His other possible wives were Dorodoche (daughter of Ortilochus) and Asterodia (daughter of Eurypylus).[5] The latter was said to have born him the following children:
In some accounts, Icarius was the father of Elatus who fathered Taenarus by Erymede, daughter Damasiclus.[8] Otherwise, Taenarus was called Icarius’ son with no mention of the birth mother.[9]
Comparative table of Icarius family
Relation
Name
Sources
Homer
Apollonius
Strabo
Apollodorus
Stephanus
Tzetzes
Ody.
Sch.
Sch. Argo.
Lyco.
Parentage
Perieres and Gorgophone
✓
✓
Oebalus and Bateia
✓
Siblings
Tyndareus
✓
✓
✓
Aphareus
✓
✓
Leucippus
✓
✓
Hippocoon
✓
Spouse
Asterodia
✓
Dorodoche
✓
Periboea
✓
Polycaste
✓
Erymede
Offspring
Penelope
✓
✓
✓
Iphthime
✓
✓
Laodamia or
✓
Laodice
✓
Perilaus or
✓
✓
Perileos
Amasichus
✓
Phalereus
✓
Thoon
✓
Pheremmelias
✓
Elatus
✓
Alyzeus
✓
Leucadius
✓
Aletes
✓
Damasippus
✓
Imeusimus
✓
Thoas
✓
Taenarus
✓
Mythology
Hippocoon, a natural son of Oebalus, expelled his two brothers, Tyndareus and Icarius, from Lacedaemon: they fled to Thestius at Pleuron, and dwelt beyond the river Achelous. Subsequently, when Heracles had slain Hippocoon and his sons, Tyndareus returned to Sparta, while Icarius remained in Acarnania. According to Apollodorus, however, Icarius also returned.[10] Another tradition relates that Icarius, who sided with Hippocoon, assisted him in expelling Tyndareus from Sparta.[11] While in Acarnania, Icarius became the father of the above progeny.
Icarius was a Spartan king[citation needed] and a champion runner who would not allow anyone to marry his daughter unless he beat him in a race. Odysseus succeeded and married Penelope,[12] but according to others, Tyndareus sued for the hand of Penelope for Odysseus, from gratitude for a piece of advice which Odysseus had given him.[13] After they got married, Icarius tried to persuade Odysseus to remain in Sparta. He did leave with Penelope, but Icarius followed them, imploring his daughter to stay. Odysseus told her she must choose whether to be with her father or with her husband. Penelope did not answer, but modestly covered her face with a veil. Icarius correctly understood that this was a sign of her will to leave with Odysseus, let them go and erected a statue of Aidos (Modesty) on the spot.[14] Icarius was apparently still alive at the time of the events of the Odyssey.