Libel tourism

Libel tourism is a term, first coined by Geoffrey Robertson, to describe forum shopping for libel suits. It particularly refers to the practice of pursuing a case in England and Wales, in preference to other jurisdictions, such as the United States, which provide more extensive defenses for those accused of making derogatory statements.[1]

A critic of English defamation law, journalist Geoffrey Wheatcroft attributes the practice to the introduction of no win no fee agreements, the presumption that derogatory statements are false, the difficulty of establishing fair comment and "the caprice of juries and the malice of judges."[2] Wheatcroft contrasts this with United States law since the New York Times Co. v. Sullivan case. "Any American public figure bringing an action now has to prove that what was written was not only untrue but published maliciously and recklessly."[2]

Two other critics of English defamation law, the US lawyers Samuel A. Abady and Harvey Silverglate, have cited the example of Irish–Saudi businessman Khalid bin Mahfouz, who by the time of his death in 2009, had threatened suit more than 40 times in England against those who accused him of funding terrorism.[3] Mahfouz also took legal action in Belgium, France and Switzerland against those repeating the accusations. George W. Bush advisor Richard Perle threatened to sue investigative reporter Seymour Hersh in London, because of a series of critical articles Hersh had written about him.[4]

A series of cases involving US citizens being sued in English courts led to new laws in both countries. In the United States, the SPEECH Act unanimously passed the US Congress, which makes foreign defamation judgments unenforceable in US courts if they do not meet US free speech standards. In England and Wales, the Defamation Act 2013 requires plaintiffs to show that England is the proper jurisdiction to hear a case when the defendant does not live in England or Wales.

Case law

Berezovsky v Michaels

Main article: Berezovsky v Michaels

In 2000, the House of Lords gave Boris Berezovsky and Nikolai Glushkov permission to sue Forbes for libel in the English courts.[5] In 2003, the case was settled when Forbes offered a partial retraction.[6][7]

The issues relating to jurisdiction of the English courts in such actions were appealed to the House of Lords, at that time the highest court in England and Wales, making this the key test case on libel tourism.[8][9][10]

The Ehrenfeld case

Further information: Funding Evil § Libel controversy

Khalid bin Mahfouz and two members of his family sued Rachel Ehrenfeld, an Israeli-born writer and United States citizen, over her 2003 book on terrorist financing, Funding Evil, which asserted that Mahfouz and his family provided financial support to Islamic terrorist groups.[11] The book was not published in Britain,[12]: 31  although 23 copies of her book had been purchased online in the UK,[13] and excerpts from the book had been published globally on the ABC News web site.[14] Ehrenfeld was advised by English lawyer Mark Stephens to claim that the suit in England violated her First Amendment rights under the U.S. Constitution and chose not to defend the action.[citation needed] Instead, she countersued in the U.S.[15] In his 2005 judgment, Justice Eady criticised Dr. Ehrenfeld for attempting to cash in on the libel action without being prepared to defend it on its merits and specifically rebutted her suggestion of forum shopping. Eady ruled that Ehrenfeld should pay £10,000 to each claimant plus costs, apologize for false allegations and destroy existing copies of her book.[14]

Eady has been internationally criticized[16] for his perceived bias in the case and his general restrictive approach to free speech. Additionally, the libel laws which were applied came under scrutiny in England, where calls for libel law reform increased after Ehrenfeld's case. Analyzing English libel law, the United Nations Human Rights Committee cautioned that: "practical application of the law of libel has served to discourage critical media reporting on matters of serious public interest, adversely affecting the ability of scholars and journalists to publish their work, including through the phenomenon known as 'libel tourism.' The advent of the internet and the international distribution of foreign media also create the danger that a State party's unduly restrictive libel law will affect freedom of expression worldwide on matters of valid public interest."[17]

Laws addressing libel tourism

England and Wales

On 1 January 2014, the Defamation Act 2013 came into force, requiring plaintiffs who bring actions in the courts of England and Wales alleging libel by defendants who do not live in Europe to demonstrate that the court is the most appropriate place to bring the action. Serious harm to an individual's reputation or serious financial harm to a corporation must also be proven. Good faith belief that a disclosure was in the public interest was made a defense.[18]

United States

Federal

The Free Speech Protection Act of 2008 and 2009 were both bills aimed at addressing libel tourism by barring U.S. courts from enforcing libel judgments issued in foreign courts against U.S. residents, if the speech would not be libelous under American law. These protections were passed in the 2010 SPEECH Act which passed unanimously in both the House of Representatives and the Senate before being signed by US President Barack Obama on 10 August 2010.[19][20]

New York

In late December 2007, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, based on a decision by the New York State Court of Appeals, ruled that the state's current "long-arm" statutes governing business transactions did not give it jurisdiction to protect author Ehrenfeld.[21] The court noted, however, that if the law were to change, Ehrenfeld could go back to court.

