Political repression is the act of a state entity controlling a citizenry by force for political reasons, particularly for the purpose of restricting or preventing the citizenry's ability to take part in the political life of a society, thereby reducing their standing among their fellow citizens.[1][2] Repression tactics target the citizenry who are most likely to challenge the political ideology of the state in order for the government to remain in control.[3] In autocracies, the use of political repression is to prevent anti-regime support and mobilization.[4] It is often manifested through policies such as human rights violations, surveillance abuse, police brutality, imprisonment, involuntary settlement, stripping of citizen's rights, lustration, and violent action or terror such as the murder, summary executions, torture, forced disappearance, and other extrajudicial punishment of political activists, dissidents, or general population.[5] Direct repression tactics are those targeting specific actors who become aware of the harm done to them while covert tactics rely on the threat of citizenry being caught (wiretapping and monitoring).[6] The effectiveness of the tactics differ: covert repression tactics cause dissidents to use less detectable opposition tactics[7] while direct repression allows citizenry to witness and react to the repression.[8] Political repression can also be reinforced by means outside of written policy, such as by public and private media ownership and by self-censorship within the public.
Where political repression is sanctioned and organised by the state, it may constitute state terrorism, genocide, politicide or crimes against humanity. Systemic and violent political repression is a typical feature of dictatorships, totalitarian states and similar regimes.[9] While the use of political repression varies depending on the authoritarian regime, it is argued that repression is a defining feature and the foundation of autocracies by creating a power hierarchy between the leader and citizenry, contributing to the longevity of the regime.[10] Repressive activities have also been found within democratic contexts as well.[11][12] This can even include setting up situations where the death of the target of repression is the end result.[13] If political repression is not carried out with the approval of the state, a section of government may still be responsible. Some examples are the FBICOINTELPRO operations from 1956 to 1971 and the Palmer Raids from 1919-1920.[14][15][16]
In some states, "repression" can be an official term used in legislation or the names of government institutions. The Soviet Union had a legal policy of repression of political opposition defined in its penal code and Cuba under Fulgencio Batista had a secret police agency officially named the Bureau for the Repression of Communist Activities. According to Soviet and communist studies scholar Stephen Wheatcroft, in the case of the Soviet Union terms such as "the terror", "the purges" and "repression" are used to refer to the same events. He believes the most neutral terms are repression and mass killings, although in Russian the broad concept of repression is commonly held to include mass killings and is sometimes assumed to be synonymous with it, which is not the case in other languages.[17]
In political conflict
Political conflict strongly increases the likelihood of state repression. This is arguably the most robust finding in social science research on political repression. Civil wars are a strong predictor of repressive activity, as are other forms of challenges from non-government actors.[18] States so often engage in repressive behaviors in times of civil conflict that the relationship between these two phenomena has been termed the "Law of Coercive Responsiveness".[19] When their authority or legitimacy is threatened, regimes respond by overtly or covertly suppressing dissidents to eliminate the behavioral threat. State repression subsequently affects dissident mobilization, though the direction of this effect is still an open question. Some strong evidence suggests that repression suppresses dissident mobilization by reducing the capacity of challengers to organize, yet it is also feasible that challengers can leverage state repressive behavior to spur mobilization among sympathizers by framing repression as a new grievance against the state.[20]
Political repression is often accompanied by violence, which might be legal or illegal according to domestic law.[21] Violence can both eliminate political opposition directly by killing opposition members, or indirectly by instilling fear.
