Lane v. Franks

Lane v. Franks
Argued April 29, 2014
Decided June 19, 2014
Full case nameEdward Lane, Petitioner v. Steve Franks
Docket no.13-483
Citations573 U.S. 228 (more)
134 S. Ct. 2369; 189 L. Ed. 2d 312
Case history
PriorLane v. Cent. Ala. Cmty. Coll., 523 F. App'x 709 (11th Cir. 2013); cert. granted, 571 U.S. 1161 (2014).
Holding
Government employee speech that is made during trial is protected citizen speech, and the employee cannot be fired for comments made in that setting
Court membership
Chief Justice
John Roberts
Associate Justices
Antonin Scalia · Anthony Kennedy
Clarence Thomas · Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Stephen Breyer · Samuel Alito
Sonia Sotomayor · Elena Kagan
Case opinions
MajoritySotomayor, joined by unanimous
ConcurrenceThomas, joined by Scalia and Alito

Lane v. Franks, 573 U.S. 228 (2014), is a U.S. Supreme Court case involving public employee's freedom of speech rights. Edward Lane sued Steve Franks for unfairly firing him, out of retaliation for sworn testimony Lane gave during a federal fraud case.[1] The Eleventh Circuit originally ruled in favor of Franks, “denying [Lane] first amendment protection to subpoenaed testimony” (Page 6, section I).[1] The case was argued before the Supreme Court on April 28, 2014. The case was decided on June 19, 2014.[2]

The Supreme Court sided with Lane that he was not responsible for something he said during a federal trial. However, the court could not award damages, because Frank's qualified immunity protected him from being sued in his personal capacity. The case is an important vote of confidence from the Supreme Court about governmental employees not being held responsible for speech that is made as a public citizen on a matter of public concern. It is in line with the Pickering v. Board of Education ruling of 1968 (Opinion para. 1).[3]

Background

Edward Lane accepted a role at Central Alabama Community College (CACC) in 2006, as the director of Community Intensive Training for Youth (CITY). Lane proceeded to terminate Suzanne Schmitz. Schmitz was a state representative and on the programs payroll, despite not performing any duties. Lane was then subpoenaed to testify “regarding the events that led to his terminating Schmitz” in two federal trials for fraud (Section 1, para. 5).[3] In 2009 after the conclusion of the trials Steve Franks, the CACC president, terminated 29 employees.

Lane was among the employees that got termination letters. Franks rescinded 27 of the 29 terminations, but two, including Lane's were not rescinded. Lane then sued Franks in “federal district court and alleged that his termination from the CITY program was in retaliation for his testimony against Schmitz and therefore violated his First Amendment right to free speech. Lane sued Franks in his official and private capacities as the president of CACC.

District Court and Circuit Court rulings

The Federal District Court for the Northern District of Alabama ruled on behalf of Franks. Citing that because Lane learned of the information on the job he was not protected as a citizen on a matter of public concern. They also ruled that Franks was protected because he had qualified immunity. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the district court’s decision.[4]

Supreme Court ruling

“The critical question is whether the speech at issue is itself ordinarily within the scope of an employee’s duties, not whether it merely concerns those duties. Corruption in a public program and misuse of state funds involve matter of significant public concern; the form and context of the speech, sworn testimony in a judicial proceeding, fortify that conclusion” (Summary).[3]

In a unanimous decision on behalf of Franks, the court affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded in part, for further judicial ruling (Section 5, para. 2).[3] The court said that Lane's speech was protected under the first amendment. However, “previous precedent, specifically Morris v. Crow, had held that public employee testimony was unprotected speech, and thus when Franks fired Lane, he was not violating a clearly established constitutional right” (Para. 4).[2]

Since that is the case Franks was entitled to qualified immunity, so the Supreme Court affirmed the Eleventh Circuit’s ruling about “claims against Franks in his individual capacity” (Section 5).[3] The court remanded the case for further proceedings dealing with Frank's defense of sovereign immunity in his official capacities. This ruling does chip away at the precedent set by the Supreme Courts ruling in Garcetti v. Ceballos, just eight years earlier.[4]

Amicus briefs

Multiple amicus briefs were filed, mostly on the part of Lane. Nine briefs were filed in support of Lane, while one was filed in support of Franks. One was filed by the American government on a neutral ground, both advocating for affirming and reversing part of the Eleventh Circuit’s decision.[5] Among the most notable organizations to file briefs in support of Lane were the ACLU, Alliance Defending Freedom, and National Whistle Blowers Center. All three of these amicus briefs, point out the importance of protecting employee speech made in the context of a federal trial. With the ACLU saying “[a]t a minimum, the State of Alabama certainly had no interest in preventing Edward Lane from complying with a subpoena issued by the United States and providing truthful testimony about public corruption in a federal criminal trial” (Page 29).[6]

