Plato's Dream

"Plato's Dream" (original French title "Songe de Platon") is a 1756 short story written in the 18th century by the French philosopher and satirist Voltaire. Along with his 1752 novella Micromégas, "Plato's Dream" is among the first modern works in the genre of science fiction.

Plot summary

"Plato's Dream" is a pointed philosophical criticism of religious doctrine, told as a dream contained within the framework of a famous (and religiously-tolerated) personality of antiquity, Plato. His story recounts a dream attributed to the renowned Greek Philosopher, wherein Demiurgos, a god-like entity referred to as the "eternal geometer", appoints to a number of "lesser superbeings" the task of creating their own worlds. Demogorgon assumes responsibility for the creation of Earth, and is at first quite pleased with his creation, believing that he had "silenced Envy herself".[1] That is to say, Demogorgon was so convinced of the perfection of his creation, critics and nay-sayers would be rendered speechless.

Much to his dismay, Demogorgon found his eminently imperfect handiwork to be the subject of ridicule by the other beings. Specifically, their onslaught of criticisms targeted the disproportionate ratio of good to evil, arguing that if his planet truly is as good as he claimed, its inhabitants would not be plagued by so much suffering.[1]

The story draws to a close amidst a quarrel among the superbeings, who mock each other's haphazard attempts at creating their own planet. Demiurgos hushes the quarrel, ironically proclaiming: "It belongs to me alone to create things perfect and immortal". To which Demogorgon replies, "Us, for example?" This exchange satirizes the idea of a perfect, harmonious universe put forth by many religious doctrines.

Voltaire in the Context of Ancient Greek Philosophy

Some of the most notable ancient Greek Philosophers (Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle) significantly shaped the later ideas and writings propounded by French Enlightenment thinkers. The Enlightenment, which aimed to depart from various aspects of religious doctrines such as "superstition, enthusiasm, fanaticism, and supernaturalism," was driven by the philosophes.[2] The philosophes, one of whom was Voltaire, aimed to further intellectual spheres by promoting reason, science, and rationalism as the foundations of knowledge.

Socrates, who is widely regarded as the very embodiment of these ideals, was venerated by French Enlightenment philosophers. In fact, Voltaire's contemporaries often likened him to the Socrates of their time, with many others tempted to adopt the same label.[3] Such a desire may be observed in the writings of Denis Diderot, who penned in a manuscript: "'As he faced death, Socrates was regarded in Athens as we are today in Paris ... My dear friends, may we in every way be like Socrates, just as his reputation resembled ours at the hour of his death,'"[3]

Voltaire, however, was not nearly as outspoken. Voltaire's attitude towards Socrates may only be inferred from his writings, where Socrates was frequently a subject of discussion.[3] Russel Goulbourne attempts to dissect this ambiguity in his book, Socrates from Antiquity to Enlightenment. He is particular drawn to an excerpt from a letter written by Voltaire in 1737 who, the year prior, was gifted a gold bust of Socrates by the crown prince of Prussia: "This present has prompted me to reread everything Plato says about Socrates," [3] Moreover, Socrates was the subject of a comedy written by Voltaire, aptly named Socrate. At surface value, this might suggest that, like Diderot, Voltaire revered Socrates; however, many historians would suggest that he was actually quite ambivalent about him.[4]

According to Goulbourne, Voltaire's rereading of Plato—specifically the Platonic dialogues—informed his perspectives on religion.[3] However, that is not to suggest that Voltaire was particularly fond of Plato's work; quite the contrary, he, among many other philosophes, considered Plato a sophist.[4]

Platonism at this time was widely regarded as "a religion that men professed from its establishment, without interruption, until lately" (trans.)[4] That is to say, Plato's philosophy reaffirmed the hierarchical structures established by religion by suggesting that philosophical inquiry should be reserved to those capable of understanding it.[4] This stance ran contrary to Enlightenment ideals and was therefore shunned by many. Voltaire was among those who disapproved of Platonism, criticizing Plato's "inintelligibility and 'galimathias' as significant pitfalls.[4] He rejected the obscurity and "inintelligibility" contained within some of Plato's most notable works, particularly Timaeus (which inspired "Plato's Dream") and the Republic, for their complicated metaphysical teachings. He viewed the foundations of Platonism as "hubristic" and convoluted.[4]

Themes

Religion

"Plato's Dream" is a critical philosophical exploration of religion and its core teachings. While not explicitly stated, Voltaire himself was highly critical of Christianity (more specifically, authority figures within the church),[5] a stance evident in his seminal work, Candide, published in 1759.