Some regimes that govern societies experiencing sustained ethno-religious conflict may be consolidated on the basis of exclusionary notions of nationhood. In such discriminatory states, political right is generated through a distinction between citizens, who are afforded the rights and moral standing of “full persons,” and outsiders, or the “subpersons” of society.[22] The privileges enjoyed by citizens are given meaning because they are denied to subpersons, on account of their perceived inferiority.[23][24] The government thereby creates a political order that justifies and enables the dominance of citizens through the systemic “exploitation of [the] bodies, land, [and] resources [of noncitizens], and the denial of equal socioeconomic opportunities to them.”[25] In this way, the regime operationalizes the domination and subordination of certain groups to establish its political authority. These repressive states distinguish between citizens and subpersons on the basis of socially agreed-upon conceptions of identity. Governments acquire legitimacy by expounding exclusionary notions of national identity, which sanctify the division between the citizenry and outsiders.[26]
Because the fabrication of nationhood often requires a reorientation of existing group identities, regimes will construe their national identity by taking advantage of soft power variables.[27][28] Muhammad Pervez defines soft power variables as attractive and intangible power resources like religion, cultural norms, and institutions, that appeal to people and encourage their compliance.[29] Soft power variables are constructed through the social imagination, meaning they are arbitrary and malleable. For this reason, when the citizenry utilizes soft power variables to contrive its national identity, it induces “securitized subjectivity,” whereby “subjects in a state desire securitization when they are afraid or feel a threat to the existence of their identity. In this situation, every self-identity requires a threat from others.”[30] State leaders, to further consolidate their political power and solidify the domination of the citizenry, deliberately vilify the subpersons of the political order and ensure a continued environment of securitized subjectivity.[31] By manufacturing an enduring security dilemma between dominant and subordinated groups, oppressive regimes convey to dominant groups that the protection provided by the state is necessary for the dominant identity group’s/nation state’s survival,[32][33] which legitimizes the state. In this way, through the manipulation of soft power variables, oppressive regimes manufacture a nationalism that is dependent on the demarcation between dominant and subordinate identity groups.
State terrorism
When political repression is sanctioned and organized by the state, situations of state terrorism, genocide and crimes against humanity can be reached. Systematic and violent political repression is a typical feature of dictatorships, totalitarian states and similar regimes. In these regimes, acts of political repression can be carried out by the police and secret police, the army, paramilitary groups and death squads. Sometimes regimes considered democratic exercise political repression and state terrorism to other states as part of their security policy.[34]
Direct vs. indirect repression
Direct repression is a form of repression where the state targets an opposing political actor by obvious violent action. The target is clearly aware of the harm that is caused to their life and livelihood. Direct repression does not exclusively occur within the boundaries of a state, but also across borders.[35] In personalist dictatorships, initiating conflicts with other states and people outside their own borders is more common because of lack of accountability via extremely limited or no competitive elections.[36]
Indirect repression relies on the threat of violence which constitutes harassment, intimidation, and administrative blockages. These tactics tend to be non-violent, yet still are built to control citizenry.[37]
Repressive success and monitoring
Individuals indirectly exposed to repression self-report higher trust in the leader and ruling party. This phenomenon was observed in Zimbabwe under Robert Mugabe, where the effects of repression increased approaching elections, even with deteriorating social and economic conditions.[38] A large signifier of whether or not repression is successful in a state is evidence of preference falsification– where the preference expressed by an individual in public diverges from their private preference.[39] In North Korea, accused of highly repressive activity in media and public culture, 100% of citizens vote in ‘no choice’ parliamentary elections so the state can identify defectors. Citizens are required to show complete devotion to North Korea's current leader and sacrifice their safety if they choose to speak out.[40] Repressive measures including prison camps, torture, forced labor, and threats of execution are just some of the costs of defection.[41] The Chinese Communist Party implements extensive surveillance measures in the People's Republic of China, including Internet censorship, camera monitoring, and other forms of mass surveillance. These practices involve the use of technologies such as AI, facial recognition, fingerprint identification, voice and iris recognition, big data analysis, DNA testing, and are closely linked to the Social Credit System in mainland China.[42][43] At the same time, many domestic Chinese technology companies are also involved in the country's large-scale surveillance programs. These primarily include companies such as Hikvision, Sensetime, Huawei, ZTE, and others.[44][45][46][47]
^Davenport, Christian, Johnston, Hank and Mueller, Carol (2004). Repression and Mobilization Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
^Hassan, Mai; Mattingly, Daniel; Nugent, Elizabeth R (November 30, 2021). "Political Control". Annual Review of Political Science.