Media coverage

Multiple media outlets covered the case when it first broke. Those included NPR, The Washington Post, and The New York Times. All of those media outlets applauded the Supreme Court for protecting the public employee's freedom of speech rights, while also noting the hurdle Lane faced in actually winning damages. With the New York Times writing “[w]hile Mr. Lane established an important legal principle, he will not benefit from it. In the second part of her opinion, Justice Sotomayor wrote that Mr. Franks, the official who fired him, was protected by qualified immunity” (Para. 16).[7] There was even a law review done by Thomas A. Schweitzer, of Touro College. The review really sums up the idea that all the decision really did was show the convoluted nature that the courts now have to consider because of previous precedent set in multiple cases, including the Garcetti case. Schweitzer does agree with the court's decision of protecting Mr. Lane's freedom of speech rights.[4] Edward Lane has written a book about his Supreme Court victory in Whistleblower: Having Ethics Regardless of the Outcome.

Subsequent developments

With the case being decided relatively recently, there have not been many subsequent opinions on the matter of governmental employee speech. Lane v. Franks has not been referenced directly in any subsequent court cases, at any level.[citation needed] The most recent development comes from Heffernan v. City of Paterson, decided in April 2016, which dealt with a similar issue. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Heffernan who had been fired because he supported a certain candidate that was running for mayor. Justice Breyer said “The Constitution prohibits a government employer from discharging or demoting an employee because the employee supports a particular political candidate” (Section 2, para. 1).[8]

See also

References

  1. ^ a b Goldstein, Thomas (October 18, 2012). "Petition for Writ of Certiorari" (PDF). amazonnews.com. Retrieved March 28, 2017.
  2. ^ a b "Lane v. Franks". Oyez. Chicago-Kent College of Law. Retrieved March 29, 2017.
  3. ^ a b c d e Lane v. Franks, 573 U.S. 228 (2014).
  4. ^ a b c Schweitzer, Thomas (2015). "Lane v. Franks: The Supreme Court Clarifies Public Employees' Free Speech Rights". Touro Law Review. 31.
  5. ^ "Lane v. Franks - SCOTUSblog". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved March 29, 2017.
  6. ^ Shapiro, Steven (March 10, 2014). "Brief of Amici Curiae American Civil Liberties Union and The American Civil Liberties Union of Alabama in Support of Petitioner" (PDF). www.supremecourtpreview.org. Retrieved March 27, 2017.
  7. ^ Liptak, Adam (June 19, 2014). "Public Worker Testimony Is Protected, Justices Rule". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved March 29, 2017.
  8. ^ Heffernan v. City of Paterson, No. 14-1280, 578 U.S. ___ (2016).

Read other articles:

Untuk lagu karya Lucinda Williams, lihat Car Wheels on a Gravel Road. Drunken AngelPoster teatrikal Jepang asliSutradaraAkira KurosawaProduserSōjirō MotokiDitulis oleh Akira Kurosawa Keinosuke Uegusa Pemeran Takashi Shimura Toshiro Mifune Reizaburo Yamamoto Noriko Sengoku Penata musik Ryōichi Hattori Fumio Hayasaka SinematograferTakeo ItōPenyuntingAkira KurosawaPerusahaanproduksiToho StudiosDistributorTohoTanggal rilis 27 April 1948 (1948-04-27) Durasi98 menitNegaraJepangBahasa...

 

 

Cette page concerne l'année 1552 du calendrier julien. Pour l'année 1552 av. J.-C., voir 1552 av. J.-C. Chronologies 18 octobre : fin du siège d'Eger. Toile de Bertalan Székely, 1867.Données clés 1549 1550 1551  1552  1553 1554 1555Décennies :1520 1530 1540  1550  1560 1570 1580Siècles :XIVe XVe  XVIe  XVIIe XVIIIeMillénaires :-Ier Ier  IIe  IIIe Chronologies thématiques Art Architecture, Arts plastiques (Dessin, Gravure, ...