On 13 January 2008, two members of the New York State Legislature, Assemblyman Rory I. Lancman (D-Queens) and Senator Dean Skelos (R-LI), introduced a "Libel Terrorism Protection Act" in both legislative houses (bills no. A09652 and S 6676-B)[22] to amend the New York civil procedures in response to the Ehrenfeld case. The bill passed the New York state legislature on a rare unanimous vote,[23] and on 29 April 2008, Gov. Paterson signed the bill into law.[24] The Libel Terrorism Protection Act enables New York courts to assert jurisdiction over anyone who obtains a foreign libel judgment against a New York publisher or writer, and to limit enforcement to those judgments that satisfy "the freedom of speech and press protections guaranteed by both the United States and New York Constitutions."[25]

California

In October 2009, California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger signed into law protections against libel tourism (California's Libel Tourism Act) that took effect 1 January 2010. The Act provides that California courts shall not recognize a foreign-country judgment if "the judgment includes recovery for a claim of defamation unless the court determines that the defamation law applied by the foreign court provided at least as much protection for freedom of speech and the press as provided by both the United States and California Constitutions" (C.C.P. sec. 1716(c)(9)) and other protections.[26] The law received significant bi-partisan support.[27]

Illinois

In August 2008, Illinois enacted a libel tourism law that is similar to the statute passed in New York.[28][29]

Florida

In May 2009, Florida also enacted a libel tourism law similar to the law passed in New York.[30]

See also

References

  1. ^ Libel Tourism Chills Investigative Journalism Archived 24 November 2010 at the Wayback Machine
  2. ^ a b Wheatcroft, Geoffrey (28 February 2008). "The worst case scenario". The Guardian. p. 32. Retrieved 17 April 2008.
  3. ^ Samuel A. Abady; Harvey Silverglate (7 November 2006). "'Libel tourism' and the War on Terror". Boston Globe. Retrieved 17 April 2008.
  4. ^ Berlins, Marcel. Index on Censorship, July 2004, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p18-20
  5. ^ "Judgments - Berezovsky v. Michaels and Others Glouchkov v. Michaels and Others (Consolidated Appeals)". publications.parliament.uk. 11 May 2000. Retrieved 19 September 2011.
  6. ^ "Shuddup". The Economist. 13 March 2003.
  7. ^ The following statement appended to the article on the Forbes website summarises: 'On 6 March 2003 the resolution of the case was announced in the High Court in London. FORBES stated in open court that (1) it was not the magazine's intention to state that Berezovsky was responsible for the murder of Listiev, only that he had been included in an inconclusive police investigation of the crime; (2) there is no evidence that Berezovsky was responsible for this or any other murder; (3) in light of the English court's ruling, it was wrong to characterize Berezovsky as a mafia boss. "Berezovsky Vs. Forbes" Forbes 31 March 2003
  8. ^ Delta, George B.; Matsuura, Jeffrey H. (2008). "Jurisdictional issues in cyberspace". Law of the Internet. Vol. 1 (3rd ed.). Aspen Publishers. pp. 3–92. ISBN 978-0-7355-7559-2. Berezovsky is the leading case in what has come to be known as "libel tourism
  9. ^ Crook, Tim (2010). "Defamation law". Comparative media law and ethics. Taylor & Francis. pp. 240–241. ISBN 978-0-415-55161-8.
  10. ^ Taylor, Daniel C. (November 2010). "Libel Tourism: Protecting Authors and Preserving Comity" (PDF). Georgetown Law Journal. 99: 194. ISSN 0016-8092. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2 January 2014. Retrieved 23 September 2011.
  11. ^ "Britain, a destination for "libel tourism"". Archived from the original on 23 January 2008. Retrieved 6 March 2008.
  12. ^ Hartley, Trevor C. (2010). "'Libel Tourism' and Conflict of Laws". The International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 59 (1): 25–38. doi:10.1017/S0020589309990029. ISSN 0020-5893. JSTOR 25622268.
  13. ^ "New York state lawmakers offer legislation to protect authors". Foster's Daily Democrat. 14 January 2008. Archived from the original on 9 September 2023. Retrieved 9 September 2023.
  14. ^ a b Full text of the High Court judgment, 3 May 2005
  15. ^ Pallister, David (15 November 2007). "US author mounts 'libel tourism' challenge". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 8 April 2023. Retrieved 9 September 2023.
  16. ^ "How our senior libel judge stamps on free speech – all over the world | George Monbiot". TheGuardian.com. 19 October 2009.
  17. ^ "Concluding Observations of the Human Rights Committee". University of Minnesota Human Rights Library. 30 July 2008. Archived from the original on 7 June 2011. Retrieved 15 July 2010.
  18. ^ Sarah Lyall (25 April 2013). "Libel Cases Now Harder to Bring in England". The New York Times. Retrieved 26 April 2013.
  19. ^ Meisel, Aylana (3 August 2010). "Congress Unites to Pass Bill Protecting American Authors and Publishers". The Cutting Edge. Retrieved 11 August 2010.
  20. ^ Greenslade, Roy (11 August 2010). "Obama seals off US journalists and authors from Britain's libel laws". The Guardian. Retrieved 11 August 2010.
  21. ^ N.Y. Court of Appeals ruling, 20 December 2007
  22. ^ Alyssa A. Lappen, "America's First Amendment lifeline", Human Events, 25 January 2008
  23. ^ Matthew Pollack (1 April 2008). "New York strikes back against libel tourism". Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.
  24. ^ "Gov. Paterson signs legislation". 1 May 2008. Archived from the original on 29 January 2010.
  25. ^ Samuel A. Abady; Harvey Silverglate (25 February 2008). "Rachel's Law: NY's 'Libel-Tourism' Fix". New York Post.
  26. ^ Cal. Code of Civil Procedure sections 1716 and 1717, as amended by Chapter 579, Statutes of 2009 (SB 320 - Corbett). http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/pub/09-10/bill/sen/sb_0301-0350/sb_320_bill_20091011_chaptered.pdf
  27. ^ CA Leg Counsel bill/vote records
  28. ^ 735 Ill. Comp. Stat 5/12-621 (b)(7) (2009)
  29. ^ 735 Ill. Comp. Stat. 5/2-209 (b-5) (2009)
  30. ^ Florida Statutes 55.605 (2)(h); 55.6055

