Political opportunity

Political opportunity theory, also known as the political process theory or political opportunity structure, is an approach of social movements that is heavily influenced by political sociology. It argues that success or failure of social movements is affected primarily by political opportunities. Social theorists Peter Eisinger, Sidney Tarrow, David S. Meyer and Doug McAdam are considered among the most prominent supporters of the theory.

Description

Three vital components for movement formation are the following:

  1. Insurgent Consciousness: certain members of society feel deprived, mistreated, and have grievances directed at a system that they perceive as unjust (see also deprivation theory).[1] When a collective sense of injustice develops, it motivates people to become movement members.[1] Movement activists do not choose their goals at random, but the political context stresses certain grievances around which movements organize.[2]
  2. Organizational Strength: similar to the main argument of the resource mobilization theory, the argument here is that the social movement must have strong and efficient leadership and sufficient resources.[1] The political opportunity theory has much in common with the related resource mobilization theory, particularly when it is seen as focusing on mobilization of resources external to the movement.[3] Associated and indigenous organizations also play a major role in recruiting and motivating actors to join and participate within social movements. Often, the rise of a movement merges with other pre-existing and highly-organized blocs of individuals, who lend the movement resources and support. The more heavily that individuals are integrated into disconnected but otherwise mobile communities, the higher the likelihood of those communities merging and lending support to causes that their members are active in.
  3. Political Opportunities: if the existing political system is vulnerable to a challenge, it creates an opportunity for others, like the movement members, to issue such a challenge and try to use this opportune time to push through a social change.[1] The vulnerability can be the result of:
    1. Increasing political pluralism
    2. Decline in repression
    3. Division within elites, particularly when it grows to a point where some support organized opposition
    4. Increased political enfranchisement[1]

Political opportunity theory argues that the actions of the activists are dependent on the existence or the lack of a specific political opportunity.[2] There are various definitions of political opportunity, but Meyer (2004) stresses that of Tarrow (1998):

"consistent – but not necessarily formal or permanent – dimensions of the political struggle that encourage people to engage in contentious politics".[3]

From the three components there emerges a proponent term which Doug McAdam coined as cognitive liberation, the ability for those active in political protest to recognize their collective strength and take advantage of political opportunities as they become available to them. As political opposition to the movement's demands weakens, members may feel a collective sense of symbolic efficacy, the capacity to enact significant change within the political arena. This opens up significant opportunities for movements to both recruit members and mobilize under a concentrated and effective cycle of demands.

Over time, the broad socioeconomic processes develop, maintain and cause decline within the movement. A movement, once developed, may be affected by the level of social control placed on it, which, in turn, affects its ability to mobilize and maintain members since when the movement's demands are portrayed as underdeveloped or unattractive, they risk losing or failing to receive support from outside institutions.

Furthermore, movements may be affected by oligarchization, a class of individuals within the movement working to ensure the maintenance of the movement itself, rather than a continual push for collective goals, or co-optation, when outside support is garnered for the movement at the same time as it is forced to sacrifice its goals to meet the demands of those supporting institutions. That, in turn, may lead to the loss of indigenous support and, along with it, many of the supporting grassroots organizations that were able to quickly mobilize members at the onset of the movement.

Meyer (2004) credited Eisinger (1973) with first use of the political opportunity theory framed in such a way (traces of which, of course, go further back).[2] Eisinger asked why in the 1960s, the level of riots about race and poverty varied between different places in the United States and noted that lack of visible openings for participation of repressed or discouraged dissident made riots more likely. Thus, the inability to air grievances legally was the political opportunity which led to organization and the mobilization of movements expressing their grievances by rioting.[4]

Meyer (2004), in his overview of political opportunity theory, noted that this broader context can affect:

  • "mobilizing",
  • "advancing particular claims rather than others",
  • "cultivating some alliances rather than others",
  • "employing particular political strategies and tactics rather than others", and
  • "affecting mainstream institutional politics and policy".[2]

A key advantage of the theory is that it explains why social movements emerge and/or increase their activity at a given time.[1] When there are no political opportunities, simply having grievances (organizational consciousness) and resources is not enough.[1] It is only when all three of these components are present that the movement has a chance to succeed.[1]

Comparison with political structure

Within the structure and agency debate, actions of activists (agents) can be understood only when they are seen in the broader context of political opportunities (structure).[2] The term structure has been used to characterize political opportunities in older scholarship.[3] A political opportunity structure has been defined as the circumstances surrounding a political landscape.[5] However, Tarrow, who used the term in his earlier publications, now argues it is misleading, as most opportunities need to be perceived and are situational, not structural.[3] Rather than just a political landscape, political opportunity structures can be described as a specific configuration of resources, institutional arrangements and historical precedent for social mobilizations.[6] Political opportunity structures are prone to change and can alter in days or last for decades. Demographics and socioeconomic factors create "structure" that affects political actors.