 

 

Baseball stadium in Fort Myers, Florida City of Palms ParkLocation2201 Edison AveFort Myers, Florida 33901OwnerLee County Sports AuthorityCapacity8,000 (2008)Field sizeLeft Field: 330 ft Center Field: 410 ft Right Field: 330 ftSurfaceGrassConstructionBroke ground1992Opened1993ArchitectPopulousStructural engineerBliss & Nyitray, IncTenantsSpring trainingBoston Red Sox (AL) (1993–2011) Minor League BaseballGCL Red Sox (GCL) (1993–2011) College baseballFlorida SouthWestern State College ...

مسجد عمر مكرم مئذنة مسجد عمر مكرم خلف تمثاله بميدان التحرير إحداثيات 30°02′36″N 31°14′02″E / 30.043232°N 31.233927°E / 30.043232; 31.233927  معلومات عامة القرية أو المدينة ميدان التحرير، القاهرة الدولة مصر معلومات أخرى تعديل مصدري - تعديل   مسجد عمر مكرم أو جامع العبيط، أنشئ في ا�...

 

 

Orsolina della Penna (Perugia, 1500 – 1536?) è stata una nobildonna italiana ed amante dell'imperatore Carlo V. Stemma della Penna Indice 1 Biografia 2 Note 3 Bibliografia 4 Collegamenti esterni Biografia Orsolina della Penna, conosciuta come la bella di Perugia ,[1] fu una nobile ed amante[2] segreta dell'imperatore Carlo V, conosciuto durante un viaggio nelle Fiandre del marito Valentino de’ Cancellieri alla corte di Bruxelles. Qui il marito si ammalò e morì. Orsolina...

 

 

追晉陸軍二級上將趙家驤將軍个人资料出生1910年 大清河南省衛輝府汲縣逝世1958年8月23日(1958歲—08—23)(47—48歲) † 中華民國福建省金門縣国籍 中華民國政党 中國國民黨获奖 青天白日勳章(追贈)军事背景效忠 中華民國服役 國民革命軍 中華民國陸軍服役时间1924年-1958年军衔 二級上將 (追晉)部队四十七師指挥東北剿匪總司令部參謀長陸軍�...

Defunct regional airline of the United States (1985–2007) America West Express IATA ICAO Callsign YVRP ASHCHQ AIR SHUTTLECHATAUQUA Founded1985 (1985)Commenced operations1985 (1985)Ceased operationsSeptember 25, 2007 (2007-09-25)(merged into US Airways Express)HubsPhoenix–Sky HarborSecondary hubsColumbus–GlennLas VegasFrequent-flyer programFlightFundParent companyAmerica West HoldingsHeadquartersTempe, Arizona, United StatesKey peopleDoug Parker (CEO)Derek Kerr (...

 

 

Cercle de l'Union interalliéeHistoireFondation 1917CadreType Club de restaurationForme juridique Association déclaréeDomaine d'activité Restauration traditionnelleSiège 8e arrondissement de ParisPays  FranceCoordonnées 48° 52′ 09″ N, 2° 19′ 12″ EOrganisationMembres 3 300Site web union-interalliee.frIdentifiantsRNA W751003921SIREN 784329161modifier - modifier le code - modifier Wikidata Le cercle de l'Union interalliée est un club social...

 

 

Questa voce sull'argomento cestisti montenegrini è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Milko Bjelica Nazionalità  Jugoslavia Serbia e Montenegro Montenegro Altezza 207 cm Peso 102 kg Pallacanestro Ruolo Ala grande / centro Squadra  Al-Ittihad Gedda CarrieraSquadre di club 2001-2006 Stella Rossa2006-2007 Braunschweig33 (395)2007-2008 Colonia 99ers33 (437)200...

此條目需要补充更多来源。 (2021年7月4日)请协助補充多方面可靠来源以改善这篇条目,无法查证的内容可能會因為异议提出而被移除。致使用者:请搜索一下条目的标题(来源搜索:美国众议院 — 网页、新闻、书籍、学术、图像),以检查网络上是否存在该主题的更多可靠来源(判定指引)。 美國眾議院 United States House of Representatives第118届美国国会众议院徽章 众议院旗...

 

 

KehormatanGenre Drama Roman Komedi PembuatMultivision PlusPemeran Primus Yustisio Nafa Urbach Tia Ivanka Reynold Surbakti Febby Febiola Pangky Suwito Ayu Diah Pasha Cut Yanthi Vicky Burky Ine Dewi Arief Rivan David Chalik Happy Salma Geofanny Tambunan Baby Gracia Doly Sihombing Teuku Sadiq Atiq Rachman Lagu pembukaKu Lakukan Semua Untukmu oleh Fatur & NadilaLagu penutupTak 'Kan oleh DeffianiePenata musik Iwang Modulus [a] Joseph S. Djafar [b] Negara asalIndonesiaBah...