Further reading

  • Barbour, Emily C. The SPEECH Act: The Federal Response to "Libel Tourism". Washington, D.C.: Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress, 2010.
  • Bell, Avi. Libel Tourism: International Forum Shopping for Defamation Claims. Jerusalem: Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 2008.
  • Brower, Amy J. Libel Tourism and Foreign Libel Lawsuits. New York: Nova Science Publishers, 2011.
  • Henning, Anna C., and Vivian S. Chu. "Libel Tourism" Background and Legal Issues. Washington, D.C.: Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress, 2009.
  • Melkonian, Harry. Defamation, Libel Tourism and the SPEECH Act of 2010: The First Amendment Colliding with the Common Law. Amherst, NY: Cambria Press, 2011.
  • Packard, Ashley. Digital Media Law. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, 2013.

Read other articles:

Sultanat de Sennar

Sultanat de Sennar 1504–1821 Le sultanat de Sennar et ses voisins vers 1750Informations générales Statut Monarchie Capitale Sannar (après 1790) Langue(s) Arabe Monnaie Troc Histoire et événements 1504 Établissement 1821 Démantèlement Sultan (1e) 1504 Amara Dunqas (De) 1821 Badi VII Entités précédentes : Peuple Funj MakurieAlodie Entités suivantes : Égypte ottomane Khédivat d'Égypte modifier - modifier le code - voir Wikidata (aide) Le sultanat (des) Funj de Sennar ...

 

 

Sakura Trick

Sakura Trick桜Trick(Sakura Torikku)GenreKomedi romantis[1]Penggalan kehidupan[2]Yuri[1] MangaPengarangTachiPenerbitHoubunshaMajalahManga Time Kirara Miracle!DemografiSeinenTerbitMarch 17, 2011 – August 18, 2017Volume8 Seri animeSutradaraKenichi IshikuraProduserHiroyuki KobayashiJunichirō TanakaNobumitsu UrasakiMasashi TakatoriEriko AokiSkenarioKenichi IshikuraMusikRyōsuke NakanishiStudioStudio DeenPelisensiAUS HanabeeNA Sentai FilmworksUK MVM FilmsSaluranasliTBS, ...

