Prior to committing to Ohio State, Hickman was an All-American lacrosse player, and he originally committed to Rutgers University for lacrosse.[6]
College career
Hickman played at Ohio State from 2019 to 2022. After redshirting in 2019 to recover from an injury he suffered his senior year in high school, he played in five games in 2020 on special teams, finishing with five tackles. In 2021, he started all 13 games recording 99 tackles, two interceptions, a sack and a touchdown.[7][8] In 2022, he started 13 games and had 53 tackles and an interception.[6] After the season, Hickman entered the 2023 NFL draft.[9]
Hickman signed with the Cleveland Browns as an undrafted free agent on May 12, 2023.[12] On August 29, 2023, the Browns announced that he had made the initial 53-man roster.[13] During the Browns' Week 17 victory over the New York Jets, Hickman recorded his first career interception off quarterback Trevor Siemian and returned it 30 yards for his first NFL touchdown.[14]