^Wang, Y. (2021). The Political Legacy of Violence During China's Cultural Revolution. British Journal of Political Science, 51(2), 463-487. doi:10.1017/S0007123419000255
^Kittrie, Nicholas N. 1995. The War Against Authority: From the Crisis of Legitimacy to a New Social Contract. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
^Sullivan, Christopher M. Resistance is Mobile: Dynamics of Repression, Challenger Adaptationm and Surveillance in US 'Red Squad' and Black Nationalist Archives. Volume 55, Issue 2.
^Sullivan, Christopher M. Resistance is Mobile: Dynamics of Repression, Challenger Adaptationm and Surveillance in US 'Red Squad' and Black Nationalist Archives. Volume 55, Issue 2.
^Hassan, Mai; Mattingly, Daniel; Nugent, Elizabeth R (November 30, 2021). "Political Control". Annual Review of Political Science.
^Serge, Victor, 1979, What Everyone Should Know About State Repression, London: New Park Publications.
^Johannes Gerschewski (2013) The three pillars of stability: legitimation, repression, and co-optation in autocratic regimes, Democratization, 20:1, 13-38, DOI: 10.1080/13510347.2013.738860
^Donner, Frank J. (1980). The Age of Surveillance: The Aims and Methods of America’s Political Intelligence System. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN0-394-40298-7
^Donner, Frank J. (1990). Protectors of Privilege: Red Squads and Police Repression in Urban America. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN0-520-05951-4
^Haas, Jeffrey. The Assassination of Fred Hampton: How the FBI and the Chicago Police Murdered a Black Panther. Chicago, Ill.: Lawrence Hill /Chicago Review, 2010.
^COINTELPRO: The FBI's Covert Action Programs Against American Citizens, Final Report of the Senate Committee to Study Governmental Operations with respect to Intelligence Activities.
^Cunningham, D. 2004. There’s something happening here: The New Left, the Klan, and FBI counterintelligence. Berkeley: Univ. of California.
^Hill, Daniel W.; Jones, Zachary M. (2014). "An Empirical Evaluation of Explanations for State Repression". American Political Science Review. 108 (3): 661–687. doi:10.1017/s0003055414000306. S2CID54908565.
^Ritter, Emily Hencken (2014). "Policy Disputes, Political Survival, and the Onset and Severity of State Repression". Journal of Conflict Resolution. 58 (1): 143–168. doi:10.1177/0022002712468724. S2CID145054180.
^Mills, Charles. “The Racial Contract.” Arguing About Political Philosophy, edited by Matt Zwolinski, Routledge, 2014, pp. 86-108.
^Pateman, Carole. The Sexual Contract, Polity Press, 1991.
^Mohanty, Chandra Talpade. “Under Western Eyes: Feminist Scholarship and Colonial Discourses.” Feminist Review, no. 30, 1988, pp. 61–88.
^Mills, Charles. “The Racial Contract.” Arguing About Political Philosophy, edited by Matt Zwolinski, Routledge, 2014, pp. 86-108.
^Pervez, Muhammad Shoaib. “India-Pakistan nuclear rivalry: the influence of ideology upon elites’ social practices.” Security Community in South Asia: India-Pakistan, Taylor and Francis, 2013, pp. 103-126.
^Rafiq, Samah. “Linear Borders, Partition, and Identity in Postcolonial South Asia.” Geopolitics, vol. 27, no. 2, 2022, pp. 478-500.
^Pervez, Muhammad Shoaib. “India-Pakistan nuclear rivalry: the influence of ideology upon elites’ social practices.” Security Community in South Asia: India-Pakistan, Taylor and Francis, 2013, pp. 103-126.
