The episode starts with the top five contestants re-entering the Werk Room following the elimination of Nina Bo'nina Brown. On a new day, RuPaul greets the contestants and reveals the mini-challenge, which tasks contestants with poking fun at each other using puppets. The contestants have twenty minutes to "drag up" the puppets, which resemble the contestants. Shea Couleé, Sasha Velour, Trinity Taylor, and Alexis Michelle have puppets of Peppermint, Trinity Taylor, Shea Couleé, and Sasha Velour, respectively. RuPaul declares Sasha Velour is the winner of the mini-challenge, and reveals the main challenge: to present three looks for The Gayest Ball Ever, a fashion show based on queer culture. The ball's categories are "Rainbow-She-Better-Do" (for rainbow flag-inspired looks), "Sexy Unicorn", and "Village People Eleganza Extravaganza", for which contestants will design original looks inspired by members of the American disco group Village People.[5]
In the Werk Room, the contestants design their Village People-inspired looks, and RuPaul visits for status updates. Trinity Taylor bases her look on the cop. Inspired by the leatherman, Peppermint's look pays tribute to the leather subculture. Alexis Michelle creates an outfit based on the Native American character, and Sasha Velour uses the cowboy for inspiration. Shea Couleé constructs a look based on the construction worker. RuPaul reveals the contestants will also perform a number based on rhythmic gymnastics. RuPaul tasks Sasha Velour with overseeing choreography for the performance because she won the mini-challenge. The contestants rehearse on the main stage, then return to the Werk Room to make final preparations for the runway.
On the main stage, RuPaul welcomes fellow judges Michelle Visage and Carson Kressley, as well as guest judges Andie MacDowell and Joan Smalls. The contestants perform the gymnastics routine. For "Rainbow-She-Better-Do", Shea Couleé wears a graffiti-inspired dress. Sasha Velour utilizes color-blocking for her look. Trinity Taylor's outfit has lots of straps. For "Sexy Unicorn", Shea Couleé presents a black outfit. Sasha Velour's look is inspired by tapestry from the Middle Ages. Alexis Michelle's look is gold and glittered. Trinity Taylor says her purple outfit is inspired by the My Little Pony franchise, and Peppermint presents a "space unicorn" pink outfit. For "Village People Eleganza Extravaganza", Shea Couleé presents a deconstructed flannelcape. Sasha Velour wears an outfit made from red kerchiefs. Alexis Michelle wears turquoise stones and a bow headpiece. Trinity Taylors's cop-inspired look includes a visor, and Peppermint has leather accessories.
The judges deliver critiques, then RuPaul asks the contestants to share who they think should be eliminated from the competition and why. Sasha Velour and Shea Couleé receive positive critiques, and Shea Couleé wins the challenge. Alexis Michelle, Peppermint, and Trinity Taylor receive negative critiques, and Trinity Taylor is deemed safe. Alexis Michelle and Peppermint place in the bottom and face off in a lip-sync to "Macho Man" (1978) by Village People. Peppermint wins the lip-sync and Alexis Michelle is eliminated from the competition.
Reception
Oliver Sava of The A.V. Club gave the episode a rating of 'B-'.[6]