Resultative

In linguistics, a resultative (abbreviated RES) is a form that expresses that something or someone has undergone a change in state as the result of the completion of an event. Resultatives appear as predicates of sentences, and are generally composed of a verb (denoting the event), a post-verbal noun phrase (denoting the entity that has undergone a change) and a so-called resultative phrase (denoting the state achieved as the result of the action named by the verb[1]) which may be represented by an adjective, a prepositional phrase, or a particle, among others.[2] For example, in the English sentence The man wiped the table clean, the adjective clean denotes the state achieved by the table as a result of the event described as the man wiped.

Resultative constructions

Resultative constructions are set syntactic patterns used to express resultativeness. Within these structures, the object NP is viewed as having undergone some change of state, and the change is viewed as a result achieved through the action expressed by the combination of the verb and the result phrase. The word order of the elements is said to be constant and crucial in conveying the resultative meaning; under this analysis, the output in its entirety is regarded as having a more complex meaning than the sum of its components' individual meanings. This constructional approach has been proposed in order to account for the semantic differences between standalone verbs that have no intrinsic resultative meaning and their resultative counterparts (e.g. hammer versus hammer ... flat).[3]

Systems of differentiation

Syntactic trees showing the difference in structure between non-resultative and resultative phrases.

Resultative constructions can be described in the framework of a sign-oriented approach: morphological signals and word order signals (based on the ordering of lexical items) interact in order to create meaning. This interaction generates a system of oppositions based on two types of differentiation: differentiation of the referent from other referents in the lexicon and differentiation of the referent from itself.[4]

Differentiation from Other Differentiation from Self
He painted the red barn. He painted the barn red.
She wore her long hair. She wore her hair long.
He found the guilty man. He found the man guilty.
He made the sacred porridge. He made the porridge sacred.

Classes of resultative constructions

Semantically, resultative constructions can be part of one of four major classes, defined by two attributes: causative vs. non-causative, and property vs. path. (See table below.) These classes are distinguished by the relation between the noun phrase undergoing the change expressed by the resultative (referred to as the host) and the resultative construction itself.[2]

In causative resultatives.the host is the direct object of the resultative construction; the subject causes the host to undergo a change. In noncausative resultatives, the host is the subject of the resultative construction; the sentence states a change of state or position.

In property resultatives, the host comes to have the property expressed by the resultative construction. In path resultatives, the resultative construction describes a path that is traversed by the host.

Causative Noncausative
Property The gardener watered the tulips flat The lake froze solid
Path Bill rolled the ball down the hill The ball rolled down the hill

Traditional view

Defining the role and category of resultatives has inspired numerous approaches from linguists. Traditionally, certain tenses and aspects have been attributed to resultatives. Namely, the present perfect aspect is pointed to in explaining resultative constructions like I have written them a letter.[5] There is a stress on the sense of completeness inherent in resultatives: A: Have you cleaned the windows? B: No, I haven't finished them yet. B: Yes, but I haven't finished them yet

In this example, answering negatively entails that either some or none of the windows have been cleaned, but you cannot answer positively unless the entire task is completed. The task does not require successful completion as found in the example He has not passed his exam.

It has been demonstrated, however, that resultatives exist independently of the perfect in sentences like I turned this offer down, creating the need to reexamine the role of resultatives.[3] To address this, it has been claimed that the resultative expresses both a state and the preceding action it has resulted from.[6] This emphasizes that the resultative describes how a state was acted upon. Therefore, it must use the passive form. However, this analysis does not account for phrases such as I turned this offer down, which uses the active rather than the passive voice.

Sign-oriented analysis

Sign-oriented analyses present an aspectual contrast, in which the approach is based on the boundaries of predication within a time-field.[4][7] An action is perceived as a whole within a predication or it could be perceived as the predication within the boundaries.[3] A markedness relationship is one between the perfective and imperfective.[8] This analysis argues against the view that the resultative meaning is identical to the perfect. Below are sentences where the verbs in the perfect do not have the ‘element of result’ in their meaning:

I’ve seen it before. It’s only been three or four times that we’ve come face to face.

In the sentences above ‘the element of result’ does not seem apparent. It is argued that the concrete result and the result phase should be distinguished from each other.[8]

The Guillaumean approach

This aspectual approach shows the relation between an action and its result. The Guillaumean approach posits that the English verb has two moments, one where any duration, any developments, or any actualizations take place with the event's duration.[9]

The Guillaumean Chart of notational chronology
before after
cause effect
condition consequence
operation result

The resultative as a feature of English

Yet another approach to resultativeness views it as “a fundamental semantic distinctive feature which cuts across almost all traditional categories: verb, noun, adjective, infinitive, gerund, participle, particle, auxiliary”.[10] It is claimed that the resultative should be a distinctive feature in language instead of being a subcategory within the verbal aspect realm.