Political mediation model

One side model, based on the political opportunity theory, is known as the political mediation model. The political mediation model focuses on how the political context affects the strategic choices of the political actors.[1] The model goes beyond looking at whether the movements just succeeded or failed and analyzes other consequences, including unintentional ones as well as collective benefits.[1]

The opposite of political opportunity is a political constraint.

Criticism

The political process model has been criticized both structurally and conceptually. Critics suggest that political process theorists use overly-broad definitions as to what constitute political opportunities, and those definitions vary widely based on the historical context of the social movement itself. Furthermore, as political process theory frames movements as legally or politically detached from the state, it ignores movements that form out of cultural solidarity or do not directly stand in opposition to extant rules or regulations. Critics contend that theorists place too great an emphasis on the role of social networks and often almost entirely ignore the cultural underpinnings that allow the networks to form and subsist. In response to some criticisms, Doug McAdam, Sidney Tarrow and Charles Tilly proposed the Dynamics of Contention research program, which focuses on identifying mechanisms to explain political opportunities, rather than relying on an abstract structure.[7]

Examples

MoveOn.org is an organization that started in 1998[8] and still operates. MoveOn.org is a progressive[8] organization that specifically centers on political issues. MoveOn.org allows viewers to start their own petitions, a form of collective behavior,[9] which could potentially start a social movement of its own. MoveOn.org also includes other petitions and political articles and video clips on the front page[10] for people to sign and view as a mechanism for people to assemble over a similar issue, perpetuating the concept of solidarity, or a sense of collective identity over political discourse. MoveOn.org can also be applied to resource mobilization theory[11] since MoveOn.org is a site that is meant to assemble people, which adds to the strength and success of the organization.

See also

References

  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Ryan Cragun, Deborah Cragun, et al, Introduction to Sociology, Blacksleet River, ISBN 1-4499-7747-2, Google Print, p.233-234
  2. ^ a b c d e David S. Meyer, Protest and Political Opportunities, Annual Review of Sociology, Vol. 30: 125-145 (Volume publication date August 2004), doi:10.1146/annurev.soc.30.012703.110545 [1]
  3. ^ a b c d Tarrow S. 1998. Power in Movement. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press. 2nd ed.
  4. ^ Eisinger P . 1973. The conditions of protest behavior in American cities . Am. Polit. Sci. Rev. 81 : 11 – 28
  5. ^ Jereon Gunning, Hamas, democracy, religion and violence
  6. ^ Kitschelt, Herbert P. (1986). "Political Opportunity Structures and Political Protest: Anti-Nuclear Movements in Four Democracies". British Journal of Political Science. 16 (1): 58. doi:10.1017/S000712340000380X. ISSN 0007-1234. JSTOR 193981.
  7. ^ McAdam D, Tarrow S, Tilly C. 2001. Dynamics of Contention. Cambridge University Press.
  8. ^ a b "What is MoveOn.org?". MoveOn.Org | Democracy In Action. Retrieved 2016-04-26.
  9. ^ "Chapter 21 Section A Types of Collective Behavior". www.peoi.org. Retrieved 2016-04-26.
  10. ^ "MoveOn.Org | Democracy In Action". MoveOn.Org | Democracy In Action. Retrieved 2016-04-26.
  11. ^ "What is Resource Mobilization and Why is it so Important? - Health Communication Capacity Collaborative - Social and Behavior Change Communication". Health Communication Capacity Collaborative - Social and Behavior Change Communication. 2014-10-20. Retrieved 2016-04-26.

Sources

  • Meyer DS, Minkoff DC. 2004. Conceptualizing political opportunity. Soc. Forces.

Read other articles:

Arachosia and the Pactyans during the 1st millennium BC Perbatasan Afganistan–Pakistan atau lebih dikenal Garis Durand (bahasa Pashtun: د ډیورنډ کرښه) adalah batas internasional sepanjang 2,430-kilometer (1,510 mi) yang memisahkan antara Pakistan dan Afghanistan. Garis ini diberlakukan sejak tahun 1896 antara Sir Mortimer Durand, seorang diplomat Inggris dan pegawai negeri sipil British India, dan Abdur Rahman Khan, Amir Afghanistan untuk memperjelas batas untuk memperba...

 

 

Mexican politician, Governor of Tabasco In this Spanish name, the first or paternal surname is Núñez and the second or maternal family name is Jiménez. Arturo Núñez JiménezGovernor of TabascoIn office1 January 2013 – 31 December 2018Preceded byAndrés Granier MeloSucceeded byAdán Augusto López HernándezPresident of the National Conference of GovernorsIn office13 December 2017 – 22 May 2018Preceded byMiguel Angel ManceraSucceeded byManuel Velasco Coello P...

