At start of his MLB career, Moeller was nicknamed The Kid by the Orioles players both for his boyish looks and making his big-league debut at age seventeen. He pitched in part of two seasons for Baltimore before his selection by the Los Angeles Angels in the expansion draft following the 1960 season. His most productive campaign came in 1961 with the Angels, when he posted career-best numbers in wins (4), strikeouts (83) and innings pitched (112+2⁄3), including a 3–0 six-hit shutout with nine strikeouts against his former Orioles team on June 5.[1] In 1963, his last major league season, Moeller went 2–0 in three starts for the Washington Senators.
In a four-season career, Moeller posted a 6–9 record with a 5.78 ERA in 52 appearances, including 22 starts, 104 strikeouts, and 100 walks in 152⅔ innings of work. He also pitched in the minor leagues from 1956 through 1963, compiling a 37–38 record with a 3,30 ERA in 118 games, 94 as a starter.
Moeller died in his native Cincinnati at the age of 71.