He directly addressed his distaste for the clergy in the Philosophical Letters, most notably in the fifth letter. In it, he portrayed the clergy as a fundamentally corrupt institution, and furthermore depicted religion as a mechanism of reinforcing a social "hierarchy".[6] In this view, the clergy, and religion more broadly, reaffirms ignorance of social realities by passing off religious teachings as objective truths.[5]

However, in "Plato's Dream," Voltaire chose to focus more so on the philosophical foundations of religious beliefs, rather than religion as a social institution. He inquired into the existence of God by examining all the imperfection and suffering inherent in the world: "You certainly were not willing that there should remain any great number of these animals on Earth at once; for, over the course of a given year, smallpox will regularly carry off a tenth of the species, and sister maladies will taint the springs of life in the remainder".[1] He further detailed the capriciousness of mankind, maintaining that humans themselves contribute to their own suffering.[1] That said, religion plays a central role in shaping the narrative's critique of Religion. For Voltaire, religion not only perpetuates ignorance, it also directly contradicts its purported aim of spreading the benevolent teachings of God.

Dreams

Voltaire opened the narrative by stating that "In ancient times, dreams were much revered, and Plato was one of the greatest dreamers."[1] This assertion, though it appears to be clothed with a layer of sarcasm, enhances the intricacy of the narrative, as most ancient Greeks interpreted dreams as prophetic messages from the gods.[7] This not only adds a layer of depth to his overarching critique of religious practitioners, but also very subtly critiques society's inclination to seek out religious, as opposed to rational, explanations of social or natural phenomenon.

Ignorance versus enlightenment

At the end of the story, Voltaire alludes to Plato's allegory of the cave: "Demiurgos scowled, and with that Plato awoke. Or did he?" Much like Voltaire's use of a dream as figurative and metaphorical device, Plato employed imagery of a cave to represent ignorance.[8] Those who partake in a "cavic existence"[8] only know what life is like inside the cave. They accept the illusions within the cave's walls as truth, rarely ever stopping to question what life might be like beyond their own echo-chamber.[8] Really, it is a demonstration of two vastly different "states of consciousness," where one man becomes aware of the life beyond his familiar existence, while the other remains trapped by his own ignorance.[8]

This idea is inextricably linked to Voltaire's brief mention of ancient Greek perspectives on dreams, as Voltaire too views willful ignorance as an affront to reason.

See also

References

  1. ^ a b c d e "Plato's Dream, Voltaire, 1756". websites.umich.edu. Retrieved 2024-12-19.
  2. ^ Bristow, William (2023), Zalta, Edward N.; Nodelman, Uri (eds.), "Enlightenment", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2023 ed.), Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, retrieved 2024-12-20
  3. ^ a b c d e Trapp, Michael B. (2007). Socrates from antiquity to the englightenment. Centre for hellenic studies. Aldershot: Ashgate. ISBN 978-0-7546-4124-7.
  4. ^ a b c d e f Bourgault, Sophie (2010). "Appeals to Antiquity: Reflections on some French Enlightenment Readings of Socrates and Plato". Lumen: Selected Proceedings from the Canadian Society for Eighteenth-Century Studies / Lumen: travaux choisis de la Société canadienne d'étude du dix-huitième siècle. 29: 43–58. doi:10.7202/1012025ar. ISSN 1209-3696.
  5. ^ a b Shank, J.B. (2024), "Voltaire", in Zalta, Edward N.; Nodelman, Uri (eds.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2024 ed.), Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, retrieved 2024-12-19
  6. ^ Voltaire (2007). Philosophical Letters. HackettPublishingCompany. pp. 15–17. ISBN 978-0-87220-882-7.
  7. ^ Barbera, Joseph (2008-12-01). "Sleep and dreaming in Greek and Roman philosophy". Sleep Medicine. 9 (8): 906–910. doi:10.1016/j.sleep.2007.10.010. ISSN 1389-9457. PMID 19014776.
  8. ^ a b c d "Allegory of the Cave". Humanities/Philosophy. Retrieved 2024-12-19.

Read other articles:

Cari artikel bahasa  Cari berdasarkan kode ISO 639 (Uji coba)  Kolom pencarian ini hanya didukung oleh beberapa antarmuka Halaman bahasa acak Bahasa KerekDituturkan diRusiaWilayahOkrug Otonom ChukotkaEtnisOrang KerekKepunahan2005[1] Rumpun bahasaChukotko-Kamchatka ChukotkaKerek Aspek ketatabahasaanTipologibahasa aglutinatif [sunting di Wikidata]Kode bahasaISO 639-3krkGlottologkere1280[2] Status konservasi Punah EXSingkatan dari Extinct (Punah)Terancam C...