 

 

Ernst HaeckelLahir(1834-02-16)16 Februari 1834Meninggal9 Agustus 1919(1919-08-09) (umur 85)KebangsaanJerman Ernst Heinrich Philipp August Haeckel (16 Februari 1834 — 9 Agustus 1919),[1] ditulis juga von Haeckel, merupakan ahli biologi ternama dari Jerman yang juga dikenal sebagai seorang naturalis, filsuf, dokter, profesor, dan seniman. Ia menemukan, menjelaskan, memberi nama untuk ribuan spesies baru, membuat peta pohon genealogi hubungan semua makhluk hidup, dan membuat isti...

ملك بابل أداد شوما أصر   ملك بابل فترة الحكمح. 1216–1187 ق م معلومات شخصية تاريخ الميلاد القرن 13 ق.م  تاريخ الوفاة القرن 12 ق.م  مواطنة بابل  الأب كشتيلياش الرابع  عائلة كاشية الحياة العملية المهنة حاكم  تعديل مصدري - تعديل   أداد شوما أصر هو ملك بابلي والملك ال32 ل...

 

 

اتحاد آيسلندا لكرة القدم الاسم المختصر KSÍ الرياضة كرة القدم أسس عام 1947 (منذ 77 سنة) الرئيس إيغرت ماغنوسون الانتسابات الفيفا : 1947 UEFA  : 1954 رمز الفيفا ISL  الموقع الرسمي www.ksi.is تعديل مصدري - تعديل   تأسس اتحاد آيسلندا لكرة القدم (بالآيسلندية: Knattspyrnusamband Íslands)‏ في عام 1947م و�...

 

 

Angkatan Pertahanan Selandia BaruNew Zealand Defence ForceTe Ope Kātua o AotearoaLambang Angkatan Pertahanan Selandia BaruAngkatan Angkatan Darat Angkatan Laut Angkatan UdaraMarkas besarWellington, Selandia BaruKepemimpinanPanglima Tertinggi Cindy Kiro, Gubernur Jenderal Selandia Baru mewakiliCharles III, Raja Selandia BaruMenteri Pertahanan Peeni HenareKepala Angkatan Pertahanan Marsekal Madya Kevin ShortKekuatan personelUsia penerimaan18Personel aktif9.778 (2021)[1]Personel ca...

Waktu MaladewaZona waktuPeta Asia Selatan dengan zona waktu; Maladewa 5 menunjukkan Waktu Maladewa.Perbedaan UTCMVTUTC+05:00Waktu kini{{time}} – unknown timezone (help)Penerapan WMPWMP tidak diterapkan di zona waktu ini. Waktu Maladewa adalah waktu yang berlaku di Maladewa. Waktu Maladewa lima jam lebih cepat dari standar Waktu Universal Terkoordinasi, yang ditulis sebagai offset UTC + 5:00.[1] Namun, beberapa resor pulau mengoperasikan zona waktunya sendiri, yang dikenal sebagai Wa...

 

 

† Человек прямоходящий Научная классификация Домен:ЭукариотыЦарство:ЖивотныеПодцарство:ЭуметазоиБез ранга:Двусторонне-симметричныеБез ранга:ВторичноротыеТип:ХордовыеПодтип:ПозвоночныеИнфратип:ЧелюстноротыеНадкласс:ЧетвероногиеКлада:АмниотыКлада:Синапсиды�...

 

 

Questa voce sull'argomento cestisti spagnoli è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. José Simeón Simeón mostra la maglia del Valencia Nazionalità  Spagna Altezza 186 cm Peso 83 kg Pallacanestro Ruolo Playmaker Termine carriera 2017 Carriera Giovanili 2002-2009 Valencia Squadre di club 2009-2011 Valencia462011-2012 Lleida2012-2016 Força Lleida2016-2017C.B. Marín201...

5th-century BC Phoenician king Tetramnestos (ruled c. 480 – 479 BCE) was, according to Herodotus, a King of Sidon who assisted the Achaemenid Emperor Xerxes I in the Second Persian invasion of Greece in 480 BCE.[1][2] Specifically, he is said to have served as the chief advisor of Xerxes in naval matters.[1] In effect, the Sidon fleet held a position of primacy among the naval forces of the Achaemenid Empire at that time, providing the best ships in the fleet, s...

