He was appointed Minister for Education, Culture, Youth Affairs, Fisheries and Agriculture from 2019.[10][11] He was the acting Premier during the arrest of Andrew Fahie in April 2022 on drug trafficking and money laundering charges in Miami, United States.[7] A Commission of Inquiry into corruption in the British Virgin Islands found that there were "appalling" failures in the islands' governance and a "high likelihood" of serious corruption, with the inquiry recommending the partial suspension of the islands’ constitution and the imposition of direct British rule of the islands for up to two years. He opposes direct rule from London during the crisis.[12][13] On 5 May 2022, he brought a motion of no confidence against his own government for the removal of Andrew Fahie as Premier.[14] The motion was passed unanimously. Wheatley was sworn in as Premier on the same day.[15]