 

 

Charles Wheatstone

Charles WheatstoneCharles WheatstoneBiographieNaissance 6 février 1802GloucesterDécès 19 octobre 1875 (à 73 ans)1er arrondissement de ParisNationalité Royaume-UniDomicile Royaume-Uni de Grande-Bretagne et d'IrlandeActivités Cryptographe, inventeur, fabricant d'instruments de musique, physicien, mathématicien, photographeAutres informationsA travaillé pour King's College de LondresMembre de Royal Society (1836)Académie des sciences de Turin (1845)Académie royale des science...

Reductive elimination

Type of reaction in organometallic chemistry Reductive elimination is an elementary step in organometallic chemistry in which the oxidation state of the metal center decreases while forming a new covalent bond between two ligands. It is the microscopic reverse of oxidative addition, and is often the product-forming step in many catalytic processes. Since oxidative addition and reductive elimination are reverse reactions, the same mechanisms apply for both processes, and the product equilibriu...

 

 

Lir

Wisatawan memutar lir. Bagian tali yang dikencangkan akan mengikat kapal ke dermaga, mengangkat layar depan, mengangkat tiang ke posisinya di tiang atau untuk memindahkan muatan ke atau dari dermaga atau pemantik api . Lir adalah mesin berputar berporos vertikal yang dikembangkan untuk digunakan di kapal layar guna melipatgandakan gaya tarik pelaut saat mengangkut tali, kabel, dan tali tambang . Prinsipnya mirip dengan mesin kerek, yaitu memiliki poros horizontal. Sejarah Bentuk awal Pada ben...

 

 

فأر الجذور

هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (مارس 2018) اضغط هنا للاطلاع على كيفية قراءة التصنيف فأر الجذور   المرتبة التصنيفية جنس[1][2]  التصنيف العلمي  فوق النطاق  حيويات مملكة عليا  خيطانيات �...

Saint-Paul (La Réunion)

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Saint-Paul. Saint-Paul Vue sur le centre-ville et la baie de Saint-Paul. Blason Administration Pays France Région La Réunion Département La Réunion (sous-préfecture) Arrondissement Saint-Paul (chef-lieu) Intercommunalité Territoire de la Côte Ouest Maire Mandat Emmanuel Séraphin (PLR) 2021-2026 Code postal 97460, 97411, 97422, 97423, 97434 et 97435 Code commune 97415 Démographie Gentilé Saint-Paulois Populationmunicipale 105 240 hab. (202...

 

 

Alto Velo Claim

Territorial dispute in the Caribbean The Alto Velo Claim, also referred to as the Alta Vela Affair, was a territorial claim against the Dominican government by American adventurers ejected from Alto Velo Island by Dominican officials in October 1860. In all, three companies claimed U.S. protection of their right to mine guano from the island under the Guano Islands Act of 1856, but the U.S. Department of State never recognized U.S. interests in the island. Claim dispute An 1868 newspaper adve...

 

 

Rules of Go

Details of the rules for the abstract strategy board game for two players For a general overview of the rules of go, see Go (game). Part of a series onGo Game specifics Rules Handicaps professional Proverbs List of terms Strategy and tactics Opening (theory; strategy) Fuseki (whole-board openings) Joseki (corner-based openings) Life and death Tsumego (Go puzzles) History and culture History Equipment Variants Four go houses List of games Players and organizations Players European Female Ranks...

Éamonn Ceannt

Irish republican (1881–1916) Éamonn CeanntBorn(1881-09-21)21 September 1881Ballymoe, County Galway, IrelandDied8 May 1916(1916-05-08) (aged 34)Kilmainham Gaol, Dublin, IrelandCause of deathExecution by firing squadBuriedArbour Hill Prison, DublinAllegianceIrish VolunteersIrish Republican BrotherhoodYears of service1913–1916RankCommandantCommands held4th BattalionBattles/warsEaster RisingSpouse(s)Áine Ceannt Éamonn Ceannt (21 September 1881 – 8 May 1916), born Edward Th...

 

 

コルク

この記事は検証可能な参考文献や出典が全く示されていないか、不十分です。出典を追加して記事の信頼性向上にご協力ください。（このテンプレートの使い方）出典検索?: コルク – ニュース · 書籍 · スカラー · CiNii · J-STAGE · NDL · dlib.jp · ジャパンサーチ · TWL（2017年4月） コルクを打ち抜いて作った瓶の栓 コルク（木栓、�...