As a system of oppositions

Result-based oppositions in the lexicon

This approach suggests the idea of viewing resultativeness as a system of oppositions. It hypothesizes that the resultative is not restricted to a tense or an aspect form.[3] It suggests that the resultativeness is expressed by oppositions of marked/unmarked forms throughout all language levels and subsystems.[3] Markedness is a system that contrasts two language forms as distinguished based on simplicity and frequency of usage.(For example, irregular verbs will be marked, whereas regular verbs will be unmarked)

These subsystems includes: morpheme, auxiliaries, lexical pairs, compounds, verb complements, tense aspect and voice forms, syntactic patters, types of sentences, word order, stress, and intonation.[3]

Gorlach, in her book, proposes that resultativeness happens depending whether the subsystem is marked or not. For example, in the sentence "I am wiping the table" the affix -ing is marked and expresses neutral state instead of resultative state. -ed, on the other hand, is unmarked form of affix, thus making the following sentence express resultativeness: "I wiped the table".[3]

Extended list of marked/unmarked form of all language subsystems can be found in the table.

Distribution

A resultative is either an adjectival phrase indicating the state of a noun resulting from the completion of the event denoted by the verb, or a verbal construction denoting the result state of an event. This verbal construction type of resultative is usually considered part of the field of aspect.

Adjectival resultatives

This type of resultative is a phrase that indicates the state of a noun resulting from the completion of the verb. In the English examples below, the affected noun is shown in bold and the resulting predicate is in italics:

  • John licked his plate clean.
  • Mary painted the fence blue.
  • The cold weather froze the lake solid.

Subjects of passive and unaccusative verbs may participate in resultative constructions:

  • Passive: The well was drained dry.
  • Unaccusative: The door swung open.

Subjects of unergative verbs may also participate in resultative constructions, but a "dummy object", that is, an otherwise absent reflexive pronoun must be inserted:

  • Gordon laughed himself helpless.
  • The girl screamed herself hoarse.

Resultatives are distinct from depictive constructions, though often both a resultative and a depictive reading is possible from the same sentence. For example, in "John fried the fish dry", a resultative reading suggests that as a result of John's frying, the fish became dry. On the other hand, also possible is a depictive reading in which John is already dry, and that is the state in which he is frying the fish (because e.g. he had been back from the beach for long enough to be dry). Both depictives and resultatives are important in the understanding of small clauses because their exact properties seem to vary considerably from language to language.

Resultatives in German

In German, some verbs can occur in adjectival resultative sentences while others cannot. In the example below, an argument can be made that the noun phrase after the verb can be interpreted as a verb argument.[11]

Der

'The

Schmied

smith

hämmert

hammers

das

the

Metall

metal

flach.

flat.'

Der Schmied hämmert das Metall flach.

'The smith hammers the metal flat.'

Verbal resultatives

This sort of resultative is a grammatical aspect construction that indicates the result state of the event denoted by the verb. English does not have a productive resultative construction. It is widely accepted that the be-perfects of various European languages (e.g. French, Italian, German, and Dutch) began as resultative constructions.[12]

Resultatives in Mandarin

Mandarin places the resultative within an verb aspect construction.

张三

Zhāngsān

Zhangsan

擦干净了

cā-gānjìng-le

wipe-clean-PFV

桌子。

zhuōzi.

table

张三 擦干净了 桌子。

Zhāngsān cā-gānjìng-le zhuōzi.

Zhangsan wipe-clean-PFV table

'Zhangsan wiped the table clean.'

In this example, the resultative gānjìng is situated within the verb aspect construction. The verb cā- takes the theta roles of agent and experiencer. Resultative phrases may also take multiple theta-roles. The linguist Fengqi Li calls these “composite roles”.[13]

斧子

Fǔzi

Axe

砍钝了。

kǎn-dùn-le

cut-dull-PFV

斧子 砍钝了。

Fǔzi kǎn-dùn-le

Axe cut-dull-PFV

'The axe became dull because of overuse.'

Here, the theta-roles are agent, experiencer and instrument. The experiencer and instrument are both the ax, but they take composite roles. The verb cut is transitive and therefore requires a direct object. The composite role allows the knife to undergo its own action.

Resultatives in Japanese

The resultative construction in English might be represented as SVO AP.

a. John shot Mary dead.
b. John painted the wall blue.

