد المتسابقين في...

 

 

Fussball Club Erzgebirge Aue 2011-2012

Voce principale: Fussball Club Erzgebirge Aue. Fussball Club Erzgebirge AueStagione 2011-2012Sport calcio Squadra Erzgebirge Aue Allenatore Rico Schmitt (1ª-20ª, 22ª) Karsten Baumann (21ª, 23ª-34ª) All. in seconda Marco Kämpfe 2. Bundesliga15º posto Coppa di GermaniaSecondo turno Maggiori presenzeCampionato: Männel, Klingbeil (34)Totale: Männel, Klingbeil (36) Miglior marcatoreCampionato: König (9)Totale: König (10) StadioSparkassen-Erzgebirgsstadion Maggior numero di spetta...