 

 

Manifeste des Seize

Le Libertaire du 1er août 1914, ultime numéro avant la Première Guerre mondiale. La Guerre Sociale. 1er aout 1914, au lendemain de l’assassinat de Jaurès. Le Manifeste des Seize est rédigé en 1916 par Pierre Kropotkine et Jean Grave puis signé par 16 personnalités du mouvement libertaire, qui prennent parti pour le camp des Alliés et contre l’« agression allemande » lors de la Première Guerre mondiale[1]. La liste comporte une dizaine de signataires importants. Dat�...

Legione Volontaria Italiana

Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento unità militari non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Legione Volontaria Italiana(AF) Italiaansche Verkennings Corp  Sudafricatrad. Corpo di ricognizione italiano Il generale Louis Botha capo della Legione Volontaria Italiana nella seconda guerra boera D...

 

 

Репьёвский район

муниципальный районРепьёвский район Флаг Герб 51°04′40″ с. ш. 38°38′00″ в. д.HGЯO Страна  Россия Входит в Воронежскую область Включает 11 муниципальных образований Адм. центр село Репьёвка Глава администрации Ефименко Роман Витальевич Глава района Рахманин�...

 

 

哈萨克斯坦总统

此条目序言章节没有充分总结全文内容要点。 (2019年3月21日)请考虑扩充序言，清晰概述条目所有重點。请在条目的讨论页讨论此问题。 哈萨克斯坦總統哈薩克總統旗現任Қасым-Жомарт Кемелұлы Тоқаев卡瑟姆若马尔特·托卡耶夫自2019年3月20日在任任期7年首任努尔苏丹·纳扎尔巴耶夫设立1990年4月24日（哈薩克蘇維埃社會主義共和國總統） 哈萨克斯坦 哈萨克斯坦政府...

1964 North Carolina lieutenant gubernatorial election

1964 North Carolina lieutenant gubernatorial election ← 1960 November 3, 1964 1968 →   Nominee Robert W. Scott Clifford L. Bell Party Democratic Republican Popular vote 815,994 526,727 Percentage 60.77% 39.23% Lieutenant Governor before election Harvey Cloyd Philpott Democratic Elected Lieutenant Governor Robert W. Scott Democratic Elections in North Carolina Federal government U.S. President 1792 1796 1800 1804 1808 1812 1816 1820 1824 1828 1832 1836 1840 184...

 

 

Baiersdorf

Baiersdorf. Baiersdorf adalah kota yang terletak di distrik Erlangen-Höchstadt di Bavaria, Jerman. Kota Baiersdorf memiliki luas sebesar 11.79 km². Baiersdorf pada tahun 2006, memiliki penduduk sebanyak 7.106 jiwa. lbsKota dan kotamadya di Erlangen-HöchstadtAdelsdorf | Aurachtal | Baiersdorf | Bubenreuth | Buckenhof | Eckental | Gremsdorf | Großenseebach | Hemhofen | Heroldsberg | Herzogenaurach | Heßdorf | Höchstadt an de...

 

 

2019–20 Angola Super Cup

Football match2019 Angola Super Cup Desportivo da Huíla Primeiro de Agosto Taça Angola Girabola 1 2 on aggregateFirst leg Desportivo da Huíla Primeiro de Agosto 1 0 Date3 August 2019VenueEstádio do Ferrovia, LubangoRefereeJoão GomaSecond leg Primeiro de Agosto Desportivo da Huíla 2 0 Date5 August 2019VenueEstádio 11 de Novembro, LuandaRefereeAntónio Cachala← 2017 2021–22 → The 2019–20 Supertaça de Angola (30th edition) was contested by Primeiro de Agosto, the 2018–1...

The Clouds

Comedy by Aristophanes This article is about the play by Aristophanes. For other uses, see Cloud (disambiguation). The CloudsStrepsiades, his son, and Socrates (from a 16th-century engraving)Written byAristophanesChorusClouds (goddesses)Characters Strepsiades an elderly farmer Pheidippides his son Slave Two Students at The Thinkery Socrates the philosopher Superior Argument (Right) Inferior Argument (Wrong) First Creditor Second Creditor Chaerephon the philosopher Silent roles Witness brought...

 

 

カタルーニャ州

「カタロニア」はこの項目へ転送されています。インキャット社建造の双胴船については「カタロニア (双胴船)」をご覧ください。 カタルーニャ州CatalunyaCataluñaCatalonha 自治州 旗紋章 歌：Els Segadors (カタルーニャ語)収穫人たち スペインにおけるカタルーニャ州 ヨーロッパにおけるカタルーニャ州 北緯41度49分 東経1度28分 / 北緯41.817度 東経1.467度 / 41.8...