The Japanese translation of the sentences a. and b. in the above table would have two distinct constructions. The first construction has a complex verb strategy, where V2 is the causative change of state verb, or result state corresponding to the AP in English construction. V1 is a verb of simple activity, which corresponds to V in the English construction.[14]

ジョンが

Jon-ga

John-NOM

メアリーを

Mearī-o

Mary-ACC

撃ち殺した。

uchi-koroshi-ta.

shoot-kill-PAST

ジョンが メアリーを 撃ち殺した。

Jon-ga Mearī-o uchi-koroshi-ta.

John-NOM Mary-ACC shoot-kill-PAST

'John shot Mary dead.'

References

  1. ^ Levin, Beth. (1993). English verb classes and alternations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  2. ^ a b Goldberg, A. E. & Jackendoff, R. (2004). The English Resultative as a Family of Constructions. Language, 80, 532-568.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g Gorlach, Marina (2004). Phrasal constructions and resultativeness in English : a sign-oriented analysis. Amsterdam: J. Benjamins. p. 54. ISBN 9027215618.
  4. ^ a b Diver, W. (1986). The Grammar of Modern English. ms: Columbia University.
  5. ^ Depraetere, Ilse (1998). On the resultative character of present perfect sentences. Journal of Pragmatics 29, 5 (1998) 608.
  6. ^ Nedjalkov, Vladimir (1988). Typology of Resultative Constructions. Amsterdam; Philadelphia: John Benjamins Publishing Company. (English translation edited by Bernard Comrie.).
  7. ^ Huffman, A. "Teaching the English tenses". Columbia University Working Papers in Linguistics. 10, i–iv, 1–153, xvi–xxi.
  8. ^ a b Allen, R. L. (1966). The Verb System of Present-Day English. Mouton: The Hague.
  9. ^ Hirtle, W (1975). Time, Aspect and the Verb. Quebec: Les Presses de l'Universite Laval.
  10. ^ Tobin, Y. (1993). Aspect in the English Verb: Process and Result in Language. London: Longman.
  11. ^ Richter, Michael; van Hout, Roeland (August 2010). "Why some verbs can form a resultative construction while others cannot: Decomposing semantic binding". Lingua. 120 (8): 2006–2021. doi:10.1016/j.lingua.2010.02.007.
  12. ^ Bybee, J., Perkins, R & Pagliuca, W. 1994. The Evolution of Grammar: Tense, Aspect, and Modality in the Languages of the World. Chicago; London: University of Chicago Press.
  13. ^ Li, Fengqi. (2011). "Theta-Structures of Mandarin Resultative Verb Compounds". Linguistik Online.
  14. ^ Washio, Ryuichi (1997). "Resultatives, Compositionality and Language Variation". Journal of East Asian Linguistics. 1. 6 (1): 1–49. doi:10.1023/A:1008257704110. JSTOR 20100710. S2CID 115305827.

Read other articles:

Adrianus MooyAdrianus Mooy, Kabinet Pembangunan V Duta Besar Indonesia untuk Belgia ke-15Masa jabatan1993–1995PresidenSoeharto PendahuluT.M. ZahirsjahPenggantiSabana KartasasmitaGubernur Bank Indonesia ke-9Masa jabatan1988–1993PresidenSoeharto PendahuluArifin SiregarPenggantiSudrajad DjiwandonoRektor Universitas Pelita Harapan Surabaya ke-2Masa jabatanSeptember 2010 – 2018 PendahuluTidak diketahuiPenggantiTidak diketahui Informasi pribadiLahir10 April 1936 (umur...

 

هذه مقالة غير مراجعة. ينبغي أن يزال هذا القالب بعد أن يراجعها محرر؛ إذا لزم الأمر فيجب أن توسم المقالة بقوالب الصيانة المناسبة. يمكن أيضاً تقديم طلب لمراجعة المقالة في الصفحة المخصصة لذلك. (أبريل 2022) مشروع إحصاء الجثث في العراق (IBC) هو جهد على شبكة الإنترنت لتسجيل الوفيات الم...

 

Thomas Ian NicholasNicholas pada 2019Lahir10 Juli 1980 (umur 43)Las Vegas, Nevada, Amerika SerikatPekerjaanPemeran, musisi, produserTahun aktif1988–kiniSuami/istriColette Marino ​(m. 2007)​Anak2 Thomas Ian Nicholas (lahir 10 Juli 1980) adalah seorang pemeran, produser dan penyanyi Amerika Serikat. Nicholas dikenal karena memerankan Henry Rowengartner dalam Rookie of the Year, Walt Disney dalam Walt Before Mickey dan Kevin Myers dalam seri film America...