 

 

У этого термина существуют и другие значения, см. Кипр. Государство крестоносцевКипрское королевстволат. Regnum Cypriгреч. Βασίλειο της Κύπρουфр. Royaume de Chypreарм. Կիպրոսի թագավորություն Флаг Герб ←   → 1184 — 1489 Столица Никосия Язык(и) латынь, старофранцузский, сре�...

 

 

Chronologies Données clés 1908 1909 1910  1911  1912 1913 1914Décennies :1880 1890 1900  1910  1920 1930 1940Siècles :XVIIIe XIXe  XXe  XXIe XXIIeMillénaires :-Ier Ier  IIe  IIIe Chronologies géographiques Afrique Afrique du Sud, Algérie, Angola, Bénin, Botswana, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cameroun, Cap-Vert, République centrafricaine, Comores, République du Congo, République démocratique du Congo, Côte d'Ivoire, Djibouti, Égyp...

Highly trained marksman For other uses, see Sniper (disambiguation). SniperFrench and British (center) snipers equipped with FR F2, Accuracy International AWM and PGM Hécate II rifles (left to right, 2012) and camouflage Ghillie suitsOccupationOccupation typeMilitary / Law enforcementActivity sectorsUse of high-precision rifles and special reconnaissance Vasily Zaytsev, left, and other Soviet snipers equipped with Mosin–Nagant M1891/30 during the Battle of Stalingrad in December 1942 A mod...

 

 

Ongoing COVID-19 viral pandemic in Kazakhstan COVID-19 pandemic in KazakhstanDiseaseCOVID-19Virus strainSARS-CoV-2LocationKazakhstanFirst outbreakWuhan, Hubei, ChinaIndex caseAlmatyArrival date13 March 2020(4 years, 3 months and 2 days)Confirmed cases1,231,856[1][2]Recovered1,067,201[1]Deaths13,134[1]Government websitewww.coronavirus2020.kz/kz The COVID-19 pandemic in Kazakhstan was a part of the worldwide pandemic of coronavirus disease 2019 (CO...

 

 

High court in the Indian state of Tamil Nadu Madras High CourtMadras High Court Building13°05′12.8″N 80°17′16.4″E / 13.086889°N 80.287889°E / 13.086889; 80.287889Established26 June 1862; 162 years ago (1862-06-26)JurisdictionTamil Nadu and PuducherryLocationPrincipal benchChennai Additional benchMaduraiCoordinates13°05′12.8″N 80°17′16.4″E / 13.086889°N 80.287889°E / 13.086889; 80.287889MottoSatyameva Jay...

Disambiguazione – Se stai cercando altri significati, vedi Crawl (disambigua). Il crawl è uno stile di nuotata consistente in un movimento quasi alternato delle braccia accompagnato ad una propulsione continua degli arti inferiori. In italiano, a livello linguistico si chiama stile libero tuttavia esiste un'ambiguità linguistica per la quale si preferisce l'inglesismo crawl. Con stile libero, i regolamenti ufficiali stanno ad indicare la gara nella quale è possibile nuotare in qualunque...

 

 

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Drag and Atmospheric Neutral Density Explorer – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (September 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this message) DANDEThe DANDE satellite in its launch configuration.Mission typeTechnologyOperatorUniversity of Colorado Bo...

 

 

Gianluca GravaNazionalità Italia Altezza172 cm Peso68 kg Calcio RuoloAllenatore (ex difensore) Squadra Napoli (Resp. settore giovanile) Termine carriera30 giugno 2013 - giocatore CarrieraGiovanili  Casertana Squadre di club1 1993-1997 Casertana84 (7)1997-1998 Turris28 (0)1998-2004 Ternana143 (1)2004-2005→  Catanzaro15 (0)2005-2013 Napoli153 (2) Carriera da allenatore 2023-2024 NapoliColl. tecnico 1 I due numeri indicano le presenze e le reti seg...

この項目では、骨髄細胞と骨髄組織について説明しています。脊髄組織については「脊髄」をご覧ください。 造血幹細胞から成熟した細胞まで、さまざまな血液細胞の発達を示す図。 造血幹細胞から骨髄系およびリンパ系の両方の成熟細胞まで、さまざまな血液細胞の発達を示す包括的な図。 骨髄組織(こつずいそしき、英: myeloid tissue[注釈 1])とは、骨髄�...

 

 

City and metropolitan borough in Greater Manchester, England For other uses, see Manchester (disambiguation). City and metropolitan borough in EnglandManchesterCity and metropolitan boroughTown HallManchester CathedralDeansgate SquareBridgewater Canal in CastlefieldManchester Central LibraryCentral Convention ComplexCorn Exchange on Exchange SquareRoyal Exchange Coat of armsWorker beeNicknames: CottonopolisMadchesterMancsSecond CityMotto(s): Latin: Concilio Et Labore, lit. ...