^Pervez, Muhammad Shoaib. “India-Pakistan nuclear rivalry: the influence of ideology upon
elites’ social practices.” Security Community in South Asia: India-Pakistan, Taylor and Francis, 2013, pp. 103-126.
^Pervez, Muhammad Shoaib. “India-Pakistan nuclear rivalry: the influence of ideology upon elites’ social practices.” Security Community in South Asia: India-Pakistan, Taylor and Francis, 2013, pp. 103-126.
^Pervez, Muhammad Shoaib. “India-Pakistan nuclear rivalry: the influence of ideology upon elites’ social practices.” Security Community in South Asia: India-Pakistan, Taylor and Francis, 2013, pp. 103-126.
^Rafiq, Samah. “Linear Borders, Partition, and Identity in Postcolonial South Asia.” Geopolitics, vol. 27, no. 2, 2022, pp. 478-500.
^Pervez, Muhammad Shoaib. “India-Pakistan nuclear rivalry: the influence of ideology upon elites’ social practices.” Security Community in South Asia: India-Pakistan, Taylor and Francis, 2013, pp. 103-126.
^Patricia., Scipioni, Estela (2000-01-01). Torturadores, apropiadores y asesinos : el terrorismo de estado en la obra dramática de Eduardo Pavlovsky. Edition Reichenberger. ISBN9783931887919. OCLC477299442.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
^Hassan, Mai; Mattingly, Daniel; Nugent, Elizabeth R (November 30, 2021). "Political Control". Annual Review of Political Science.
^Frantz, Erica (November 15, 2018). Authoritarianism: What Everyone Needs to Know. Oxford University Press. ISBN9780190880194.
^Hassan, Mai; Mattingly, Daniel; Nugent, Elizabeth R (November 30, 2021). "Political Control". Annual Review of Political Science.
^Garcîa-Ponce, Omar; Pasquale, Benjamin (2015). "How Political Repression Shapes Attitudes Toward the State".
Bartusevičius, Henrikas; van Leeuwen, Florian; Petersen, Michael Bang (June 2023). "Political repression motivates anti-government violence". Royal Society Open Science. 10 (6). doi:10.1098/rsos.221227.
Books
Davenport, Christian; Appel, Benjamin (2022). The Death and Life of State Repression: Understanding Onset, Escalation, Termination, and Recurrence. Oxford University Press.
Jensen, Joan M. Army Surveillance in America, 1775 - 1980. New Haven. Yale University Press. 1991. ISBN0-300-04668-5.
Talbert Jr. Roy. Negative Intelligence: The Army and the American Left, 1917 - 1941. Jackson. University Press of Mississippi, 1991. ISBN0-87805-495-2.
Irvin, Cynthia L. Militant Nationalism between movement and party in Ireland and the Basque Country. University of Minnesota Press, 1999.
Seigel, Micol. 2018. Violence Work: State Power and the Limits of Police. Duke University Press.
2014 Georgian local elections ← 2010 15 June 2014 (first round)12 July 2014 (second round) 2017 → Turnout43.31% (first round)35.99% (second round) Party Georgian Dream UNM United Opposition Popular vote 719,431 317,395 144,691 Percentage 50.82% 22.42% 10.22% Party APG Labour Party EPO Popular vote 66,805 48,862 31,725 Percentage 4.72% 3.45% 2.24% The 2014 Georgian local elections (Georgian: საქართველოს ადგილობ
3A 3B Halte PelabuhanHalte Trans SemarangLetakKecamatanSemarang UtaraKelurahanTanjung MasAlamatJl. CoasterKode pos50174Informasi lainStatusDibuka. Halte TerminusKonstruksi dan FasilitasPintu1 (keberangkatan dan kedatangan)Petugas TiketTidak adaPelayananAwal PelayananPukul 05.30 WIBAkhir PelayananPukul 17.40 WIBLayanan Lua error in Modul:Adjacent_stations at line 221: Jalur tidak dikenal "Koridor 3A". Halte Pelabuhan atau Halte Pelabuhan Tanjung Mas atau disebu...