 

Book by Ion Idriess The Nor'-westers First editionAuthorIon IdriessCountryAustraliaLanguageEnglishPublisherAngus and RobertsonPublication date1954 The Nor-'westers : Stories and Sketches of Life in Australia's Out Back is a 1954 book by Ion Idriess.[1][2][3] It consists of a series of sketches by Idriess about the north west of Australia, much of it autobiographical.[4] References ^ Ion Idriess for Collectors. ^ Idriess In The Nor'-West. The Farmer & S...

 

American baseball player (born 1999) Baseball player Henry DavisDavis with the Altoona Curve in 2022Pittsburgh Pirates – No. 32Right fielder / CatcherBorn: (1999-09-21) September 21, 1999 (age 24)Bedford, New York, U.S.Bats: RightThrows: RightMLB debutJune 19, 2023, for the Pittsburgh PiratesMLB statistics (through March 30, 2024)Batting average.211Home runs7Runs batted in24 Teams Pittsburgh Pirates (2023–present) Henry Davis (born September 21, 1999) is an American pr...

Designation for political or class opponents to the ruling power This article is about the epithet. For other uses, see Enemy of the people (disambiguation). Class enemy redirects here. For the Bosnian play, see Class Enemy (play). For the Slovenian film, see Class Enemy (film). Hostis publicus: In the year 49 BCE, the Roman Senate declared Julius Caesar the enemy of the people of Rome The terms enemy of the people and enemy of the nation are designations for the political opponents and for t...

 

Virtual reality headset developed by Sony Interactive Entertainment PlayStation VR2Also known asPS VR2 (abbreviation)DeveloperSony Interactive EntertainmentManufacturerSonyProduct familyPlayStationTypeVirtual reality headsetGeneration2ndRelease dateFebruary 22, 2023 (2023-02-22)Introductory price$549.99 / €599.99 / £529.99Units sold<600,000Units shipped2,000,000DisplayOLED, HDR, 110° field of viewGraphics4K PenTile (2000 × 2040 per eye; 90 or 120 Hz refresh rate)[1&...

 

Questa voce sull'argomento arbitri di calcio norvegesi è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Dag Vidar Hafsås Informazioni personali Arbitro di Calcio Sezione Kolstad Fotball Attività nazionale Anni Campionato Ruolo 2008- Eliteserien Arbitro Attività internazionale 2012-2018 UEFA Arbitro Esordio 5 luglio 2012 Dag Vidar Hafsås (Trondheim, 26 giugno 1973) è un arbitro di calcio norvegese. Carriera Helgerud arbitrò il primo incontro nell'...

Disambiguazione – Se stai cercando altri significati, vedi Secessione dell'Aventino (disambigua). Alcuni parlamentari dell'opposizione mentre discutono sulla proposta di secessione detta dell'Aventino La secessione dell'Aventino fu un atto di protesta attuato a partire dal 27 giugno[1] 1924 dalla Camera dei deputati del Regno d'Italia nei confronti del governo Mussolini in seguito all'uccisione di Giacomo Matteotti avvenuta il 10 giugno dello stesso anno. L'iniziativa, che cons...

 

Administrative county (comitatus) of the Kingdom of Hungary This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Kis-Küküllő County – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (December 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Kis-Küküllő CountyComitatus Cuculiensis Minor (Latin)Kis-Küküll...

 

Halaman ini berisi artikel tentang tim Formula Satu yang dikenal sebagai Force India pada paruh akhir tahun 2018. Untuk tim Formula Satu Force India yang asli, lihat Force India. Untuk tim yang berkompetisi pada tahun 2019 dan 2020, lihat Racing Point F1 Team. Force IndiaNama resmiRacing Point Force India Formula One TeamKantor pusatSilverstone, Britania RayaPendiriLawrence StrollStaf terkenalSteve CurnowAndrew GreenAndy StevensonOtmar SzafnauerPembalap terkenalEsteban OconSergio PérezNama s...

Louisfertcomune (dettagli) Louisfert – Veduta LocalizzazioneStato Francia Regione Paesi della Loira Dipartimento Loira Atlantica ArrondissementChâteaubriant CantoneChâteaubriant TerritorioCoordinate47°41′N 1°26′W / 47.683333°N 1.433333°W47.683333; -1.433333 (Louisfert)Coordinate: 47°41′N 1°26′W / 47.683333°N 1.433333°W47.683333; -1.433333 (Louisfert) Superficie18,16 km² Abitanti916[1] (2009) Densità50,44 ab./...

 

Disambiguazione – Se stai cercando altri significati, vedi Angola (disambigua). Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento Angola non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Commento: Intere sezioni senza fonti Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Angola (dettagli) (dettagli) (LA) Virtus unita fortior(IT) La virtù unita è più forte Angola - Localizzazione Dati amministrativiNome completo...