Hyperiidea Hyperia galba (Hyperiidae) Klasifikasi ilmiah Kerajaan: Animalia Filum: Arthropoda Subfilum: Crustacea Kelas: Malacostraca Ordo: Amphipoda Subordo: HyperiideaH. Milne-Edwards, 1830 Familia Lihat teks Hyperiidea adalah subordo Amphipoda, krustasea akuatik kecil. Berbeda dengan subordo Amphipoda lainnya, Hyperiidea secara eksklusif berhabitat di laut dan tidak terdapat pada air tawar. Hyperiidae dibedakan dengan subordo lainnya dengan ciri mata besar dan habitat planktonik. Sebagian...

 

Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat Daerah Kabupaten KarimunDewan Perwakilan RakyatKabupaten Karimun2019-2024JenisJenisUnikameral SejarahSesi baru dimulai29 Agustus 2019PimpinanKetuaMuhammad Yusuf Sirat, S.IP. (Golkar) sejak 30 September 2019 Wakil Ketua IHasanuddin (PKS) sejak 30 September 2019 Wakil Ketua II Rasno (PDI-P) sejak 30 September 2019 KomposisiAnggota30Partai & kursi  PDI-P (3)   NasDem (1)   PKB (3)   Hanura (3)   Demokrat ...

 

William SaroyanWilliam Saroyan in 1940Lahir(1908-08-31)31 Agustus 1908Fresno, California, U.S.Meninggal18 Mei 1981(1981-05-18) (umur 72)Fresno, California, U.S.MakamArarat Cemetery, Fresno[1]Komitas Pantheon, Yerevan, ArmeniaPekerjaanNovelist, playwright, short story writerKebangsaanAmericanPeriode1934–1980Karya terkenalThe Armenian and the Armenian (1935)My Heart's in the Highlands (1939)The Time of Your Life (1939)My Name Is Aram (1940)The Human Comedy (1943)PenghargaanP...

Cinema of Bangladesh List of Bangladeshi films 1928–1947 India 1948–1958 East Pakistan 1959–1970 East Pakistan 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971–1979 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980s 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990s 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000s 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010s 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020s 2020 2021 2022 2023 vte A list o...

 

Three Irish nationalists hanged in 1867 Portraits of the Manchester Martyrs – Larkin (left), Allen (centre) and O'Brien (right) – on a shamrock The Manchester Martyrs (Irish: Mairtirígh Mhanchain)[1][2] were three Irish nationalists – William Philip Allen, Michael Larkin, and Michael O'Brien – who were hanged in 1867 following their conviction of murder after an attack on a police van in Manchester, England, in which a police officer was accidentally shot dead,[3&...

 

UFC mixed martial arts event in 2022 UFC 270: Ngannou vs. GaneThe poster for UFC 270: Ngannou vs. GaneInformationPromotionUltimate Fighting ChampionshipDateJanuary 22, 2022 (2022-01-22)VenueHonda CenterCityAnaheim, California, United StatesAttendance17,387[1]Total gate$5,290,213[1]Event chronology UFC on ESPN: Kattar vs. Chikadze UFC 270: Ngannou vs. Gane UFC Fight Night: Hermansson vs. Strickland UFC 270: Ngannou vs. Gane was a mixed martial arts event produced...

Catherine ColemanLahirCatherine Grace Coleman14 Desember 1960 (umur 63)Charleston, Carolina SelatanKebangsaanAmerika SerikatAlmamaterMassachusetts Institute of Technology, University of Massachusetts AmherstPekerjaanKimiawatiKarier luar angkasaAntariksawati NASAPangkatKolonel, Angkatan Udara Amerika Serikat, pensiunMisiSTS-73, STS-93, Soyuz TMA-20 (Ekspedisi 26/27)Lambang misi Catherine Grace Cady Coleman (lahir 14 Desember 1960) adalah seorang kimiawati, mantan perwira Angkatan Udara A...

 

Map of the Silverstone Circuit (2000-2002) The 2002 FIA GT Silverstone 500 km was the second round the 2002 FIA GT Championship season. It took place at the Silverstone Circuit, United Kingdom, on 5 May 2002. Official results Class winners in bold. Cars failing to complete 70% of winner's distance marked as Not Classified (NC). Pos Class No Team Drivers Chassis Tyre Laps Engine 1 GT 12 Paul Belmondo Racing Fabio Babini Marc Duez Chrysler Viper GTS-R P 96 Chrysler 8.0L V10 2 GT 15 Lister ...