Ігор Дмитрович Чуєшов Народився 23 вересня 1951(1951-09-23)ЛенінградПомер 23 квітня 2016(2016-04-23) (64 роки)ХарківКраїна СРСР УкраїнаДіяльність математикAlma mater ХНУ імені В. Н. КаразінаГалузь Теорія ймовірностей та математична фізикаЗаклад ХНУ імені В. Н. КаразінаВчене звання про�...
Stiftskirche (Aufnahme vor 1886) Das Stift Borghorst, heute Teil von Steinfurt, wurde in der zweiten Hälfte des 10. Jahrhunderts gegründet. Es war ein freiweltliches adeliges Damenstift. Es bestand bis zu seiner Aufhebung 1811. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Gründungsphase 2 Rechtsstellung 3 Vogtei 4 Materielle Basis 5 Charakter der Gemeinschaft 6 Kirchliche Rechte 7 Kapitel 8 Stiftsämter 9 Entwicklung seit der Reformation 10 Säkularisation 11 Baulichkeiten und Kunstwerke 12 Literatur 13 Weblinks ...
Municipality in Lithuania Minor/ Samogitia, LithuaniaŠilutė District Municipality Šilutės rajono savivaldybėMunicipalityVentė Cape Coat of armsLocation of Šilutė district municipality within LithuaniaMap of Šilutė district municipalityCoordinates: 55°21′N 21°29′E / 55.350°N 21.483°E / 55.350; 21.483Country LithuaniaEthnographic regionLithuania Minor/ SamogitiaCounty Klaipėda CountyCapitalŠilutėElderships11Area • Total1,706 km2...
Unincorporated area and neighborhood in Orange County, California PlaceEl Modena, CaliforniaUnincorporated community in Orange County, CACoordinates: 33°47′16″N 117°48′31″W / 33.78778°N 117.80861°W / 33.78778; -117.80861Population • Total11,045 View from a trail in the El Modena Open Space at night. Most of northwest Orange County can be seen here. El Modena /məˈdiː.nə/[1] is an unincorporated community and neighborhood surrounding E...
2013 soundtrack album by Alexandre DesplatPhilomena (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack)Soundtrack album by Alexandre DesplatReleased25 October 2013 (2013-10-25)GenreFilm scoreLength51:16LabelDeccaProducerAlexandre DesplatAlexandre Desplat chronology Venus in Fur(2013) Philomena (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack)(2013) The Monuments Men(2014) Philomena (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) is the score album composed by Alexandre Desplat to the 2013 film of the same na...
ديوان الموظفين العام (فلسطين) تفاصيل الوكالة الحكومية البلد دولة فلسطين تأسست 1994 المركز البيرة31°53′24″N 35°12′26″E / 31.889897°N 35.2072898°E / 31.889897; 35.2072898 الإدارة موقع الويب الموقع الرسمي تعديل مصدري - تعديل ديوان الموظفين العام في دولة فلسطين هو مؤسسة ...
EuroMillions Basketball League awards and leaders Individual awards Most Valuable Player Finals MVP Star of the Coaches Belgian Player of the Year Coach of the Year Rising Star Statistical leaders Points Assists Blocks Rebounds Steals vte In basketball, an assist is a pass to a teammate that directly leads to a score by field goal.[1] The Basketball League Belgium Division I's assist title is awarded to the player with the highest assists per game average in a given regula...
Syringe pump A media dispenser or a culture media dispenser is a device for repeatedly delivering small fixed volumes (typically between 1 ml and 50 ml) of liquid such as a laboratory growth medium like molten agar or caustic or volatile solvents like toluene into a series of receptacles (Petri dishes, test tubes, Fernbach flasks, etc.). It is often important that such dispensers operate without biological or chemical contamination, and so must be internally sealed from the environm...