 

Sports season 2009 F.I.M. Grand Prix motorcycle racing season Previous 2008 Next 2010 2009 World ChampionsValentino Rossi became the MotoGP World ChampionHiroshi Aoyama became the 250cc World ChampionJulián Simón became the 125cc World Champion The 2009 Grand Prix motorcycle racing season was the 61st F.I.M. Road Racing World Championship season. The season consisted out of 17 races for the MotoGP class and 16 for the 125cc and 250cc classes, beginning with the Qatar motorcycle Grand Prix o...

هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (مارس 2016) وقت السلام أو وقت السلم أو زمن السلام أو زمن السلم هو مصطلح سياسي يستخدم للتمييز بين فترة السلام والحرب ويدل على فترة تخلو منها الصارعات بين جهتين أو أكثر، ويس...

 

nyambek Nyambek merupakan hewan yang sangat lucu, juga merupakan nama sebuah kepulauan di Jawa Barat, Indonesia. Untuk kegunaan lain, lihat Biawak (disambiguasi). Biawak Komodo (Varanus komodoensis) Klasifikasi ilmiah Kerajaan: Animalia Filum: Chordata Kelas: Reptilia Ordo: Squamata Subordo: Sauria Infraordo: Anguimorpha Superfamili: Varanoidea Famili: Varanidae(Merrem, 1820) Genus: VaranusMerrem, 1820 Spesies Lihat pada teks. Biawak adalah kelompok kadal berukuran menengah dan besar yang ter...

 

International rowing regatta 2013 World Rowing ChampionshipsVenueTangeum LakeLocationChungju, South KoreaDates25 August to 1 SeptemberCompetitors878 from 73 nations← 2012 Plovdiv2014 Amsterdam → The 2013 World Rowing Championships were World Rowing Championships that were held from 25 August to 1 September 2013 at Tangeum Lake, Chungju in South Korea.[1][2] The annual week-long rowing regatta was organized by FISA (the International Rowing ...

.paris البلد فرنسا  تعديل مصدري - تعديل   Paris. هو اسم نطاق المستوى الأعلى لمدينة باريس، فرنسا. وقد أدخلَ في يونيو 2008 من قبل آيكان، وأول 100 عنوان ويب.paris سجلَ منتصف عام 2014. وقد أصبح النطاق في المتناول العام في الثاني من ديسمبر 2014. وهو أول نطاق لمدينة في فرنسا.[1] و�...

 

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Amédée de Savoie. Amédée VII de Savoie Amédée VII de Savoie, dit le comte rouge Titre Comte de Savoie 1er mars 1383 – 1er novembre 1391(8 ans et 8 mois) Prédécesseur Amédée VI Successeur Amédée VIII Biographie Dynastie Maison de Savoie Date de naissance 24 février 1360 Lieu de naissance Château d'Aveillane Date de décès 1er novembre 1391 (à 31 ans) Lieu de décès Château de Ripaille (Savoie) Sépulture Abbaye d'Hautecombe ...

 

Ein Pfahlbautendorf der Orang Laut auf den Riau-Inseln Siedlung von Urak Lawoi auf Ko Adang (Nationalpark Tarutao) Die Orang Laut, auch „Seevolk“ genannt, sind ein Überbegriff für ethnischen Gruppen, die in den Küstengewässern des südöstlichen Sumatra, Batam, dem südlichen Johor und den Riau-Inseln von Indonesien leben.[1] Aufgrund ihrer Lebensweise in Booten zählten sie zu den sogenannten Seenomaden. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Ethnologische Abgrenzung 2 Etymologie 3 Geschichte ...

Popular revolt in England, 1450 For the American Civil War scout, see Jack Cade (scout). Jack Cade's RebellionJack Cade's Rebellion, depicted in a mural of the history of the Old Kent RoadDate1450LocationSouth-east EnglandResulted inGovernment victoryParties England City of London Jack Cade's Rebels Lead figures Henry VI of England Jack Cade  † Casualties and losses 40 London citizens 200 Rebels Lord Saye and Sele brought before Jack Cade, painting by Charles Lucy Jack Cade's Rebel...

 

この項目では、1337年 - 1453年にフランスとイギリスで実際におきた戦争について説明しています。 18世紀の戦争については「第2次百年戦争」をご覧ください。 装甲騎兵ボトムズでの架空の戦争については「百年戦争 (装甲騎兵ボトムズ)」をご覧ください。 この記事は検証可能な参考文献や出典が全く示されていないか、不十分です。 出典を追加して記事の信頼性向上�...