 

 

Частина серії проФілософіяLeft to right: Plato, Kant, Nietzsche, Buddha, Confucius, AverroesПлатонКантНіцшеБуддаКонфуційАверроес Філософи Епістемологи Естетики Етики Логіки Метафізики Соціально-політичні філософи Традиції Аналітична Арістотелівська Африканська Близькосхідна іранська Буддій�...

GFOA Logo The Government Finance Officers Association (or GFOA) is a professional association of approximately 19,000 state, provincial, and local government finance officers in the United States and Canada. GFOA is headquartered in downtown Chicago. Name The original predecessor of GFOA was the National Association of Comptrollers and Accounting Officers which was formed in February 1906. Its name was changed in December 1931 to the International Association of Municipal Finance Officers. In...

 

 

Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento unità militari non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento guerra ha problemi di struttura e di organizzazione delle informazioni. Motivo: Perché l'Italia è in una sezione a parte? Risistema la struttura espositiva, logi...

 

 

غينوييو   الاسم الرسمي (بالفرنسية: Genouilleux)‏  الإحداثيات 46°07′08″N 4°47′13″E / 46.118888888889°N 4.7869444444444°E / 46.118888888889; 4.7869444444444 [1]  [2] تقسيم إداري  البلد فرنسا[3]  التقسيم الأعلى آن  خصائص جغرافية  المساحة 4.08 كيلومتر مربع[1]  عدد السكان  �...

عماد خميس رئيس وزراء سورية 67 في المنصب3 تموز 2016 – 11 يونيو 2020 الرئيس بشار الأسد نائب رئيس مجلس الوزراء وليد المعلم وائل الحلقي حسين عرنوس وزير الكهرباء في المنصب14 نيسان 2011 – 3 تموز 2016 رئيس الوزراء عادل سفررياض فريد حجابوائل الحلقي أحمد قصي كيالي محمد زهير الخربوطلي مدير عام ...

 

 

此條目需要擴充。 (2012年11月12日)请協助改善这篇條目,更進一步的信息可能會在討論頁或扩充请求中找到。请在擴充條目後將此模板移除。 新熱帶界 新熱帶界,是组成地球陆地表面的八个生物地理分布区之一。它包括热带美洲大陆的热带陆地生态区和南美洲全部温带区。 概况 在生物地理学中,新热带界是八个陆地生物地理分布区之一。它的面積達到1990万平方千米,涵蓋�...

 

 

A κ-opioid agonist drug SpiradolineClinical dataRoutes ofadministrationN/AATC codenoneIdentifiers IUPAC name 2-(3,4-Dichlorophenyl)-N-methyl-N-[(5R,7S,8S)-7-pyrrolidin-1-yl-1-oxaspiro[4.5]decan-8-yl] acetamide CAS Number87151-85-7 YPubChem CID55652IUPHAR/BPS1653ChemSpider50257 NUNIIN18ZH0M4NPChEMBLChEMBL118865 NCompTox Dashboard (EPA)DTXSID1048679 Chemical and physical dataFormulaC22H30Cl2N2O2Molar mass425.39 g·mol−13D model (JSmol)Interactive image SMILES CN([C@H]1CC[...

1996 single by Michael JacksonStranger in MoscowSingle by Michael Jacksonfrom the album HIStory: Past, Present and Future, Book I B-sideOff the Wall (Junior Vasquez Mix)Released November 4, 1996 (1996-11-04) (worldwide) July 4, 1997 (1997-07-04) (US) Recorded1993 – January 1994[1]Studio Neverland Ranch (Los Olivos, California) The Hit Factory (New York City) Sony Music (New York City) GenreR&BLength 5:44 (album version) 5:24 (album edit) 4:05 (radi...

 

 

Disambiguazione – Se stai cercando altri significati, vedi Violante d'Aragona (disambigua). Violante d'AragonaLa regina Violante in una miniatura medievaleRegina consorte di Castiglia e León In carica30 maggio 1252 –4 aprile 1284 PredecessoreGiovanna di Dammartin SuccessoreMaria di Molina Regina consorte di Germania(titolo contestato)In carica1º aprile 1257 –1º ottobre 1273 PredecessoreSancha di Provenza SuccessoreGertrude di Hohenberg Altri titoliRegina consorte di ...