American- Srilankan artistic gymnast Tiana SumanasekeraSumanasekera at the 2022 Pan American Gymnastics ChampionshipsPersonal informationFull nameTiana SumanasekeraNickname(s)TCountry represented United StatesBorn (2007-09-15) September 15, 2007 (age 16)Fremont, California USAHometownPleasanton, California, USADisciplineWomen's artistic gymnasticsLevelSenior International EliteYears on national team2021 – Present (USA)ClubWorld Champions CentreCollege teamUCLA ...
Genus of plants in the family Proteaceae from southeastern Australia For other uses, see Waratah (disambiguation). Waratah Telopea speciosissima Scientific classification Kingdom: Plantae Clade: Tracheophytes Clade: Angiosperms Clade: Eudicots Order: Proteales Family: Proteaceae Subfamily: Grevilleoideae Tribe: Embothrieae Subtribe: Embothriinae Genus: Telopea(Sm.) R.Br. Synonyms Hylogyne Salisb. Waratah (Telopea) is an Australian-endemic genus of five species of large shrubs or small trees, ...
German World War II submarine The U.S. Coast Guard patrol boat USCGC Argo (WPC-100) and a tug escort the surrendered German Type IXD2 submarine U-873 to the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard, New Hampshire (USA) on 16 May 1945. History Nazi Germany NameU-873 Ordered25 August 1941[1] BuilderAG Weser, Bremen[1] Yard number1081 Laid down17 February 1943[1] Launched11 November 1943[1] Commissioned1 March 1944[1] Fate Surrendered on 16 May 1945[1] Scrapped i...
KISS OF DEATH(Produced by HYDE)中島美嘉的单曲B面GLAMOROUS SKY (Re:Present 2018)发行日期2018年3月7日格式CD單曲、音樂下載类型J-POP唱片公司Sony Music Associated Records排行榜最高名次 週間最高順位17位(Oricon) 中島美嘉单曲年表 A or B(2017年) KISS OF DEATH(Produced by HYDE) (2018年) Innocent Rouge(2020年) 《KISS OF DEATH (Produced by HYDE)》,日本女歌手中島美嘉的第44張單曲。2018年3月7日發行,標題曲則�...
Arnold SommerfeldArnold Sommerfeld năm 1897 tại đại học Göttingen.Sinh(1868-12-05)5 tháng 12 năm 1868Königsberg, nước PhổMất26 tháng 4 năm 1951(1951-04-26) (82 tuổi)München, ĐứcQuốc tịchĐứcTrường lớpđại học KönigsbergNổi tiếng vìMô hình Drude-SommerfeldHằng số cấu trúc tinh tếKhoảng cách Sommerfeld-KosselLượng tử hóa Sommerfeld-WilsonLý thuyết Sommerfeld-BohrGiải thưởngHuy chương Matteucci (192...
Paghimo ni bot Lsjbot. Alang sa ubang mga dapit sa mao gihapon nga ngalan, tan-awa ang Dover. 83°46′37″S 55°45′11″W / 83.77697°S 55.75295°W / -83.77697; -55.75295 Dover Dover, Mount Bukid Kontinente Antartika Gitas-on 1,645 m (5,397 ft) Tiganos 83°46′37″S 55°45′11″W / 83.77697°S 55.75295°W / -83.77697; -55.75295 GeoNames 6632325 Bukid ang Dover sa Antartika.[1] Siya nahimutang sa kasadpang bahin sa kontinent...
Paghimo ni bot Lsjbot. Alang sa ubang mga dapit sa mao gihapon nga ngalan, tan-awa ang Irwin Island. 55°43′55″N 99°58′50″W / 55.73187°N 99.98064°W / 55.73187; -99.98064 Irwin Island Pulo Nasod Kanada Lalawigan Manitoba Gitas-on 287 m (942 ft) Tiganos 55°43′55″N 99°58′50″W / 55.73187°N 99.98064°W / 55.73187; -99.98064 Timezone CST (UTC-6) - summer (DST) CDT (UTC-5) GeoNames 5984095 Pulo ang Irwin I...