In 1630,[1]Giovanni Battista Baliani sent a letter to Galileo Galilei after he noticed that his siphon could not raise water more than about 10 m (34 feet).[4] Galileo proposed that a vacuum held the water up and that it could not hold any more.[5] At the time the existence of vacuums was controversial.[5]
Berti's vacuum experiment
Galileo's ideas, presented in his Discorsi (Two New Sciences), reached Rome in December 1638.[6] Upon reading Galileo's theory, physicists Gasparo Berti and father Raffaello Magiotti decided to seek a better way to test the possibility of producing a vacuum. Magiotti devised such an experiment. Four accounts of the experiment exist, all written some years later.[6] No exact date was given, but since Two New Sciences reached Rome in December 1638, and Berti died before January 2, 1644, science historian W. E. Knowles Middleton places the event to sometime between 1639 and 1643.[6] Present were Berti, Magiotti, Jesuit polymath Athanasius Kircher, and probably Jesuit physicist Niccolò Zucchi.[6]
Berti built an 11 m lead tube, filled it with water, and sealed both ends. He submerged one end in a basin of water and unsealed it. Though some of the water flowed out, much of it remained, filling the tube to about 10 m (34 feet)[7] above the water level in the basin, the same height as in Baliani's siphon.
What was most important about this experiment was that the lowering water had left a space above it in the tube which had no intermediate contact with air to fill it up. Berti claimed that in this space was a vacuum.[5] His claim was strongly contested however, and multiple experiments were performed attempting to disprove the existence of a vacuum. Berti's experiment led to Evangelista Torricelli's research into the weight of air and his invention of the barometer.