Approximate identity involving logarithms of primes
In number theory , Selberg's identity is an approximate identity involving logarithms of primes named after Atle Selberg . The identity, discovered jointly by Selberg and Paul Erdős , was used in the first elementary proof for the prime number theorem .
Statement
There are several different but equivalent forms of Selberg's identity. One form is
∑ ∑ -->
p
<
x
(
log
-->
p
)
2
+
∑ ∑ -->
p
q
<
x
log
-->
p
log
-->
q
=
2
x
log
-->
x
+
O
(
x
)
{\displaystyle \sum _{p<x}(\log p)^{2}+\sum _{pq<x}\log p\log q=2x\log x+O(x)}
where the sums are over primes p and q .
Explanation
The strange-looking expression on the left side of Selberg's identity is (up to smaller terms) the sum
∑ ∑ -->
n
<
x
c
n
{\displaystyle \sum _{n<x}c_{n}}
where the numbers
c
n
=
Λ Λ -->
(
n
)
log
-->
n
+
∑ ∑ -->
d
|
n
Λ Λ -->
(
d
)
Λ Λ -->
(
n
/
d
)
{\displaystyle c_{n}=\Lambda (n)\log n+\sum _{d\,|\,n}\Lambda (d)\Lambda (n/d)}
are the coefficients of the Dirichlet series
ζ ζ -->
′ ′ -->
′ ′ -->
(
s
)
ζ ζ -->
(
s
)
=
(
ζ ζ -->
′ ′ -->
(
s
)
ζ ζ -->
(
s
)
)
′ ′ -->
+
(
ζ ζ -->
′ ′ -->
(
s
)
ζ ζ -->
(
s
)
)
2
=
∑ ∑ -->
c
n
n
s
.
{\displaystyle {\frac {\zeta ^{\prime \prime }(s)}{\zeta (s)}}=\left({\frac {\zeta ^{\prime }(s)}{\zeta (s)}}\right)^{\prime }+\left({\frac {\zeta ^{\prime }(s)}{\zeta (s)}}\right)^{2}=\sum {\frac {c_{n}}{n^{s}}}.}
This function has a pole of order 2 at s = 1 with coefficient 2, which gives the dominant term 2x log(x ) in the asymptotic expansion of
∑ ∑ -->
n
<
x
c
n
.
{\displaystyle \sum _{n<x}c_{n}.}
Another variation of the identity
Selberg's identity sometimes also refers to the following divisor sum identity involving the von Mangoldt function and the Möbius function when
n
≥ ≥ -->
1
{\displaystyle n\geq 1}
:[ 1]
Λ Λ -->
(
n
)
log
-->
(
n
)
+
∑ ∑ -->
d
|
n
Λ Λ -->
(
d
)
Λ Λ -->
(
n
d
)
=
∑ ∑ -->
d
|
n
μ μ -->
(
d
)
log
2
-->
(
n
d
)
.
{\displaystyle \Lambda (n)\log(n)+\sum _{d\,|\,n}\Lambda (d)\Lambda \!\left({\frac {n}{d}}\right)=\sum _{d\,|\,n}\mu (d)\log ^{2}\left({\frac {n}{d}}\right).}
This variant of Selberg's identity is proved using the concept of taking derivatives of arithmetic functions defined by
f
′ ′ -->
(
n
)
=
f
(
n
)
⋅ ⋅ -->
log
-->
(
n
)
{\displaystyle f^{\prime }(n)=f(n)\cdot \log(n)}
in Section 2.18 of Apostol's book (see also this link ).
References
Pisot, Charles (1949), Démonstration élémentaire du théorème des nombres premiers , Séminaire Bourbaki, vol. 1, MR 1605145
Selberg, Atle (1949), "An elementary proof of the prime-number theorem", Ann. of Math. , 2, 50 (2): 305– 313, doi :10.2307/1969455 , JSTOR 1969455 , MR 0029410