A cover version recorded by American girl group the Shirelles[1] reached number 83 in 1959.[3] This version was re-released in 1961 and reached number three on the Billboard Hot 100 chart and number two on Billboard's Hot R&B Sides.[4] The song was subsequently included on their 1961 album Tonight's the Night. In Canada, the re-release reached number 13.[5]
The song has the same mix on both the single and album versions, unlike some of their other tracks. However, there are different versions of the song:
The mono single and mono album versions are the same. Michelle's voice is double-tracked but mixed to sound like one voice. Cass's vocals and the piano are more prominent. The song ends with all four members singing in harmony.
The stereo album version moves the piano to the background, and Cass's voice is more blended with the others, especially at the end, where her vocals are almost absent.
Cash Box called the single a "groovey, harmonic, soft rock venture that is sure to please all of the group's many fans."[7]
The group appeared on The Ed Sullivan Show in 1967 to perform both this song and the single to follow, "Creeque Alley". Although the single has a running time of 2:56, and the group performed the song in its entirety, edited versions of the song appear on internet video sites with a much shorter running time.
DTV, in 1984, set the Mamas & the Papas version of the song to Sleeping Beauty and was featured on the VHS DTV: Groovin' for a 60's Afternoon.
Personnel
According to the AFM contract sheet, the following musicians played on the track.[11]