 

Questa voce sull'argomento calciatori italiani è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Francesco Varicelli Nazionalità  Italia Calcio Ruolo Difensore Termine carriera 1959 CarrieraGiovanili 19??-1942 SavonaSquadre di club1 1942-1943 Cairese10 (0)1945-1947 Savona40+ (?)1947-1949 Cremonese67 (0)1949-1950 SPAL37 (1)1950-1953 Livorno32 (0)1956-1957 Savona25 ...

Middle-Javanese kidung Palm leaf manuscript of the poem, click for the full archival pdf of the poem. Kidung Sunda is a Middle-Javanese kidung of probable Balinese provenance. In this poem, the story of King Hayam Wuruk of Majapahit who was looking for a bride-to-be, is narrated. At last, he chose the princess of Sunda, a kingdom in West Java. The princess' name has remained undisclosed in this story, however, she corresponds to Dyah Pitaloka Citraresmi in Pararaton. Hayam Wuruk's grand vizie...

 

Norwegian sports club Football clubDonnFull nameDonn ToppfotballFounded24 June 1909; 114 years ago (1909-06-24)GroundKristiansand Stadion, KristiansandCapacity16,600Head coachKjetil Ruthford Pedersen[1]League4. divisjon (men)20233. divisjon, group 4, 13th of 14 (relegated)[2] Home colours Away colours Fotballklubben Donn is a Norwegian football club from the neighbourhood Lund in Kristiansand, most notable for its women's football team. It was founded on 24 J...

 

В Википедии есть статьи о других людях с фамилией Арциховский. Артемий Владимирович Арциховский Дата рождения 13 (26) декабря 1902 Место рождения Санкт-Петербург, Российская империя[2] Дата смерти 17 февраля 1978(1978-02-17) (75 лет) Место смерти Москва, СССР Страна  СССР Ро...

Type of inflorescence 1. Leaves and Inflorescence of the Arum maculatum, 2. Underground root-stock, 3. Lower part of spathe cut open, 4. Spike of fruits- showing in succession (from below) female flowers, male flowers, and sterile flowers forming a ring of hairs borne on the spadix. Diagram of spadix In botany, a spadix (/ˈspeɪdɪks/ SPAY-diks; pl.: spadices /ˈspeɪdɪsiːz/ SPAY-dih-seez, /speɪˈdaɪsiːz/ spay-DY-seez) is a type of inflorescence having small flowers borne on a fleshy st...

 

TelephoneSingel oleh Lady Gaga featuring Beyoncédari album The Fame MonsterDirilis26 Januari 2010 (2010-01-26)FormatDigital download, CD single, 7GenreElectropop, dance-popDurasi3:40LabelStreamline, Kon Live, Cherrytree, InterscopePenciptaLaShawn Daniels, Lazonate Franklin, Stefani Germanotta, Rodney Jerkins, Beyoncé Knowles[1]ProduserDarkchildKronologi singel Bad Romance (2009) Telephone (2010) Alejandro (2010) Kronologi singel Beyoncé Video Phone(2009) Telephone(2010) P...

 

Polish light utility helicopter SW-4 / AW009 SW-4 with the Polish Air Force Role Multipurpose utility helicopterType of aircraft National origin Poland Manufacturer PZL-Świdnik First flight 29 October 1996 Introduction 2002 Status In service Primary user Polish Armed Forces Produced 1996-Present Number built 40[1] The PZL SW-4 Puszczyk (en: tawny owl) is a Polish light single-engine multipurpose helicopter manufactured by PZL-Świdnik. Following a protracted development, the SW-...

Cet article est une ébauche concernant une localité hongroise. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?) selon les recommandations des projets correspondants. Ásványráró L'église Saint-Roch (Szent Rókus) de Ráró Blason de ÁsványráróDrapeau de Ásványráró Géolocalisation sur la carte : Győr-Moson-Sopron Ásványráró Ásványráró Ásványráró Administration Pays Hongrie Comitat (megye)  Győr-Moson-Sopron (Transdanubie occiden...

 

この記事の出典や参考文献は、一次資料や記事主題の関係者による情報源に頼っています。 信頼できる第三者情報源とされる出典の追加が求められています。出典検索?: 奈良学園大学 – ニュース · 書籍 · スカラー · CiNii · J-STAGE · NDL · dlib.jp · ジャパンサーチ · TWL(2019年1月) 奈良学園大学 奈良学園大学(旧三郷キャンパス...